Death was the least that she deserved

In fact, from my reading of various Muslim and non-Muslim sources, the practice appears to have been endemic in pre-Islamic tribal Arabic societies. The introduction of Islam did nothing to stop the practice, or many other similar pre-Islamic "female purity" practices, such as female genital mutilation; and different Islamic sects appear to have adopted them wholesale.

Something a lot of non-Muslims don't realize is just how variable and amorphous Islam really is. Christianity, Buddhism, Judaism, and most other major religious have a fairly well-defined set of holy scriptures and/or dogmas. Most of the schisms between the sects typically come as a result of differences of interpretation of the texts, rather than arguments over what exactly constitutes the holy texts themselves. There are exceptions, but not many. Islam, by contrast, has no well-defined set of texts outside the Quran. Like much of the rest of the Arabic world, the religion depends heavily on cult of personality. Schisms originally came about from disagreements over who would be the religio-political successor to Mohammad, and the leader of the world of Islam. On a relatively equal footing with the Quran is the hadith, the collected oral history of Mohammad's actions and teachings. Since the hadith were predominantly oral for over a century after Mohammad's death, there is a huge amount of debate over which ones are authentic, whether they should be accepted, and what the proper interpretation should be. The problem is that, unlike the relationship between the Torah and the Talmud, the Quran cannot be understood and interpreted seperately from the hadith. While they're not actually necessary for the religion, they are critical for application of the holy scripture to jusrisprudence and everyday life, and are thus inextricably linked to it. There is a strong belief by many secular Arabic and Persian scholars that few of them are authentic, and most were created long after the time of Mohammad to justify various practices not mentioned in the Quran or more reliable traditions.

So, briefly: They're crazy, but they have lots of written work by crazy people to justify themselves?

In all honesty, nice summary of a very strange religion, and a good explanation of why its so strange.
 
Last edited:
So, briefly: They're crazy, but they have lots of written work by crazy people to justify themselves?

In all honesty, nice summary of a very strange religion, and a good explanation of why its so strange.

I once witnessed a Shiite Muslim and a Sunni Muslim engage in a fist-fight provoked by an argument about whether or not scripture required them to begin to break fast at the exact moment of sunset during Ramadan. A (presumably Sunni) policeman intervened, asked what they were fighting about, and, when told, then proceeded to help the Sunni beat the crap out of the Shiite.
 
In fact, from my reading of various Muslim and non-Muslim sources, the practice appears to have been endemic in pre-Islamic tribal Arabic societies. The introduction of Islam did nothing to stop the practice, or many other similar pre-Islamic "female purity" practices, such as female genital mutilation; and different Islamic sects appear to have adopted them wholesale.

Granted, but the discussion as I understood it was about traditions picked up after the advent of Islam outside of the Arabian Peninsula; if you want to include this area and time, fine by me!

As for the female genital mutilation, in my 'Umdat al-Salik it says the prepuce of the clitoris is to be cut away because it's "sunna" (meaning Muhammad did it / ordered it or "lived it this way"):

[quote='Umdat al-Salik, Purification - e4.0 THE BODY]

e4.3 Circumcision is obligatory (O: for both men and women. For men it consists of removing the prepuce from the penis, and for women, removing the prepuce (Ar. bazr) of the clitoris (n: not the clitoris itself, as some mistakenly assert). (A: Hanbalis hold that circumcision of women is not obligatory but sunna, whileHanafis consider it a mere courtesy to the husband.)[/quote]

Anyway, we had another case of an "honour killing" here in Hamburg, Germany:

Police arrested the man on Friday after the stabbing death of his 16-year-old sister early Friday morning in Hamburg's Sankt Georg district. Neighbours and a passing group of youths heard the girl screaming near the Berliner Tor metro stop and called police at 11:21 pm on Thursday. The girl died about an hour later at the scene of the stabbing.

The girl's oldest brother - like her a German citizen of Afghan origin - admitted to police he had killed her because she had turned away from her family, DDP reported. The family immigrated to Germany from Afghanistan 13 years ago, German news magazine Der Spiegel reported in its online edition.

:( Reminds me of another case where an Iraqi first stabbed his wife then poured gasoline over her and burnt her alive while she was dying for trying to leave him / get a divorce:

“No”, said the slightly-built man before the Munich criminal court, “I don’t regret that I killed my wife.” He would do it again. She would have earned it. And above all the politics of the Federal Republic of Germany are also guilty of her death. Why: “Because the women here have so many rights, they become immodest”.

...

As he spoke, there was there no indication that he could excuse this as acting out of his mind from rage or passion. Calmly, as if he were discussing a vacation, Iraqi Kurd Kazim Mahmud Raschid, 35, described why he murdered Sazan Bajez Abdullah, 24, his wife, why he stabbed her with a knife and then poured gasoline over the dying woman and set her on fire. His “culture and religion” obligated him “to do what I wanted to do”. And also her father-in-law wanted Sazan, who had brought dishonor over the family, to die: “If you do not kill her, then I am killing you”, he claims he had said, although the father denies it.

Link. :mad:

Let's wait for Joe to come in and talk some rubbish, shall we!
 
Last edited:
Regardless of what anyone in any other culture does, and what their justification is, I don't see why anyone feels they can judge it. I have sex outside of marriage and I talk to guys every day in public and in private! If I were the daughter of some strict machete-wielding Muslim, I would be dead. So I'm glad I live in America and my family's religious background is of the non-honor killing variety. That's it. They would say I'm a disgrace to my family and deserved to be killed, I would say that I have the personal freedom to do what I want. Who has the moral authority to judge which is correct?

Also, I'm sure whether she slept with the guy or not was besides the point. Talking to him in public is enough.
 
Regardless of what anyone in any other culture does, and what their justification is, I don't see why anyone feels they can judge it. I have sex outside of marriage and I talk to guys every day in public and in private! If I were the daughter of some strict machete-wielding Muslim, I would be dead. So I'm glad I live in America and my family's religious background is of the non-honor killing variety. That's it. They would say I'm a disgrace to my family and deserved to be killed, I would say that I have the personal freedom to do what I want. Who has the moral authority to judge which is correct?

Also, I'm sure whether she slept with the guy or not was besides the point. Talking to him in public is enough.

My morals come from, "Strive at all times to not be a ****ing dick." With very rare exceptions, killing someone is not allowed in this system.

So if you insist your daughters be locked up from the eyes of men, that's one thing.

Killing them for having an innocuous conversation is another.

Just because other cultures and mores exist doesn't make them right. My culture and its mores have things in them that are not right (selfishness, greed, hypocrisy) but we're not actively condoning petty killings.
 
Regardless of what anyone in any other culture does, and what their justification is, I don't see why anyone feels they can judge it. I have sex outside of marriage and I talk to guys every day in public and in private! If I were the daughter of some strict machete-wielding Muslim, I would be dead. So I'm glad I live in America and my family's religious background is of the non-honor killing variety. That's it. They would say I'm a disgrace to my family and deserved to be killed, I would say that I have the personal freedom to do what I want. Who has the moral authority to judge which is correct?

Also, I'm sure whether she slept with the guy or not was besides the point. Talking to him in public is enough.

Well, if you are a christian you should not judge and you should woory about the beam in your on eye. That being said, don't you think there is a line somewhere that is just unacceptable, no matter what that culture believes is right? You obviously don't believe honor killing meets this criteria, how about sexual molestation of children? Or, maybe human sacrifice? Cannalbalism? How about human sacrifice AND cannablism?
 
Regardless of what anyone in any other culture does, and what their justification is, I don't see why anyone feels they can judge it. I have sex outside of marriage and I talk to guys every day in public and in private! If I were the daughter of some strict machete-wielding Muslim, I would be dead. So I'm glad I live in America and my family's religious background is of the non-honor killing variety. That's it. They would say I'm a disgrace to my family and deserved to be killed, I would say that I have the personal freedom to do what I want. Who has the moral authority to judge which is correct?
I do. And you know why?

I don't murder women for talking to guys in public.

I think this gives me the moral high ground here.
 
Granted, but the discussion as I understood it was about traditions picked up after the advent of Islam outside of the Arabian Peninsula; if you want to include this area and time, fine by me!
Well, the "advent" of Islam covers a huge amount of time. It was well over a century, at least, before it became effectively codified. Most of the major schisms occurred over the next two centuries, starting with the Sunni/Shi'a split immediately following Mohammad's death; and there was a considerable amount of modification that occurred to the hadith and other essential scriptures and commentaries during this time. During this time, Islam spread to pretty much all its historically-consistent major centers of influence in the Middle East, Asia Minor, and North Africa, and absorbed local customs along the way. On top of that, there had already been a considerable amount of trade and travel throughout the region by that time, so there was a lot of overlap of custom as well.
As for the female genital mutilation, in my 'Umdat al-Salik it says the prepuce of the clitoris is to be cut away because it's "sunna" (meaning Muhammad did it / ordered it or "lived it this way"):
Indicating that the practice predated Muhammad in his own homeland.
 
Who has the moral authority to judge which is correct?
Each and every person has the moral authority to judge between what is right and wrong. The fact that so many of them choose to not only choose the wrong, but even enshine it as if it was the morally superior position, doesn't change the fact that it's wrong.

And it's a very simple, very clear jugement to make. Removing all religion, removing all hair-splitting philosophical debate; it comes down to one simple thing: self-determination. The right to determine for one's self how best to live one's own life, doing whatever one feels is best for one's self, as long as doing so doesn't infringe on the equal right of someone else to do the same. Any culture which does not recognize this, and attempts to restrict this right by force, is wrong, period. Allowing people to voluntarily form communities which conform to a more restrictive worldview wouldn't violate this principle. Forcibly imposing such a worldview on others, preventing dissenters from disassociating themselves from it, or preventing members from learning of or communicating dissenting viewpoints, would violate it.
 
I am reminded of the words of the British Governor of India Charles Napier

from Wikipedia said:
A story for which Napier is famous involves a delegation of Hindu locals approaching him and complaining about prohibition of Sati, often referred to at the time as suttee, by British authorities. This was the custom of burning widows alive on the funeral pyres of their husbands. The exact wording of his response varies somewhat in different reports, but the following version captures its essence:

"You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: when men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom