My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

It's especially interesting that you would erroneously berate me for making an assumption and then proceed to make another assumption about me (the first being that I have no concern for present human suffering and the second being that I make no effort to lessen the suffering of others). Not to mention that, even if you were correct about me, your argument amounts to nothing but a tu quoque fallacy.
Oh. I missed that one about abortion.

So far, then, we have:

It is OK for god to demand genocide and the slaughter of infants and babies because...

1.) They could be an evil parasitic alien species.
2.) America dropped the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
3.) abortion is legal.
 
Wow, you've got a fair bit of explaining to do!
OK, let me see if I can simplify it for you.

*Many people claim that the Bible is the inspired word of God and a source of divine morality.

*Others note that the Bible contains many descriptions of atrocities, such as the slaughter of entire communities including women, children and infants.

The debate should proceed from the above points. But you keep trying to direct attention away from the Bible by talking about other atrocities. But the fact that other horrors have taken place though out history doesn't lessen the disgusting nature of biblical claims of genocide. The killing fields of Cambodia don't lessen the gravity of the Russian pogroms.
 
The usual argument,especially from the religious, is that people murder, rape, pillage and commit genocide because they are inherently imperfect, if not downright rotten, evil and sinful and in need of salvation. Pointing out human atrocities as a tu quoque for those the Bible attributes to God seems a poor start to arguing against the assertion of Randfan and others that the God of the Bible is all too human.
 
Foster Zygote said:
But we do know why those things happened, according to the authors of the Bible, at least. They happened because God willed it.

That is argument by extreme simplicity. I find it very difficult to believe you think that's all the Bible says there is to it.

Foster Zygote said:
You may speculate all you like. I'm sure it makes you feel better to dismiss my position using the above assumption, however, you are incorrect.

The alternatives are, if anything, worse; perhaps that your reading of the Bible has been so superficial that you've gained a very simplistic impression, and yet, apparently not realising how superficial your reading of the Bible has been, you confidently trumpet your ideas as if they're the ultimate truth. Why would you do that? Or maybe there's yet another explanation, that you speak out with perceptions distorted by anger, after feeling as if you were betrayed all that time you were a Christian because you were taught to believe things you now think were wrong, so now you want to just condemn and condemn in the hope that other people don't have to suffer your fate, or in simple reactionary outrage at feeling as if you were deceived?

Yes, speculating about your motives does indeed make me feel better, because it's interesting and fun. Thanks for not minding. But now, back to the issues:

Foster Zygote said:
It's quite simple. You suggested that we needed to "delve into the cultural background of the day so you could reel off atrocities without making it look
as if you're making things look worse than is warranted". This implies that there are mitigating circumstances that make acts that seem to be atrocious
more acceptable once one is aware of the contemporary context. So I would like to know what further information can help to justify genocide. Again, what
can make the act of splitting a three year old girl's skull open with a bronze sword and then turning to plunge the blade into the belly of her pregnant
mother seem warranted? I'd really like to know.

Possibly something similar to what might make the terrible American nuking of Japan seem warranted. Apart from the fact that your use of the term genocide is a misnoma - the Bible doesn't say that any race was driven to extinction, and you'd probably realise that if your examination of it wasn't so evidently superficial as to make you think it says any killing took place simply because "God willed it" - what you're basically doing is simply selecting one of the worst examples of the kinds of suffering in war there might have been, and using it to appeal to emotion in order to score points - basically just Argument by Outrage.

OK, here are some survivor stories from victims of the American nuking of Hiroshima. Since you obviously haven't got my points yet, I'm going to have to hammer them home a bit more. These stories seem terrible, and if the background to the attacks was not known, the Americans would seem like a horrible, psychopathic people, and anyone who would dare defend them would seem a repulsive person not worthy of any respect but only disgust.

Eiko Taoka, then 21, was one of nearly 100 passengers said to have been on board a streetcar that had left Hiroshima Station at a little after 8:00 a.m. and was in a Hatchobori area, 750 m from ground zero, when the bomb fell. Taoka was heading for Funairi with her one year old son to secure wagon in preparation for her move out of the building which was to be evacuated. At 8:15, as the streetcar approached Hatchobori Station, an intense flash and blast engulfed
the car, instantly setting it on fire. Taoka’s son died of radiation sickness on August 28. The survival of only ten people on the streetcar have been confirmed to date.

Code:
When we were near in Hatchobori and since I had been holding my son in my arms, the young woman in front of me said, ‘I will be getting off here. Please take this seat.’ We were just changing places when there was a strange smell and sound. It suddenly became dark and before I knew it, I had jumped outside....
I held [my son] firmly and looked down on him. He had been standing by the window and I think fragments of glass had pierced his head. His face was a mess because of the blood flowing from his head. But he looked at my face and smiled. His smile has remained glued in my memory. He did not comprehend what had happened. And so he looked at me and smiled at my face which was all bloody. I had plenty of milk which he drank all throughout that day. I think my child sucked the poison right out of my body. And soon after that he died. Yes, I think that he died for me.

Ms. Akiko Takakura was 20 years old when the bomb fell. She was in the Bank of Hiroshima, 300 meters away from the hypocenter. Ms. Takakura miraculously escaped death despite over 100 lacerated wounds on her back. She is one of the few survivors who was within 300 meters of the hypocenter. She now runs a kindergarten and she relates her experience of the atomic bombing to children.

Code:
Many people on the street were killed almost instantly. The fingertips of those dead bodies caught fire and the fire gradually spread over their entire
bodies from their fingers. A light gray liquid dripped down their hands, scorching their fingers. I, I was so shocked to know that fingers and bodies could be burned and deformed like that. I just couldn't believe it. It was horrible. And looking at it, it was more than painful for me to think how the fingers were burned, hands and fingers that would hold babies or turn pages, they just, they just burned away. For a few years after the A-bomb was dropped, I
was terribly afraid of fire. I wasn't even able to get close to fire because all my senses remembered how fearful and horrible the fire was, how hot the blaze was, and how hard it was to breathe the hot air. It was really hard to breathe. Maybe because the fire burned all the oxygen, I don't know. I could
not open my eyes enough because of the smoke, which was everywhere. Not only me but everyone felt the same. And my parts were covered with holes.

Read more.

Now imagine I know some children and I tell it like this, before they've even heard of World War 2. I read the Hiroshima survivor stories to them, and then say,

"That is the story of what the Americans did to the Japanese in August 1945. They dropped a massive bomb on a Japanese city that caused terrible painful injuries and deaths for thousands of people. Some died later, because there was a horrible thing called radiation sickness that killed many of the people who'd escaped with their lives when the bomb first fell. Quite a lot of people have got cancer today because it was so horrible it affected people for a long long time afterwards. As for the people who got injured at the time, a lot of them had to have legs and arms amputated so they were disabled for the rest of their lives."

I could go on like that for the next ten minutes about how terrible the American atrocity of dropping the bomb was because it did so much harm to the people. Your splitting the skull of a three-year-old and then killing the pregnant mother example would look tame compared to what I could say about the disgusting atrocity of the American attack on Hiroshima. Compared to the deaths of a few hundred Amalekites, the Americans achieved death and injury and suffering on a much wider scale. And that's only one war! The Americans have been involved in many wars where children, little babies and pregnant women were horribly killed.

I could tell a child all that, doing a bit of research and then reeling off American atrocities for days, and turn them into a person filled with virrulent hatred towards Americans, thinking they didn't deserve to even be allowed to live! Ironically, they might then go on to justify the killing of American children and little babies and pregnant women, as an expedient preventative measure against the psychopathic race reproducing. But for the rest of their lives, they might spew hate against Americans on all the Internet forums they become members of, and in all the discussions with friends they have.

--------

I'm sorry it has been necessary for me to stoop to such an analogy, people. ... (Well, not that sorry at all really, if the truth be told.) I may well have to do the like of it again and again before the point gets home.

The basic point is that it's extremely easy to rage against atrocities that you have an utterly distorted impression of. You can't legitimately divorce the killing of a baby from its context and hold it up as an example of a terrible thing that could never be justified under any circumstances. Context is essential to understanding what was really going on. If the example of the three-year-old with the pregnant mother is repeated, or any variation of it, I'm just going to have to illustrate this point again with more Hiroshima stories, or stories of other wars where American atrocities have left women, children and babies brutally injured, killed or psychologically traumatised, and more examples of how I could make Americans look like the most depraved psychopaths by simply telling such stories to people who didn't know about World War 2 or the other wars, without giving any context to them.

... Well, that's enough sadistic glee for a few minutes. I need to go and calm down with a cup of tea immediately. I'll be back to respond to the rest of what Foster Zygot said when I've psyched myself down from the mood I've just psyched myself up into where I'm raring to go and gleefully plaster the skies with anti-American hate propaganda. ... No sorry, I'm exaggerating here. Honestly, truly I am. A lot. Please don't chase me from the board in outrage just yet, American contingent of the audience. :D

... I'll be back!
 
The alternatives are, if anything, worse; perhaps that your reading of the Bible has been so superficial that you've gained a very simplistic impression, and yet, apparently not realising how superficial your reading of the Bible has been, you confidently trumpet your ideas as if they're the ultimate truth. Why would you do that? Or maybe there's yet another explanation, that you speak out with perceptions distorted by anger, after feeling as if you were betrayed all that time you were a Christian because you were taught to believe things you now think were wrong, so now you want to just condemn and condemn in the hope that other people don't have to suffer your fate, or in simple reactionary outrage at feeling as if you were deceived?
It's a bit amusing that you just created two fictional scenarios in order to defend a fictional book.
 
This isn't an argument that you want to make, really. The logical progression is:

-we should be doing more to prevent these attrocities.
-most of these attrocities, as evidenced in both Scholarly history and Biblical History, are a result of religion.
Therefore, the only logical response is to abandon religion. And before you start, I will agree that not all of bad things are a result of religion. But it is still a leading cause, and abandoning it is still the logical thing to do based on your arguments.

Really, I don't think this is going to end where you want it.

Wow! Another person who's totally missed the point! How could you have got where you got? Just because the Bible is a religious book, it doesn't follow that any atrocities recorded in it happened because of religion.

And you're absolutely right that this debate won't end where I want it. It won't end the way I'd ideally like it to at all. But that will not be because I'll lose the argument. On the contrary, it'll be because I will be provoked into putting arguments on the board that I would ordinarily prefer that no one made, arguments more militant and prone to antagonise than I would wish anyone to put here normally, arguments like these, for example. I'll provide the links. If I'm provoked some more with the "religion is inherently bad" line of argument, I will quote them in order to illustrate points that will clearly have been missed. ... OK, just one link for now, the joyfully entitled: The Real Murderers: Atheism or Christianity?

It estimates figures for the number of people who've been killed by Christian regimes and the number who've been killed by atheist ones; and the number killed by atheist ones is far, far, far higher!

As I said, I'd rather not bring these kinds of arguments into a debate; they are as simplistic as the arguments my opposition are using. Of course most of those people weren't killed just because those regimes were Christian or atheist.

What I have said on this board before is that the real problem is not atheism or religion but militancy on both sides. See my post here. I'll quote from it:

I can understand the knee-jerk impulse to abolish religion, designating it worthless. I had just such an impulse for a few seconds earlier this week when
I read this gruesome article: Fr Edward, survivor of arson in Orissa: the Hindu radicals are terrorists

...

Code:
Mumbai (AsiaNews) - Fr Edward Sequeira, one of the victims of the violence committed by Hindu radicals in Orissa, does not hesitate to call them "terrorists".
Groups connected to Sangh Parivar seized him, beat him for more than an hour, and then shut him inside a room that they set on fire. Fr Edward was able
to save himself by taking shelter in the bathroom. Before he passed out, he heard the screams of Rajni Majh, who was tied up and thrown into the flames, ...

[Read the original post or article for more]

There we seem to see a clear example of religion being used as a vehicle to whip people's feelings into a frenzy so they do terrible things. But does that
mean the world would be a better place if religion were to go? Wouldn't those who wanted to rouse a rabble just use a different style of propaganda that
whipped up a different kind of bigotry? "Those immigrants! They ..."; "Those foreigners who want to replace our culture with corrupt Western culture where
thousands of families break up every week ..." and so on. What I think needs to go is extremism of any form. After all, atheism can just as easily be used
as a vehicle through which psychopaths can whip up violence as religion can. Take the Jacobins in France, for instance: France's great paradox to pursue secularism with religious zeal

Code:
It began in 1792, with the extremist Jacobins seizing power in France. Jacobinism is a paradox: a mix of revolutionary atheism and authoritarian republican
statism. This resulted in a concerted attack on religion, leading to a hideous civil war which claimed hundreds of thousands of victims in the west of
France. 

The coming to power of Napoleon meant the repeal of much Jacobin anti-clericalism and for a time, there was peace between politicians and the church. However,
in 1880 the militantly atheistic Jules Ferry (an ancestor of the present Education Minister, philosopher Luc Ferry) started the war with religion again,
expelling all religious staff from public schools, and nuns from hospitals. France seemed set for turmoil again, but fortunately moderate elements intervened.

Does the fact that atheism can be used as a catalyst for violence mean atheism ought to be forbidden? Of course not. It's militancy of all descriptions
that can easily be manipulated by people wanting to stir up trouble. Extremism thrives in places where people have grievances, such as where there are
big wealth inequalities.

Not long ago, there was a programme on the BBC World Service that asked the question of whether growing prosperity was the key to solving the problem of
extremism and thus terrorism, since greater satisfaction with life and more opportunities to do fulfilling things in life would dampen extremist sentiment
and divert people who might have been extremists into better things. It was argued on one side that prosperity might not be the key, since the leaders
of extremist organisations tended to be prosperous. But someone pointed out that ...

If you want to know the rest, read the original post.
 
WowJust because the Bible is a religious book, it doesn't follow that any atrocities recorded in it happened because of religion.

Indeed, one need not assume that atrocities are caused by religion simply because they are caused by the religious and because the perpetrators used religion as an excuse. They might have done these things anyway.

If we start with the assumption that at least a part of the Bible is inaccurate, un-authoritative, or just plain lies, it's easy enough to reconcile the atrocities attributed to divine guidance and order with the possibility of a God, if one is inclined to believe that such a god exists - even with the possibility of the God named in the Bible, and even with the possibility that that God is good. But it only works if you assume the Bible is in error, and cherry pick accordingly. If what the Bible says is all true, then God has genocide on his record.
 
That is argument by extreme simplicity. I find it very difficult to believe you think that's all the Bible says there is to it.
Then by all means, please present your far more sophisticated and scholarly interpretation of why the Bible claims that Joshua's army murdered children.

The alternatives are, if anything, worse; perhaps that your reading of the Bible has been so superficial that you've gained a very simplistic impression, and yet, apparently not realising how superficial your reading of the Bible has been, you confidently trumpet your ideas as if they're the ultimate truth. Why would you do that? Or maybe there's yet another explanation, that you speak out with perceptions distorted by anger, after feeling as if you were betrayed all that time you were a Christian because you were taught to believe things you now think were wrong, so now you want to just condemn and condemn in the hope that other people don't have to suffer your fate, or in simple reactionary outrage at feeling as if you were deceived?
I'm sorry. You still aren't any closer to understanding me than you were.

Yes, speculating about your motives does indeed make me feel better, because it's interesting and fun. Thanks for not minding.
I get the impression that it's much more interesting and fun that addressing any of my actual points. But please keep in mind that you have now opened the door to anyone who cares to do so engaging in open speculation as to your motives.

Possibly something similar to what might make the terrible American nuking of Japan seem warranted.
"Probably." So you don't really know. The reason could have been that the Hebrews simply wanted their land. We are told in a number of places that various communities in Canaan were terrified of Joshua's army. It is difficult to argue that all of the bloodshed attributed to Joshua's command was strictly in self defense.

Apart from the fact that your use of the term genocide is a misnoma
Firstly, it's "misnomer". Secondly, the 1948 United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, article 2 says that you are wrong.

"any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: killing members of the group; causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life, calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; [and] forcibly transferring children of the group to another group."

And are you really going to argue that the Nazis didn't commit genocidal acts simply because they didn't succeed in rendering the Jews extinct?

- the Bible doesn't say that any race was driven to extinction,
You're right. After all, YHWH kills every human being on Earth other than a single family. Joshua merely slaughters every living thing in several cities and towns. He can't match his god for pure killing power.

Makkedah: Joshua 10:28 He annihilated everyone who lived there and left no survivors.

Libnah: Joshua 10:30 Israel put the sword to all who lived there and they left no survivors.

Lachish: Joshua 10:32 They put the sword to all who lived there, just as they had done to Libnah.

Eglon: Joshua 10:35 They captured it and put the sword to all who lived there, utterly destroying everyone in it, just as they had done to Lachish.

Hebron: Joshua 10:37 They left no one alive. As they had done at Eglon, they utterly destroyed all who lived there.

Debir: Joshua 10:39 They utterly destroyed everyone who lived there, and left no one alive. 40 Thus Joshua struck the whole country. He left not one survivor, as Yahweh, god of Israel had commanded.

Hazor: Joshua 11:11 In accordance with the curse of destruction, everyone who lived there was put to the sword, not sparing anything that breathed.

Joshua 11:14 But they utterly destroyed all the human beings (22 kingdoms), not sparing a single soul.

and you'd probably realise that if your examination of it wasn't so evidently superficial as to make you think it says any killing took place simply because "God willed it"...
Really?

Joshua 10:40 Thus Joshua struck the whole country. He left not one survivor, as Yahweh, god of Israel had commanded.

OK, here are some survivor stories from victims of the American nuking of Hiroshima...
Let's go with an even better analogy: the destruction of the Native American cultures by the United States Government. Imagine an American who attempts to justify the destruction lest he have to admit that his own nation could commit genocidal murder. Well that's what you seem to be doing. You are unwilling to condemn the Bible just as someone might be unwilling to condemn his own culture. So you respond with a bunch of tu quoque arguments that do nothing to justify the killing of children claimed by the authors of the Bible.

Ironically, considering your fondness for telling others that they miss the point, you don't seem to understand, despite it being clearly and elegantly pointed out by Bruto, that the point of most of us arguing against your position it that the descriptions of cruelty presented as the work of a perfect and just god by the authors of the Bible simply goes to show that the true origin of the Bible is all too human.
 
Last edited:
bruto said:
If what the Bible says is all true, then God has genocide on his record.

Not genocide as such - I don't think the Bible says entire races were wiped out. For instance, after it says the Israelites killed the Amalekites, it mentions Amalekites, so some were still around, according to that.

Still, a lot of what happened seems really gross. The funny thing is, I never claimed it was possible to put up a really good defence of it - I simply said I could put up a "better" one than Hamelekim had in the election thread, and was suddenly faced with outraged screaming opposition. I'll give them what they deserve! Or I should say, I already have. Not that I expect them to pay enough attention to it to take it in well.

It's been argued that both the Amalekites and Canaanites had histories of aggression against other nations, which would naturally involve the suffering of men, women, children and little babies. How true the allegations are are open to question. This article makes the claims about the Amalekites and this one makes them against the Canaanites. Warning - they're both very long, so skimming them might be better than taking on the daunting task of reading them fully, should anyone be thinking of trying.

A basic mistake some skeptics make that just antagonises opposition is to dismiss such things out of hand as reasons aggression against those nations could be justified, just brushing them off as if Amalekite or Canaanite aggression against other nations would be no more significant than stealing a few grapes from one of their vineyards. Then they argue that to kill children would have been unjust no matter what, completely failing to suggest alternatives. They hold up examples of cruelty to children and appeal to the emotion of their audience by giving lurid descriptions of them, without suggesting alternative ways the children could have been dealt with. If the children were kept by the communities who warred against their menfolk, they're accused of keeping them for sex slavery. So it seems we have a lose/lose situation.

But is it not possible that assimilating the children into their communities rather than killing them, could be storing up trouble for them in a future generation, if the male children were to grow up and become discontented and, still harboring feelings of revenge for the deaths of the warring adults of their communities, they turned against the host community they'd been taken into? It's the utter failure of some skeptics to take such issues as these into account and provide counter-arguments to the specific issues that makes their arguments seem simplistic, when all they muster up is yet more emotional outrage at the idea that children could be killed.

bruto said:
Indeed, one need not assume that atrocities are caused by religion simply because they are caused by the religious and because the perpetrators used religion
as an excuse. They might have done these things anyway.

That wasn't the point I was making. They didn't use religion as an excuse, at least, not in a simplistic way, as in "My religion's better than yours so yours needs to go". The Law of Moses describes religious practices such as child sacrifice as reasons why the people were so evil they needed to be conquered. It also describes other things. Look at Leviticus 18, for example - all those prohibitions on sex with various relatives. At the end, it says the people of Canaan did all those things and that it was because of such things as that that they were going to be driven out of their land.

Later on, when Bible books like Isaiah and Jeremiah start prophesying horrendous destruction on the people of Israel through foreign invaders, they give a long list of cruel and harmful behaviours they accuse Israelites of havving engaged in, saying that they're the reason destruction has been decreed. See a long litany of the things the prophets accused them of being guilty of, plus things the Canaanites were said to be guilty of like child sacrifice. That page consists mainly of lots of Bible quotes making accusations of cruelty. That is why I have claimed before, much to people's horror, that although the Old Testament is full of descriptions of disgusting atrocity that it would be extremely difficult to justify, it does in fact contain a core of compassion, because the reason for many of the atrocities is said to be a reaction against the cruelty of the people the atrocities were committed against.

OK, I'll illustrate by quoting several of the Bible passages from that page:

Amos chapter 2 (TEV)

6 The Lord says, "The people of Israel have sinned again and again, and for this I will certainly punish them. They sell into slavery honest people who cannot pay their debts, the poor [just because they] cannot repay even the price of a pair of sandals."

Amos chapter 2 (NLT)

7 They trample helpless people in the dust and deny justice to those who are oppressed. Both father and son sleep with the same woman, corrupting my holy name. 8 At their religious festivals, they lounge around in clothing stolen from their debtors. In the house of their god, they present offerings of wine purchased with stolen money.

Micah chapter 2 (NLT)

1 How terrible it will be for you who lie awake at night, thinking up evil plans. You rise at dawn and hurry to carry out any of the wicked schemes you have power to accomplish. 2 When you want a certain piece of land, you find a way to seize it. When you want someone's house, you take it by fraud and violence. No one's family or inheritance is safe with you around! 8 Yet to this very hour my people rise against me! You steal the shirts right off the backs of those who trusted you, making them as ragged as men who have just come home from battle. 9 You have evicted women from their homes and stripped their children of all their God-given rights. 11 Suppose a prophet full of lies were to say to you, "I'll preach to you the joys of wine and drink!" That's just the kind of prophet you would like!

Amos chapter 5 (GWT)

7 You, Israel, turn justice into poison and throw righteousness on the ground. 10 Israel, you hate anyone who speaks out against injustice. You are disgusted by anyone who speaks the truth. 11 You trample on the poor and take their wheat from them for taxes. ... 12 I know that your crimes are numerous and your sins are many. You oppress the righteous by taking bribes. You deny the needy access to the courts. 13 That is why a wise person remains silent at such times, because those times are so evil.

Isaiah Chapter 59 (NIV)

3 Your hands are stained with blood, your fingers with guilt. Your lips have spoken lies, and your tongue mutters wicked things. 4 No one calls for justice; no one pleads his case with integrity. They rely on empty arguments and speak lies; they conceive trouble and give birth to evil. 7 Their feet rush into sin; they are swift to shed innocent blood. Their thoughts are evil thoughts; ruin and destruction mark their ways. 8 The way of peace they do not know; there is no justice in their paths. They have turned them into crooked roads; no one who walks in them will know peace. 14 So justice is driven back, and righteousness stands at a distance; truth has stumbled in the streets, honesty cannot enter. 15 Truth is nowhere to be found, and whoever shuns evil becomes a prey.

The LORD looked and was displeased that there was no justice. 16 He saw that there was no one, he was appalled that there was no one to intervene;

Isaiah chapter 5 (NIV)

7 He looked for justice, but saw bloodshed; for righteousness, but heard cries of distress.

Ezekiel chapter 23 (NLT)

37 They have committed both adultery and murder - adultery by worshiping idols and murder by burning their children as sacrifices on their altars. 38 Then after doing these terrible things, they defiled my Temple and violated my Sabbath day! 39 On the very day that they murdered their children in front of their idols, they boldly came into my Temple to worship! They came in and defiled my house!

Jeremiah chapter 7 (GWT)

30 "The people of Judah have done what I consider evil," declares the LORD. "They set up their detestable idols in the house that is called by my name. They have made it unclean. 31 They have built worship sites at Topheth in the valley of Ben Hinnom in order to burn their sons and daughters as sacrifices. I did not ask for this. It never entered my mind."

Ezekiel chapter 20 (GWT)

30 "Tell the nation of Israel, 'This is what the Almighty LORD says: Will you dishonor yourselves the way your ancestors did? Will you chase their detestable idols like a prostitute? 31 You offer your children as sacrifices by burning them alive. You dishonor yourselves with all your disgusting idols to this day. Should you be allowed to ask me for help, nation of Israel? "

Ezekiel chapter 9 (NLT)

9 Then he said to me, "The sins of the people of Israel and Judah are very great. The entire land is full of murder; the city is filled with injustice. They are saying, 'The LORD doesn't see it! The LORD has forsaken the land!'

Ezekiel chapter 24 (NLT)

6 "Now this is what the Sovereign LORD says: Destruction is certain for Jerusalem, the city of murderers! She is a pot filled with corruption. ... 7 for her wickedness is evident to all. She murders boldly, leaving blood on the rocks for all to see. She doesn't even try to cover it!"

Jeremiah chapter 7 (NLT)

8 "'Do you think that because the Temple is here you will never suffer? Don't fool yourselves! 9 Do you really think you can steal, murder, commit adultery, lie, and worship Baal and all those other new gods of yours, 10 and then come here and stand before me in my Temple and chant, "We are safe!" - only to go right back to all those evils again? 11 Do you think this Temple, which honors my name, is a den of thieves? I see all the evil going on there, says the LORD.

Amos chapter 8 (TEV)

4 Listen to this, you that trample on the needy and try to destroy the poor of the country. 5 You say to yourselves, "We can hardly wait for the holy days to be over so that we can sell our grain. When will the Sabbath end, so that we can start selling again? Then we can overcharge, use false measures, and fix the scales to cheat our customers. 6 We can sell worthless wheat at a high price. We'll find someone poor who can't pay his debts, not even the price of a pair of sandals, and we'll buy him as a slave."

Ezekiel chapter 7 (CEV)

10 Injustice and arrogance are everywhere, 11 and violent criminals run free. 23 Your whole country is in confusion! Murder and violence are everywhere in Israel.

Isaiah Chapter 9 (NIV)

16 Those who guide this people mislead them, and those who are guided are led astray. 17 Therefore the Lord will take no pleasure in the young men, nor will he pity the fatherless and widows, for everyone is ungodly and wicked, every mouth speaks vileness.

Jeremiah Chapter 6 (NIV)

13 "From the least to the greatest, all are greedy for gain; prophets and priests alike, all practice deceit."

Jeremiah chapter 9 (NIV)

3 "They make ready their tongue like a bow, to shoot lies; it is not by truth that they triumph in the land. They go from one sin to another; they do not acknowledge me," declares the LORD. 4 "Beware of your friends; do not trust your brothers. For every brother is a deceiver, and every friend a slanderer. 5 Friend deceives friend, and no one speaks the truth. They have taught their tongues to lie; they weary themselves with sinning. 6 You live in the midst of deception; in their deceit they refuse to acknowledge me," declares the LORD. 8 Their tongue is a deadly arrow; it speaks with deceit. With his mouth each speaks cordially to his neighbor, but in his heart he sets a trap for him.

Jeremiah chapter 17 (NLT)

9 "The human heart is most deceitful and desperately wicked. Who really knows how bad it is? 10 But I know! I, the LORD, search all hearts and examine secret motives. I give all people their due rewards, according to what their actions deserve."

11 Like a bird that hatches eggs she has not laid, so are those who get their wealth by unjust means. Sooner or later they will lose their riches and, at the end of their lives, will become poor old fools.

Isaiah chapter 1 (TEV)

21 The city that once was faithful is behaving like a whore! At one time it was filled with righteous people, but now only murderers remain. 22 Jerusalem, you were once like silver, but now you are worthless; you were like good wine, but now you are only water. 23 Your leaders are rebels and friends of thieves; they are always accepting gifts and bribes. They never defend orphans in court or listen when widows present their case.

Jeremiah chapter 5 (NIV)

11 "The house of Israel and the house of Judah have been utterly unfaithful to me," declares the LORD. 26 "Among my people are wicked men who lie in wait like men who snare birds and like those who set traps to catch men. 27 Like cages full of birds, their houses are full of deceit; they have become rich and powerful 28 and have grown fat and sleek. Their evil deeds have no limit; they do not plead the case of the fatherless to win it, they do not defend the rights of the poor."

Habakkuk chapter 1 (NLT)

2 How long, O LORD, must I call for help? But you do not listen! "Violence!" I cry, but you do not come to save. 3 Must I forever see this sin and misery all around me? Wherever I look, I see destruction and violence. I am surrounded by people who love to argue and fight. 4 The law has become paralyzed and useless, and there is no justice given in the courts. The wicked far outnumber the righteous, and justice is perverted with bribes and trickery.

Isaiah chapter 28 (NLT)

7 Now, however, Israel is being led by drunks! The priests and prophets reel and stagger from beer and wine. They make stupid mistakes as they carry out their responsibilities. 8 Their tables are covered with vomit; filth is everywhere.

Isaiah Chapter 10 (NIV)

21 Woe to those who are wise in their own eyes and clever in their own sight.

22 Woe to those who are heroes at drinking wine and champions at mixing drinks, 23 who acquit the guilty for a bribe, but deny justice to the innocent.

---------

There are lots more where those came from.
 
Not genocide as such - I don't think the Bible says entire races were wiped out. For instance, after it says the Israelites killed the Amalekites, it mentions Amalekites, so some were still around, according to that.

Still, a lot of what happened seems really gross. The funny thing is, I never claimed it was possible to put up a really good defence of it - I simply said I could put up a "better" one than Hamelekim had in the election thread, and was suddenly faced with outraged screaming opposition. I'll give them what they deserve! Or I should say, I already have. Not that I expect them to pay enough attention to it to take it in well.

It's been argued that both the Amalekites and Canaanites had histories of aggression against other nations, which would naturally involve the suffering of men, women, children and little babies. How true the allegations are are open to question. This article makes the claims about the Amalekites and this one makes them against the Canaanites. Warning - they're both very long, so skimming them might be better than taking on the daunting task of reading them fully, should anyone be thinking of trying.

A basic mistake some skeptics make that just antagonises opposition is to dismiss such things out of hand as reasons aggression against those nations could be justified, just brushing them off as if Amalekite or Canaanite aggression against other nations would be no more significant than stealing a few grapes from one of their vineyards. Then they argue that to kill children would have been unjust no matter what, completely failing to suggest alternatives. They hold up examples of cruelty to children and appeal to the emotion of their audience by giving lurid descriptions of them, without suggesting alternative ways the children could have been dealt with. If the children were kept by the communities who warred against their menfolk, they're accused of keeping them for sex slavery. So it seems we have a lose/lose situation.
Excellent we can now add two more to the list:

It is OK for god to demand genocide and the slaughter of infants and babies because...

1.) They could be an evil parasitic alien species.
2.) America dropped the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
3.) Abortion is legal.
4.) God didn't kill everyone, just almost everyone (so it wasn't genocide.
5.) killing all the children will prevent future wars.


that last one is just priceless. The Cut off my nose to spite my face defense.

It's the utter failure of some skeptics to take such issues as these into account and provide counter-arguments to the specific issues that makes their arguments seem simplistic, when all they muster up is yet more emotional outrage at the idea that children could be killed.
So god's best policy is scortched earth? It's better to punish the kids for things the MAY do, rather than things they will do? Are you telling me that god couldn't come up with a better way than simply demanding the death of children?

Nowadays, the world community denounces and fights agaisnt such totalitarian methods. So, the answer is, There are other more noble moral ways and people have discovered them. Why couldn't god have taught us this then?
 
If the children were kept by the communities who warred against their menfolk, they're accused of keeping them for sex slavery. So it seems we have a lose/lose situation.
Except that it doesn't say that they kept the children. In fact it specifically says that all the male children were killed. Only young virgin girls were kept alive. Now why do you suppose that was?

But is it not possible that assimilating the children into their communities rather than killing them, could be storing up trouble for them in a future generation, if the male children were to grow up and become discontented and, still harboring feelings of revenge for the deaths of the warring adults of their communities, they turned against the host community they'd been taken into? It's the utter failure of some skeptics to take such issues as these into account and provide counter-arguments to the specific issues that makes their arguments seem simplistic, when all they muster up is yet more emotional outrage at the idea that children could be killed.
Listen to yourself: you are saying that the people with the problem are the ones who are appalled by the glorification of murdering whole communities, including children, while you yourself offer apologetics in defense of the killers. Do you really feel this way or are you simply determined not to condemn actions attributed to the god of Abraham.

I wonder, do you have any children?
 
Warning - they're both very long, so skimming them might be better than taking on the daunting task of reading them fully, should anyone be thinking of trying.
Do you really want to say things like that?

Here We Go...

The author of this piece said they had received a reply to their own piece, which was "How could a God of love order the annihilation of the Canaanites"... This author then stated that the person who sent in the reply wasn’t the original author, and that author requested that the reply be removed, which the site author did; however, the site author “rewrote and reorganized” the reply, which seems to me that the request was not really honored at all. Be that as it may, the first question in the reply was apparently:

Does the bible actually portray God as “infinitely merciful and just” and at the same time as a genocidal deity, contradicting itself at a deep, moral level?

The site author replied that God isn’t necessarily always merciful, just “most of the time: or “tending more towards mercy,” and then tried to argue that God’s genocidal behavior didn’t “count” because later historical genocide just seems so much worse. This is the same ridiculous fallacy the site author uses time and time again in other arguments, and it is totally wrong for reasons that a three-year-old could understand. Leaving aside all other reasons why this is so, one injustice does not excuse another. An accused murderer who tries to say “Sure, I killed someone, but there’s this other person 2,000 miles away who killed someone else, you know!” is not going to get a verdict of “not guilty” because of this argument.( He’d be a lot better off trying to get a verdict of insanity because of it.) This argument is so completely false that everyone should simply ignore it from now on, and nobody with an IQ high enough to be posting anything on a discussion forum should bring it up. It does not make sense for the site author to try to build a case that the slaughter of the Amalekites somehow wasn’t comparable to historical genocide ((because it wasn’t ideological, retributive, developmental, or despotic, because the Amalekites weren’t targeted because they were a member of a particular group, and so on.)

Then the author wanders off into discussing how this incident might be used to try to “prove that God didn’t exist” because God can’t perform an unjust act, God ordered the killing of children, that can never be a just act, so this means that God really CAN perform an unjust act and there’s your contradiction. So the author finds the problem in the part where the killing of children supposedly could NEVER be an unjust act—in other words, there might be exceptions!! Incredibly creepy.

Next, the site author offers what they describe as “the meat of the issue.” It is not. Not for one second. The real meat of the issue is so simple and obvious that it’s incredible to think anybody would write such a long essay when a five-year-old should have known this. To prove I’ve read this thing, however, I’m going to analyze what was said, although it’s a stupid waste of time.

What was the timing of the events surrounding the judgment of the Amalekites?

Israel sins against God in Numbers 14, God allows the Amalekites to attack them, God makes a prophecy that Israel will someday destroy them, and after 40 years of wandering, God reminds them that it’s time to fulfill the prophecy. There’s a bit of PR about the Amalekites in the Bible, most of it not great, but as the site author reasonably asks, Do we have any reason to believe that this “Israelite-version” of the history is reliable, and not just the ‘song of the conquering victors’, who have violently stolen the land from the innocent Amalekites and naturally leave such ‘crimes’ out of their literature? The author says yes, but there’s no reason to believe this is true. The author admits there’s no extra-biblical records of the Amalekites at all, although he/she weakly offers “evidence” (which we don’t know is true) about supposed negative traits of other tribes in the same region and the same era (with no explanation, AGAIN, of how on earth this justified what the Israelites did to the Amalekites. AGAIN, this nonsensical tactic would not fly for one millisecond in any court of law.)

Then, the author moves on to:
But doesn’t this event fit the anti-biblical pattern of “punishing the children for the sons of the parents”?
(yes, that’s actually what it literally says. Clearly, the SINS of the parents is what’s meant. Freudian slip/?)
Basically, the arguments just become more and more offensive from here on out. The author pretty much says that in reality, children DO suffer for the sins of the parents. We then get some silliness about how what is supposedly being said in the Old Testament is that children are being punished for sinning in the same way as their fathers rather than being themselves sinless and having the sins of their fathers visited upon them, which is then equated with the idea of a people sinning in the same way as their rulers have sinned. This argument really has nothing to do with anything, even though the author tries to say that the current set of Amalekites (who were slaughtered by the Israelites) somehow were sinning in the same way as the previous set of Amalekites (who killed the previous set of Israelites hundreds of years before), even though this was never proven.

Then, we get;

But aren’t individuals supposed to be punished for their OWN misdeeds ONLY, and not the misdeeds of others? (Deut 24:16, 2 Kings 14:1)


The author actually states: “Absolutely, but we need to not make the assumption that the killing of the dependents was a punishment on them, as opposed to a consequence of the punishment on the fathers. Morally, there is a huge difference.”This was followed by a number of Biblical examples where people’s descendants were punished for what their ancestors did, such as (2 Sam 1.14ff), .(I Kings 2.31ff), and (I Kings 2.36), and some horrible arguments about how because children suffer the consequences of what their parents do anyway, that somehow makes it all right, but I have a difficult time believing that the site author actually was crazy enough to write this, frankly.

Here is the heart of the problem, the real “meat of the argument:

The original argument was that God commanded inexcusable crimes in the Bible—for example, telling Israel to slaughter Amalekites because other Amalekites had killed other Israelites hundreds of years ago. The author just brings up a lot more examples of God doing the exact same thing in other situations and makes it very, VERY clear that these things happen because God wants them to happen. To try to argue against the criminal behavior commanded by God by bringing up even more examples of the criminal behavior commanded by God is insane. Nobody in their right mind should be making this argument. The rest of the argument is evil and sick, and I hope this author is not allowed around children.

The author ends up with the weakest argument yet:

But why couldn’t the Israelites just ‘ignore’ the Amalekites?
Because they were evil, etc., but the problem is that the author is relying on the Israelites’ version of what they were, and he/she’s already admitted that there are no extra-Biblical sources on this.
Then, of course, we come to the worst part of all. I will analyze this in detail, but again, a detailed analysis is completely unnecessary. The real solution can be summed up in one sentence, and at the end, that’s what I’ll do. However, here’s the one important thing to keep in mind when it comes to this author’s analysis of why it supposedly made so much sense to kill off all the women and children. This analysis is being made purely and solely in terms of practical history, of the actual, literal history of two peoples called the Israelites and the Amalekites. Got it? Good.

So, if the Amalekite aggression virtually required the elimination of the warrior-class, what practical options for survival remained for the women/kids?

Just to put this in perspective, here’s exactly how the author began this section:
Well, if this analysis is correct so far, we are faced clearly with the problem I pointed out earlier--the widows and fatherless kids, in the desert. This is, as pointed out above, a situation that the Amalekite warriors put their families in--NOT the Israelites per se.

Next, we’re told that the Israelites’ only options for the women and children were:

1. Take them back as slaves (or to be sold as slaves)
2. Take them back and turn them over to social relief programs/processes in Israel.
3. Leave them there in the desert to their fate
4. Kill them there in the desert

The author analyzes why it was not “practical” for Israel to keep all those women and children as slaves (no resources to assimilate all these people) and coolly notes that God didn’t create a miracle that could have saved all those lives because, well, God just doesn’t do miracles to solve problems that way.

On to #2. The author states that there were no social relief programs in the ancient world that could have possibly handled that number of people.

Then #3. The author argues that this would mean either prolonged and agonizing death or being captured by foreign slave traders, which would be worse.

As for #4… you’re not even going to believe this… the author spends several paragraphs presenting lots of historical data on how people prefer quick deaths over long, drawn-out ones or foreign slavery, and how this “moral difficulty was forced on the Israelites by the Amalekite warrior aggression.”

We are swiftly steered away from pondering how this might apply to such issues as ‘death with dignity” or advanced directives by the author insistently reminding us that only God has the power to decide on “euthanasia”.

Then, we get:
But if we visualize the horror of the scene—mothers watching children be killed, and children watching their mother be cut down—surely this cannot be ‘right’?!

Again, the site author engages in the most disturbing moral relativism imaginable. We are told that well, yes, this is disturbing, but just compare it to that! (completely made-up and extra-Biblical stories about apocryphal things the Amalekites supposedly did.)

And;

But doesn’t the “justice of the biblical god” in this situation look more like the most horrific of war crimes?
This is probably the most common-sense question yet asked, but the author naturally doesn’t really answer it. First, he/she dithers about how God actually was too lenient in not doing anything about the Amalekites for hundreds of years after they originally attacked the Israelites; then there’s some nonsense about how the main thrust of the command to kill was against the warriors and the women and children just happened to be killed as part of their “property”, and then we once again get the argument that killing that “property” was actually the most merciful thing to do.

As a penultimate argument, we get:

But if the biblical god was indeed omnipotent, then it would seem he could have done many things rather than slaughter so many people. And if he couldn't have done anything else, wouldn’t this show then that He is NOT omnipotent? (aren’t we back to “God is either good OR omnipotent—but not BOTH” kind of arguments?)

It’s worth also quoting the rest of the main argument here:
The major problem with this is theological, concerning the omnipotence of God.

The omnipotence argument can be sketched out like this:

a. God can do all things
b. Accordingly, God could have resolved the issue by some other means that extermination of the group.
c. God DIDN'T use a different method than the one involving extermination.

Therefore either:
d. God is omnipotent, but cruel (because He chose extermination rather than other presumably less-violent paths)

or . God is not necessarily cruel, but He is NOT omnipotent either(because He couldn't come up with non-cruel alternatives)

There’s no way out of this, which is why the author can’t find one. First he/she makes a very weak argument, which is that for God, “omnipotence normally doesn't 'play' in historical settings.” God sets up the rules, so he just has to stick to them. He supposedly decides that he’s not going to behave as if he’s omnipotent, and so he doesn’t interfere. In the author’s words, the main thing is “the principle of God holding up the law of moral consequences (within social and cultural contexts of connections and community).” But for one thing, the author has already portrayed God as omnipotent all over this argument. For instance, he/she has already said that God was “too lenient” with the Amalekites, ‘allowing” them to “infiltrate” Israel for hundreds of years before commanding the Israelites to destroy them. Of course, we could just look at the main sentence of this argument. “It would seem he could have done many things rather than slaughter so many people.” If God had the power to slaughter all of these people to begin with, then how can this simply be “God holding up the law of moral consequences”? Why did we get a history lesson about the disturbing practical realities of the lives of nomadic peoples in the desert several thousand years ago if the central point is supposed to be the omnipotence of God? Isn't God supposed to be better than his human creations? Morally above us?

And of course, this is far, FAR from the biggest problem. In one way, of course, the biggest problem is the same one I’ve been saying all along: talking about how Atrocity A somehow cancels out Atrocity B is just nuts. In another way, you could say that the real problem is the insane argument that the slaughter of the Amalekites somehow represents the “law of moral consequences “, no matter what kind of inane codicil is added to the statement. But the biggest problem of all—I’ve saved it for last.

Finally, we end up with this:

But isn’t this using a “you gotta see the Big Picture” approach, to avoid accepting responsibility for clear ethical atrocities in the lives of specific individuals?

The author does something just bizarre here, and it reveals what’s really going on with this entire essay. She/he poses the main question as faced by God in this situation as being: “ In the case of the innocents here, we are facing a moral dilemma that essentially consists of "do we kill them swiftly?" or "do we let them die, slowly, painfully, and agonizingly?"--which is more merciful, given no other alternatives exist?” The ‘lifeboat scenario” is presented (some people may be familiar with this—it’s a classroom exercise often given in ethics classes. You’re the captain of a lifeboat, if you don’t throw someone overboard, everyone dies, how do you decide who to throw overboard, yada yada yada. )




And after a summary of the entire essay, here’s what we end up with:
So, as in the emotionally-churning alternatives of the Lifeboat, I am forced to say (with heavy heart, but probably not nearly as heavy as God's was that day--judgment has always grieved God--He knows all about the sorrow of governance, believe me) that the swift death of the innocents, in the context of a certain and much-more-suffering death in the desert, was the most merciful and least tragic course of action...

The author has equated themselves with God, and has made God not only human but into the worst kind of human. That’s why the God presented in this essay, the God who “had no choice” but to slaughter all the Amalekites—the men, the women, and the children—is not divine, but human. This idiocy is not only offensive and disgusting beyond all description, but, as bizarre as the word may sound, blasphemous. It pulls God down to a level lower than the worst human being. God is made into the serial killer of the universe. This is why this makes me so sick and offends me in a way that I can’t even describe. This is more destructive to Christianity and to faith than any kind of atheism or disbelief or secularism could ever be.
 
Last edited:
Forgive me for intruding on this... fascinating debate... but I can't help noticing the topic drift. The OP was on Jesus' last words, not whether there is genocide in the Bible.
 
I'll get around to replying to the latest things on the board and other things I've still got to catch up on later. First though, back to this:

Foster Zygote said:
Baby Nemesis said:
RandFan said:
No. The evidence against god stands and I'll leave it to you to decide if you've the temerity to defend the worst of depravity and cruelty. I don't need
to beg you. You either will play the devil's (god's)advocate or you won't. It's your choice. I've been here some 9 years. You know where to find me.
*
Perhaps you didn't hear me. I said who cares!

Many of us care enough to have an intelligent discussion of the subject. You appear to be merely dodging an issue that you are not comfortable discussing.

Not surprisingly, you're wrong. You completely misinterpreted my meaning.

What I was actually suggesting when I first said "who cares" to his challenge to a debate about how cruel the Bible portrays God as, was that if people find Christianity inspirational and it changes people's lives for the better so they and their communities benefit, does it really matter if in the end it turns out to have been based on a falsehood when everyone in the world just hurtles off into oblivion when they die rather than going into an after-life? Does it really matter if the Old Testament says God ordered some very nasty things if people aren't actually emulating them but instead finding inspiration to change for the better because of the good stuff? I know Christianity has been used as an excuse to do a lot of harm over the years, but I see that as a case not for squashing it, but for preaching the core issues more widely, to stop people getting distorted impressions of what it's about and using them to do harm. I'm talking about the core issues like these, from the New Testament, as I've said:

What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
What The Bible Says About Honesty And The Love Of Money.
A Short Story About Tackling Prejudice, And What The Bible Says About Despising People, Judging By Appearances, And God's Mercy.
What The Bible Says About Love And Caring.
What The Bible Says About Drunkenness and Why It's Wrong.
What The Bible Says About Lies, Gossip, Quarrelling, Insulting Language And Dirty Jokes.
What The Bible Says About Sex And Marriage.
What The Bible Says About Lustful And Nasty Thoughts.
What The Bible Says About Avoiding Sin And Loving One Another, God's Mercy, And The Return Of Jesus Christ.
What The Bible Says About The Life-Changing Power Of The Holy Spirit.

Edited by LibraryLady: 
Do not spam or flood the forums.


*****************************

Surely you can't deny they're inspirational? And a lot of people's lives have changed for the better when they've become Christians and started dedicating their lives to following them. Here are several testimonies from people who gave up lifestyles that were doing others harm - sometimes a lot of harm - when they became Christians:

How to Handle Angry People.
Gamblers Beware.
Leaving Unbelief and Promiscuity to Finding Jesus.
A Captive Set Free.
Three Times a Loser, Now Forever a Winner.
Testimony of Skip Lewis.
A Prodigal in Blue.
The Void.
Testimony of a Police Sergeant.
*Son of Hope.
The Coin Momma Lost.
Charles Barry Mayson's Testimony.
Shoplifting - breaking free. There is hope!
The Story of Walid - Former Palestinian Troublemaker.
The Story of Adel Mohammed El Naggar.
Boyhood Dream Almost Ate His Soul!
Freedom (Escape from) a Life of Violence.
Still Changing Lives!
The History of Keith Green.
The Testimony of Eric & Melanie Barger.
*
Would you see squashing their new-found hope as more important than the fact that they've been inspired to stop doing harm? Must they have Christianity argued out of them regardless of how it's inspired them to change?

Measures can surely be brought into being to stop Christianity being distorted and used for harmful purposes, without trying to squash the whole thing.

It's ironic indeed that some people seem convinced that Christianity is a terrible thing and that everyone should be argued out of it, until they notice a Christian not living up to those standards; and then, suddenly, Christianity becomes in their minds the force for good it purports itself to be, and they scold the Christian for not living up to Christian standards! If you know Christianity teaches that Christians should live up to high standards, why would you wish to see people stop being Christians?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What I was actually suggesting when I first said "who cares" to his challenge to a debate about how cruel the Bible portrays God as, was that if people find Christianity inspirational and it changes people's lives for the better so they and their communities benefit, does it really matter if in the end it turns out to have been based on a falsehood when everyone in the world just hurtles off into oblivion when they die rather than going into an after-life?
I'd rather believe in something closer to the truth than to believe in a pleasant lie.

Does it really matter if the Old Testament says God ordered some very nasty things if people aren't actually emulating them but instead finding inspiration to change for the better because of the good stuff?
You seem to be suggesting taht the good stuff outweighs the bad stuff.


If I was to donate all my money to the poor, selflessly help everyone arround me and killed a homeless person because I felt like it...am I any less a murderer?

I know Christianity has been used as an excuse to do a lot of harm over the years, but I see that as a case not for squashing it, but for preaching the core issues more widely, to stop people getting distorted impressions of what it's about and using them to do harm. I'm talking about the core issues like these, ...
You can teach all of the "core values" without needing the bible. it's not inherent or exclusive to the religion.

Besides, your claim of "trying to squash" is a straw man. I do not attempt to squash religion. Only that religion is held accountable like everyone else.
 
What I was actually suggesting when I first said "who cares" to his challenge to a debate about how cruel the Bible portrays God as, was that if people find Christianity inspirational and it changes people's lives for the better so they and their communities benefit, does it really matter if in the end it turns out to have been based on a falsehood when everyone in the world just hurtles off into oblivion when they die rather than going into an after-life? Does it really matter if the Old Testament says God ordered some very nasty things if people aren't actually emulating them but instead finding inspiration to change for the better because of the good stuff?

Yes, it certainly does in this context-- because you keep posting links to these absolutely horrible essays. The site author doesn't make that argument or anything remotely close to it. Instead, he/she deliberately presents massacres (such as the Israelites slaughtering the Amalekites) as the specific actions of God. What this author does not do is what you're doing in the above paragraph, which would seem to be to vaguely say that people should just find what's good in the Old Testament and ignore the bad. That line of argument isn't anywhere in that essay.

I know Christianity has been used as an excuse to do a lot of harm over the years, but I see that as a case not for squashing it, but for preaching the core issues more widely, to stop people getting distorted impressions of what it's about and using them to do harm. I'm talking about the core issues like these, from the New Testament, as I've said:

No, that kind of cherry-picking just doesn't work here. What we have all been talking and arguing about has nothing, nothing at all to do with these broader issues. We have all been specifically discussing the argument that God was justified in commanding Israel to slaughter the Amalekites-- men, women, and children-- because a completely different set of Amalekites killed a completely different set of Israelites two to four hundred years ago.

More specifically yet, this plays right into what I have been talking about-- the fact that the site author didn't bring up one single word about anything in the Gospels or the New Testament, or Jesus, or a new covenant, or... well, why even go on here. Why not? Wouldn't that have seemed natural here? Why did this author completely miss the most natural point in her/his pathetic excuse for an explanation here? Why didn't we see the argument that the Amalekites couldn't yet benefit from the saving grace and sacrifice of Jesus? Well, I'll tell you why: because if Jesus proceeds from the Father, then Jesus was eternally present, and a few thousand years didn't make any difference. This site author has officially shot herself and her theology right in the foot.


Since BN seems to suddenly like cherry-picking verses so much after accusing everyone else of it for several pages on end, here's another one,
Corinthians 13:12

For now we see things in a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now my knowledge is in part; then it will be complete, even as God's knowledge of me.

The only solution to this entire mess is that there is no way at all to argue for three things at once: the omnipotence of God, the goodness of God, and the literal inerrancy of the Bible. This one essay proved this fact all on its own, and also told us all everything we needed to know about the moral impoverishment of this site author (and everyone connected with the Tektonics site.) If BN is so determined to keep quoting and linking to sites and essays that are firmly committed to biblical inerrancy, and to keep arguing and arguing and arguing for them and using quotes from them in a gazillion posts, then he should understand that you don't get to pick and choose when it comes to that. You either believe in it, or you don't. You don't get to go back and forth. You have to dance with the one who brought you. BN or anyone else who tries to play the biblical inerrancy card can't turn around and then post things like the first paragraph I quoted. Well, they can, but it's a little late. What human being can or should pretend that they understand God by reading about how other imperfect human beings have struggled to understand God? How and why do people deceive themselves like this?
 
Ok, guys, own up. Whose strawman is Baby Nemesis? I mean, seriously, even if you want an easy apologist to smack down, it can be better done than the whole wide-eyed wonder act at some of the most stupidly illogical apologetics, or the wholesale posting of links to such retarded apologetics. I'm sorry, but linking to some page with two non-sequiturs and an appeal to authority as some great apology, or for that matter as anything but an example of brain damage, is laying it a bit thick even for a strawman sockpuppet.
 
Forgive me for intruding on this... fascinating debate... but I can't help noticing the topic drift. The OP was on Jesus' last words, not whether there is genocide in the Bible.


It's weird how these threads do seem to drift when BN is involved. I hope he isn't a sockpuppet, actually, because I will feel kind of dumb after writing all of those long reply posts.... ;)

Anyway, I think the way the drift happened (looks back over the thread) seems to be that people were arguing over the legitimacy of some of BN's arguments, and some of the quoted and linked material got dragged in (correct me if I'm wrong, please!) I don't BN expects anyone to actually read any of those long, long essays he links to. So I had to prove him wrong, of course. ;) It wasn't an essay on the OP, though. However, I personally think the link is that the essay's author didn't link any of her/his arguments to anything in the New Testament, which she/he logically should have done. The OP can be analyzed only in the context of Old Testament incidents and prophecies.
 
Very simple.
A con man and a lunatic was dying one of the few deaths that might almost be agonizing enough to make up for a fraction of the pain and misery he still causes to this day--and in his final moments, he began to realize the sham that his entire life had been. There were no angels descending to lift him up, no God that could save him from his torment. His powers were parlor tricks, ephemeral and useless against wooden beams and iron nails. And there was no reward awaiting him, nor even a punishment--in that moment, I think Yeshua bin Yosef saw the tiniest glimpse of the utter oblivion that awaits us all.
I also notice that there are a ton of legends surrounding the blood of Christ, but nowhere does anyone attribute mystical properties to the contents of his bowels, which would have voided themselves at the moment of death, and thus, logically, should be more potent relics than the True Cross itself. Strange how nobody seems to have a phial or two of that in a shrine somewhere.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom