How do you know when a War On Terror is won?

I had a little stroll on the DITIB-webpage (since DITIB was the organizer of the event, or protest) and came across this little press statement about apostasy. Maybe you can imagine why I was a bit confused. But hey, even DITIB can change (or can they?)! Some time ago when I was on their page they had instructions for women and a rather scary definition of honour and what constitues the 'breach' of it. Read about it here. Now, mind you, their webpage is probably the least consulted place for guidance seeking Muslims. It's rather the hundreds of mosques with their imams who are being sent over to Germany from Turkey. Yea.

Maybe you can see why I don't really trust such organizations. Especially not those who are being controlled by the Turkish ministry for religion. When they pull off their demonstrations, well, good for the Muslims who believe that. For DITIB it's probably just that - propaganda in the name of Islam.

Oh and call me paranoid, but if "To kill innocent people does not mean jihad", does killing the 'guilty'?

[qimg]http://c.imagehost.org/0465/0_1020_409624_00.jpg[/qimg]

ok lets see. Ditib stated that rejection of Islam in islam does not call for deathpenalty. they revered to the koran twice.

then you link to wiki to show me that islam does demand deathpenalty. funny is when you change to german, it states that the Sharia laws indeed do punish with deathpenalty for moslems rejecting Islam. And also state that there is no justification for it in the koran.

what is it now?

and your remark about killing innocent does not mean jihad is kinda strange as you speak german very well.....
 
If I am not mistaken he has published a book or books with positions of holocaust denial a few years back. This was mentioned in one of the reports of the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, or Verfassungsschutz. I think it was the Baden-Württemberg one. My understanding is that he has not gone back to publically proclaim this view, because of understandable repercussions that would await him in Germany. This guy is a propagandist par excellence, who covers many things with his various movies or 'documentaries' to lure people into Islam.



I don't know about shalom, but you are wrong about Islam. Islam means submission. Submission to 'Allah'.




Yes, publically they might condemn things like 9/11 or other things. What they do in their mosques is a different thing. Not that I'd have any evidence to the contrary regarding 9/11; it's not my concern at the moment what they think of 9/11. Publically they won't and can't say different anyway. But this is hardly the only matter. Organisations like DITIB are actively working against any integration as we understand it. Their understanding of integration is pretty much just that - to integrate Muslims into a foreign society without interacting much with this foreign society. See this in case you haven't already. You might also know the farce that has been going on for years we call 'Integration Summit' where they let 'orthodox' and 'fundamentalists' voice their opinion and actively shape the 'integration process'. You can imagine much woo-ing is going on there. As a matter of fact so much that the 'moderates' or ex-Muslims have left the discussions for the most part already.

and those books are? i really would like to know, cause i would never link again to him.

lure people into Islam..... okey? ( irrational fear comes to mind)

where does the word Islam come from?

aah i see, you are also a CT :)

while i fear that mighty people inside governments might have conspired
you fear the muslims to conspired against us. those evil Allah worshippers that gather in those evil mosques and heck out al those terror atacks around the globe.woooo scary :D

but hey for everyone his own CT :)

but i partialy agree on the integration part. there are indeed those moslems that run around in theyr almost burkas (forgot how they are called) that are living very isolated and hang around only with others like they are.
btw they dislike those moderate fluffy moslems, kinda antimonolithic.
but they are still a small minority around here, but its a shame they live that way, but hey its their life, each his own way.
i know the same from Jewish people, orthodox jews. its almost impossible to get in contact with them. but hey if they want so. i atleast prefer the jewish clothes :) but then again i found also friends among the jews living in my neighberhood, they was not orthodox but still jews.
btw there are italians that are here for some 40 or more years, they almost speak no german, hang around only with other italians, they have italian schools for their kids.

that is not an islamic problem.
 
Last edited:
Irrational behavior? Not as such, no.

Irrational fear? Well....

What's irrational about it? Jihad is - like I told Cheney just now - hardly the only matter.

Fine, quintolithic then. Do you see them as able to change an evolve over time or are they still the same dangerous people Mohammad and the Qur'an define them to be?

What is quintolithic? Monolithic x 5? You have to take in account Islam's main source of power - unity in form of the caliphate - was abolished about 80 years ago and their territory was split up. There's a good reason you see stuff like this:



From 3:34 onward said:
ONE UMMAH
ONE DAY...
ONE WAR
ONE PEACE
ONE WAR
ONE PEACE
ONE STRUGGLE
ONE GOAL

ONE VOICE

Gee, I wonder what those peace loving Muslims mean with that, when they say this in the context of the re-establishment of the caliphate. You know what the Ummah is though, don't you?

They have their 'freedom fighters' doing the jihad for them right now as we speak all over the world and Muslim charity organizations are supporting those. Giving money to their jihadists is a nice and accepted form of giving 'zakat' mind you and apparently it comes close to fighting yourself.

When you generalize your hatred of certain members of a large group to the group as a whole, as you do when say the religion is dangerous rather than just the extremists, you are irrationally (see? I didn't forget) prejudiced against that group.

Good grief. Please point out where I said I hate anyone. I'd be surprised if you were able to actually find a spot. I'll quote a Ziggurat for now.
For some time now I feel like what Ziggurat says here:

No, you do not correctly understand my argument. You never have. Your counterarguments have always consisted primarily of misunderstanding or misrepresentations of my argument.

Shame.
 
Last edited:
ok lets see. Ditib stated that rejection of Islam in islam does not call for deathpenalty. they revered to the koran twice.

'to revere' bedeutet verehren. Was du meinst ist 'to refer'.
Anyway, 2:256 and 109:6. See here and the end here for some Ibn Kathir. Both does not touch apostasy if I am not very mistaken. Or have some Jalalayn here and here. As for the latter, notice the following:

You have your religion, idolatry, and I have a religion’, Islam: this was [revealed] before he was commanded to wage war [against the idolaters] (all seven Qur’ānic readers omit the yā’ of the genitive possessive construction [in wa-liya dīni] whether with a pause or without; Ya‘qūb, however, retains it in both cases).

then you link to wiki to show me that islam does demand deathpenalty. funny is when you change to german, it states that the Sharia laws indeed do punish with deathpenalty for moslems rejecting Islam. And also state that there is no justification for it in the koran.

Just goes to show how much influence the ahadith have. Stoning isn't in the Quran either, yet it's prescribed in shari'a.

I don't know what you mean when you say 'when you change to German'; do you mean when you have a look at the German version? If so, that is not what I linked to.

what is it now?

If I remember correctly you can leave Islam before you reach puberty. After that it's pretty much your death warrant to leave. There is a reason why ex-Muslims and converts are being threatened all over the world including those in our countries. And, on the fly, I'd say it's only the logical outcome to this kind of action when you consider the animosity towards any non-Muslim, except for maybe the 'people of the book', namely Christians and Jews (and Zoroastrians, but they're as good as extinct as far as I know).

and your remark about killing innocent does not mean jihad is kinda strange as you speak german very well.....

It might be strange to you, since you apparently didn't understand it. What a surprise.
 
and those books are? i really would like to know, cause i would never link again to him.

I'm pretty sure it was one book and it was Turkish and I am not going to get you a copy or whatever it is you want here. Just google for him and the Verfassungsschutzbericht of.. I think 2004.

lure people into Islam..... okey? ( irrational fear comes to mind)

Idiocy came to mind when I read your reply.
If you'd sit through one of his propaganda pieces you'd know what I mean.

where does the word Islam come from?

Stop JAQing off and do some yourself.

aah i see, you are also a CT :)

Excuse me? No I'm not. Obviously you haven't spend any time on what Muslims say publically compared to what they preach in their sermons and other events. If you got about an hour I recommend 'Dispatches - Undercover Mosque

UK Channel 4, aired 15th January 2007.
Radicalisation of UK mosques by Saudi Wahabbism'



while i fear that mighty people inside governments might have conspired

Without any evidence whatsoever, yes.

you fear the muslims to conspired against us. those evil Allah worshippers that gather in those evil mosques and heck out al those terror atacks around the globe.woooo scary :D

Heck out, ha, funny you (what he used is part of a German proverb 'etwas aushecken' - to concoct or plot something). But yea, exactly. Since you're a conspiracy tard I know this might never sink in. Then again, I don't know what your stances are on the London bombings, the Madrid bombings or the failed bombings of German trains. This is no fantasy, this is a real threat.

btw there are italians that are here for some 40 or more years, they almost speak no german, hang around only with other italians, they have italian schools for their kids.

that is not an islamic problem.

No, but it's also bad. Personally I can't even understand those people. They're missing out on so much.
 
Last edited:
What's irrational about it?
What is irrational about believing there is a global conspiracy bent on world domination and that most, if not all, Muslims are in favor of it?

I can't imagine what I was thinking.... :rolleyes:


What is quintolithic? Monolithic x 5?
Divided by 5, actually. I was playing on words again. It's not important.

You have to take in account Islam's main source of power - unity in form of the caliphate - was abolished about 80 years ago and their territory was split up.
A moment ago, you were arguing that you did not believe Islam was monolithic. Are you now arguing that it is (or wants to be) monolithic?


Good grief. Please point out where I said I hate anyone.
Sorry about that, Captain Literal. Your posts just ooze love for the peace loving Muslim people you accuse of funding an Islamic NWO.
 
What is irrational about believing there is a global conspiracy bent on world domination and that most, if not all, Muslims are in favor of it?

I can't imagine what I was thinking.... :rolleyes:

Either you don't understand my position yet again, over and over and over again, or you are really wilfully doing this ****. And I'm fed up with it.

A moment ago, you were arguing that you did not believe Islam was monolithic. Are you now arguing that it is (or wants to be) monolithic?

Yes and no. Those people you see in the video want one unified entity called caliphate. The last caliphate was a Sunni one I suppose, if that makes you happy. Seriously, what is your problem?

Sorry about that, Captain Literal. Your posts just ooze love for the peace loving Muslim people you accuse of funding an Islamic NWO.

Islam's goal is world domination. Like it or not. If it makes you happy to have modifiers like Sunni or Shia, here, have some:

Shia

Sunni

See, your problem still is that you are apparently too much of a dolt to recognize when I am talking about Islam and when I am talking about Muslims.
Either that, or you are wilfully doing this, which I suspect.
 
Obviously you haven't spend any time on what Muslims say publically compared to what they preach in their sermons and other events.

I'd like to add this transcript of another BBC programme. You should read it, Cheney and you as well, Upchurch. But Upchurch, you should read up on something called 'CAIR' and their connections to terrorists. Since you're American I deem it to be of more interest to you.
 
Okay, help me reconcile these statements:

Islam's goal is world domination. Like it or not.

mrbaracuda said:
Gee, I wonder what those peace loving Muslims mean with that, when they say this in the context of the re-establishment of the caliphate.

Upchurch said:
What is irrational about believing there is a global conspiracy bent on world domination and that most, if not all, Muslims are in favor of it?
Either you don't understand my position yet again, over and over and over again, or you are really wilfully doing this ****.
Exactly what part of your position don't I understand?
 
"Gee, I wonder what those peace loving Muslims mean with that, when they say this in the context of the re-establishment of the caliphate."

You see me applying that statement to all Muslims, correct?
Well that is not the case. I am applying it to those taking part in the events actively rallying for a new caliphate - with all the consequences. And this wish for a new caliphate is pretty common among Muslims mind you. If I am not very mistaken: According to Islam a caliph is supposed to be there to lead the 'Ummah' to whatever, victory, world domination; you name it.
 
"Gee, I wonder what those peace loving Muslims mean with that, when they say this in the context of the re-establishment of the caliphate."

You see me applying that statement to all Muslims, correct?
Well that is not the case. I am applying it to those taking part in the events actively rallying for a new caliphate - with all the consequences.
And how many Muslims do you think that means?

If it is most Muslims, my statement stands. If it is few, then you are once again painting the entire group with the negative aspects of a small faction.
 
Do you see them as able to change an evolve over time or are they still the same dangerous people Mohammad and the Qur'an define them to be?

They changed over time for a period. But as I said before, the gates if ijtihad are closed. Go look it up if you don't understand what that means.

When you generalize your hatred of certain members of a large group to the group as a whole

mrbaracuda already objected to this, but it bears repeating: I haven't seen him say he hates anyone. Your accusation of hatred on his part is unsupported. But since you regularly fail to understand your opponent's position, I'm not surprised to see you baselessly attribute negative qualities to him as well.
 
Yes. Thank you, Captain Literal, Jr.

That's a cop-out. He not only hasn't used the literal word "hate", he hasn't even said its equivalent. You are using a strawman to vilify him, engaging in ad hominem attacks against him by labelling his position as one of hatred. And that should be beneath you, but it really isn't. For you, it's just sadly typical.
 
the war on terror will be won when islamic extremists no longer seek to harm the usa.

which will be...never.

never ending war...is very very profitable.
 
And how many Muslims do you think that means?

Millions. I suppose you could count those in of your Gallup poll who are for shari'a, since shari'a prescribes a caliphate. One motivator for the establishment is the discontent with their individual governments, which for some is not Islamic enough, not Islamic at all or shari'a wrongly implemented. Whether the individual Muslims really know what comes with the establishment or not. But this is the form Islam was lead and maintained by from its early days, from Muhammad to his four successors and the empires. So there's a great appeal not only from a shari'a POV.

Now, personally, I really don't see how they can establishing a caliphate soon; most likely not even in my lifetime. I'd be very surprised with all the animosity and hatred towards each other among the Arab countries and their current (especially split up) state.

If it is most Muslims, my statement stands. If it is few, then you are once again painting the entire group with the negative aspects of a small faction.

Get it in your head already that it's not a small faction which adheres to these negative aspects.

They changed over time for a period. But as I said before, the gates if ijtihad are closed. Go look it up if you don't understand what that means.

Yes Upchurch, do that. I gave you a list of terms. Have you looked them up at all or will you continue to talk out of your ass coming from the superfluous 'it's like Christianity' viewpoint?

mrbaracuda already objected to this, but it bears repeating: I haven't seen him say he hates anyone. Your accusation of hatred on his part is unsupported. But since you regularly fail to understand your opponent's position, I'm not surprised to see you baselessly attribute negative qualities to him as well.
That's a cop-out. He not only hasn't used the literal word "hate", he hasn't even said its equivalent. You are using a strawman to vilify him, engaging in ad hominem attacks against him by labelling his position as one of hatred. And that should be beneath you, but it really isn't. For you, it's just sadly typical.

Neither am I surprised and it really does seem typical for him. At least it's not the first time I see this happening if I am not mistaken. Like I said: Shame.
 
Last edited:
He not only hasn't used the literal word "hate", he hasn't even said its equivalent.
Does it really take that much of a cognitive leap to infer "hate" from words like "dangerous" and "just want to kill me"?

Look, we obviously have two different perspectives going on here. I believe in holding people accountable for what they actually do. You two believe that the entire group is responsible. You see this as religious in nature. I see it (both the conflict and the use of religion) as political in nature. I think you are unfairly lumping the good with the bad. You think I'm being naive.*

At this point, I guess we're just talking past one another and not really listening to what the other is saying. I knew I wasn't going to convince you of anything and you haven't shown me anything that convinces me, anyway.




* I'm being broadly general here. For ed's sake, take it the way it was meant and don't over parse it.
 
afaik comes salam, silm, shalom and islam from the semitic s-l-m. thus i would say one can indeed translate it that way.


Sin-Lam-Min is a triconsonantal root from which a wide range of Semitic words are produced. There is no related meaning between these words, and translating one as another is total nonsense.
 
I find it odd that one of the factors for Islamaphobia is the thought that Islam is a political ideology. By that logic many Muslims are thus Islamaphobes.
 
At this point, I guess we're just talking past one another and not really listening to what the other is saying.

No, you are.

I find it odd that one of the factors for Islamaphobia is the thought that Islam is a political ideology. By that logic many Muslims are thus Islamaphobes.

Beautiful term, isn't it? Oh by the way, the PM of Turkey sees Islam as a monolith. Better watch out for that Islamophobe!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom