1337m4n
Alphanumeric Anonymous Stick Man
- Joined
- May 10, 2007
- Messages
- 3,510
Anything that debunks flyover, debunks NoC
CIT proponents ignore all debunking of Flyover, passing it off as "we don't argue for flyover, we argue for NoC".
However, this handwave is defeated by Craig Ranke's own logic. In the PentaCon video, he explains how it is impossible for the plane to have both hit the Pentagon AND flown north of the Citgo. This is given all available evidence and witness testimony. The entire CIT case is contingent upon this. If CIT abandons the argument that the plane hitting the Pentagon and NoC flight path are mutually exclusive events, their entire case falls. It is what their entire case is based on; without it, I can just say, okay, the plane flew north of the Citgo, but it was still Flight 77 and it was still flown by Islamic radicals, and it still hit the Pentagon. The official story is no longer contradicted. CIT MUST accept that P(Plane hitting the Pentagon | Plane flying north of the Citgo) = 0, or else they don't have anything on the "official story".
Now if we accept that these are mutually exclusive events, I will now show that flyover is the only possibility for NoC. CIT's own witnesses all agree on and corroborate one fact: that the plane hit the Pentagon. CIT's handwave is that the fireball must have covered the plane so that everyone would be fooled into thinking that it crashed. This REQUIRES a Flyover, because there is no other option. What else could have happened? Did the plane tunnel under the Pentagon? Did the plane phase out of physical timespace and go through the Pentagon? Did the plane suddenly lose all forward momentum and go around the Pentagon? There is simply no other logical possibility. If the plane flew on the NoC flight path, then it MUST have flown over the Pentagon.
And therefore, any argument that debunks a flyover in turn debunks NoC, by the transitive property of mathematical logic.
QED.
CIT proponents ignore all debunking of Flyover, passing it off as "we don't argue for flyover, we argue for NoC".
However, this handwave is defeated by Craig Ranke's own logic. In the PentaCon video, he explains how it is impossible for the plane to have both hit the Pentagon AND flown north of the Citgo. This is given all available evidence and witness testimony. The entire CIT case is contingent upon this. If CIT abandons the argument that the plane hitting the Pentagon and NoC flight path are mutually exclusive events, their entire case falls. It is what their entire case is based on; without it, I can just say, okay, the plane flew north of the Citgo, but it was still Flight 77 and it was still flown by Islamic radicals, and it still hit the Pentagon. The official story is no longer contradicted. CIT MUST accept that P(Plane hitting the Pentagon | Plane flying north of the Citgo) = 0, or else they don't have anything on the "official story".
Now if we accept that these are mutually exclusive events, I will now show that flyover is the only possibility for NoC. CIT's own witnesses all agree on and corroborate one fact: that the plane hit the Pentagon. CIT's handwave is that the fireball must have covered the plane so that everyone would be fooled into thinking that it crashed. This REQUIRES a Flyover, because there is no other option. What else could have happened? Did the plane tunnel under the Pentagon? Did the plane phase out of physical timespace and go through the Pentagon? Did the plane suddenly lose all forward momentum and go around the Pentagon? There is simply no other logical possibility. If the plane flew on the NoC flight path, then it MUST have flown over the Pentagon.
And therefore, any argument that debunks a flyover in turn debunks NoC, by the transitive property of mathematical logic.
QED.
Last edited: