Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?

The matter of indoctrination.

I like to ask you if you subscribe to the statement time and again made by atheists that babies are born atheists.

Next, you do subscribe to the statement that atheists simply lack belief in God?


I seem to get the impression that atheists give themselves the credit of intelligence in the formulation of those two statements.


Let's focus on the first statement:

Babies are born atheists.​




Yrreg


You all seem to agree among yourselves that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.

I see that some bring up the matter of indoctrination, saying that babies are born atheists unless or until they are indoctrinated in the belief in God.


The topic of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, "Is atheism an intelligent worldview?"


Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?





Yrreg
 
Bravo! These are great questions, yrreg.
Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?
The answer to both of your questions depends upon HOW the person came to those conclusions and not the conclusions themselves.

Your person could be atheist/thiest for intelligent or unintelligent reasons. It all depends on the person in question.

If the person says,
God makes the sun appear in the sky every day to provide light. Why else would the sun appear in the sky? That would be reasonable, as he is unaware of the valid heliocentric solar system model.

If he was to say, god makes leaf-doodoo pie and therefore god loves me. Well, that would be just crazy jibberish.
 
Last edited:
Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?

The answer to both questions is: It depends on what information he has available to him.

You would do well to look up the concept of deism about now. People who grow up to believe in god without any indoctrination often become deists. What the typical deist believes is something you would not like.

You may not be able to recognize it, but there are more than two possible outcomes to the situation you describe. Belief and non-belief in higher powers is not a zero sum game.
 
Bravo! These are great questions, yrreg.
The answer to both of your questions depends upon HOW the person came to those conclusions and not the conclusions themselves.

Your person could be atheist/thiest for intelligent or unintelligent reasons. It all depends on the person in question.

If the person says,
God makes the sun appear in the sky every day to provide light. Why else would the sun appear in the sky? That would be reasonable, as he is unaware of the valid heliocentric solar system model.

If he was to say, god makes leaf-doodoo pie and that proves therefore god loves me. Well, that would be just crazy jibberish.

Oh sure, beat me to the best possible answer!
 
Oh sure, beat me to the best possible answer!
Well, to be fair, your's is a better answer as it includes the excluded middle.

But mine says leaf-doodoo pie, which has that going for it.
 
Pretentious wanking often makes me go AAH. Or OOH. Or whatever.

Then again, that's not pretentious at all - it's quite apretentious.
 
How? Anyhow, the question is his intelligent use of his brain.

How? Anyhow, the question is his intelligent use of his brain.


Read again my post, and answer my questions as you would answer them intelligently in an essay test on reading comprehension, where you cannot ask any questions of the guy watching that you don't do anything dishonest like copying from some texts surreptitiously brought in -- you are only allowed to bring with you your working brain, but paper as much as you need and ball pens are freely provided.




Please don't tergiversate and think that you are so smart.


Don't waste readers' time and this forum's bandwidth.




Yrreg
 
Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?

I suppose you can suppose anything into your argument Yrreg, but lets suppose the babies are all agnostics and have no other human to teach indoctrination. How would they contract a belief in something that requires faith without any proof of it's existence and be confident that it exists?
 
Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that Santa Claus exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that Santa Claus does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?
 
How? Anyhow, the question is his intelligent use of his brain.

You already have your answer twice.

Read again my post, and answer my questions as you would answer them intelligently in an essay test on reading comprehension, where you cannot ask any questions of the guy watching that you don't do anything dishonest like copying from some texts surreptitiously brought in -- you are only allowed to bring with you your working brain, but paper as much as you need and ball pens are freely provided.
Two of us did that and came up with very similar answers. Nobody copied anybody else. Your assumption here that we are just copying each other here is rather arragant on your part and tells us who is not thinking.

Consider the answers rather than just rejecting that which you don't want to hear. You have no legitimate reason for not responding to us.


Please don't tergiversate and think that you are so smart.
I did not see anybody trying to be smart or even silly when answering your latest question. The two most likely things seen in this latest post here is either dishonesty or ignorance on your part. Either we tell you what you want to hear or reject it if you don't like it. To bad for you. Have somebody you trust read this tread and then ask them why you are not getting through to people.
 
Last edited:
How? Anyhow, the question is his intelligent use of his brain.
I answered this.

The intelligent use of his brain isn't measured by the answer but by the process that the answer was derived. It is the only way to distinguish between a logical intelligent answer and a lucky guess.



Read again my post, and answer my questions as you would answer them intelligently in an essay test on reading comprehension, where you cannot ask any questions of the guy watching that you don't do anything dishonest like copying from some texts surreptitiously brought in -- you are only allowed to bring with you your working brain, but paper as much as you need and ball pens are freely provided.
This is arrogant and insulting.
 
You all seem to agree among yourselves that babies are born atheists because they lack belief in God.

I see that some bring up the matter of indoctrination, saying that babies are born atheists unless or until they are indoctrinated in the belief in God.


The topic of this thread is

Are atheists acting intelligently in embracing atheism?​

In other words, "Is atheism an intelligent worldview?"


Suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God exists, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?


Now, suppose when a baby as he grows up all by himself without any other humans indoctrinates himself that God does not exist, by the use of his brain.

Is he acting intelligently?





Yrreg

A person acts intelligently if he or she believes what is reasonable. It has nothing to do with what you know when you are born. A baby is also born not believing in the principles of buddhism or the ridiculous lies of scientology. What bearing does this have on the truth of those ideas? Your attempt to link atheism with neonatal ignorance is nonsense.
 
Before I can answer your question, I need you to define "baby" in your own words, in 15 words or less. I will return to this thread in 24 hours.
 
See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.

See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.


Just in case atheists don't know what is to tergiversate, just look up that word in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.




Yrreg
 
See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.


Just in case atheists don't know what is to tergiversate, just look up that word in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.




Yrreg


I'll save everyone the trouble:


tergiversate -
To be evasive or ambiguous


Would you like to explain how the answers given to you were evasive of ambiguous? Just in case theists don't know what it is to be evasive or ambiguous, just look up those words in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.
 
See? readers here, they atheists here are as always tergiversating.

"I do not think that word means what you think it means."

Just in case atheists don't know what is to tergiversate, just look up that word in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.




Yrreg

"I do not think that words means what you think it means."

Ohhhhh... What about 'Not having a conversation? What about theists who refuse to have a conversation, and ignore anything that doesn't have their preferred outcome?

How about you just let us know your conclusion, so we can all get along with out lives, and you can stop wasting bandwidth?


Are Atheists using intelligence when they choose Athieism?

YES

Are theists using intelligence when they use big words to try and point out how stupid atheists are?

NO, they just think they are.

Your refusal to actually address anything anyone has said here tells a lot about you. Your constant repeating of your posts, expecting your preffered outcome, but not getting it, shows you are insane.
 
I'll save everyone the trouble:


tergiversate -
To be evasive or ambiguous


Would you like to explain how the answers given to you were evasive of ambiguous? Just in case theists don't know what it is to be evasive or ambiguous, just look up those words in five good standard well-patronized English dictionaries.

Yregg's dictionary:

tergiversate - To not give the answer that the speaker is expecting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom