krelnik
Graduate Poster
Oh cool, thanks! I didn't realize Rosemary had a new site. I'll fix it my next batch of updates.
Why are the GPS items in there? They seem more like general stupidity, possibly leading to Darwin awards. A GPS isn't based on pseudo-science, nor is it a woo device. It's more like a high-tech map.
I also think the non-woo stuff looks odd. Critical thinking is not a synonym for "use your brain", although it is related.
...
However, many proponents of woo are honestly self-deluded about the validity of their stuff. Many (most?) homeopaths honestly believe that their magic water actually works. So intent is not a good dividing line at all.
...
Surely the difference is that GPS is a product that has been shown scientifically to work? "Woo" just means stuff that is anti-science or pseudoscience. If you're going to include all misuse of genuine science, or cases where science has been wrong and caused harm, you're going to have to include all cases of medical malpractice, all cases where scientifically proven drugs have done harm... etc etc.Remember that the site is targeted both at skeptics and believers. So I can't really use "woo" as the dividing line, because that is meaningless to a believer. (Heck, some skeptics have trouble with the term).
Only things not scientifically verified and/or plausible.But help me find a clear articulation of it. "Only woo" is not it. "Requires more than just common sense" is not it. Neither of those have a real clear definition.
Suggestions?
It's not the concept of onboard GPS navigation systems that is being targeted with the category - it's people blindly following the navigation system's instructions and not actually checking that they make sense. To blindly accept information when you can be (and are supposed to be, when driving) checking whether it's right is a failure to apply critical thinking.Surely the difference is that GPS is a product that has been shown scientifically to work? "Woo" just means stuff that is anti-science or pseudoscience. If you're going to include all misuse of genuine science, or cases where science has been wrong and caused harm, you're going to have to include all cases of medical malpractice, all cases where scientifically proven drugs have done harm... etc etc.
Only things not scientifically verified and/or plausible.
And this distinction is completely clear to the visitors of the site?He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."
And how would you do that?He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."
It's not the concept of onboard GPS navigation systems that is being targeted with the category - it's people blindly following the navigation system's instructions and not actually checking that they make sense. To blindly accept information when you can be (and are supposed to be, when driving) checking whether it's right is a failure to apply critical thinking.
He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."