Please help with the "Wall of Harm"

You might be interested in this story from New Zealand. Last year a self-proclaimed 'New Age Healer' was sued by two of his former patients after he tricked them into having sex with him. Both patients had come to him to get over sex abuse related trauma. The sad part about this is that the guy had allegedly been in operation for ten years prior to this.

Date format is (DD/MM/YY), oldest story first. All are from the New Zealand Herald. Unfortunately due to legal reasons the victims cannot be named.

The Geoffrey Mogridge Saga

The search for insight on healer (04/06/06)
http://tinyurl.com/2tp6ef

The 'Healer' who had sex with abused women (04/06/06)
http://tinyurl.com/2kov3b

Counsellor had sex with female clients(04/06/06)

http://tinyurl.com/2v8pj6

Therapist labelled sexual predator (12/12/06)
http://tinyurl.com/3bl34h

Therapist a 'sexual predator', says health commissioner (12/12/06)
http://tinyurl.com/2qzp9b

Client says she was duped into sex (30/12/07)

http://tinyurl.com/3clrfd

Healer facing sex allegation allowed to question patients' claims (31/12/07)

http://tinyurl.com/3cz63h

Healer told to pay up after sex with clients (26/12/07)
http://tinyurl.com/37fdz3
 
Last edited:
Why are the GPS items in there? They seem more like general stupidity, possibly leading to Darwin awards. A GPS isn't based on pseudo-science, nor is it a woo device. It's more like a high-tech map.
 
Why are the GPS items in there? They seem more like general stupidity, possibly leading to Darwin awards. A GPS isn't based on pseudo-science, nor is it a woo device. It's more like a high-tech map.

Well, as I noted in the site introduction, the overarching theme of the site is misinformation and critical thinking. Misinformation is the one thing that all forms of "woo" have in common, and critical thinking is the common tool to combat them.

So I deliberately decided to put in some non-woo topics to show how some misinformation is less obvious than others. I don't think vegetarianism is woo either, but I think you can get into trouble if you take it too far (such as choosing a vegetarian diet for a small baby).

You might want to read my answer to FAQ question #7, which is closely related.
 
Last edited:
I also think the non-woo stuff looks odd. Critical thinking is not a synonym for "use your brain", although it is related. If you want to list all those cases where people have been hurt because they trusted products or manuals, you will have your work cut out (even more).

Products like GPS recievers will of course lead to accidents if they have errors. Without errors, GPS receivers work, and are an advantage. Wooism never works, and when at best, nothing happens. There is a world of difference.
 
I also think the non-woo stuff looks odd. Critical thinking is not a synonym for "use your brain", although it is related.

Remember that the site is targeted both at skeptics and believers. So I can't really use "woo" as the dividing line, because that is meaningless to a believer. (Heck, some skeptics have trouble with the term).

Point about thinking taken. While some of the cases of GPS misuse seem like blatant stupidity, there are more subtle cases. For instance, when someone is sent down a long road that gradually narrows and becomes unsafe. Theres a point there where you have to use some thinking skills beyond the level of "don't drive into a river" and realize, this road really doesn't look like its going to get me to my destination.

I thought about drawing the line on intent of the proponent of the information. Clearly the GPS vendors are NOT intentionally sending people into rivers or crash them into bridges. When these things are pointed out to them, they fix the maps.

However, many proponents of woo are honestly self-deluded about the validity of their stuff. Many (most?) homeopaths honestly believe that their magic water actually works. So intent is not a good dividing line at all.

I'm open to switching to a dividing line that would eliminate the GPS category. But help me find a clear articulation of it. "Only woo" is not it. "Requires more than just common sense" is not it. Neither of those have a real clear definition.

Suggestions?
 
...
However, many proponents of woo are honestly self-deluded about the validity of their stuff. Many (most?) homeopaths honestly believe that their magic water actually works. So intent is not a good dividing line at all.

...

Homeopaths and their fans get very upset when I post your page on homeopathy. They usually excuse the problem by saying the homeopath was not competent, and they never have an answer about the baby girl who died from sepsis from untreated eczema whose father was a homeopath.
 
Remember that the site is targeted both at skeptics and believers. So I can't really use "woo" as the dividing line, because that is meaningless to a believer. (Heck, some skeptics have trouble with the term).
Surely the difference is that GPS is a product that has been shown scientifically to work? "Woo" just means stuff that is anti-science or pseudoscience. If you're going to include all misuse of genuine science, or cases where science has been wrong and caused harm, you're going to have to include all cases of medical malpractice, all cases where scientifically proven drugs have done harm... etc etc.

But help me find a clear articulation of it. "Only woo" is not it. "Requires more than just common sense" is not it. Neither of those have a real clear definition.

Suggestions?
Only things not scientifically verified and/or plausible.
 
Last edited:
Surely the difference is that GPS is a product that has been shown scientifically to work? "Woo" just means stuff that is anti-science or pseudoscience. If you're going to include all misuse of genuine science, or cases where science has been wrong and caused harm, you're going to have to include all cases of medical malpractice, all cases where scientifically proven drugs have done harm... etc etc.


Only things not scientifically verified and/or plausible.
It's not the concept of onboard GPS navigation systems that is being targeted with the category - it's people blindly following the navigation system's instructions and not actually checking that they make sense. To blindly accept information when you can be (and are supposed to be, when driving) checking whether it's right is a failure to apply critical thinking.

He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."
 
He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."
And this distinction is completely clear to the visitors of the site?
 
He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."
And how would you do that?
 
By occasionally looking at the road instead of the GPS screen? If I look ahead of me and see a cliff, and my GPS unit tells me to keep going straight, I'm going to apply some critical thinking and decide that the GPS unit is in error. The same goes for trying to drive across a flooded road, turning into a building, and the various other mistakes people have made because they trusted their GPS more than they trusted their eyes.
 
It's not the concept of onboard GPS navigation systems that is being targeted with the category - it's people blindly following the navigation system's instructions and not actually checking that they make sense. To blindly accept information when you can be (and are supposed to be, when driving) checking whether it's right is a failure to apply critical thinking.

He's not warning people "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you shouldn't use GPS", he's warning them that "Person X drove off a cliff when using a GPS unit, so you should make sure your GPS isn't telling you to drive off a cliff."

But that goes for all products. It would be a consumer warning site instead. Or something akin to the Darwin Awards.
 
Thanks for the FAQ point, I'd missed that. I don't agree, though. Of course, you are right that just blindly accepting what you are told is a problem. But the crucial thing for me is that the woo side is out actively peddling disinformation. The GPS people (and the moderates in vegetarian & home birth advocacy) are not.

The GPS stories remind me of that one about the guy who put the cruise control in his RV, and then got up out of the drivers seat to go back and make a sandwich. Material for Snopes or Darwin Awards, not so much a lesson for the rest of us. The idea is to answer when people ask "Where's the harm?" in silly beliefs, right? But we all already know there's harm in being an idiot. If you're seriously going to document all harm from Failure to Use Brain, then your site is going to get huge and unfocussed.
 
Last edited:
Hi Krelnik, sorry to keep bothering you. This time I'm having a run-in with some anti-vaccination weirdos on the JABS forum, and it would be cool to have some handy links to news items about the consequences of not being vaccinated.
Keep up the good work!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom