Faith leads to evil.

I wouldn't claim such a thing wasn't mandated by scripture - because I can well imagine someone could interpret the sections of the New Testament dealing with transubstantiation and find a justification for cannibalism there.


Dammit and there was me trying to think of something abhorrent that couldn't be supported by scripture.


Because their Christian beliefs incorporate their moral beliefs. They did not consider their moral judgement as seperate from their Christianity.


So beliefs that a christian holds are christian beliefs? Is that what you're saying?


The idea that a Christian decides how to feel about a particular issue by poring through the bible is more Atheist Fundamentalism. The Christians who opposed slavery didn't need to go much further than "Love your neighbour as yourself".


I didn't say christians have to consult the Bible to come to a decision on something, only if they want to come to it from a christian perspective.

Also "love your neighbor" means love your neighbor, not love your property.


It's fair comment when the hypocrisy of Christian slave-owners is pointed out. I won't try to pretend that they weren't somehow real Christians. But the abolitionist movement was dominated by Christians acting according to their Christian principles.


What hypocrisy?
 
Abolishment of slavery is not a christian principle. The bible even supports slavery and prescribes how to treat slaves. The abolishment of slavery is a secular value. It did not come from religion, but from reason and free thought.
 
Abolishment of slavery is not a christian principle. The bible even supports slavery and prescribes how to treat slaves.

In the Old Testament, yes. This is not a New Testament teaching as far as I'm aware.

The abolishment of slavery is a secular value. It did not come from religion, but from reason and free thought.

This is untrue. At least in the US, the concept of all men (and women) being granted inalienable rights was both secular and religious. Most of the religious at the time such concepts first entered the arena were Christians. A good number of abolitionists were die-hard, even fundamental Christians, and I think you'd be hard-pressed to find many who did not claim some Christian religious affiliation, and who did not use those "Christian values" as part of their platform against slavery. John Brown, for example, originally trained to be a minister. Abby Kelley and Benjamin Lundy were Quakers. The list can go on and be quite lengthy.

Couldn't you imagine an atheist king who believed that the plebs needed religion to survive?

"A tyrant must put on the appearance of uncommon devotion to religion. Subjects are less apprehensive of illegal treatment from a ruler whom they consider god-fearing and pious." -- Aristotle, Politics

"I am driven with a mission from God. God would tell me, 'George go and fight these terrorists in Afghanistan'. And I did. And then God would tell me 'George, go and end the tyranny in Iraq'. And I did." President George W. Bush, Sharm el-Sheikh, August 2003

But I think the point being made was that those states founded on a system that included and espoused atheism tended to repress other religions as a matter of course. This does not mean that all systems that include atheism would do this, but that the historical course has shown this more often than not.
 
Last edited:
Suffering is, by definition, unpleasant. It is logical to minimize suffering.

I give you a shot. You spend 90 minutes deliriously happy, then die, ensuring you never suffer again. I have moved your lifetime suffering to a dead minimum.

Similarly, I stop an Olympic athlete from working out, because he is frequently in pain after a long training session.

I am doing good, in a logical manner.

I find the minimization of suffering a rather pathetic goal.
 
Last edited:
Was it ever condemned in the New Testament?

No, it never condemns slavery, although 1 Corinthians 7:23 does make a pronouncement against becoming "slaves of men". The New Testament does not "support" or "prescribe how to treat slaves" either.

What religion was that?

Ummm, I addressed this if you'll read further along. If anything there didn't make sense or seemed erroneous, please feel free to question.
 
And what "evil" has that lead to again?

If my kids need food and I come over to your house and kill you for your food, I would say that is evil based on human instinct of self-preservation. It's something you will see worldwide as the food crisis begins in smaller countries.

ETA: poor not small
 
Last edited:
If my kids need food and I come over to your house and kill you for your food, I would say that is evil based on human instinct of self-preservation. It's something you will see worldwide as the food crisis begins in smaller countries.

ETA: poor not small

Look at the world as a whole and you could say that it's happening right now.
 
In the Old Testament, yes. This is not a New Testament teaching as far as I'm aware.

The NT condones the laws of the OT.

This is untrue. At least in the US, the concept of all men (and women) being granted inalienable rights was both secular and religious.

Wrong. The concept of equality is not Christian. It is a secular value that, thankfully, many christians finally accepted, but it did not originate within christianity. The bible says nothing about equality and, in fact, condones the idea of people being more or "better" than others.

A good number of abolitionists were die-hard, even fundamental Christians, and I think you'd be hard-pressed to find many who did not claim some Christian religious affiliation, and who did not use those "Christian values" as part of their platform against slavery. John Brown, for example, originally trained to be a minister. Abby Kelley and Benjamin Lundy were Quakers. The list can go on and be quite lengthy.

They were all mistaken to call equality a christian value. I'm glad christians are happy to incorporate and water down their religion with good secular values, but please don't attribute such great concepts to christianity. It's simply a lie. Freedom, equality and tolerance are secular values that transcend any religious belief and originated from reason and empathy, not religion.
 
So beliefs that a christian holds are christian beliefs? Is that what you're saying?


I didn't say christians have to consult the Bible to come to a decision on something, only if they want to come to it from a christian perspective.

Also "love your neighbor" means love your neighbor, not love your property.

There's a reason they're called "Christians", not "Biblers".

The message of the NT is simple enough. Christ was asked what the essence of his message was, and he said it. The atheists seem to be upset when Christians go by this and don't go poring through Leviticus for something appalling.

What hypocrisy?

The slave owners didn't love their neighbour. And yes, Christ did tell them who their neighbour was. They did what the Atheist Fundies like in a Christian - delve into scripture to find the bits that suited them. Unfortunately there were others, as detailed on this thread, who took the fundamental teaching seriously and acted on it.
 
westprog,

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that faith - religious faith - is wrong. That a reasonable person must agree that Jesus, Buddha and Allah can all be classed with IPU and FSM as inherently absurd ... So what's the conclusion? Well, I certainly don't think that in a world where religious fanatics fly planes into buildings killing thousands of people, that religion is a panacea. But obviously, neither is atheism. But maybe, just maybe, tolerance is. Acceptance that while I like my beliefs, the other guy should be considered as if his beliefs were of equal value. Or at least of some value.

I do not think that faith in and of itself is evil, I see it more as a motivating factor; but I do think that misguided faith or faith without reason can be an unskillful motivating factor when it comes to our actions, i.e., acts leading to harmful results. People who kill thousands of other innocent people out of faith is certainly one example of how I think faith can be an unskillful motivating factor. Nevertheless, is faith always going to lead to such behavior, is it all the same? On the issue of faith in Buddhism, for example, while there is certainly room for skepticism toward matters of faith, there is also a limit to that skepticism. The Buddha often stated that faith in a teacher is what leads one to learn from that teacher, to put their teachings to the test to see what results they will bring; and the only valid basis for faith is the instruction that, when followed, brings about the end of one's own mental defilements (DN 11).

As Thanissaro Bhikkhu explains, "The Buddha never placed unconditional demands on anyone's faith ... We read his famous instructions to the Kalamas, in which he advises testing things for oneself, and we see it as an invitation to believe, or not, whatever we like. Some people go so far as to say that faith has no place in the Buddhist tradition, that the proper Buddhist attitude is one of skepticism. But even though the Buddha recommends tolerance and a healthy skepticism toward matters of faith, he also makes a conditional request about faith: If you sincerely want to put an end to suffering — that's the condition — you should take certain things on faith, as working hypotheses, and then test them through following his path of practice" (Faith in Awakening). In other words, one must have at least a modicum of faith that an end to suffering is possible, otherwise one will not bother working toward that goal.

One must also understand what faith means in this context. In the Pali Canon, the word saddha can be translated as "confidence," "conviction," or "faith." More specifically, it is a type of confidence, conviction, or faith that is rooted in understanding as well as what we would conventionally refer to as faith in the West, i.e., confident belief in the truth, value, or trustworthiness of a person, idea, or thing. To give an example, for one to truly take refuge in the Buddha (as a teacher), one has to take his awakening on faith until they too have achieved that particular goal. Until then, they have no way of verifying the experience of awakening until they have experienced it for themselves. Therefore, while saddha by itself is not a sufficient condition for arriving at the end of suffering, there are elements of faith that are important to the practice. The question is, does this type of faith lead to unskillful or negative behavior?

Biased as I am, for me the answer is no. For one reason, taking the doctrine of kamma on faith, as a working hypothesis, has the potential to lead to skillful actions. As Thanissaro Bhikkhu explains in Faith in Awakening, "...instead of an empirical proof for his teaching on karma, the Buddha offered a pragmatic proof: If you believe in his teachings on causality, karma, rebirth, and the four noble truths, how will you act? What kind of life will you lead? Won't you tend to be more responsible and compassionate? If, on the other hand, you were to believe in any of the alternatives — such as a doctrine of an impersonal fate or a deity who determined the course of your pleasure and pain, or a doctrine that all things were coincidental and without cause — what would those beliefs lead you to do? Would they allow you to put an end to suffering through your own efforts? Would they allow any purpose for knowledge at all?"

To put it another way, if I ask a person who I feel to be wise, which should be determined by careful observation and analysis of their words and deeds per AN 4.192, "What when I do it will be for my long-term welfare and happiness," and their answer leads me to place faith in putting forth the effort to abstain from killing, abstain from stealing, abstain from lying, abstain from sexual misconduct, abstain from intoxicating drinks and drugs which lead to carelessness; to cultvating wholesome mental states (e.g. compassion, equanimity, etc.) and abandoning unwholesome mental states (e.g., greed, hatred, etc.); to developing alertness, mindfulness, and wisdom through various forms of meditation, will this type of faith lead to unskillful actions that harm myself or others? In most cases, if the effort is genuine, the answer is no. Therefore, in a pragmatic sense, faith is not inherently detrimental to oneself or society.

None of this can prove that such actions are universal moral laws, and therefore ultimately valid in all circumstances, but it does go to show that the answer to whether faith is "evil" is relative as opposed to absolute. If a person believes that violence is "evil," for example, then faith in the idea that actions based upon harmlessness and non-violence such as those found in Buddhism and Jainism can be seen as being "good" if they lead to non-violent actions. Then there are the moral grey areas such as when we ask whether violence is sometimes necessary, e.g., in WW II when violence was perhaps the only way to end the Nazi death camps; and our faith in the right answer determines our actions. One can reason that violence in cases such as these is ethically acceptable, but even that view depends on faith in a certain set of assumptions about things such as ethics, morality, the intrinsic value of human life, etc.

As for how to deal with the issue of faith in a broader context, there is no simple solution. Matters of faith can be complex, and as much as certain people dislike the idea of faith, there is little that one can do to prevent another from having faith in something. I think that one very important tool is education; I think that if more people around the world had access to quality education, and were taught critical thinking skills, then there would be less reliance on faith. But even this is not a foolproof solution seeing as how many of the 9/11 hijackers well educated. I definitely agree with Sam Harris that having an open discourse about these matters is another step in the right direction; but in the end, I think that people need to start taking an honest look at their beliefs and what their beliefs motivate them to do. I think that this kind of self-awareness can eventually dispel a lot of the harm that faith can engender.

Jason
 
Last edited:
The NT condones the laws of the OT.

As this is not my understanding, please provide a citation from the Bible that makes this statement.

Wrong. The concept of equality is not Christian. It is a secular value that, thankfully, many christians finally accepted, but it did not originate within christianity. The bible says nothing about equality and, in fact, condones the idea of people being more or "better" than others.

Wrong:

"But God has combined the members of the body and has given greater honor to the parts that lacked it, so that there should be no division in the body, but that its parts should have equal concern for each other. If one part suffers, every part suffers with it; if one part is honored, every part rejoices with it." 1 Corinthians 12: 24-26 [emphasis added]

"Our desire is not that others might be relieved while you are hard pressed, but that there might be equality. At the present time your plenty will supply what they need, so that in turn their plenty will supply what you need. Then there will be equality, as it is written: 'He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little did not have too little.'" 2 Corinthians 8: 13-15 [emphasis added]

I can provide more, if so required.

Freedom, equality and tolerance are secular values that transcend any religious belief and originated from reason and empathy, not religion.

While I agree with the former part of this statement, and even applaud it, I disagree with the latter. There is no single origin for such concepts as freedom and equality. They did not spring, fully-formed from the forehead of secularists lacking input from any other source; social, cultural, religious or otherwise.
 
Last edited:
There's a reason they're called "Christians", not "Biblers".

The message of the NT is simple enough. Christ was asked what the essence of his message was, and he said it. The atheists seem to be upset when Christians go by this and don't go poring through Leviticus for something appalling.


And part of Jesus's message was that the laws of the Old Testament were to be upheld. What annoys atheists is the inconsistancy christians show even when it comes to following the teachings of Jesus.


The slave owners didn't love their neighbour. And yes, Christ did tell them who their neighbour was. They did what the Atheist Fundies like in a Christian - delve into scripture to find the bits that suited them. Unfortunately there were others, as detailed on this thread, who took the fundamental teaching seriously and acted on it.


Er, isn't that exactly what they, and you are doing? You're delving into scripture and picking only the nice bits.
 
Seneca the Younger said it well:

“Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful.”

Religion is nothing more than a tool with powerful potential. Whenever the tool is wielded (particularly by the powerful), tolerance mixed with plenty of vigilance and a readiness to act when it’s employed abusively seems the prudent response.
 
Last edited:
While I agree with the former part of this statement, and even applaud it, I disagree with the latter. There is no single origin for such concepts as freedom and equality. They did not spring, fully-formed from the forehead of secularists lacking input from any other source; social, cultural, religious or otherwise.

I think you misunderstand what a secular value is. A secular value is not one that was invented or thought up by secularists. It is a value that is shared by many, despite what their religions say. Secular values formed, not because of faith, but because people decided that these values or ideas were a bit better. Many, if not all, of the values shared in the free world today didn't come from a bible, but from discussion and debate, which is a form of reasoning and logic.
 
I give you a shot. You spend 90 minutes deliriously happy, then die, ensuring you never suffer again. I have moved your lifetime suffering to a dead minimum.

Similarly, I stop an Olympic athlete from working out, because he is frequently in pain after a long training session.

I am doing good, in a logical manner.

I find the minimization of suffering a rather pathetic goal.

I'm having a rotten day. I'll respond some other time.

I suspect you have an idea how I will respond though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom