Faith leads to evil.

Really? You can be Christian and not believe one single word of the Bible is true? Not the bits about Jesus? Not the bits about Heaven? Not the bots about the crucifixion and resurrection?

You can be a Christian if you think the entire Bible is a fiction? Really?
Yes, really.
Which self-proclaimed Christian denomination does not believe in the literal truth of a single sentence of the Bible? Show me one and I'll eat my hat.
The Congregationalist Church I attend feels that each individual is required to interpret the bible according to the dictates of their own conscious. If an individual choose to believe it is entirely the work of mortal men who are subject to human error rather than divinely inspired literal Truth with a capital T, that's just fine.

Congregationist churches are creedless, which is to say they have no dogma which members are supposed to adhere to. Each church is entirely self-governed, so there's quite a bit of variance. The one I attend is particularly welcoming to atheists and agnostics. You might want to boil your hat to make it a bit softer and a bit of seasoning might make it go down a little easier.
Which is my entire point.
Sorry, but I don't understand why this is a problem for any but the literalist fundamentalist denominations.
 
Last edited:
So you think it's perfectly possible to be a Christian without believing Christ was a real person? Or that God is a real entity?

ETA: You're wrong.

Research on Congregationalism turned up the following:

"Doctrine: Based on the Reformed or Calvinist tradition which believes in the trinity, the final authority of scripture, salvation by faith alone, and observes two sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper." (http://philtar.ucsm.ac.uk/encyclopedia/christ/esp/congreg.html)

"Rather than following the dictates of a single human individual, Congregationalists believe that Jesus Christ is the head of each congregation." (http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=580)

" Our church is a Christian covenant Community exclusively devoted to Jesus Christ and inclusively committed to God's unconditional grace. In joy and gratitude, we live out the call of Christ to worship God, make disciples, support one another, and share God's extravagant welcome." (http://www.fcc-elgin.org/)

"The UCC acknowledges as its sole head, Jesus Christ, Son of God and Saviour." (http://www.triconchurch.org/about_ucc.html)

Guess my hat is safe after all. Seeing that the only source if information about Jesus Christ is in the Bible, and being a Christian involves recognising the existence of Christ, then you cannot be a Christian without believing in at least one part of the Bible (John 3:16, I guess) is absolutely true.
 
Last edited:
Long post to address all the lovely discussion points. Apologies ahead of time.

In another thread I could have sworn you said you were an atheist (or at least that you "lacked religious belief", which amounts to the same thing:

It does? I didn't know that having a lack of religious beliefs made me an atheist. <shrug>

Abolition of slavery, as I understand it, grew out of the broad cultural background of Enlightenment philosophy - which, as I'm sure you know, has very little to do with Scriptural Christianity.

Which I've disagreed with. But I don't think we're going to come to any kind of resolution in that regard. I feel that the majority of abolitionists were Christians, who felt compelled to act because of their faith, and that faith was instrumental in their arguments.

That the same text was used to counter them is unfortunate. But it doesn't render their faith any less fundamental to their cause. If you can show me this is not the case, then we might have something. Right now, I'm not seeing it, and everyone on that side of the fence seems to think this makes me an apologist. Okey dokey then! :cool:

That conveniently ignores the "until Heaven and Earth have passed" quote from Matthew, "It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail." from Luke, "Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever" from Psalms etc. etc.

It wasn't meant to be convenient. Jesus was saying that the law had to be fulfilled, that it was fulfilled through him, and that therefor the law hadn't failed. There is no need for heaven and earth to pass away, since the law didn't fail, and it was fulfilled. I can try to restate it again, but I think you're just going to keep getting hung up on the trees in this forest in order to make your argument. It doesn't suit you and your particular beliefs (or lack) so there it is. <shrug>

Of course, there are quotes from Romans and Galatians which state entirely the opposite, but then we're back into tarot reading again, aren't we? The Bible says whatever the reader wants it to say. No more, and no less. There is no "fundamental message" as Westprog was claiming earlier because the same set of texts can justify any set of behaviours you so choose.

Sure, depending on where you pull them and how you use them, you can pretty much justify anything. No argument there.

But I do think there is a fundamental message. I think all religious texts have a fundamental message. For the Bible, I've disagreed with Westprof that that fundamental message is, as he claimed hard to follow. That seems to be a retcon for the proclaimed Christians who did bad things in their time.

You're just picking the set of interpretations which suits your particular agenda (which is a little obfuscated at the moment).

No agenda than that which I stated: thaiboxerken was making false statements. I've provided several times the two points that I felt were incorrect. You are welcome to go back up and re-read them. I believe I numbered them at least twice, so they shouldn't be tricky to find. :D

You mean this stuff is supposed to make sense? Or be internally narratively coherent?

To the Christian point of view, yeah. Since we're looking at this through that lens, asking what it means, then I don't automatically disregard that claim because it's inconvenient.

If you're asking me personally, then that's a different matter entirely.

Seriously? You don't think "Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ" or "Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear, not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward" are not condoning the servitude of slaves to their masters?

Do you have a job? I have a job. I’ve worked for several companies in my time. Some rather large. You may have heard of them. For almost all of them I was generally rated pretty highly on performance reviews. I was “obedient” to my boss, though perhaps not with “fear and trembling”, but I usually worked with a “singleness of” purpose, even if it wasn’t imbedded in my heart.

So yeah, seriously, that’s what I think is being said. Which is vastly different, as I also said, from the Old Testament view of slaves. <shrug>

meg said:
Just exactly what is so great about this "faith"? Why do people wear their faith so proudly? Why do christians laud other people's faith?

Overall, I’d say nothing is so great about faith. I think people “wear their faith so proudly” because it lends an us-versus-them mentality, it’s nice to be “right,” and there is certainly strength in numbers. Christians seem to laud other faiths for this same reason. They can point to someone they consider great, attach the moniker of “powerful faith” to them, and hold them up to others to show that “our God is better than your God”.

volatile said:
ACS? RR? Any thoughts on the above?

Nopers. I’ve never argued against this notion.

Mobyseven said:
So, I really don't see how you can say that the old law was abolished by Jesus, when his own words speak otherwise.

I suppose I can’t. I’ve done my best to explain how I understand the scripture to be interpreted (and widely, not in a limited sense to this discussion). :) But I do appreciate that you understood that Jesus was providing an either-or scenerio. I don’t know why I wasn’t able to get that portion of the text across to volatile and others before.

As for the quotes, no, I didn’t miss them. We’ve discussed them all along. :)

westprog said:
At least Articulett has permitted you to talk to me and my ilk. Bloody generous of her.

Indeed. She’s gracious and giving like that. ;)

Actually, I was quite shocked when she elected to put me on ignore. We only ever crossed swords in one discussion. Other times I found her reasonable, rational and to some degree lived up to her moniker. <shrug>

Beth said:
No, wrong. Depends on the particular denomination. In addition, some passages are considered factual by students of the history of that place and time. Asimov's guide to the bible is illuminating in that regard.

You’ve just contradicted yourself here. What volatile is saying (and volatile, correct me if I’m misinterpreting you) is that in order to be Christian, some aspects of the Bible have to be taken literally. There was literally a Jesus, he literally taught, preached, died, rose, etc. There were literally other figures of the Bible who are historic figures like David, Saul, Moses, etc.

There is not a single Christian denomination that interprets the Bible as one big figurative piece of fiction.
 
So you think it's perfectly possible to be a Christian without believing Christ was a real person? Or that God is a real entity?
Apparently so, yes.

ETA: You're wrong.

Research on Congregationalism turned up the following:

"Doctrine: Based on the Reformed or Calvinist tradition which believes in the trinity, the final authority of scripture, salvation by faith alone, and observes two sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper." (http://philtar.ucsm.ac.uk/encyclopedia/christ/esp/congreg.html)

"Rather than following the dictates of a single human individual, Congregationalists believe that Jesus Christ is the head of each congregation." (http://www.ohiohistorycentral.org/entry.php?rec=580)

" Our church is a Christian covenant Community exclusively devoted to Jesus Christ and inclusively committed to God's unconditional grace. In joy and gratitude, we live out the call of Christ to worship God, make disciples, support one another, and share God's extravagant welcome." (http://www.fcc-elgin.org/)

"The UCC acknowledges as its sole head, Jesus Christ, Son of God and Saviour." (http://www.triconchurch.org/about_ucc.html)

Guess my hat is safe after all. Seeing that the only source if information about Jesus Christ is in the Bible, and being a Christian involves recognising the existence of Christ, then you cannot be a Christian without believing in at least one part of the Bible (John 3:16, I guess) is absolutely true.

And yet, my church doesn't require it. Go figure.

Nor does any of what you've quoted here exclude someone who chooses to interpret the bible wholely as a metaphor and Jesus as the metaphorical/mythical head of the church rather than as a real person.

P.S. I didn't believe you'd actually eat your hat. Probably wouldn't be healthy in addition to tasting awful. So keep your hat on and just enjoy learning new things about the vast diversity of beleifs that fall under the umbrella of Christianity.
 
That is amazing!
ALL of the bible.. all of it, from Genesis to Revelations can be considered a work of fiction, yet still be considered .... um.. um.. words fail!
The whole shebang, the Fall, the Resurrection, heaven, hell, all are merely parts of a ripping good yarn.
..
Oh, now it's coming thru.
The Elrons of the past that wrote the books are duplicated in our time by L. Ron himself. The clap-trap that is Scientology are obviously from the same sources of clap-trap, but are acceptable as a life guide.
OK.
I get it.
Folks lacking any self-governing potential look to books or movies for ways to live their lives.
OK.
As long as they don't force that mental incapacitance on me, OK.
With the seperation clause, we're safe here, but way too many other cultures don't acknowledge that reality and the spectral world can't be reconciled.
Pooh Bear's philosophy would be equally acceptable to these people, if wrapped in a feature length novel.
 
Apparently so, yes.

Out of all of your examples, not a single one reflects your claim of a metaphorical or figurative Jesus. All of them begin with the divinity of Jesus who walked the planet.

By definition, to be a Christian, you have to believe that Jesus was a real, historical figure.

And yet, my church doesn't require it. Go figure.

Which one of these is your church? Or is yours not listed?

Nor does any of what you've quoted here exclude someone who chooses to interpret the bible wholely as a metaphor and Jesus as the metaphorical/mythical head of the church rather than as a real person.

Nopers, sorry. An individual can claim whatever they want, but fundamental to being a Christian, survey says you're 100% wrong.
 
My slave is not my neighbour, he is my property. Therefore, I do not have to love him, QED.
You skipped a step. Sloppy of you. How is making the slave property consistent with "love thy neighbor as thyself."

Thanks for the reply, though, it got a grin out of me.

DR
 
It does? I didn't know that having a lack of religious beliefs made me an atheist. <shrug>

:confused:

You have no religious beliefs, but are not an atheist? Really?


Which I've disagreed with. But I don't think we're going to come to any kind of resolution in that regard. I feel that the majority of abolitionists were Christians, who felt compelled to act because of their faith, and that faith was instrumental in their arguments.

That the same text was used to counter them is unfortunate. But it doesn't render their faith any less fundamental to their cause. If you can show me this is not the case, then we might have something. Right now, I'm not seeing it, and everyone on that side of the fence seems to think this makes me an apologist. Okey dokey then! :cool:

Meg provided a quote from a scholar who has studied this in depth. Let me remind you of one pertinent sentence:

"Because of these assumptions, pro-slavery arguments carried the day in the United States in the first half of the nineteenth century. Abolitionists went so far as to say that the greatest obstacle to their cause was the text of the Bible!"

How does this tessellate with your contention that Christianity drove abolition? Further, I'll repeat something I said earlier: if Christianity is in and of itself useful to make an argument in favour of abolition, then abolition would have happened long before the Enlightenment. It strikes me that the general philosophical climate of the Enlightenment drove the moral Zeitgeist such that people were in favour of abolition, which they then sought to justify through recourse to their own Biblical interpretation. What you're doing is putting the Bible first, which seems entirely backwards given the chronology of events.


It wasn't meant to be convenient. Jesus was saying that the law had to be fulfilled, that it was fulfilled through him, and that therefor the law hadn't failed. There is no need for heaven and earth to pass away, since the law didn't fail, and it was fulfilled. I can try to restate it again, but I think you're just going to keep getting hung up on the trees in this forest in order to make your argument. It doesn't suit you and your particular beliefs (or lack) so there it is. <shrug>

Ditto, frankly.

You have an interpretation which quite manifestly does not chime with what is written right there on the page in black and white. Jesus says that the law will not be fulfilled. How you can argue that he said the opposite is still eluding me.


But I do think there is a fundamental message. I think all religious texts have a fundamental message. For the Bible, I've disagreed with Westprof that that fundamental message is, as he claimed hard to follow. That seems to be a retcon for the proclaimed Christians who did bad things in their time.

How can there be a 'fundamental message' when there is vast disagreement about what that 'fundamental message' might be? You can't on the one hand accept that people read the Bible to mean whatever suits them at the same time as saying there is a 'fundamental' message. It's a non-sequitor.

Do you have a job? I have a job. I’ve worked for several companies in my time. Some rather large. You may have heard of them. For almost all of them I was generally rated pretty highly on performance reviews. I was “obedient” to my boss, though perhaps not with “fear and trembling”, but I usually worked with a “singleness of” purpose, even if it wasn’t imbedded in my heart.

So yeah, seriously, that’s what I think is being said. Which is vastly different, as I also said, from the Old Testament view of slaves. <shrug>

Seriously? You're now trying to say a verse that says "Servants, tremble before your masters" is actually talking about gainful employment, and not about servants and masters?
 
Doesn't cause me a problem, really. Just confuses the hell out of me. It's weird. It's irrational. It's unjustifiable (as your consistent refusal to justify or even clarify your faith professes). I do not understand it at all, particularly from someone who proclaims to be sceptical.
I do not acknowledge any requirement for me to justify anything I do to you.
I'm a curious guy. I do curious for a living. So I ask questions. I have no desire to ask 'loaded' questions, they are the just the questions as they occur to me. They are the obvious, glaring questions that need answers, and I'm always confused as to why I never get a straight answer.
See once again where the loads are in your question, and you'll understand my skepticism regarding your motives.
You're a sceptic.
I do not wear that title, for me skepticism is a tool.
You're a rational guy. An eloquent, rational guy.
Tell my wife that, please. :D
So maybe you're the one that can finally explain to me how theism is compatible with rationality. I know you've thought about this, and I know you must have some rationalisation process. I'd just like to hear it, that's all.
Easy. I an Christian. I am rational. I exist. It can work. It does work. The guiding principles of Christian faith work, in the main.
It's strange to watch you get all high and mighty every time this question is asked of you, because you're so open and honest and forthright and clear in every other area of thought. It's actually quite frustrating, and even a little depressing.
Consider it an artifact of internet communication. We each share X amount of who we are in a very public forum, one where sharpshooters abound. I have no emotional need for your approval, nor for much of anyone's here. I've met a few kindred spirits, and some folks who are, in combination with me, friction meeting fuel meeting oxygen.
As for reconciliation, can you reconcile "love thy neighbour" with:
How about answering my question first? ;) That was a dodge, my dear Volatile. (Aside: I often substitute "Voltaire" when I read your name, which I hope you'll take as a compliment.)
"Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother, and the daughter in law against her mother in law", or
I am here to change things. (Looks like it worked. The slavery thing took a while, of course.)
"Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them",
The death penalty is OK with God. He'll sort out any errors in due course. Humans can be assumed to err now and again, it's part of our charm.
"For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy; and mercy rejoiceth against judgment"?
Thou shalt cherry pick what thou wilst, if thou desireth a bountiful harvest of pointless sniping.
As we said before, the Bible can be reconciled with whatever you want to reconcile it with. I'm sure you know this, as history testifies that this is the case. So why do you subscribe to it? What about it convinces you of not only its utility, but also its veracity?
Another loaded question. Its utility speaks for itself. You seem to mistake me for another kilt wearing sola scriptura blowhard.

Don't.

By the way, I am hardly at the end of my spiritual journey. I am a work in progress, I readily admit (About ten years so far. We all are, to a certain extent, works in progress.) Huntster, had he not been banned, could give you better than I can offer in a pure defense. I'm not yet, in my own estimation, qualified via competence to so perform.

A man has to know his limitations.

volatile to Rob Roy said:
ETA: You have no religious beliefs, but are not an atheist?
That would describe me very well, from birth into my thirties. Agnostic, open minded on the discussion, and not much concerned with the topic in general.

DR
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the world of Religious Moral Truth(tm), where nothing is true and morals are a matter of convenience, re-interpretable at the merest whim...

Welcome to the world of belief, where everything is true if you want it to be. Beats the snot out of reality. Accept no limitations...

Welcome to the world of faith, the land of do-as-you-please (And that's not all!!! You are absolutely morally Right to do so too...)

Welcome to the world of conscience, making everyone else obsolete right before your mind's eye. A ticking time-bomb in every head...
 
Last edited:
Darth. A serious question: Are you embarrassed by why you believe what you believe?

You don't need to justify yourself to me. I just want have a conversation, though you make it rather difficult. I want to understand how a rational and intelligent human being holds what seem to me to be quite clearly irrational thoughts. I've tried to explain why I think they're irrational, but you haven't even uttered a word on the subject. Your entire scope of discourse on this topic (and this topic alone, I note) seems to be "Not telling!". If anyone could clearly explain why it is sensible and rational to hold Christian beliefs, you'd be him. But you won't.

I can't work out why that is. You're obviously capable of explaining your reasoning. You're obviously wise enough to have given this some serious thought. You're obviously open enough to discuss plenty of other things here, and you're obviously sufficiently sceptical of extra-ordinary and irrational claims to be dogged in your pursuit of them whence they arrive. So what's so different about this conversation?

You presume some ulterior motive. I have none. I admit I have made some assumptions about you, but in the absence of any forthcoming information from your own mouth, you can't blame me for that, can you?
 
Last edited:
:confused:

You have no religious beliefs, but are not an atheist? Really?

Perhaps I'm using the wrong terminology? Or you are?

How does this tessellate with your contention that Christianity drove abolition?

Since you're rejecting my argument out of hand, reference the above quotations from A Christian Sceptic.

What you're doing is putting the Bible first, which seems entirely backwards given the chronology of events.

Nopers, not at all. I claimed that Christianity had a large hand in driving abolition. Humanist thought also had a large hand in it.

You have an interpretation which quite manifestly does not chime with what is written right there on the page in black and white. Jesus says that the law will not be fulfilled. How you can argue that he said the opposite is still eluding me.

Nopers. Reference Mobyseven's review of the same scripture. He says exactly the same thing I've been trying to say all along. :)

How can there be a 'fundamental message' when there is vast disagreement about what that 'fundamental message' might be? You can't on the one hand accept that people read the Bible to mean whatever suits them at the same time as saying there is a 'fundamental' message. It's a non-sequitor.

No it's not. There is a fundamental message if you follow the Christian thought. It boils down to "do unto others". That's it. No frills or frippery. That's Jesus' fundamental message (it's also a lot of other folks to, but again, different thread). That doesn't mean people reading the Bible don't use it for their own ends. They deny the fundamental message, support their position as they may, and do whatever they want. I wouldn't deny that, and haven't.

Seriously? You're now trying to say a verse that says "Servants, tremble before your masters" is actually talking about gainful employment, and not about servants and masters?

I didn't say it wasn't about servants and masters. Where did you get that? And yes, I do think it's about a servant's relationship to his/her job duties. Why is that so shocking? The authors seem to be saying that as a Christian you should be a good person in all aspects of your life, including whatever your job is, and whoever you're doing the job for. <shrug>
 
I suppose I can’t. I’ve done my best to explain how I understand the scripture to be interpreted (and widely, not in a limited sense to this discussion). :) But I do appreciate that you understood that Jesus was providing an either-or scenerio. I don’t know why I wasn’t able to get that portion of the text across to volatile and others before.

I understand that you have put your interpretation forward, but my point is that your point appears to be inconsistent with scripture itself. If the old laws were to be done away with, why does Jesus specifically restate a number of them, and then extend their application? If the old laws were to be done away with, why does Jesus not introduce any contradictary laws?

I would far prefer it if you would address my argument, rather than just telling me that I'm incorrect. If I'm incorrect, why am I incorrect?

As for the quotes, no, I didn’t miss them. We’ve discussed them all along. :)

They have, in a manner, been discussed, but the extent of that discussion appears to have been either, "They're out of context," or, "They don't actually condone slavery," of which neither argument actually holds up for most of the quotes - the quote from Timothy even refers to slaves owned by Christians! (See 1 Timothy 6:1-2)

How can the bible address slaves owned by Christians in such a manner, and not have it considered approval of slavery?

And yet, my church doesn't require it. Go figure.

I'd figure your church isn't a Christian church then. And no, not a no true Scotsman fallacy, to preempt that incorrect idea.
 
You skipped a step. Sloppy of you. How is making the slave property consistent with "love thy neighbor as thyself."

Thanks for the reply, though, it got a grin out of me.

DR

Glad I got a grin out of you, but how is my reasoning sloppy? The slave is property, and just like my television, my iPod and my mule (we are, of course, in first century Jerusalem here ;)) he is therefore not my neighbour. Property =! Neighbour. The slave, being property, is not my neighbour, so I don't have to love him.
 
Glad I got a grin out of you, but how is my reasoning sloppy? The slave is property, and just like my television, my iPod and my mule (we are, of course, in first century Jerusalem here ;)) he is therefore not my neighbour. Property =! Neighbour. The slave, being property, is not my neighbour, so I don't have to love him.

Pity that the text didn't come with an explanation of whom we are to regard as our neighbours. A worked example, say. That would have made things easier.
 
Nopers. Reference Mobyseven's review of the same scripture. He says exactly the same thing I've been trying to say all along. :)

Nearly the same thing. I recognise that the primary part of the verse is that nothing shall be removed until the law has been fulfilled. I wouldn't say it was an either-or statement: "Till heaven and earth come to pass" seems to me to be a hyperbolic metaphor - a way of saying, the only way this is ever going to happen is if the law is fulfilled. Sort of like if I said, "I'll buy a small Greek island if I work really, really hard the rest of my life...or win the lottery twenty times in a row." The second part isn't going to happen - it's just there to emphasise how hard I'd need to work to buy a Greek island.

We disagree, however, over the precise meaning of this. I take it to mean that until all the law is fulfilled none shall be removed, and that Jesus fulfills only the old laws - thus the old laws shall stand until the new are fulfilled. I justify this interpretation by pointing out that none of the laws Jesus then introduces contradict the old laws - in many situations he states an old law and then (far from contradicting it) he extends its application to give it a broader meaning (such as forbidding lust by extending adultery, anger by extending murder, and so on).

My question to you then is: I understand how you are interpreting that verse of scripture - but what is your justification for doing so? To me it seems as though the interpretation you propose (and it is a popular one) is a good way to get rid of some of the less desirable laws, but goes against the remainder of the very chapter it comes from.
 
Last edited:
Volatile, I certainly don't mean to speak for Darth Rotor as I have no idea of his personal beliefs, but I think I can speak for some of the christians I know that are also what I consider to be good thinkers.

As far as I can tell, there are a number of christians that intentionally don't think too much about the virgin birth, contradictions of scriptures, holy trinity, physical ascension and all that sort of religious stuff, but instead they choose to believe that Jesus was a smart dude who taught some good things about how we should be more forgiving, how we should try to love one another, and how we should take care of each other. And they enjoy going to a place that regularly reminds them and encourages them to think about these good things, and try to do them in their life. They feel their life is improved by doing this.

And sometimes they get ticked off by people that seem to assume all christians are rabid lying self aggrandizing proselytizers and feel a need to at least half heartedly chime in with a "well not all christians are like that, ya know."

Sometimes they jump to the conclusion that anyone that seriously questions their religion is one of the above, because they are regularly taught at church that this is so.

And these people don't really like talking seriously about their religion or the bible, because it means they would have to actually look hard at it, and deep down they know it doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but they don't want to stop, so they just choose to not talk about it much.

As I said before, I'm most definitely NOT trying to speak for Darth Rotor. I'm just saying, this is what I've observed in some other people.

Hope this helps.
 
Pity that the text didn't come with an explanation of whom we are to regard as our neighbours. A worked example, say. That would have made things easier.

What a strange, and incorrect, criticism. I don't need to show who is regarded as a neighbour for my argument to work. I merely need to show that slaves belong to a class of things that are not neighbours. Slaves are property, and property cannot be my neighbour (it is something owned by me, and therefore not equal to me).

Honestly, westprog, I would invest in some logic lessons if I were you. Your understanding of formal logic is extremely flawed.
 
I don't respond well to stupid loaded questions. See bolded words. My core objection to some of the complaints here is that they toss the baby out with the bathwater, and dwell only on the negative aspects of organized religion, in particular Christianity. No surprise on the latter, as familiarity breeds contempt, and we see few if any people willing to discuss Islam in depth. We have had some interesting discussions on Bhuddism, which I have always found refreshing.

Lose your Christian in a Kilt attitude, and you might find me less cynical. (Or not, I've been cynical for a long time, and I'm working my way up to curmudgeon. Seven years is my schedule.)

As I pointed out months ago, I am not formally trained in Christian apologetics. Any attempt I would make in that vein would be substandard, and probably not up to my own standards.

My faith works for me, and my family.

If it doesn't work for you, fine. Get on with it.

If you want to stand about kvetching about how awful Christians are, by engaging in the standard group think, country club attitude of self-reinforcing bias that screams off of the pages of this forum, that's fine too. Be aware that the darks, as well as the self appointed brights, are also in the club, Massa Volatile.

ETA: Reconcile "love thy neighbor as thyself" with the practice of slavery, if you can.

DR

Nobody doubts Christianity works for you DR. It is just that people like volatie and I wonder how this is any different from declaring that the religion of the Ancient Egyptian's works as a guiding principle in your life. I think we would both agree that if someone came on here declaring their belief in Osiris, we would think them either insane or a fool. Why is Christianity not treated the same?

I'm still bemused as to how slavery can be said to be anti-Christian when it is condoned in the New Testament more than a couple of times. If "Love your neighbour as yourself" is exempt from intense interpretation, why are the verses advocating the keeping of slaves not treated with the same literalism?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom