This is Cain's version of coherency. To minimize one moral wrong find one worse. It's a form of Tu Quoque.
You do it to and you are worse.
Here's some advice. Think twice before you commit yourself to using a term you do not understand -- even if you have used it before and, for whatever reason, nobody chose to call you on it. Take special care when using Latin, and
extra special care with anything that has a whiff of "fallacy" to it.
"Technoextreme" suggests a moral principle: we are responsible for the consequences of our actions, even if the outcome is not intended. Moreover, even if nothing bad
does happen, an action can still be condemned for its recklessness. There is no "tu quoque" because I am not arguing his (possible) failure to recognize actual atrocities
invalidates his claim against eco-terrorists. Quite the opposite, I said "these are important considerations," so let's apply them across the board, which, yes, has to do with coherency and consistency.
It's funny you'd spout this sort of nonsense right after taking issue with my signature, which has been up for a few days. And on that I do not think anyone will entertain A), and the only people will take B) seriously are those who have had the misfortune to read your posts in threads such as this one.
--------------------
GreNME not surprisingly echos the same error but adds fabrication and innuendo.
"equivocating the eco-terrorists with the likes of suicide bombers or something."
Where do I do that?
And then:
"Sometimes it even bears the characteristics of cult-like behavior, but not in all cases."
Earlier you attempted a similarly slimy comparison, but against Kevin and myself:
"Considering you and Cain are making similar absolute arguments (if X then Y, no exception), one could infer based on your arguments alone that you were religious about this matter."
Even though you're the one mistakenly inferring an "absolutist" position, and then inferring other nonsense from this false position.
And as I've said before, I've read Shermer's book, wrote an e-mail to him and received a reply back. Now that Hotmail has a search function, I can reproduce it here. I've also read Pinker, Wright, Ridley, Dawkins, and others. More importantly, I also read moral philosophy, bio-ethics...
------------
technoextreme writes:
I had no idea that I had been included in his signature.
Maybe you guys are less perceptive than I thought...
thaiboxerken:
I think he places the most damaging points to his positions in his signature.
So, as I was saying about perceptiveness...