In fact, from my reading of various Muslim and non-Muslim sources, the practice appears to have been endemic in pre-Islamic tribal Arabic societies. The introduction of Islam did nothing to stop the practice, or many other similar pre-Islamic "female purity" practices, such as female genital mutilation; and different Islamic sects appear to have adopted them wholesale.
Something a lot of non-Muslims don't realize is just how variable and amorphous Islam really is. Christianity, Buddhism, Judaism, and most other major religious have a fairly well-defined set of holy scriptures and/or dogmas. Most of the schisms between the sects typically come as a result of differences of interpretation of the texts, rather than arguments over what exactly constitutes the holy texts themselves. There are exceptions, but not many. Islam, by contrast, has no well-defined set of texts outside the Quran. Like much of the rest of the Arabic world, the religion depends heavily on cult of personality. Schisms originally came about from disagreements over who would be the religio-political successor to Mohammad, and the leader of the world of Islam. On a relatively equal footing with the Quran is the hadith, the collected oral history of Mohammad's actions and teachings. Since the hadith were predominantly oral for over a century after Mohammad's death, there is a huge amount of debate over which ones are authentic, whether they should be accepted, and what the proper interpretation should be. The problem is that, unlike the relationship between the Torah and the Talmud, the Quran cannot be understood and interpreted seperately from the hadith. While they're not actually necessary for the religion, they are critical for application of the holy scripture to jusrisprudence and everyday life, and are thus inextricably linked to it. There is a strong belief by many secular Arabic and Persian scholars that few of them are authentic, and most were created long after the time of Mohammad to justify various practices not mentioned in the Quran or more reliable traditions.
So, briefly: They're crazy, but they have lots of written work by crazy people to justify themselves?
In all honesty, nice summary of a very strange religion, and a good explanation of why its so strange.
Last edited: