Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

I have already said that we must theists and atheists agree that we exist objectively, and start from that point to discuss whether God exists or does not exist.

Then would you do us the favor of reading the posts addressed to you and responding? Sticking your head in the sand does not actually advance your cause any; it merely makes us all think you're a nutjob.

:deadhorse
 
I have already ...etc.etc. bandwidth.


Yrreg
I have made non-evasive posts directly to your question (or at least to the question this thread was about before you changed the criteria): the question of whether it is empirically possible both to know both that God exists, and whether the God so known meets what you have given as a definition. I used your definition of God. If you accuse others of evading that definition, you are either lying or being very careless in your reading of posts! I repeat: throughout this thread, I have accepted your working definition of God as the basis for discussion.

You accuse others of evasion and irrelevancy. I contend that your narrowing of the confines of the discussion, and refusing to acknowledge posts that do not meet your additional criteria, is evasion and irrelevancy, indicative of an unwillingness to discuss issues in good faith. We do not need to list the organs of perception in order to address the epistemological problem of whether we can know certain things about God. That would be true even if you could somehow demonstrate that there is a God and that his existence could be empirically proven.

You insisted on starting with a "quintessential" definition of God, and when it was pointed out to you that there is no one such universal definition, you provided your own. Good enough: I think that is the only way to proceed without misunderstanding, and I find it quite acceptable to continue the discussion using your working definition of God.

I assert that your defninition of God, like most others, is inherently incapable of being empirically proven, because the characteristics involved are not perceptible attributes or qualities. The best you could do, if a divinity were to prove its existence and whatever perceptible qualities accompany it, would be to arrive at the rest of the definition through logic, testimony or faith.

I repeat, this would be the case no matter what the organs of perception are, and even if you were to invent or imagine new organs of perception to get around the obstacle that God has so far not been shown to be perceptible using the commonly accepted set of sensoria.

Stop evading and let's start discussing.
 
I would just like to make some comment on these for my own satisfaction. I mean to try to understand what the charges are and make some reply
<snipped the best parts, sorry>
Ok, so we are going to talk about Brahma? Do you see the problem ?

Bravo, Fiona. A real pity that if this is read that it won't be comprehended or acknowledged by yrreg. And it is the answers he has been asking for all along but doesn't want to know.
 
Yes, lots of people believe there is a god which is
an existent entity independent of man's mind creator of heaven and earth and everything.

Lots of people believe in other gods.

Atheists don't.
 
Robert Downey Jr. was not in Iron Man.

Sorry, he wasn't.

You're wrong. I'm right.

If you think I'm wrong I require you to answer this question: "How could Robert Downey Jr. be in Iron Man if, by definition, an Iron Man would be made of Iron, where Robert Downey Jr. is made of flesh and blood?"

Don't respond unless you want to have a serious exchange of ideas about this issue.
 
It seems, after several hundred posts, that this thread is asking 3 main questions:


1. What do you know to be the quintessential concept of God among theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2008 c.e?

2. What exactly is an empirical test by which God must be susceptible to in order that His existence can be established to the satisfaction of atheists?

3. What do you think are the organs of man's experiences by which man gets to know realities outside his mind and also inside his mind?​


I admit I didn't know the answer to the first question. So I did some research into theistic scientists and found quotes regarding God from the likes of Blaise Pascal, Robert Boyle, Sir Isaac Newton, Sir William Herschel, Michael Faraday, and Sir Joseph Lister. I now realize that these folks are long dead and do not represent the thought of theistic scientists of 2008 c.e. I wouldn't know where to begin to look, nor would I have the time, to come up with a reliably accurate answer to the question. I think some sort of research organization that conducts surveys would need to be involved to get accurate results to that question. However, one survey that I did come across shows that only 7% of scientists could even be called theistic.

Yrreg proposed the following as being what the majority of contemporary theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists consider to be the quintessential concept of God:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


But, there are two caveats:

i. This is his concept of God and may or may not be representative of all theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists today in 2008 c.e

I have already said time and again that my concept of God is the following:

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, the creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


ii. The question that the above is the answer to now seems to have been given a Christian slant:

...what learned theists in particular Christian theistic thinkers understand quintessentially the concept of God as...


Although I have my doubts that there are many Christian concepts of God that don't mention Salvation, or Grace, or remission of sin, or Jesus, I will take yrreg at his word and accept that the quintessential concept of God among contemporary theistic scientists, philosophers, and artists is what he says it is. As many others in this thread have also done.


I don't have a specific answer to the second question either. Haven't scientists, theistic or otherwise, been working on that one for quite a while? I don't know whether this counts as an empirical test or not but I wonder if we could set up a mountain into the sea experiment? This is based, of course, on the words of Jesus where he said:
Mathew 21:21 said:
Jesus answered and said unto them, Verily I say unto you, If ye have faith, and doubt not, ye shall not only do this which is done to the fig tree, but also if ye shall say unto this mountain, Be thou removed, and be thou cast into the sea; it shall be done.


We currently have mapped all the continents as well as the sea floor. If a mountain moved from the land to the sea we would surely be able to detect it. This experiment is repeatable too since it appears to be addressed to all believers and there are plenty of mountains on this planet.


As for the third question, I would say that the organs for detecting realities outside man's mind would include:

  • Light detecting organs (e.g. eyes)
  • Sound detecting organs (e.g. ears)
  • Chemical detecting organs, gustation (e.g. tongue)
  • Chemical detecting organs, olfaction (e.g. nose)
  • Pressure detecting organs, somatic sensation (e.g. skin)
  • Temperature detecting organs, thermoception (e.g. skin)
  • Pain detecting organs, cutaneous, somatic and visceral

As for "realities outside his mind and also inside his mind," I will not even attempt that one and await the responses of those more qualified to handle that type of question.
 
I will not answer any messages here where the author says that I am lying.

So, use the search function here and find your use of the word lying on me, rewrite the message and inform me by pm that you have removed the word lying from the message, and also revise the message making it more civil, and I will consider reacting to your thoughts.



Yrreg
 
Will you answer any of the questions where the poster doesn't accuse you of lying? How about my question in your "Why I am angry at atheists" thread?
 
So, use the search function here and find your use of the word lying on me, rewrite the message and inform me by pm that you have removed the word lying from the message, and also revise the message making it more civil, and I will consider reacting to your thoughts.



Yrreg

Who said you were lying?
Can you give us the quote so we might evaluate the claim?
 
The ultimate proof of self-existence.

There is no need to prove one's existence to oneself.

However, not referring to anyone here, if a person cannot be sure of his existence and has to insist that people prove to him that he exists outside his own mind, and is pestering others to prove to him his objective existence...

I will tell that person that he is sick.

If he is insisting that he is not sick but of sound mind and full consciousness, then I will challenge him to employ the ultimate proof to himself by himself of his own existence: by getting a gun and shooting himself in the head.

Or just slitting his jugular veins so that before he stops existing as a live being he can already know prior to departure that he is existing but on the way to non-existence.




Yrreg
 
Here is my definition of God, if you don't like it, please leave.

God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


If you want me to prove God's existence by empirical testing, please just first give me a brief exposition of what is empirical testing, and most important the organs of man whereby he can experience existing entities outside his mind as also inside his mind.

If you don't give me a brief and coherent and workable exposition of empirical test or evidence, and enumerate the organs of man for experiencing realities outside his mind as also realities inside his mind...

Please go away and don't come back here.


Don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
 
There is no need to prove one's existence to oneself.

However, not referring to anyone here, if a person cannot be sure of his existence and has to insist that people prove to him that he exists outside his own mind, and is pestering others to prove to him his objective existence...

I will tell that person that he is sick.

If he is insisting that he is not sick but of sound mind and full consciousness, then I will challenge him to employ the ultimate proof to himself by himself of his own existence: by getting a gun and shooting himself in the head.

Or just slitting his jugular veins so that before he stops existing as a live being he can already know prior to departure that he is existing but on the way to non-existence.
Why should anyone need to prove their own existence to themselves?

How about YOU prove the existence of your god to everyone else? How about you take a gun to your god and shoot it?
 
Last edited:
My time is my own and the forum bandwidth is not yours or mine to dictate.

I don't agree with your definition of god (liking doesn't really come into it).

You are the one claiming existence for your god. The burden of proof of that god's existence falls squarely on you.

Do you have evidence to bring to the thread? If so, please post such evidence.
 
God is an existent entity independent of man's mind, creator of heaven and earth and everything.​


If you want me to prove God's existence by empirical testing, please just first give me a brief exposition of what is empirical testing, and most important the organs of man whereby he can experience existing entities outside his mind as also inside his mind.

If you don't give me a brief and coherent and workable exposition of empirical test or evidence, and enumerate the organs of man for experiencing realities outside his mind as also realities inside his mind...
Your definition of god is garbage.
Your attempt to special plead your way out of providing evidence is garbage.
Your continued trolling attempt is garbage.

Please go away and don't come back here.
No.

Don't waste people's time and this forum's bandwidth.
You first.
 
There is no need to prove one's existence to oneself.

Then why bring it up?

However, not referring to anyone here, if a person cannot be sure of his existence and has to insist that people prove to him that he exists outside his own mind, and is pestering others to prove to him his objective existence...

How about if he thinks there's an invisible sky buddy watching over him?

I will tell that person that he is sick.

Try calling him kettle instead.

If he is insisting that he is not sick but of sound mind and full consciousness, then I will challenge him to employ the ultimate proof to himself by himself of his own existence: by getting a gun and shooting himself in the head.

Sort of like challenging someone to come up with proof of any gods. The same method could be used.

Or just slitting his jugular veins so that before he stops existing as a live being he can already know prior to departure that he is existing but on the way to non-existence.

Back to suggesting suicide for anyone who doesn't share you world view?



Weird, just weird.
 
Who said you were lying?
Can you give us the quote so we might evaluate the claim?

I did.

Yrreg said:
Another example of their refusal to come to concurring concepts is their to the present willful silence on what is empirical testing or evidence, when they are the ones to have waved furiously the flag of empirical testing.

Fiona said:
That is a lie. You have been told by several people what counts as evidence: it is a demonstration that god has an effect on the world which is detectable in the same way as your effect is detectable: let him build a building or stand on my toes or do anything which would change the world as much as the smallest baby can when it sicks up its milk.

I stand by the charge. I have no need of the search function to find it: I made the statement quite deliberately. I did not say he lied because I was emotional nor through frustration. From my perspective it is a simple statement of fact.

I do not intend to

Yrreg said:
rewrite the message and inform me by pm that you have removed the word lying from the message, and also revise the message making it more civil, and I will consider reacting to your thoughts.

because to revise the message would be pussyfooting about and I intend to express my thought in plain language, as Yrreg has recommended.

So Yrreg: put up or shut up. I say you are a liar: show me how this is not the case and I will apologise happily. But show me
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom