Possibility of proving that God maker of everything exists.

Why are you always afraid?

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.

I will agree that I am angry at each and every god, that I am afraid of each and every god, that there is no need to fear each and every god if I will just face each and every god and live with each and every god....
if you,Gerry, will agree to all the same things about the flying spaghetti monster.
 
The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.


The problem with your second and third assumptions is that being certain does not mean that you are right.

People used to be certain that the sun orbited the earth.

They were certainly wrong.
 
But before everything we must agree on some assumptions otherwise the exchange of ideas among us humans would be impossible or an exercise in futility.


The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

Yes, we are classified as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

Yes, we can reason with thought and develop subjective conclusions.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.

You will have to clarify this one Gerry. What is meant by "human certainty"?
 
Here is my idea of human certainty and possible examples.

Yrreg said:
The first assumption is that we exist as humans.

The second assumption is that we have reason and it is a dependable faculty for thinking and arriving at certainty.

The third assumption is that the only certainty we can have is what I call human certainty.


OK, I'll bite. I cannot accept assumption three until you define 'human certainty' and explain how it is different from just plain old certainty.


How can I begin to explain to you human certainty, except to ask you if you know what is man?


I have come across people who demand absolute certainty, but even the most accomplished philosophers and scientists if I am not mistaken admit that there is no such thing as absolute certainty for mankind.

On that above statement that absolute certainty is not available for mankind, I have come to the idea that we should we humans should just settle for human certainty.

What is human certainty? It is the certainty that humans can arrive at using their reason sincerely in order to decide questions which for humans are important to live together peaceably and productively together.

I like for you to give me some samples of human certainty as I have just describe human certainty.


My own examples of human certainty is the certainty arrived at by people who have to make a finding of guilty or not guilty in a court of law, or who has the right and who not in a court of law.

Another example of human certainty is the idea that mothers love their children.



I will appreciate very much if you can from my ideas here on human certainty see what I am driving at and also contribute to my concept of human certainty.





Yrreg
 
Many mothers do not, in fact, love their children. That shows the limits of your kind of certainty right there.

How about we use reasonable certainty instead?
 
I am asking you guys to agree on the assumptions I present before you, because unless we adhere to the assumptions human discourse of any worth is impossible.
You are asking us to agree with your baseless assertions derived without evidence.

But as usual you guys keep avoiding what is crucially necessary to have any constructive and thus productive discourse on the issue at hand.
This is laughable. In your latest thread you avoided responding to posts that exposed the weakness of your argument and then in obvious frustration you resorted to accusing atheists of being afraid of god and needing psychiatric help.

Why are you always afraid?
I don't know, Gerry. Why are you afraid of Buddhism?

That is why I always believe that the only productive study of atheists is their psychology of being angry at God because they are afraid of God whereas there is no need to fear God whatever if you guys will just face God and live with God.
And here we go again. Is the above "productive study of atheists" what led you to suggest that atheists have no sense of beauty and love and should therefor commit suicide? This sort of insult is a transparent display of your frustration at your inability to construct a cogent argument.

Let me see if someone among you have the courage to either accept these the assumptions or to point out which assumption(s) you cannot accept and why.
What you seem to be saying is "Let me see if anyone among you will stop pointing out the errors in my arguments and just agree with me because otherwise I will call you a coward".

Gerry, do you have the courage to provide us with a rational reason to assume that the universe had a beginning? Can you show real physical evidence that the universe is ordered by an intelligence? You can treat each as a separate question but please answer each in no more than ten words. As you are so clever and statements with less than eleven words are the hallmark of a solid argument this should be no problem for you.
 
I will appreciate very much if you can from my ideas here on human certainty see what I am driving at and also contribute to my concept of human certainty.

Yrreg

Pastafarians are certain that The FLying Spaghetti Monster exists.
Children of age 7 are certain that Santa exists.
Theists are certain that god(s) exist.

That kind of thing?
 
I affix the word human to the word certain to make certainty a big useful umbrella.

Many mothers do not, in fact, love their children. That shows the limits of your kind of certainty right there.

How about we use reasonable certainty instead?


I think that is a suggestion that should be acceptable.


May I just say that I use the word human in order that the word certainty will be under a big enough umbrella as to include all and every certainty that mankind live with and under and no man will challenge except that he must live by himself alone in the jungle or in the forest or in the desert, or better put himself in a dungeon away from all human presence.


You know, I can see better and better in the course of writing in web forums why people are afraid of the truths in everything, of course understanding by truths, the truths men live by and live together peaceably and productively, even though mankind can never achieve absolute truths.

Why can mankind never achieve absolute certainty and absolute truth? Because man is a limited being, only God is unlimited in contrast to man being limited.

Can God create a being just like Himself? He can but He is not silly, because two Gods are not better than one, that is also a human certainty for myself and a human truth for myself.

Dear Godless Dave, why do you have to adopt that name, godless dave? Is it any really useful way for you to arrive at human certainty in everything that counts for anything that is good and noble and uplifting to mankind starting with yourself?


That is why I always believe and get more an more certain, humanly certain that is, that the only for the present productive in terms of human knowledge of human behavior in the study of atheists, mind you I say atheists not atheism, is the psychology of atheists as atheists, in particular their anger at God.





Yrreg
 
I have come across people who demand absolute certainty, but even the most accomplished philosophers and scientists if I am not mistaken admit that there is no such thing as absolute certainty for mankind.
Nice strawman, but we are not demanding absolute certainty from your claims. We are asking that you provide even a loose framework of an argument to support your assertions that the universe had a creator and that it was intelligently designed.

On that above statement that absolute certainty is not available for mankind, I have come to the idea that we should we humans should just settle for human certainty.
That sounds an awful lot like you're just going to hammer your god into the gaps in our knowledge. "We don't know what's on top of that mountain so that's where God lives."

What is human certainty? It is the certainty that humans can arrive at using their reason sincerely...
This makes sense, but let's call it reasonable certainty then.

...in order to decide questions which for humans are important to live together peaceably and productively together.
This makes no sense.

I like for you to give me some samples of human certainty as I have just describe human certainty.
I am not a brain in a vat dreaming the universe.

The North American plate is emerging from the mid-Atlantic ridge.

The last living T. rex walked about 65 million years ago.

I will appreciate very much if you can from my ideas here on human certainty see what I am driving at and also contribute to my concept of human certainty.
I see what you are driving at, but there is a problem. Take my last example above: we know that T. rex has been extinct for some 65 million years because of a great deal of physical evidence that has allowed paleontologists to formulate testable hypotheses regarding their history. Your assertion that the universe was designed and created by an intelligence does not lend itself to the formation of a testable hypothesis. Indeed, as I have already pointed out, you have yet to provide evidence that the universe had a beginning or was intelligently designed.
 
Yrreg, there is a vast difference between certainty and truth, rather like there is a vast difference between belief and knowledge.

You might want to sample from column B, one of these days.
 
Can God create a being just like Himself? He can but He is not silly, because two Gods are not better than one, that is also a human certainty for myself and a human truth for myself

Clearly god is silly because I am certain two gods are better than one.
Why is your certainty better than my certainty?
 
I think that is a suggestion that should be acceptable.


May I just say that I use the word human in order that the word certainty will be under a big enough umbrella as to include all and every certainty that mankind live with and under and no man will challenge except that he must live by himself alone in the jungle or in the forest or in the desert, or better put himself in a dungeon away from all human presence.

What? I have no clue what this means. Unless you are still railing that 'I do not know' is an invalid answer.

You know, I can see better and better in the course of writing in web forums why people are afraid of the truths in everything, of course understanding by truths, the truths men live by and live together peaceably and productively, even though mankind can never achieve absolute truths.

People are not afraid of truths. But they get annoyed at others who try to force their person truths upon others. Your truth involves God. Someone elses truth is Allah. A third might even be the Flying Spaghetti Monster. A Child truths is Santa Claus. Each of these truths is just as well valid as the others, even if each claims that only they have the real truth,. and all other are lies and falsehoods.

Why can mankind never achieve absolute certainty and absolute truth? Because man is a limited being, only God is unlimited in contrast to man being limited.

And what is absolute certainty and truth? God has nothing to do with these, but rather in how we perceive the world around us. While I am certain that the sun will rise one again tomorrow, I could be wrong.


Can God create a being just like Himself? He can but He is not silly, because two Gods are not better than one, that is also a human certainty for myself and a human truth for myself.

What? Well, whatever. Just accept that your certainty and truth are not mine, or others certainty or truths.

Dear Godless Dave, why do you have to adopt that name, godless dave? Is it any really useful way for you to arrive at human certainty in everything that counts for anything that is good and noble and uplifting to mankind starting with yourself?

"A rose by any other name, would smell as sweet." It is a name. Are you offended by his name? Others may find it inspiring, showing that people can be good, and noble, and uplifting without needing god to prop them up.


That is why I always believe and get more an more certain, humanly certain that is, that the only for the present productive in terms of human knowledge of human behavior in the study of atheists, mind you I say atheists not atheism, is the psychology of atheists as atheists, in particular their anger at God.

Once again, please understand, Atheists are NOT angry at god. They simply do not believe that god exists at all. Are you angry at Allah? Thor? Zeus? It is the same rationale.

Atheists do not believe your god exists. And in fact, think you are silly to be clinging to such a false belief. Once you understand that, then perhaps you might be able to have a rational discussion with an atheist.
 
Dear Godless Dave, why do you have to adopt that name, godless dave?

I didn't have to adopt it, I chose to. My name is Dave and I'm godless.

Is it any really useful way for you to arrive at human certainty in everything that counts for anything that is good and noble and uplifting to mankind starting with yourself?

Choosing a forum name isn't usually done to arrive at certainty. I do, however, think godlessness is good, noble, and uplifting to humankind.
 
Pastafarians are certain that The FLying Spaghetti Monster exists.
Children of age 7 are certain that Santa exists.
Theists are certain that god(s) exist.

That kind of thing?

I should also point out that some theists incorrectly use the word "know" when they really mean "believe".

So, yrreG, can we use these three examples of being certain of things? Then we can get on to your complete definition of your god(s) including all attributes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom