Faith leads to evil.

He can't even use the "it's the old testament" excuse. I'm sure some apologetic crap will surface though. I predict "servants are not slaves" and "those verses are taken out of context."
 
Assuming perfect reason, and the same assumptions, and putting aside issues of language and comprehension, starting with the same fundamental principles it should be possible to derive the same moral code. Naturally this will never happen.

Well, there's a non sequitur if I ever saw one. Why would it not be possible for two people to derive the same moral code? Do you have a rational basis for saying such a thing, or are you merely arguing from incredulity?

However, the principle on which a moral system is founded is typically not something which can be determined as faulty or sound. If the fundamental principle is "Increase human happiness" then it's not possible to use reason to determine whether that is a correct premise or not.

I wouldn't necessarily say 'typically' - there are plently of moral systems out there that have as their base values the worship of a human, or even an entity that does not appear to exist!

However, there are also a number of values that are not faulty on which moral systems can be based.

But a large number of systems have been based on such a view, explicitly or implicitly. Admittedly they tend not to turn out so well.

http://www.iht.com/articles/1994/10/19/ederic.php

Well, that's part of the point, isn't it? The other part is that their moral system is unjustified (in the sense that moral systems can be justified by not having a poor foundation).
 
I'm having a rotten day. I'll respond some other time.

I suspect you have an idea how I will respond though.

I'm sorry you are having a rotten day.

I can respond-- we don't randomly kill people for a lot of reasons... mostly we don't care too. Many of us are for euthanasia, but we would suffer legal consequences if we enabled the death of a terminally ill loved one. Most of us have no desire to kill others for any reason; I've sure never wanted to KILL someone. But even if we logically put someone out of their misery (and we do for our pets)... we know that is a right that we want to make for ourselves and our loved ones-- we wouldn't take that right away from someone else or destroy their loved ones by doing so. People who ask such inane questions like Grey_ice sound so creepy and immoral to me-- like they would kill without whatever it is they have keeping them from doing so. Humans seemed to do pretty well for themselves just evolving basic social reciprocity which served for eons before anyone made any holy book. We are their ancestors. We carry their social influences in our genes.

Atheists... including atheists since childhood seem to behave as morally or more morally than their indoctrinated counterparts... however, the indoctrinated to "believe" they are more moral just as they "believe" that they got their morality form some god.

If god is supposed to help people get along better socially-- it isn't working:

There is evidence that within the U.S. strong disparities in religious belief versus acceptance of evolution are correlated with similarly varying rates of societal dysfunction, the strongly theistic, anti-evolution south and mid-west having markedly worse homicide, mortality, STD, youth pregnancy, marital and related problems than the northeast where societal conditions, secularization, and acceptance of evolution approach European norms.http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/2005/2005-11.html

And let's not forget the pedophiliac clergy... whom even threats of hells don't seem to control.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but... it is getting to the point that "outspoken Christian on the Internet" is almost a synonym for "bigoted liar." It is weird, since real-life Christians don't follow that pattern nearly as closely. When someone starts a thread here defending theism, however, I'd bet you dollars to donuts that they'll be lying by page 2.

and fighting straw man version of something the atheist said, call the atheist a liar, play the offended card, and criticize others with criticisms that so much more clearly apply to him or herself. Oh yeah... and the loaded tangential questions that they don't really want answered.
 
"We are their ancestors. We carry their social influences in our genes."
.
"Descendants" please... :)
And social influences are learned (at Mommy's knee), not transmitted thru the genes, although many animal species do exhibit altruistic behavior, it's probably learned as well.
 
"But God has combined the members of the body and has given greater honor to the parts that lacked it, so that there should be no division in the body, but that its parts should have equal concern for each other. If one part suffers, every part suffers with it; if one part is honored, every part rejoices with it." 1 Corinthians 12: 24-26 [emphasis added]

That passage, when read in context, appears to refer to the members of the Church, not humankind in general. Moreover, it appears (once again) to condone slavery.

"For by one Spirit are we all baptized into one body, whether [we be] Jews or Gentiles, whether [we be] bond or free; and have been all made to drink into one Spirit." 1 Corinthians 12:13 [emphasis added]

"Our desire is not that others might be relieved while you are hard pressed, but that there might be equality. At the present time your plenty will supply what they need, so that in turn their plenty will supply what you need. Then there will be equality, as it is written: 'He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little did not have too little.'" 2 Corinthians 8: 13-15 [emphasis added]

Er...just because a passage talks about 'equality' doesn't mean that it's talking about slavery. The equality in this passage appears to be referring to the sharing of goods (such as crops) - not equality in people.

Feel free to try again though.
 
It seems to me that Westprog is making a rather serious assumption that is without basis. He rightly points out that logical analysis doesn't begin until one identifies premises and conclusions (or more to his point) axioms and derivations from the axioms. According to him, if I understand correctly, to develop of logic of a "moral" system, we must first posit axiomatic "principles" and then use logic afterwards to determine the internal consistency of the derivations from those axiomatic "principles." Quite so.

However, how one views those axioms (however one wants to describe them) is rather important. It is, by no stretch of the imagination, necessary to believe-in in the faith manner, internalize (or however else one wishes to characterize this function), or otherwise hold as True any axiom, even if we depict them as moral principles. One can, I think, perfectly coherently view the axioms as conditional and one can choose not to hold them as matters of faith. And this is where Westprog, and faith, goes awry.

Now, interestingly enough, if we look at the "principles" or axioms as conditional on some desired result then we can then do away with normative language and move towards verifiability and, in this manner, we can, not span, but render uninteresting the is-ought barrier. In such a way of seeing things, we can replace words like "ought" and "should" with "must." If we value X then we must prohibit Y or make Z an obligation. Sometimes whether something is a matter of verifiability or not is in how one phrases the question...

Now Westprog, and possibly others, may claim that I've simply created an additional step in that now the values are listed as first principles, but the critical difference, again, is not in the fact that we posit axioms, but in the manner in which we view them. it is a radically different thing to say "I value this" as opposed to "This is valuable." Do we view them as practical matters or do we view them as Truths(tm)? This very simple, but profound difference, can significantly alter the frame of reference and change the character of the whole endeavor.

Faith is maladaptive precisely because matters of faith are not held as conditional - they are held as Truths or absolute.

It takes a moral relativist to say that murder is not Wrong, but it takes a moral absolutist to say that murder is Right. This is another way of high-lighting the difference between positing as conditional and holding as a matter of faith. However, with a more sophisticated understanding of morality as a social function, as opposed to some kind of absolute Truth(tm), it is quite possible to speak of morality without speaking of Right or Wrong, Good or Evil.

To the absolutist, this makes morality slippery and difficult to understand as their vision of "moral." To the absolutist this is a reason to condemn lack of faith in moral principles as non-moral. Interestingly enough, we do have GreyICE claim that a non-faith-based principles of morality are not morality as he or she and/or most others understand it. I think GreyICE is correct about this, but does this indicate that we must work within the framework of the current understanding, even if widespread, or that we need a different understanding?

In the non-absolutist, however, this indicates a different approach to understanding of morality - one based more on reliance on negotiation of our understanding of what it is to be moral. It isn't "slippery" because it is subject to revision; it is adaptive to changing circumstances. This is not to say that non-absolutists must go this route, but only that it is possible. Functions fo moral language can still be accounted for, if we feel it is necessary to do so: Universalizability may expressed in the scope and breadth of application of the axiom set. Prescriptivity can be developed as an understanding of morality as a negotiated realm of reasonable expectations.

However, and this is where it gets interesting, what are we to say of people who posit morality as a matter of faith (again, believe-in or internalize the principles as Truth or absolute), but who also posit that they have direct access to moral Truths by some function of their private internal realms - conscience, and who, at the same time, treat conscience as sacrosanct? Now, here's an entirely other scenario which can, and often does, have catastrophic results, because these folks hold on faith that their Truths are absolute while at the same time deriving them from knowledge with no external referents.

Somewhere we developed this bizarre idea that conscience leads to understanding of moral Truth. What it actually does is remove the understanding of morality from the public realm and places it firmly in the realm of the entirely private, non-verifiable and non-refutable and also, non-negotiable realm. Sometimes they don't even realize what they are doing. A prime example is the person who claims that Biblical content represents moral Truth, but who also contradict that content at will, still believing they are holding to absolute Truth. Interesting perspective, that.
 

Nice try. ;) Unfortunately, this is taking what Jesus was saying out of context, and not looking at the whole chapter of Matthew. He was saying that he wasn't doing away with the old laws, but rather that the old laws have been fulfilled, that they had done what needed to be done, and their task was now complete (it can be argued that this shows an inconsistency on God's part, but that's a different thread). Then Jesus goes on to provide the new message, which includes his "turn the other cheek" (Matthew 5:39) and his "love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44). :D


Ummm, so where's all this condoning of slavery and how to treat slaves as prescribed by the New Testament? I don't see it in this citation. Do you have another you'd like to try? :D

I think you misunderstand what a secular value is. [snip]

Not at all. I think you’ve misunderstood what I’m saying. I’ll repeat for you, and try to be a little plain.

You claimed that “The abolishment of slavery is a secular value. It did not come from religion, but from reason and free thought.” This is patently false as I’ve already shown. I have not claimed that there was not secular thought involved in the concept of the abolishment of slavery, rather that it did not originate solely from a secular field. The concept of abolition was one that came from many different areas, some of them secular, some of them religious. Most of the abolitionists in the United States were, in varying degrees, religious folk. Of them, many used the Bible as a means to support their stance on an abhorrent practice. I hope that’s more clear to you now.

Why do atheists always seem to know more about what the Bible says than its supposed adherents do? This never ceases to amaze me.

If this is aimed at me it’s an erroneous assumption that you’re making. But thanks for playing!

If you’re follow up is then why am I taking this stance, it’s because I don’t like to see erroneous information being espoused as facts.

He can't even use the "it's the old testament" excuse. I'm sure some apologetic crap will surface though. I predict "servants are not slaves" and "those verses are taken out of context."

And you’d be wrong as well. The citations Civilized Worm provided were from the New Testament, unless Matthew and Timothy somehow got moved in your version. ;) While there is some cross over use between the terms slaves and servants, it is just that: cross over use. The two are used reasonably synonymously in the Bible, and that’s a dead end argument; or “apologetic crap” as you put it. The first verse was taken out of context, though I’ll admit it’s a confusing verse to read. The second citation doesn’t address anything that we’re discussing in this argument. But thank you also for playing! :D

That passage, when read in context, appears to refer to the members of the Church, not humankind in general. Moreover, it appears (once again) to condone slavery.

True enough, it is aimed at the followers of Jesus (not certain what church you’re referring, since they still considered themselves as part of the Jewish tradition, but for simplicity, we can let that lie). But that doesn't change the fact that the concept of equality (albeit under God) was being promoted by the Bible. But I'm not seeing any condoning of slavery by this passage or anywhere else in the New Testament. I suppose we could make the argument that

Er...just because a passage talks about 'equality' doesn't mean that it's talking about slavery. The equality in this passage appears to be referring to the sharing of goods (such as crops) - not equality in people.

Feel free to try again though.

Sorry, looks like you’re confused here. I was answering thaiboxerken’s erroneous claim that the equality is not a Christian concept. This particular part of the argument didn’t necessarily have to do with slavery, besides which I’ve already stated that the New Testament doesn’t condemn slavery. Unfortunate, but there it is.

Still, in the matter of equality, I can provide additional citations in this regard:

Galatians 3:28
Luke 4:18
Ephesians 6:8
Matthew 20: 11-13

Shew, that was a lot work! Thanks for putting me to the task, guys. This is a lot of fun. :D
 
Last edited:
Nice try. ;) Unfortunately, this is taking what Jesus was saying out of context, and not looking at the whole chapter of Matthew. He was saying that he wasn't doing away with the old laws, but rather that the old laws have been fulfilled, that they had done what needed to be done, and their task was now complete (it can be argued that this shows an inconsistency on God's part, but that's a different thread). Then Jesus goes on to provide the new message, which includes his "turn the other cheek" (Matthew 5:39) and his "love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44). :D


For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled.

Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven: but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.


Seems pretty clear from that that the law still stands. (Although strangely enough it seems you can break them and still get in to heaven, you just have to suffer the punishment of being called "least")


Ummm, so where's is the condoning of slavery and how to treat slaves as prescribed by the New Testament? :D


:confused:
 
Seems pretty clear from that that the law still stands. (Although strangely enough it seems you can break them and still get in to heaven, you just have to suffer the punishment of being called "least")

Yeah, it's a pretty confusing passage, as I said. So no fault of yours that you didn't get it. Jesus here is applying the law to himself, and, as I said, he's claiming it is "fulfilled" and thus no longer necessary, which is why he then goes on to provide new laws.


Sorry if I was unclear. The argument was that the New Testament supports and condones slavery. This quote doesn't reflect support or condoning slavery.
 
"We are their ancestors. We carry their social influences in our genes."
.
"Descendants" please... :)
And social influences are learned (at Mommy's knee), not transmitted thru the genes, although many animal species do exhibit altruistic behavior, it's probably learned as well.

I knew that.

Damn, I hate when I do that. And I have a Masters in Genetics.

Brain Fart.

Thanks for the correction.

(I blame your maddening avatar.)

ETA: RR--the new testament says it supports everything in the old testament... it doesn't say that the new rules alter the old ones... they just build upon them. If slavery was okay in the old testament, it didn't suddenly become "wrong" in the new.
 
Last edited:
You're delving into scripture and picking only the nice bits.

Which is bad how? What is the sense in picking out the stupid and malevolent parts of religious belief? What's the point in ignoring useful insights and wisdom?

Do people who apply Newton's laws of motion have to believe in astrology?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, it's a pretty confusing passage, as I said. So no fault of yours that you didn't get it. Jesus here is applying the law to himself, and, as I said, he's claiming it is "fulfilled" and thus no longer necessary, which is why he then goes on to provide new laws.


He said they wouldn't all be fulfilled until "heaven and earth pass" and people must still obey them unless they want to be "least" in heaven.


Sorry if I was unclear. The argument was that the New Testament supports and condones slavery. This quote doesn't reflect support or condoning slavery.


In what way is "Slaves must be obedient to their masters in everything, and do what is wanted without argument" NOT supporting slavery?
 
Yeah, it's a pretty confusing passage, as I said. So no fault of yours that you didn't get it. Jesus here is applying the law to himself, and, as I said, he's claiming it is "fulfilled" and thus no longer necessary, which is why he then goes on to provide new laws.

There's a more basic point here as well. There seems to be outrage from atheists that Christians fail to follow the authorised athiest interpretation of the bible, and insist on accepting their own view, or that of other Christian believers. Naturally the kind of Christian who lives in an armed compound in Utah and shoots gays is more acceptable to the atheists. At least he knows what he believes.

The reason that Christians don't take their message from Atheist bible scholars is that the fundamental Christian message is quite simple, really. It's also difficult to actually practice.
 
There's a more basic point here as well. There seems to be outrage from atheists that Christians fail to follow the authorised athiest interpretation of the bible, and insist on accepting their own view, or that of other Christian believers. Naturally the kind of Christian who lives in an armed compound in Utah and shoots gays is more acceptable to the atheists. At least he knows what he believes.

Our "outrage" (it's more incredulity, really) stems from the fact that whilst you profess to be "Christians", and certainly do take at least some parts of the Bible literally (otherwise, you're no kind of Christian at all), you decide that other bits aren't valid, aren't valid any more, or were metaphorical all along, all on an ad-hoc and totally arbitrary basis depending on cultural and / or personal mores. You also even pretend that the bits you find abhorrent from a personal standpoint (the gang-rapes, genocides, murders, lies and slavery) don't even mean what they explicitly say. The mental gymnastics your particular breed of Christian has to go through just leaves us atheists pretty dumbstruck. It's all so absurd from this side of the fence.

That's why we're confused. Why claim to be a Christian of you don't even believe in your own Scripture? Why believe in one thing the Bible says as absolute truth but dismiss passages from the same book as metaphor? Why even be a Christian, if your basic values are utterly opposed to the very Book you claim to take as your moral and metaphysical guide?

I think Dawkins makes a similar point in Delusion. Woolly Christians are just weird.
 
Last edited:
Which is bad how? What is the sense in picking out the stupid and malevolent parts of religious belief? What's the point in ignoring useful insights and wisdom?

Do people who apply Newton's laws of motion have to believe in astrology?


It's not bad at all, it's good. It shows you have an innate sense of morality that you then apply to biblical teaching and take only what you already know to be good. You don't need the Bible to tell you how to be moral any more than I do.


There's a more basic point here as well. There seems to be outrage from atheists that Christians fail to follow the authorised athiest interpretation of the bible, and insist on accepting their own view, or that of other Christian believers. Naturally the kind of Christian who lives in an armed compound in Utah and shoots gays is more acceptable to the atheists. At least he knows what he believes.


Of course atheists don't want you to be fundamentalists, we much prefer moderate religious people who tolerate homosexuality, accept scientific findings and so forth. What I'm trying to get across is that sensible people like yourself find much of the Bible to be as absurd and wicked as we do.

You are right in one sense that we find it slightly less frustrating to debate a believer who is clear and upfront about what they believe, but they're certainly not the kind of believer we want to share a planet with.
 
There's a more basic point here as well. There seems to be outrage from atheists that Christians fail to follow the authorised athiest interpretation of the bible, and insist on accepting their own view, or that of other Christian believers. Naturally the kind of Christian who lives in an armed compound in Utah and shoots gays is more acceptable to the atheists. At least he knows what he believes.

The reason that Christians don't take their message from Atheist bible scholars is that the fundamental Christian message is quite simple, really. It's also difficult to actually practice.

There's an even more basic point that I don't think you're getting.

The reason you believe your own version of what is important in the bible is the exact same reason the armed compound christians believe their version about what is important in the bible.

You just want to. It seems to fit with how you think the world works.

It has nothing to do with "Truth". You just like your version better.
 
There's an even more basic point that I don't think you're getting.

The reason you believe your own version of what is important in the bible is the exact same reason the armed compound christians believe their version about what is important in the bible.

You just want to. It seems to fit with how you think the world works.

It has nothing to do with "Truth". You just like your version better.

Hear, hear.

Every single Christian on the planet is convinced that his particular and esoteric interpretation of what the "fundamental message" of the Bible is the One True One. Fred Phelps does. Rowan Williams does. Pope Ratzinger does. You all think your message is the one true one, but none of you agree.

Why might that be?
 
Which is bad how? What is the sense in picking out the stupid and malevolent parts of religious belief? What's the point in ignoring useful insights and wisdom?

Do people who apply Newton's laws of motion have to believe in astrology?

.
It's pretty bad because it glosses over or just plain fails to mention the icky parts which conflict/contradict the nice smarmy feel-good stuff.
When balancing the whole, the icky parts outweigh the nice parts, when giving each of them equal weight.
"All-loving" is trumped by "eternal damnation", for instance.
These are in direct conflict with each other. Considered as being from the same source, the source is obviously screwed up.
Astrology, like religion, is outside science, and can say (and does say) anything it damn well please, reality not withstanding.
Just like religion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom