Are antioxidants woo?

What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

The difference is that homeopathy at its core is ineffective and dangerous. Modern medicine is very effective. While it's true that some hospitals/doctors/insurance companies make mistakes, the foundation of these institutions is rock solid.
 
The difference is that homeopathy at its core is ineffective and dangerous. Modern medicine is very effective. While it's true that some hospitals/doctors/insurance companies make mistakes, the foundation of these institutions is rock solid.

I would have said homoeopathy is ineffective and close to 100% safe, while modern medicine is somewhat to very effective and often extremely dangerous.
 
I would have said homoeopathy is ineffective and close to 100% safe, while modern medicine is somewhat to very effective and often extremely dangerous.

I guess it depends on your definition of safety here. It's legitimate to say that homeopathy is safe in the sense of "no side effects", but there is the fact that choosing to use homoepathic "treatments" for many otherwise treatable conditions can result in increased morbidity and mortality over using effective medical treatments. In that sense, it's also reasonable to say that homeopathy is dangerous -- but it's dangerous like not wearing your seat belt, rather than dangerous like using an airbag.
 
Most people i know have no medical insurance. Seeking treatment can be a debilitating experience, especially for general malaise or health problems that are a matter of lifestyle.
They drive long distances; take time off from work, without pay, and do a lot of waiting in offices...frequently coming away from it all no better than they were.

In the case of broken bones and obviously needed surgeries, its a different matter.
 
In a culture that has become increasingly deficient in fruit and vegetable intake, even if "anti-oxidants" are woo, I don't see the hype about them as harmful in any way. Instead, I see it encouraging people who would not normally eat/drink fruits and vegetables to do so -- thus actually being beneficial, even if the benefit is not exactly the one advertised.

Homeopathy has no such benefit, except to line the pockets of the people selling ineffective products.

As to the discussion of problematic experiences with modern medicine: Yes, I have had numerous issues in getting proper treatment from medical professionals. Yes, these experiences have left me jaded towards the medical community in general. But do I think that those are problems with medicine itself? No. Once I was finally able to find a doctor who wasn't more concerned with the monthly fee my HMO would pay than he was about my health, I was able to be treated effectively. Of course, that meant ditching health insurance all together and instead paying out of pocket for everything... Which, surprisingly has been less expensive than the insurance premiums :boggle: Anyway, my medical situation would not have been able to be treated without modern medicine, let alone diagnosed. They didn't exactly have PET scans 100 years ago. I don't think the problem is with medicine or science. I think the problems we experience with the medical community are, in general, socio-economic in nature or even just differences in personality.
 
It's well supported that the deaths from all causes(sum of all deaths, not deaths from each individual cause) is lower among people who eat a diet heavy in fruits, vegetables and legumes; that's really all I care about.

I happen to really like eating fruits, vegetables and legumes and I find the desire to distill the active compounds down to some kind of magical elixir that allows you to eat disgusting food and still derive some of the benefits of eating properly kind of silly.
 
In a culture that has become increasingly deficient in fruit and vegetable intake, even if "anti-oxidants" are woo, I don't see the hype about them as harmful in any way. Instead, I see it encouraging people who would not normally eat/drink fruits and vegetables to do so -- thus actually being beneficial, even if the benefit is not exactly the one advertised.


Forgetting the point of "doing the right thing" for a moment, one thing I bump into daily at my work is that the pro-organic movement markets the higher antioxidant levels of their products as a significant health benefit. Organic products cost almost double the price of similar non-organic products, sometimes even more. This combined with the fact that, at least in my town, many pro-organic people are poor well meaning modern hippies, who are forced to use their money on expensive organic foods instead of cheaper non-organic foods that are as healthy. It doesn't take much to come up with possible problems in this scenario.
 
Last edited:
A concern I've had about supplements, which may be complete nonsense, is that our digestive system might get "lazy" (for lack of better word) at getting the most vitamins out of normal foods. Opinions?
 
What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

Beautiful post! I agree. Issues of negligence or mistakes in the conventional medical profession should never be ignored, since by exposing them and campaigning for change, procedures might be improved.

In an old article in the "FDA Consumer magazine", it quotes some statistics:

Based on a recent report on medical mistakes from the National Academy of Sciences' Institute of Medicine, ... the IOM estimates that 44,000 to 98,000 Americans die each year not from the medical conditions they checked in with, but from preventable medical errors. ...

The Institute of Medicine (IOM) estimates that fully half of adverse reactions to medicines are the result of medical errors. ...

The statistics in the IOM report, which were based on two large studies, suggest that medical errors are the eighth leading cause of death among Americans, with error-caused deaths each year in hospitals alone exceeding those from motor vehicle accidents. ...

But the numbers in the report don't tell the whole story, its authors acknowledge. People in the hospital are just a small proportion of those at risk. ...
http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/2000/500_err.html

I personally know of people who had years of problems because their conditions weren't diagnosed.

Still, focusing entirely on the negative ignores the wonderful health improvements that've been made possible for lots of people by medical advancement.

I think the person who posted after you made a good point about how though medical science is error-prone, at least it works a lot of the time, whereas things like homeopathy won't. But I don't entirely agree that such things are never useful, because the placebo effect can be very powerful in some circumstances. What maybe needs to happen is that there needs to be more investigation into why these things sometimes work, so the factors that make them work can be harnessed. For instance, one reason why such things can alleviate physical pain and increase well-being is because having a lot of attention paid to you by a caring person who prescribes you something you believe in so it reduces your stress, can reduce your muscle tension that might have been causing you pain, and increase your body's ability to fight certain ailments, because stress impairs the functioning of the immune system, so being with someone who helps you relax, if the feeling of relaxation lasts some time beyond the time when you see them, can sometimes improve your lot physically.
 
A concern I've had about supplements, which may be complete nonsense, is that our digestive system might get "lazy" (for lack of better word) at getting the most vitamins out of normal foods. Opinions?

You mean much like regularly taking laxatives can cause "lazy bowel syndrome". Interesting thought.
 
Yes.

At least according to the Cochrane Collaboration.


And according to The American Heart Association.



And most recently, according to the WAFACS study.



So, why are we focusing all our energy on homeopaths? Why aren't we going after Pom, Emergen-C, and all the other "health drinks" which cost a fortune and do nothing?

Just curious.

Who's this "we" that are focusing "all" our energy on homeopaths? Skeptics have been after the dietary supplement industry from day one. Antioxidants fall under dietary supplement and crackpot diet critiques.

Homeopathy is only a small slice of the healthfraud pie.

My impression is that subjects on JREF Forums are reflect the level of participants' discussion, rather than the level of general interest. Homeopath subjects are common, because homeopaths start topics and debate relentlessly. ie: they fuel discussion out of proportion to ordinary interest.

If there were a few more antioxidant supplement MLM apologists on the forum, we'd be asking why skeptics spend all their time talking about it.
 
Last edited:
Most people i know have no medical insurance. Seeking treatment can be a debilitating experience, especially for general malaise or health problems that are a matter of lifestyle.
They drive long distances; take time off from work, without pay, and do a lot of waiting in offices...frequently coming away from it all no better than they were.

In the case of broken bones and obviously needed surgeries, its a different matter.

Well, that's not an issue with medical treatments. That's an issue with medical policy (which is, I agree, terrible). A friend of mine had her doctor's visit to determine the medical necessity of further care itself ruled medically unnecessary by her insurance company.

That should make your head hurt all on its own.
 
Most people i know have no medical insurance. Seeking treatment can be a debilitating experience, especially for general malaise or health problems that are a matter of lifestyle.
They drive long distances; take time off from work, without pay, and do a lot of waiting in offices...frequently coming away from it all no better than they were.

In the case of broken bones and obviously needed surgeries, its a different matter.

this is a failure of politics though not medicine.
 
In a culture that has become increasingly deficient in fruit and vegetable intake, even if "anti-oxidants" are woo, I don't see the hype about them as harmful in any way. Instead, I see it encouraging people who would not normally eat/drink fruits and vegetables to do so -- thus actually being beneficial, even if the benefit is not exactly the one advertised.


This depends on if they get the antioxidants from fruits or vegetables or buys some antioxidant fortified sugar water.
 
I suppose it could be a problem if they took antioxidant supplements instead of going to the doctor to get prescribed some useful heart medication, thinking antioxidants would be just as good.
 
What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.

it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.

What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.

For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?

Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.

Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?

Can we hear from you, please?

As a health professional, I would say this.

1. You are correct, mistakes happen, all too commonly, in conventional medicine. The inadequacies of standard medicine, however, does not legitimize in any way, the use of other forms. As for the "faith" in conventional medicine, most of it is built, at least nowadays, on the fact that most times we are in fact correct both in our diagnosis, and in the treatments, when available, for the diagnosis.

2. The trouble I have with a variety of "alternative" medicines, is the lack of quality evidence to back up their claims. The reason we are discussing this, the OP, provides prime examples.

eg. I can tell you that the soup of boiled canary feathers can increase your "well being" and how are you or anyone else going to prove me wrong?

Well one of the ways can, is to perform a double blinded randomized control trial, where we boil the canary feathers and provide the "soup" to group A (a group of randomized individuals), and then to group B (also randomized) we provide a similar tasting "placebo" drink. Now neither the experimenters, or the guinea pigs know which one they get. We then use a scale, let us say, that will provide us with some idea that the persons "well being" has been made better, and we use this scale on every participant, both group A and B, and see how they compare.

The trouble is you can find virtually no such data on any of the major "alternative" medicines, and if you do, it is usually riddled with errors, or uses such a small population of participants, as to render the results poor in terms of extrapolation.

In science, in medicine, we have various grades of evidence, with the DBRCT (Double Blinded Randomized Control Trial) being the sort of "gold Standard" or Grade A evidence, various other study types falling after this, and the weakest forms of evidence being "Expert Opinion" and "Anecdotal accounts".

"Alternative Medicine" is full, to the top, with "Expert Opinion" and "Anecdotal Evidence" but near baron of the more rigorous forms of evidence.

TAM:)
 
The trouble is when trials take place and drug companies hide some of the data. For instance:

Drugs giant GlaxoSmithKline knew that the anti-depressant Seroxat could not be proved to work on children in 1998, according to a leaked internal document.

The secret document, relating to two clinical trials held in the 1990s, reveals that drug trials had shown little or no effect on helping depression in minors.

The company was also advised to avoid publishing the full data because it would be "commercially unacceptable" and would "undermine the profile" of the drug.

The confidential paper, sent anonymously to BBC's Panorama programme, reveals that the company were advised to publish only the positive aspects of one study and that there were no plans to publish a second - more negative - study.

It also urged GSK not to send the data to the regulators because they would have had to include a statement about the effectiveness of the drug. ...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/panorama/3454873.stm
 
In a culture that has become increasingly deficient in fruit and vegetable intake, even if "anti-oxidants" are woo, I don't see the hype about them as harmful in any way. Instead, I see it encouraging people who would not normally eat/drink fruits and vegetables to do so -- thus actually being beneficial, even if the benefit is not exactly the one advertised.

This is similar to the idea that the ends justify the means. What's the danger of making false claims about antioxidants if they get people to eat more fruits and vegetables?

The problem is that you get people claiming to have pills and tonics with "pure" antioxidants in them and marketing them as alternatives to fruits/vegetables/medicine/excercise/etc. Or you get other forms of spinoffs and hybrids that, at best, waste people's money and, at worst, convince them to forgoe effective activities and cures.
 
So, does anybody here know of a good source for boiled canary feathers?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom