What bothers me about these arguments on this website is the background faith in legitimate medical intervention. I don't like woo. really, i don't.
it is often mentioned that some people that eschew legit medical treatment for homeopathy and such waste their money for no benifit; sometimes dying from their stupidity.
What is often ignored is the amount of money and time and pain that people go through in their effort toward legitimate medical treatment. It often fails. Sometimes, catastrophicly. I wish we could address this stuff with some true statistics.
For every child that dies because their parents were a-hole Christian Scientists, or homeopaths, how many die because of crappy hospitals, lousy surgeons, and the poverty that often comes with doing the right thing?
Its like a speck in the eye, all this woo.
meanwhile, there's a log in our collective eye regarding our faith in modern medicine.
Any one here ever have a bad experience with modern medical treatment?
Know anyone that did?
Can we hear from you, please?
As a health professional, I would say this.
1. You are correct, mistakes happen, all too commonly, in conventional medicine. The inadequacies of standard medicine, however, does not legitimize in any way, the use of other forms. As for the "faith" in conventional medicine, most of it is built, at least nowadays, on the fact that most times we are in fact correct both in our diagnosis, and in the treatments, when available, for the diagnosis.
2. The trouble I have with a variety of "alternative" medicines, is the lack of quality evidence to back up their claims. The reason we are discussing this, the OP, provides prime examples.
eg. I can tell you that the soup of boiled canary feathers can increase your "well being" and how are you or anyone else going to prove me wrong?
Well one of the ways can, is to perform a double blinded randomized control trial, where we boil the canary feathers and provide the "soup" to group A (a group of randomized individuals), and then to group B (also randomized) we provide a similar tasting "placebo" drink. Now neither the experimenters, or the guinea pigs know which one they get. We then use a scale, let us say, that will provide us with some idea that the persons "well being" has been made better, and we use this scale on every participant, both group A and B, and see how they compare.
The trouble is you can find virtually no such data on any of the major "alternative" medicines, and if you do, it is usually riddled with errors, or uses such a small population of participants, as to render the results poor in terms of extrapolation.
In science, in medicine, we have various grades of evidence, with the DBRCT (Double Blinded Randomized Control Trial) being the sort of "gold Standard" or Grade A evidence, various other study types falling after this, and the weakest forms of evidence being "Expert Opinion" and "Anecdotal accounts".
"Alternative Medicine" is full, to the top, with "Expert Opinion" and "Anecdotal Evidence" but near baron of the more rigorous forms of evidence.
TAM
