What's wrong with this definition of God: maker of heaven and earth and everything?

Merged with earlier thread which covers the same question.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Let me put the question this way : How did god begin?

It makes no sense to answer that god began himself, because if he was there to begin himself then it was not a beginning. There must be some other answer.

So how did god begin?

Actually, you could invoke circular time and state that YHVH created himself, but that explanation could equally explain the beginning of the universe without resorting to deities.

It's the essential flaw of the 'First Cause' argument; Either everything has a preceding cause, or it does not. In the first case, nothing can have begun. In the second, deities are unnecessary. Given that we are considering the issue, the first case cannot be correct, therefore deities are unnecessary in the creation of the universe.
 
Your answer is illogical and irrational. If you cannot comprehend why, I'm afraid it's going to be very difficult, if not impossible, for anyone here to explain it to you.

Your answer essentially posits that God did not create God - rather, that God has infinitely existed. The problem with this solution is that if God the Maker of Everything could have existed without a creator, then Everything could likewise have existed without a creator. Otherwise, your claim is that Everything needs a creator except God, which is simply an irrational exception to your universal rule.

For someone who wants to trumpet on and on about your inborn reasoning and intelligence, that you cannot grasp such a basic tenet of logic speaks volumes.
 
What's exactly, specifically wrong with my definition of God?
as maker of heaven and earth and everything.​


Your definition does not reflect your beliefs and is misleading. You could use the above definition only if there were no further properties you added to God further down the track. Omniscience, omnipotence, omnibenevolence, intelligence, consciousness and freedom are all traits you assign to God, but exclude from your definition. Why?

To illustrate:

What is wrong with the following definition of a square?

A shape.

It is obvious that the above definition is far too vague to be useful.

What is an appropriate definition of a square?

An enclosed shape with four sides of equal length with each side being at 90 degrees from the adjoining side.


That to me is a question that is irrational and illogical, but just the same suppose you tell me what is wrong with my answer below:



If God is the maker of everything, who made God?

He made Himself and then made Himself again and again and again and again all in a circle endlessly.​


Firstly, why would he need to keep re-making himself after he had done it once? Your argument is ridiculous.

Secondly, if God does not require an intelligent, conscious and free maker, than there is no reason to suppose the universe does.
 
....and the puddle was amazed that the pothole was designed so perfectly for it.

Gerry, please cling as strongly as you like to your comfortable mythology. As you do so, please understand that your faith will not be acceptable to people who are empiricists. So keep your faith to yourself...or share it with others who may find the subjective acceptable. As you go forward in life take some classes in logic. When you believe that you have found a sound logical proof for your idea of the deity then come here and explain it to us.

Lacking that Gerry...your threads here are both pointless and insulting to the intelligence of people who are, objectively speaking, your superiors in both education and intelligence.

-z
 
That to me is a question that is irrational and illogical, but just the same suppose you tell me what is wrong with my answer below:
If God is the maker of everything, who made God?
He made Himself and then made Himself again and again and again and again all in a circle endlessly.​
What is wrong with this answer? It involves infinite regression. For God to have made himself, he had to already have existed. But if he already existed, what need is there for him to make himself?


That is why He does not have to make Himself unless He wants to repeat endlessly the making of Himself around and around in a circle.
This contradicts your previous statement. Did God make himself, as you stated previously, or did God not have to make himself, as you state here?

Or are you simply using a rhetorical trick? In which case, please clearly mark the posts you make where you use rhetorical tricks.
 
Gerry said, "...even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning."

Exactly. Little kids have no trouble using a word like 'god' to mean 'all the stuff I can't understand or don't know where it came from'.

It 's when you get older that you start asking questions like "How do I know that?"

And when there's no satisfying answer to that, and yet you can live quite comfortably with the enigma, then you are an all-grown-up skeptic, and are eligible to vote or get married or drive a car on public roads.

Until then, better stay in the shallow end of the pool. And don't reproduce.
 
Gerry said, "...even kids in nursery school have no trouble with the word God and its meaning."

Exactly. Little kids have no trouble using a word like 'god' to mean 'all the stuff I can't understand or don't know where it came from'.

It 's when you get older that you start asking questions like "How do I know that?"

And when there's no satisfying answer to that, and yet you can live quite comfortably with the enigma, then you are an all-grown-up skeptic, and are eligible to vote or get married or drive a car on public roads.

Until then, better stay in the shallow end of the pool. And don't reproduce.

When I was in nursery school I had less problem believing in Tinkerbelle than in God. By Gerry's logic, I guess that means that now we can answer the old question "who created God?"
 
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread gets suspended
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode <-- You are here
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists
...
 
If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread gets suspended
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode <-- You are here
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists<-- yrreG is, was and always will be here
...
...
 
Genuine pseudo arguments of atheists against God.

Thread merged into similar subject thread.
Posted By: Darat


yrreg - do not keep starting threads to discuss issues you are are already discussing in other threads.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat


I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


No, most atheists I know use the argument that there is no reliable evidence for the existence of any god.

I think you are conflating arguments for the non-existence of god with rebuttals to the arguments for the existence of god.
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg

Which god(s)? What are the characteristics of the god(s) that you believe in?
 
I am now convinced that atheists have only genuine pseudo arguments against God.


1. Bad-mouthing God, like calling Him a Flying Spaghetti Monster, leprechaun, invisible pink unicorn, etc.

2. Laughing at God and theists who want to explain to them how God is a fact by engaging in frivolities, instead of attending carefully to the explanations from theists.

3. Pretending not to know what the issue is all about, or to not know anything which might enlighten them on the fact that God exists.
​


What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?





Yrreg

what if we are both wrong, and the Hindus got it right?
 
What do you guys here say, atheists and theists and people who are neither but interested in the issue of God or no God for an academic inquiry?

Are you acknowledging that atheists may have genuine reasons for discussing religion, or are you still insisting that any atheist who speaks on the subject must secretely believe in god? (a.k.a. "the only real atheist is one who shuts up" argument)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom