Atheists, are you ready to talk God and no God?

Yrreg:
Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God.

Does this mean that empirical evidence is whatever you can imagine/fantazise?
 
You know what, guys?

What we need are professional experts in conflict resolution to settle our conflicts, that should save us so much time and trouble, and the forum bandwidth.

.

So are you unable to answer questions that conflict with your method of empirical testing?
 
Last edited:
At this point in time I have discovered that I will insist on my own concept of God which is:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

And another discovery is that I want to suggest to you people here, who don't want to accept for a concept of God on a hypothetical basis my concept of God, then not to post here, and even just to put me on ignore, so that you will not waste time and forum's bandwidth.
How can we stay on topic for this OP if Yrreg first ignores, then changes it?
Moderators?
 
Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 2 ]

Good man, Randfan, did you see my title of post #594 above, it says: Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.





[ Title: Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. ]


I have been trying to get you people to come to a concept of God that I first and then you will agree on for a hypothetical God, and work from that concept to discuss whether such a God exists or cannot exist.


At this point in time I have discovered that I will insist on my own concept of God which is:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

And another discovery is that I want to suggest to you people here, who don't want to accept for a concept of God on a hypothetical basis my concept of God, then not to post here, and even just to put me on ignore, so that you will not waste time and forum's bandwidth.


Someone, Wowbagger, brought up the need for empirical testing to ascertain the existence of such a God.

That is another discovery for me, that God if He does exist should be susceptible to empirical testing.


So I am now into the empirical testing of God; that is why I am asking people to list the organs of man for empirical testing of the existence of anything and everything that is outside man as inside man.

No one mentioned man's brain which I was hoping someone to bring up, so I took the initiative to bring it up in order to save so much time for everyone, and forum bandwidth.


Now my position is that man's brain is an organ of man's experience, empirical testing, the ultimate and the indispensable organ.

Man's brain is the organ for man to experience consciousness and reason and intelligence, and also to engage in consciousness and in reasoning and in processes of intelligent thinking.



This is thus my thesis at this point of the thread:

Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God.​

What things?

Things like for example communication satellites and the moon, which both we see to be orbiting the earth, which earth we are consciously experiencing with our feet firmly planted on it.


[...]



I will attend to your post #595, the rest I will not give attention to, so you have to bang your head against the wall to see whether your brain might be activated enough for you to get to the consciousness that they have nothing to do with the biggest pictures of things, in other words, you are playing dumb or you are really dumb.

Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson

See next post from me, it will take some time for me to draft a good reaction.



Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well threads develop, Czarcasm. This one is developing in a rather unusual way. The OP asked us to come to some concept of god which we could agree on, and this has been done insofar as Yrreg eventually presented his definition and several posters agreed to proceed on that basis. For myself I thought the aim of that was to clear the ground for a discussion and I imagined that having established agreed terms we would go on to discuss something: but for some reason that does not seem to be the case.

I do not know any longer what the topic is: if it is an agreed definition of god we have achieved that and there is no more to say: I suspect it is not. My impression is that the topic of the thread is Yrreg's deep philosophical insight: and the method of demonstrating that is insult and obfuscation. But I still hope to be proved wrong
 
I have been trying to get you people to come to a concept of God that I first and then you will agree on for a hypothetical God, and work from that concept to discuss whether such a God exists or cannot exist.


At this point in time I have discovered that I will insist on my own concept of God which is:

An existent entity independent of man's mind,
creator of heaven and earth and everything.​

And another discovery is that I want to suggest to you people here, who don't want to accept for a concept of God on a hypothetical basis my concept of God, then not to post here, and even just to put me on ignore, so that you will not waste time and forum's bandwidth.


You should have done from the start. The way you began was disingenuous.


Haha, gotcha!

I cannot take you seriously. In fact, every time you say this, I feel painfully embarrassed for you. For the sake of mature reasoning, could you please refrain?
 
I do not know any longer what the topic is: if it is an agreed definition of god we have achieved that and there is no more to say: I suspect it is not. My impression is that the topic of the thread is Yrreg's deep philosophical insight: and the method of demonstrating that is insult and obfuscation. But I still hope to be proved wrong
Am I wrong in thinking that all of this boils down to all of us agreeing that Yrreg has a specific idea about what God is? Why does he need our consensus on his opinion??
 
Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things. [ Take 3 ]

Quote:
Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God. -- Yrreg


Your posts are somewhat confusing. I'll acquiesce to your demand regarding questions.


Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?

Quote:
What we need are professional experts in conflict resolution to settle our conflicts, that should save us so much time and trouble, and the forum bandwidth. -- Yrreg


Much of the conflict is the result of your unwillingness to answer questions or engage in discussion. If you would respond and answer questions things would go much smoother.

Please answer the questions.


Here are your questions which I find to be apropos to the thread at the present point of development, apropos, i.e., on the basis of man's brain being the ultimate organ for the experience of everything, starting with consciousness and conscious reasoning and intelligent processes, and the use thereof.


1. Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

2. Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

3. Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
​


Answers:

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

3. Yes.




Yrreg
 
Good man, Randfan, did you see my title of post #594 above, it says: Concentrate on the biggest pictures of things.
That doesn't help anything. If I don't understand something I can only ask questions. Please answer those questions.

I will attend to your post #595, the rest I will not give attention to, so you have to bang your head against the wall to see whether your brain might be activated enough for you to get to the consciousness that they have nothing to do with the biggest pictures of things, in other words, you are playing dumb or you are really dumb.
Attacking me personally won't advance the discussion. Banging my head against the wall won't help anything. I just need for you to answer questions.

See next post from me, it will take some time for me to draft a good reaction.
Thanks.
 
Concentrate on the biggest pictures. [ Take 3 ]

Quote:
Man has empirical evidence of God with the use of his brain: to be conscious of things and to reason and think intelligently on things to arrive at the existence of God. -- Yrreg


Your posts are somewhat confusing. I'll acquiesce to your demand regarding questions.


Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?

Quote:
What we need are professional experts in conflict resolution to settle our conflicts, that should save us so much time and trouble, and the forum bandwidth. -- Yrreg


Much of the conflict is the result of your unwillingness to answer questions or engage in discussion. If you would respond and answer questions things would go much smoother.

Please answer the questions.


Here are your questions which I find to be apropos to the thread at the present point of development, apropos, i.e., on the basis of man's brain being the ultimate organ for the experience of everything, starting with consciousness and conscious reasoning and intelligent processes, and the use thereof.


1. Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

2. Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

3. Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
​


Answers:

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

3. Yes.




Yrreg
 
Here are your questions which I find to be apropos to the thread at the present point of development, apropos, i.e., on the basis of man's brain being the ultimate organ for the experience of everything, starting with consciousness and conscious reasoning and intelligent processes, and the use thereof.

1. Is it your position that consciousness is empirical evidence of the existence of god?

2. Is it your position that the ability to reason and think intelligently empirical evidence of the existence of god?
I'm happy to accept your "concept of god".

3. Are the moon and satellites proof of the existence of god?
​
Answers:

1. Yes.

2. Yes.

3. Yes.
Thank you.

  • Is there any reason for anyone else to agree with these propositions?
  • Can you tell us what that reason is?
 
Would you be disposed to accept this statement from me:

[ Again this caveat: of course without your ever admitting that God exists all, but just to get to know what exactly you are denying the existence of, namely, God's existence, which is quintessentially the concept of God by theistic scientists, theistic philosophers, and theistic artists. ]​


God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.​


If you think that the statement above should be corrected, then please suggest your corrections and we can discuss on revising this very first statement on the concept of God, to arrive at one that is mutually acceptable to you and me.

Yrreg
Since you are disinclined to discuss clarification, I will accept for the record that you believe that God is an existent entity independent of man's mind.

Now that that is out of the way, and now that it would be silly to discuss by which senses you gather evidence, could you please tell us what empirical evidence there is to support your premise?
 
I tried, by god, to come up with a god that would satisfy theists and atheists, as per the o.p.

Most atheists, I assume, believe that the existence of the universe is independent of themselves. Should they choose to think of the universe as god, which I believe is possible, what, if anything then defines them as atheists?

Is it that they don't presume to understand the totality? That they are content to continue learning about the nature of that god? Does it have to do with worship?

Awe? Belonging to an organized religion? A desire for an ethical life?
We can certainly have a personal relationship with the universe. We effect it; it effects us; we are 'of' it; it nourishes us...on and on.

What is it, exactly, that defines a person as theist or atheist?
Certainly, believing in multiple gods can count as a religion...though mono-theism is the new game.

Is a proper god somehow seperate from the universe?
Is that the problem?
 
I have just skipped from post #440...

Have I missed anything worthwhile?
 
Since god is that which created the universe and everything, the fact that we think the universe and everything exist is proof that god exists.
Did I get it right gerry?
 
You miss information and the nano factory of a living cell.

Breckmin, let me try to break down your argument to its constituent parts, so that hopefully you can understand why we think it's fallacious.

1. Everything that we know was designed by humans looks designed to humans.
2. Everything that was designed by humans has a designer (a human, and most of the time we know exactly who that designer was)
3. Everything that looks designed to humans must have a designer.
4. If it looks designed it must therefore have a designer, and if we know that the designer wasn't human, then it must have been designed by God.
5. Therefore, the appearance of design proves God.

Old argument from others perhaps. This is not my argument.

I consider the above in someways to be a strawman.

You would have been better off to start with information that is transcribed,
translated, recognized to provide instructions to form a particular operation,
etc. . If I formulated an argument based on our uniform and repeated experience with such information, the conclusion would be that information
needs an intelligence source. That would be closer to one of my arguments.

~Michael
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom