Religion's value questioned

Apparently you are a person who looks to the state for your instructions. It's hard to know if you live in America or some other nation where the people are not protected by the Constitution...

...My dear, you may need the 10 Commandments to save your sorry ass out of jail but most thinking humans whether agnostic or secular certainly do not. You sound very young and you might indeed need help when you start breaking small laws and find it is hard to break that habit.

...If you were raised in front of a television, it might be that you missed this learning event.

What a SUPERB example of the ad hominem fallacy. In addition to be logically invalid, these comments also appear to lack understanding of methods of persuasion. Insults, be they passionate, powerful, or merely clever, have been proven to persuade people... to the opposite opinion. One of the know tactics of politics is to discredit the opponent by using a schill to "support" the opponent's arguments in a rude and insulting manner... thus discrediting the arguments. Again, it is an ad hominem fallacy - the intelligence, personality, or manners of a proponent have absolutely no logical correlation to the legitimacy of her/his position. BUT it works. Humans unfortunately tend to first judge the arguer, and only later, if at all, the argument.

For example, I might make the obvious argument: "Two plus two is four, and only an a-hole would disagree."

My readers would FIRST conclude that the real A-Hole here is me. Only secondarily would they conclude that I had somehow stumbled on the truth.

However, lets make an argument that is just slightly less obvious: "You can dye from lack of sodium in your diet, but you a fat dumb@ss liberal you might not unerstand that." (spelling and grammar errors intentional)

In this case, those who know sodium is a necessity conclude the writer lacks education, intelligence, and basic social skills, and that he should probably be banned from decent society. However, if the reader does not know anything about nutrional requirements, he is very likely to ALSO conclude that the statement itself is false because the writer is obviously untrustworthy.

So y'all lame asses need to listen up and be polite so you can at least pretend to have some brains in those empty skulls of yourn.
 
we (!) are obligated (!) to train (!) our children to instinctively (!) make choices (!) for which they (!) will be responsible (!).

There is so much wrong with this sentence that I find it hard to even guess at where it went wrong in the first place. However, I don't think that it has much to do with being "mountain-nature lovers". I also cannot relate it to "the joy we have in doing this".
 
My family raised and trained horses and dog and we did it without the bible. At no time did we threaten hell and damnation when our animals failed to obey. I did not use hell and damnation but a simple set of rules of right over wrong.

Hmm... wanting animals to "obey" you indicates a rather discredited approach to animal training! And do people really still think that animals understand "right" and "wrong"?
 
Hmm... wanting animals to "obey" you indicates a rather discredited approach to animal training! And do people really still think that animals understand "right" and "wrong"?

I hope this is sarcasm. Please tell me it is.

If animals had no comprehension of right and wrong behavior then we'd never be able to train them, never mind the entire problem that would occur in pack animals or animals that even rarely interact with their own species.
 
I hope this is sarcasm. Please tell me it is.

No, it's not.

If animals had no comprehension of right and wrong behavior then we'd never be able to train them, never mind the entire problem that would occur in pack animals or animals that even rarely interact with their own species.

Non human animals are not, by and large, moral agents. (Of course, it's debateable in species such as the "higher apes" etc. but I'm referring to cats, dogs, horses etc.). They certainly understand reward and punishment. For example, the reason your dog looks "guilty" when you return home to find he's crapped on the floor, is not because he thinks he's done something "wrong". It's because he's scared he's going to get yelled at or hit.

It is not necessary to assume that animals have an understanding of right and wrong in order to train them. Contemporary "reward based training" using the principles of behavioural psychology is a successful method.

Animals, particularly pack animals, have evolved behaviours that enable group living, but that does not mean they "understand right and wrong".
 
How would you be able to tell the difference?

Now that's a good question. :)

Actually I don't think human beings "understand right and wrong" either. I mean, I don't think issues of "right and wrong" are anything other than issues about rules enabling pack behaviour, even when applied to humans.

I suppose I'm arguing against the view that animals should be held "morally accountable." At least, I think that's what I mean. :confused:
 
Being an atheist, of course, I would like to believe the results of this study. My problem with this study is that many other factors could explain the results, aside from faith. Comparing the US to Japan or Norway, factors such as guns, or racial inequities, could also be at the heart of these disparities in wealth, social disfunction, crime and murders.

Were these factors even taken into account before the "correlations" were drawn?

Exactly. This type of argument against religion is one that frequently pops up here. It's an argument of convenience. Nothing more. It can be applied to anything, even science, and is therefore useless.
 
Well, the writer of the letter did mention that correlation does not imply causation. However, many things seem to indicate that misery is a very good starting point for developing a religious sentiment.

In experiments participants who lacked control were more likely to perceive a variety of illusory patterns.

When the former socialist countries in Eastern Europe decided to try with capitalism instead, which lead to large-scale impoverishment paranormalism was rampant, and when people are so poor that they cannot feed their children, they use superstition as an excuse to abandon them.

On the other hand, in Scandinavia religion seems to be slowly dying out, and even (some) vicars don’t believe in god. And the Scandinavian countries are allegedly the happiest in the world.
Happiest Countries in the World. "And the U.S. ranked only 23rd, due to nagging poverty and spotty health care."
Denmark, the World’s Happiest Country
Map of World Happiness.
Reasons to visit the world’s happiest country
The Happiest Place on Earth
Denmark ‘Happiest’ Country in the World
Denmark happiest country in the world

However, I can still think of a lot of things wrong with conditions in Denmark, which we have to do away with in order to abolish religion as the illusory happiness of the people. There is still way too much poverty and superstition.
 
The problem I have with the supposed positive influence of religion is that the influence is inconsistant. That is, that the same set of beliefs and doctrine can result in such disparate behavior. The example I use in discussion is Catholicism. The same book, same doctrine, same belief and the same devotion to the Pope led Mother Terresa to go to India and devote her life to the care of the poor, deseased and orphaned, and also led Torquemada to torture and murder hundreds of thousands of his countrymen.
To conclude that the same belief led to both behaviors seems difficult. It would seem to make much more sense that belief only furnished a form for behavior that was based on character. Had Torquemada appeared at a different time and place he might well have done the same job for Hitler or Stalin that he did for the Pope.

My $0.02

Robert Klaus

I'm fairly certain I'd be guessing accurately if I were to guess that neither Torquemada nor Mother Teresa actually read much of the Bible. And their beliefs, and the God they imagined they were devoting themselves to, might actually have been very different indeed, even if they did both grow up Catholics. They still could have grown up with their churches teaching very different things from each other.

It may be that Torquemada didn't even believe in God. Someone on another forum quoted me something from the Catholic Encyclopedia a while ago, which was a list of Bible quotes that had been put together hundreds of years ago to justify the Catholic Church's persecution of those they considered heretics. It was a list of snippets from the New Testament, all taken out of context, so their meaning was distorted, and the collective whole could have looked to someone who hadn't actually read the Bible like a convincing document instructing Christians to persecute non-believers. Anyone familiar with the Bible would have spotted instantly that it was a deceptive attempt to twist it to fit the corrupt ends of those who put it together.

But those were the days when you could actually be killed for having the Bible in your own language! So laymen wouldn't have been able to tell that, in the unlikely event that they could have got hold of the document. Also, they were the days before the mass media, and the days before even the printing press, I think, so anyone who did want to blow the whistle would probably have been captured and killed long before word got around to many people at all.

Many of the people in power in the Church were not people with an interest in spreading and following the message of the New Testament. That much is obvious from the results of their control of the Church, when you compare it to the many, many beautiful and inspirational verses in the New Testament that tell people to treat others with brotherly love and respect and consideration etc.

It may be that many of the people in power in the Church didn't even believe in God. They can't have taken The New Testament that seriously, because they certainly weren't cowed by the threats of hell for those who live immorally into obeying such verses, although paradoxically, it was partly the danger they believed heretics posed to the eternal life of anyone who became their followers that motivated them to seek them out. More sense can be made of the paradox if these people hadn't read the Bible themselves but had just been indoctrinated with certain beliefs, so they saw certain things as being of all-importance while not paying attention to others.

Having said that, torture and death were common punishments and means of discipline of the day for law-breaking, apparently. So the inquisitors were often using techniques in common use, not inventing new and unusually harsh punishments.

But also, religion could be used by the Church as a means to make lots of money from the masses, and a means of social control over them. Social control may have been the primary motive for the inquisitions. Because it was illegal to have the Bible in your own language - it was mainly only available in Latin, anything could be preached to the bulk of the population and they wouldn't know any better. So the Church could be an instrument of social control.

But heresy wasn't just seen as a religious problem, but a threat to the order of communities. The social control the inquisitions aimed to gain over the people wasn't altogether a bad thing, since those punished were often people living lifestyles that risked harming the well-being of others, apparently. But much of it may have been motivated by unfounded suspicions that various groups, such as the Jews, were working to cause social disturbances that would lead to communal suffering.

The fanaticism of inquisitors may indeed have derived, partly anyway, from the same kind of propaganda that Hitler proclaimed - indoctrinating people with inflammatory rhetoric about the evils of certain sections of society. Having said that, I think your figures for the number killed and tortured are quite exaggerated.

Mother Teresa, on the other hand, might have grown up in a church that taught something a lot closer to the ethos of the New Testament - the importance of living a life caring for others. Rather than a church that preached to the elite of society, with a vested interest in turning out instruments of social control, it might have been one interested in furthering the good of the community it was part of, by social action. She does, unfortunately, seem to have had an over-focus on the idea that suffering is good for the soul, in that when she did have the money to provide painkillers and medical treatment for those in her care, she apparently didn't take advantage of it; although it seems she didn't apply that belief to herself, getting the best medical treatment for herself when she was ill, or so I've heard. So what her real views and motives were, we might never know.
 
I'm fairly certain I'd be guessing accurately if I were to guess that neither Torquemada nor Mother Teresa actually read much of the Bible.
...a list of snippets from the New Testament, all taken out of context, so their meaning was distorted...
Many of the people in power in the Church were not people with an interest in spreading and following the message of the New Testament. That much is obvious from the results of their control of the Church, when you compare it to the many, many beautiful and inspirational verses in the New Testament that tell people to treat others with brotherly love and respect and consideration etc.

Well, yes... but...

just a random example from recent reading:

1 Timothy 2:11-15:
"A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner. But women will be saved through childbearing—if they continue in faith, love and holiness with propriety."

What makes your compassionate and liberal reading of the New Testament any more valid than Torquemada's?
 
Last edited:
Well, yes... but...

just a random example from recent reading:

1 Timothy 2:11-15:
"A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be silent. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner. But women will be saved through childbearing—if they continue in faith, love and holiness with propriety."

What makes your compassionate and liberal reading of the New Testament any more valid than Torquemada's?

Your post suggests that you think there are two or more equally valid interpretations of the New Testament, one compassionate and one harsh. But actually, if you read it straight, you'll realise that the harsh-sounding verses are an exception. The general ethos of it is one that urges people to be compassionate and caring. The passage you quote, and a few others, can seem disturbing and unpleasant and bigoted. But they'd be nowhere near enough in themselves to convince someone innocently reading the New Testament that the thing to do was to go out and arrest and harshly punish heretics, or to oppress women, or do any other thing that would harm society, and there are a lot of verses that would suggest people should do the exact opposite.

There are dozens of verses similar to these:

1 Timothy chapter 6 (NLT)

11 Pursue a godly life, along with faith, love, perseverance, and gentleness.

Galatians chapter 5 (NLT)

13 For you have been called to live in freedom - not freedom to satisfy your sinful nature, but freedom to serve one another in love. 14 For the whole law can be summed up in this one command: "Love your neighbor as yourself." 15 But if instead of showing love among yourselves you are always biting and devouring one another, watch out! Beware of destroying one another. …

22 But when the Holy Spirit controls our lives, he will produce this kind of fruit in us:

• love,
• joy,
• peace,
• patience,
• kindness,
• goodness,
• faithfulness,
• 23 gentleness,
• and self-control....

Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)

12 Since God chose you to be the holy people whom he loves, you must clothe yourselves with tenderhearted mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.
13 You must make allowance for each other's faults and forgive the person who offends you. Remember, the Lord forgave you, so you must forgive others.

1 Timothy chapter 2 (NLT)

1 I urge you, first of all, to pray for all people. As you make your requests, plead for God's mercy upon them, and give thanks. 2 Pray this way for kings
and all others who are in authority, so that we can live in peace and quietness, in godliness and dignity. 3 This is good and pleases God our Savior, 4
for he wants everyone to be saved and to understand the truth.

Romans chapter 12 (NLT)

17 Never pay back evil for evil to anyone. Do things in such a way that everyone can see you are honorable. 18 Do your part to live in peace with everyone,
as much as possible.

There are dozens of verses like that. Most of the New Testament's full of sentiments like that. It would be impossible to read it and come to the conclusion that violent retribution against apostates was what it was preaching. Most of it's like an appeal to people's better nature. I'm sure no one could read it objectively without coming away with the impression that there are lots of beautiful and inspirational verses in it.

As for the passage you quoted, I'm not sure it would have had any bearing on the behaviour of the inquisitors, because I'm not sure it related to anything they were doing. But perhaps you were thinking it might shape their attitude to society in general, or that verses like it might.

There's an important principle of Bible interpretation, which is that if one or two verses seem to run contrary to most of what most of it's saying, no one should ever build a doctrine on them. I think much of the trouble with different sects is that some have done just that.

There's also something about the passage you quoted that Torquemada and his ilk couldn't have been expected to know, because it would have taken research into the culture of the day; but given the other factors, that shouldn't have made a difference.

Paul wrote his letters in response to problems going on in the churches at the time he was writing. Probably, at least some of the time, his letters were replies to letters people had sent him which asked for advice on various problems. His replies were partly meant for the churches of the day, addressing their current dilemmas. He might not, for one moment, have envisaged that people would still be reading them hundreds of years in the future, although perhaps he did. But that means that when we read his letters, it's sometimes like only getting half the story. So a passage that seems disturbing and offensive to us, because it sounds like something he meant to be addressed to all Christians for all time to come, might actually have simply been an attempt to quieten one particular problem in one particular church.

We also don't get the whole story, because the original Greek he wrote in often has nuances of meaning missed by translators.

An explanation for the passage you quoted that makes sense can be found on this web page: Paul, Timothy, the Gnostics and Women

AS predicted by Paul, the ‘falling away’ or apostasy of sections of the early Christians from the true Gospel was swift. One of the greatest apostasies was the heresy known as Gnosticism. ...

What was Gnosticism about? Let’s construct a ‘statement of faith’ for it: ...

4) The body is evil and to be treated harshly by fasting etc. But sexual immorality is fine because it breaks the law of the evil creator; marriage however
is forbidden.

5) Creating more vile flesh by having children is evil. Women who give birth will be hindered from entering Gnostic heaven.

6) Eve is worshipped as a perfect, spirit being, Adam’s creator and, united with the Serpent, the enlightener of mankind with the True Knowledge.

7) Knowledge of your origins via your family tree is important to salvation; Eve is the origin of all. ...

Consider 1 Timothy 1:4 which makes it plain that Timothy’s congregation at Ephesus is beset by false teachers: ...

Silence (AV/RSV) in v.12 does NOT mean ‘silence’; it is the Greek word hesychia, which carried the idea of ‘quietness’ – ‘being less loud’ – as in NIV. The adjective form is translated as quiet in verse 2 (‘that we may live peaceful and quiet lives’). If Paul meant for a woman not to speak he would have used sigan which does mean, ‘to refrain from speaking’. This fits our context; a woman should cooperate with sound instruction, and not be boisterous and rebellious like a Gnostic virago! ...

The clinching verse is 15, because out of the Gnostic context it makes no obvious sense at all; is it saying good women don’t die while giving birth (they do) or that they are saved by having children? Paul was denying the Gnostic doctrine that having children would hinder a woman’s salvation. ...
 
Thank you for the effort you put in to that reply, and I take some of your points. But...

"I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man; she must be a bit quieter. For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner."

What has this got to do with a correction of Gnosticism?

"I do not permit a woman... to have authority over a man." Is this just Paul's personal view - as I have seen some say - or does it represent God's position - as i have seen others say.

Couple this with the "reasons" Paul gives - God made a man first, not a woman; and the woman was the one deceived, not the man. It is a clear devaluing of women in comparison with men. Yes, I know there are other NT verses - "In Christ there is no... etc etc". But it's this anti-women stance/interpretation that has pervaded Christianity throughout history until very recently. Look at the ongoing furore about women priests and bishops.

It seems to me that the Bible has only been interpreted more "liberally"/"progressively" as a response to social changes occurring in (secular) society as a whole.

Secular society now sees sexism as something wrong, and lo and behold, here are the Christians saying "that's what we meant all along."

It happened with slavery and it happened with racism.

Edit:
The clinching verse is 15, because out of the Gnostic context it makes no obvious sense at all; is it saying good women don’t die while giving birth (they do) or that they are saved by having children? Paul was denying the Gnostic doctrine that having children would hinder a woman’s salvation. ...

But it does make an obvious sense: women should not try to teach or have authority over men - that's not their role, instead their role to be child bearers. That has been the mainstream interpretation in Christian history.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, there are one or two bits of that article I linked to that would have clarified things if I'd quoted them. It was a bit awkward though, since the more I quoted, the more I risked breaking the copyright rule.

Here's a bit more:

For there is one God and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus, who gave himself as a ransom for all .... (1 Timothy 2: 5-7)

What other mediators were competing with Christ in Timothy’s Ephesus? Obviously the fertility Goddess Artemis held strong sway in the public imagination of Ephesus (Acts 19). Women mediated her to her followers. Gnosticism conflated spirit-guide Eve with many pagan mother-deities, including Artemis, and the hidden ‘gnosis’ was only to be learnt from feminine spirit-beings and women gurus. Paul is arguing against the idea that only women had the saving teaching; it was the man Christ Jesus who was the mediator! ...

In verse 12 Paul says that a woman (wife?) is not to have authority’ or authentein over a man (her husband?). When we want to understand the meaning of a scriptural word, we generally look at how the scriptures elsewhere use it; we can’t do this with authentein because this is its one and only appearance! Koine Greek writings in general use it in several ways:

*‘Precedence (coming first)’ which ties in with the Gnostic doctrine of Eve creating Adam

*‘domineering, usurping authority’ like that of the Gnostic teachers.

‘To murder a wife and take her place.’ Again, extreme usurpation and violence!

Most of these meanings are about the abuse of power; I am certainly against that. The following translation is a perfectly permissible translation of the Greek text, and best suits the Gnostic context:

I do not permit (such) a woman to teach nor to represent herself as the originator of man; she is to be in conformity (to the scripture teaching) for Adam was created first, not Eve….

A woman who does not peddle Gnostic rubbish but who holds sound doctrine should teach and can hold proper authority, in line with Paul’s teaching elsewhere! Eve was deceived and a sinner, not enlightened and perfect as the Gnostics taught! This is far removed from saying that because Eve sinned all women are unfit to speak or lead. ...

Bear in mind that Paul actually says, I do not allow a woman to teach, rather than, "Women must not teach". That strongly suggests that he was saying it was he himself who was instructing against it, rather than him saying that was what God wanted.

In the Book of Acts, it says he spent time with a woman who went on to teach one of his fellow evangelists. He clearly had no objection to that, since if he had, I don't think there would be any doubt that the writer of Acts would have recorded it.

Acts 18:

1*After this, Paul left Athens and went to Corinth. 2*There he met a Jew named Aquila, a native of Pontus, who had recently come from Italy with his wife Priscilla, because Claudius had ordered all the Jews to leave Rome. Paul went to see them, 3*and because he was a tentmaker as they were, he stayed and worked with them. ...

18*Paul stayed on in Corinth for some time. Then he left the brothers and sailed for Syria, accompanied by Priscilla and Aquila. Before he sailed, he had his hair cut off at Cenchrea because of a vow he had taken. 19*They arrived at Ephesus, where Paul left Priscilla and Aquila. He himself went into the synagogue and reasoned with the Jews. ...

24*Meanwhile a Jew named Apollos, a native of Alexandria, came to Ephesus. He was a learned man, with a thorough knowledge of the Scriptures. 25*He had been instructed in the way of the Lord, and he spoke with great fervor and taught about Jesus accurately, though he knew only the baptism of John. 26*He began to speak boldly in the synagogue. When Priscilla and Aquila heard him, they invited him to their home and explained to him the way of God more adequately.

In some of his letters, Paul mentions women who he says have "worked tirelessly" with him to spread the gospel, or whom he gives other such compliments, although he doesn't specify exactly what work they were doing.

I think it's a great pity that clergy over the centuries have been so eager to attribute massive significance to the verses in Timothy and use them to devalue women, rather than balancing them with other scriptures such as the story of Deborah in the Old Testament, or spotting the contradiction between the Timothy verses and other scriptures and looking into the linguistics of the original Greek and the cultural context, to solve the riddle. I'm sure it's true that the Church is only changing now because of modern cultural changes.

But then, I don't think the Bible can be entirely blamed. Think of what popes and other church leaders did when they caused great hardship in the Middle Ages by declaring that all priests had to be unmarried from then on, despite scripture saying no such thing. Their land apparently became the church's - which if I recall correctly was the original motive, or at least a predominant one, for the new rule. Wives were abandoned by priests all over Europe, in direct contravention of scripture, which urges people not to divorce.

I think power-hungry church officials had an interest in using whatever they could to their own ends. That's my opinion. It was easier to do when people didn't have Bibles of their own, so clergy could tell them whatever they liked and they wouldn't have been able to challenge it. Nowadays, when information is so much more freely available and we have an effective mass media to spread it, I think it would be more difficult to get away with that kind of thing in the West, although abuses still do go on unchallenged.

I once browsed the website of a Jewish man who'd written something about Jewish history, who said that in the Middle Ages in Europe, Church officials would often stir up religious hatred among the peasants against the Jews and incite them to violence against them; but when Protestantism became widespread and people were able to read the Bible for themselves, they realised it didn't preach Jew-hatred and the authorities couldn't do that any more. I think the problems have often been to do with unscrupulous men in power exploiting their positions, rather than the Bible itself. One of the first people to translate the Bible into English, William Tyndale, was burned at the stake! Why would it have been so important to keep knowledge of what it really says from the masses and to keep it in the hands of the few with the power? They clearly thought it was.
 
Again, thanks for your reply. I have to say that I'm not at all convinced by your source.

The following translation is a perfectly permissible translation of the Greek text, and best suits the Gnostic context:

I do not permit (such) a woman to teach nor to represent herself as the originator of man; she is to be in conformity (to the scripture teaching) for Adam was created first, not Eve….

A woman who does not peddle Gnostic rubbish but who holds sound doctrine should teach and can hold proper authority, in line with Paul’s teaching elsewhere! Eve was deceived and a sinner, not enlightened and perfect as the Gnostics taught! This is far removed from saying that because Eve sinned all women are unfit to speak or lead. ...

Whether or not this is indeed a better interpretation, there seems to be a hidden process going on, which is, I suggest, characteristic of all "liberal" readings of the Bible. The process is something along the lines of:

  1. The Bible (or the New Testament) must be right because it's the Word of God.
  2. It therefore can't be saying that women are inferior to men because we now know (from secular ideas) that isn't true.
  3. Therefore the Bible can't mean what it has been taken to mean throughout most of Christian history.
  4. So the Bible must mean what I am now telling you it means.

You can replace "women are inferior to men" in point 2 with a great many other things e.g. "the world is flat", "God created the world in a literal 6 days" etc.etc.

The question is, why cling to the Bible at all?
 
Whether or not my source is correct is open to question, but anyone who dismisses it will only be being rational if they have researched the information using other sources before rejecting it.

Why are you so quick to reject it? How do you imagine it could be possible that there could be such a contradiction between Paul's behaviour in working with women who taught men, and what it seems he said in the letter to Timothy? Doesn't it puzzle you? And why do you imagine there would have been such a contradiction between what he seems to have said about women being saved through childbearing, as if that was a necessity for them, and what he says in dozens of other places about people being saved through a combination of moral lifestyles and faith in Christ? How do you imagine he could have held both positions? How do you think it would be possible for him to have held such strong opposing opinions?

Why do you imagine, if childbearing was so important for a woman's salvation, that we only hear about it once, and only in a minor little letter, rather than splashed across all his letters where everyone would see it? Could he have hated women so much he didn't really want them to know the fearsome news? But then how could he bear to have worked with them?

Do you think he may have been a Jekyl and Hyde character, who somehow managed to accommodate totally opposing views in the same brain? ... Or do you, after all, think there might be a more rational explanation for the contradictions, such as the one I presented?

As for your conviction that we only know that women aren't inferior to men because of modern secular ideas, that isn't in fact true. It's a simplistic view, which research into social history would correct. Secular laws have disadvantaged women through the centuries, while some religious leaders hundreds of years ago were urging the importance of marital harmony, rather than one unfeelingly dominating the other. Hundreds of years ago, there were movements to promote women's education and status in society, which were quoshed at other times. Women could only rarely, until recently, hope to achieve as much in public life as men, because large families were the norm, so the most practical thing was for women to stay at or near home looking after them. Women are treated appallingly in some societies that have never heard of a Bible. Etc. It's a more complex picture than you imagine.

As for the reasons the Bible is still a worthwhile book, I hinted at them yesterday. I'll now go into more detail, and it has a direct bearing on the thread title.

As I said, there are many beautiful and inspirational verses in the New Testament. The fact that they are said to have the authority of God behind them may make the idea of following them more compelling to many people. If everyone in the world did follow them, there would actually be far fewer problems in the world. I'll give you some examples. Sorry this will be a long post, but if someone asks me questions, that's what they must expect. You may feel you've learned your lesson afterwards. :p But to give you the examples:

1. If everyone obeyed the New Testament, there would be no financial crisis. Thus, houses would not be being repossessed because of it. Jobs would not be being lost because of it. Families would not be suffering because their breadwinners were being thrown out of work. Etc. etc. In fact, not only would there not be a financial crisis, but throughout the centuries, landlords would not have exploited peasants to the point of starvation; governments would not have brought tragic suffering on their people by enacting evil laws that favoured the rich while exploiting or disregarding the poor; callous profiteers would not have set up businesses where the making of money was put very much at the top of the agenda, at the expense of the well-being of workers, such that health and safety in the workplace was neglected, leading to numerous tragic accidents, and wages were so low that it was impossible for workers to have a good standard of living. Property investors would not have built with the cheapest materials available, such that in regions where earthquakes are common, they wouldn't have built houses in the most risk-prone regions which were nowhere near earthquake-proof. There would be no sweatshops. There would be no exploitation by multi-national companies of workers in places where regulations concerning workers' rights are weak. This list could go on for a very long time. But I'll just conclude by saying that nothing like that would happen.

And Why? Because none of the fraud and callous transactions that led to such things would have been committed. Why? Because everyone would be obeying the many Bible verses that admonish against greed, and urge people to use their money not just to make themselves rich but in the care of others. Verses such as these:

1 Timothy chapter 5 (NLT)

17 Tell those who are rich in this world not to be proud and not to trust in their money, which will soon be gone. But their trust should be in the living God, who richly gives us all we need for our enjoyment. 18 Tell them to use their money to do good. They should be rich in good works and should give generously to those in need, always being ready to share with others whatever God has given them. 19 By doing this they will be storing up their treasure as a good foundation for the future so that they may take hold of real life.

1 John chapter 3 (NLT)

16 We know what real love is because Christ gave up his life for us. And so we also ought to give up our lives for our Christian brothers and sisters. 17 But if anyone has enough money to live well and sees a brother or sister in need and refuses to help - how can God's love be in that person? 18 Dear children,
let us stop just saying we love each other; let us really show it by our actions. 19 It is by our actions that we know we are living in the truth.

James chapter 2 (NLT)

14 Dear brothers and sisters, what's the use of saying you have faith if you don't prove it by your actions? That kind of faith can't save anyone. 15 Suppose you see a brother or sister who needs food or clothing, 16 and you say, "Well, good-bye and God bless you; stay warm and eat well" - but then you don't give that person any food or clothing. What good does that do? 17 So you see, it isn't enough just to have faith. Faith that doesn't show itself by good
deeds is no faith at all - it is dead and useless.

Mark chapter 10 (TEV)

42 Jesus called [his disciples] together to him and said,
"You know that those who are considered rulers of the heathen have power over them, and the leaders have complete authority. 43 This, however, is not the way it is among you. If one of you wants to be great, you must be the servant of the rest; 44 and if one of you wants to be first, you must be the slave of all. 45 For even the Son of Man did not come to be served; he came to serve and to give his life to redeem many people."

Luke chapter 12 (TEV)

13 A man in the crowd said to Jesus, "Teacher, tell my brother to divide with me the property our father left us."

14 Jesus answered him, "Friend, who gave me the right to judge or to divide the property between you two?"

15 And he went on to say to them all, "Watch out and guard yourselves from every kind of greed; because your true life is not made up of the things you own, no matter how rich you may be."

--------

I could go on and on, but I'll spare you for the moment. But I'll give you more examples of problems that just wouldn't exist if everyone followed New Testament teaching:

2. Drunkenness: It makes people more prone to violence and other forms of criminal behaviour. There have been cultures where it was not at all unheard of for wages to be blown on drink by men whose actions caused their families with young children to have to struggle in semi-starvation. Drunk drivers cause a lot of death and misery. Unwanted pregnancies leading to years of deprivation for single mothers and their children have been caused by behaviour the women would never have indulged in had they been sober. And so on. And none of that would have happened if everyone followed the New Testament teaching that says:

Ephesians chapter 5 (NLT)

18 Don't be drunk with wine, because that will ruin your life.

Etc.

Another example of a problem that just wouldn't exist if people obeyed the Bible:

3. Violence.

Imagine if everyone in the world followed New Testament teaching. There would be no more war; no more wife beating; no more mugging; no more bullying, and so on.

And why? Because everyone would be obeying Bible verses like:

Colossians chapter 3 (NLT)

12 Since God chose you to be the holy people whom he loves, you must clothe yourselves with tenderhearted mercy, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.

Hebrews chapter 12 (NLT)

14 Try to live in peace with everyone, and seek to live a clean and holy life, for those who are not holy will not see the Lord.

1 Peter chapter 3 (NLT)

8 Finally, all of you should be of one mind, full of sympathy toward each other, loving one another with tender hearts and humble minds. 9 Don't repay evil for evil. Don't retaliate when people say unkind things about you. Instead, pay them back with a blessing. That is what God wants you to do, and he will bless you for it. 10 For the Scriptures say,

"If you want a happy life and good days, keep your tongue from speaking evil, and keep your lips from telling lies.
11 Turn away from evil and do good. Work hard at living in peace with others.

1 Thessalonians chapter 5 (NLT)

13 ... Remember to live peaceably with each other.

Ephesians chapter 4 (TEV)

23 Your hearts and minds must be made completely new, 24 and you must put on the new self, which is created in God's likeness and reveals itself in the true life that is upright and holy. 26 If you become angry, do not let your anger lead you into sin, and do not stay angry all day. 27

Galatians chapter 5 (NLT)

13 For you have been called to live in freedom - not freedom to satisfy your sinful nature, but freedom to serve one another in love. 14 For the whole law can be summed up in this one command: "Love your neighbor as yourself." 15 But if instead of showing love among yourselves you are always biting and devouring one another, watch out! Beware of destroying one another.

19 When you follow the desires of your sinful nature, your lives will produce these evil results: sexual immorality, impure thoughts, eagerness for lustful pleasure, 20 idolatry, participation in demonic activities, hostility, quarreling, jealousy, outbursts of anger, selfish ambition, divisions, the feeling that everyone is wrong except those in your own little group, 21 envy, drunkenness, wild parties, and other kinds of sin. Let me tell you again, as I have
before, that anyone living that sort of life will not inherit the Kingdom of God.

Ephesians chapter 4 (NLT)

2 Be humble and gentle. Be patient with each other, making allowance for each other's faults because of your love. 3 Always keep yourselves united in the Holy Spirit, and bind yourselves together with peace.

... And so on and so on.

I could give you several more examples of problems that wouldn't exist if everyone in the world obeyed various New Testament instructions, but I won't for now.

How could it not be worth reverencing a book that could inspire all that if only it was followed?

Of course, I'm not saying that following the Bible would be the only way to solve such problems; I'm saying that although it would be most unlikely to happen, if everyone followed New Testament teaching well, there would be far fewer problems in the world.

-------

Of course, things are more complicated than that. For instance, the Bible gives bear instructions for husbands and wives not to have affairs; but someone tempted to have one might need advice on how to increase their satisfaction with their marriage to decrease their temptation in order to make it easy for them to follow the Bible's commands. And so on. The Bible is only the bare basis of a blueprint for living. It's meant to be complimented by other things.

Unfortunately, the institution of Christianity as it stands is very different from what it would be in an ideal world, so Christianity in itself couldn't be expected to solve those problems, and the way it's often been distorted does mean that many people have suffered because of it and would be better off without it.
 
And religion even has the withdrawal symptoms in common with drugs, in particular when your condition needs illusions:

http://www.skepticreport.com/mystics/confessionswoo.htm
"So that brings me to date. Still have to keep a check on the MTM. If it raises its head again in times of stress, I will say stop, that was the old Sharon, and have a word with myself. To be honest, I haven't found the cross-over easy. I know it will get easier and that my mind is well on its way to being re-programmed." (MTM = Magican-Thinking Monster)

That's a very interesting story, about someone who was cold reading for years without actually realising she was doing it. She genuinely thought she was psychic. It's interesting that people can do that.

The link broke, but I found the story again here.

I think it's a bit of a stretch to say religion causes withdrawal symptoms when people abandon it though, and it can't be extrapolated from the story. After all, someone who's used to having a warm bath when they're stressed, or anything else, who is then denied it, will probably crave it sometimes.

But then, I have heard that some people can find it quite traumatic when they've believed in a religion for years but then something seriously shakes their faith so they lose it. Someone on another board once told the story of how he'd taken a course at college that made him doubt all the religious things he'd grown up believing, and he got seriously depressed over it. I'm not sure exactly why - whether it was because he concluded God wasn't there for him after all, or that he'd been betrayed by people who'd taught him things that weren't true, or what.

Maybe the same thing could happen with anything though, for instance politics, if someone had grown up admiring a particular party and believing in their politics, only to discover they were a load of corrupt selfish money-grubbers who habitually lied and had harmed the country rather than improving it as they'd claimed. Being disillusioned would be the key factor.
 
It is not really "a bit of a stretch to say" that "religion causes withdrawal symptoms when people abandon it." It does not even have to be "extrapolated from the story" since Sharon Sifford, the author, makes it obvious when she compares the "Magical Thinking Monster" with the "nicotine monster".

Your own parallel, "someone who's used to having a warm bath when they're stressed, or anything else, who is then denied it, will probably crave it sometimes", stresses the kind of attitude to your illusions required for disillusionment (be it of a religious, political or emotional nature) to give rise to withdrawal symptoms: It is necessary for you to feel bereft. The disillusionment does not simply produce relief, which would be the case if a child growing up with the Old-Testament threat of Hell realizes that there is no such thing. Instead, an attitude like the one described by Marx when he refers to religion as "the opium of the people" is required in order for you to feel something similar to withdrawal symptoms as a result of your disillusionment.

The discovery of the unfaithfulness of a lover you no longer care for probably won't bother you as much as discovering the same thing about one that you do care for and trust.

In your polical example, "if someone had grown up admiring a particular party and believing in their politics, only to discover they were a load of corrupt selfish money-grubbers", I think that you confuse two things: on the one hand, belief in the politics, and on the other, the idealization of its practitioners, i.e. the personality cult, which modern democrats tend to find only on enemy territory, e.g. Cuba, even though for instance the US version is obvious to anybody with impartial powers of observation.

Disillusionment is only a step forward, liberation, for people who can handle it, and their ability to do so is very different from being strong or tough.
If you believe in the benefits of a free market economy, if not for all of mankind then at least, for the right kind of people who deserve the benefits, and if, accordingly, you have convinced yourself that it favours industrious and enterprising people who apply themselves, i.e. you, being made redundant or losing your business may actually kill you if you refuse to give up the illusion and instead hang onto it since it is an illusion not only about politics but also about yourself as a social-darwinist wonderboy: Success was what proved your worth, your self-respect, your right to exist. It is not very hard to extrapolate the 'logical' next step when reality proves you wrong. One thing is facing unemployment and impoverishment; people may be able to cope with those. Losing your raison d´étre is a very different thing. When that is at stake, you not only believe, you actually need to believe.
(And this is not very different from what a staunch defender of and believer in the Soviet Union as the realization of 'scientific socialism' must have felt when his admired leaders changed their minds ...)
 
It may be that you didn't mean quite what I thought you did.

But though she compared what she got from her psychic activities to a nicotine buzz, it's generalising to extrapolate from what she said that religion as a whole is akin to an addiction that causes withdrawal symptoms when abandoned. If you'd brought in other examples, and phrased what you said in less general terms, I wouldn't have had an issue with what you said.

I would guess that Marx was probably right in calling religion the opium of the masses, and compassionately saying that the people shouldn't be deprived of religion until their living conditions had improved enough that they didn't need such a thing - which might have been consolation/escapism/hope for a better life to come to make their lives bearable, and similar things. Campaigning to educate them out of religious belief without improving their lives might have led to quite tragic effects in some cases, not drug-like withdrawal symptoms per se, but possibly despair, and basically the kinds of feelings some of them used opium to alleviate.

Then again, nicotine withdrawal symptoms don't have to do entirely with the chemical composition of nicotine, but can be a lot to do with emotions. See this thread, for example, from post 44 onwards.

It may have been specific emotions the woman in the story you linked to was suggesting nicotine addiction and psychic practice had in common. For instance, in the thread I've just linked to, I tell the story of how my dad's former tobacco addiction was mainly to do with the buzz of always being fairly close to running out of it and having a drive to get more. Things that could have fuelled her compulsion to be involved in the psychic world could have been partly the sense of community she had with her psychic friends, the excitement of doing a reading and being told she was right - that might have put her on quite a high; meeting new people, and so on. It might have helped her to substitute other things that would have given her the same feelings, such as if she'd found a new hobby or taken up a job where she'd be meeting new people and making friends she had something in common with, and exploring genuine talents she had that would have given her a similar high when she succeeded at something using them. It wouldn't necessarily be disillusionment making her feel bereft, but could be a number of other things, like those I suggested, that could be effectively substituted with healthy things.

Regarding my political example, I was suggesting that giving up a belief in a various form of politics may have the same upsetting disillusioning effect as realising those in power are corrupt. For instance, if you believed staunchly that right wing politics were the best possible thing for a country, and then saw their detrimental effects, some personalities might struggle a lot with the blow to their egos of realising they've been wrong for years. All I was really suggesting was that religion isn't unique or especially harmful as regards the effects people can suffer when they abandon it.
 
Basically we agree, I think, but I have a couple of objections:

I don’t think that Marx, ”compassionately” or otherwise, said ”that the people shouldn't be deprived of religion until their living conditions had improved enough that they didn't need such a thing”. (He also didn’t recommend opium addiction as a way of tackling the suffering caused by capitalism.) He was a materialist and stressed that religion is there for a reason – but not a very good one:
Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again. But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man—state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d'honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification. It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality. The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that world whose spiritual aroma is religion. Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_of_the_People
http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1843/critique-hpr/intro.htm

This is why he criticized the idealism of wanting people to do away with their opium without simultaneously criticizing the conditions that make them crave it. (An awful lot of skeptics share this idealism!) The history of the labour movement shows that religion tends to lose its appeal as soon as you start to fight against the ”heartless world” and the”soulless conditions”. And you have to admit that former socialist countries managed to render religion almost non-existent.
To this very day East Germans tend to be less religious than their Protestant and Catholic compatriots in the West and the South. Poland was a little different: In that country Catholicism was combined with nationalism in the struggle against Soviet supremacy. It is ironic that, for this very reason, Poles tended to lose faith only after the introduction of capitalism – much to the regret of the Catholic church, which complains about the secularisation of Poland today.

Marxists don't stop criticizing Christian faith and bourgeois morality.


Maybe the same thing could happen with anything though, for instance politics, if someone had grown up admiring a particular party and believing in their politics, only to discover they were a load of corrupt selfish money-grubbers who habitually lied and had harmed the country rather than improving it as they'd claimed.
For instance, if you believed staunchly that right wing politics were the best possible thing for a country, and then saw their detrimental effects, some personalities might struggle a lot with the blow to their egos of realising they've been wrong for years.

I hope that you know that a guy like Hitler accused the Jews of being ”corrupt selfish money-grubbers who habitually lied and had harmed the country rather than improving it as they'd claimed”, which does not imply that this kind of criticism is not compatible with a democratic sentiment. On the contrary. If the good of the country, the nation, is your yardstick for good politics, then you are a nationalist, right-wing or left-wing. What is good for the country is usually achieved at the expense of its impecunious citizens.
”Ask not what your country …”
How citizens’ discontent is turned to good use for the progress of rule
Remarks on the Patriotism of an Imperialistically Successful Nation
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom