Warning - they're both very long, so skimming them might be better than taking on the daunting task of reading them fully, should anyone be thinking of trying.
Do you really want to say things like that?
Here We Go...
The author of this piece said they had received a reply to their own piece, which was "How could a God of love order the annihilation of the Canaanites"... This author then stated that the person who sent in the reply wasn’t the original author, and
that author requested that the reply be removed, which the site author did; however, the site author “rewrote and reorganized” the reply, which seems to me that the request was not really honored at all. Be that as it may, the first question in the reply was apparently:
Does the bible actually portray God as “infinitely merciful and just” and at the same time as a genocidal deity, contradicting itself at a deep, moral level?
The site author replied that God isn’t necessarily always merciful, just “most of the time: or “tending more towards mercy,” and then tried to argue that God’s genocidal behavior didn’t “count” because later historical genocide just seems so much worse. This is the same ridiculous fallacy the site author uses time and time again in other arguments, and it is totally wrong for reasons that a three-year-old could understand. Leaving aside all other reasons why this is so,
one injustice does not excuse another. An accused murderer who tries to say “Sure, I killed someone, but there’s this other person 2,000 miles away who killed someone else, you know!” is not going to get a verdict of “not guilty” because of this argument.( He’d be a lot better off trying to get a verdict of insanity because of it.) This argument is so completely false that everyone should simply ignore it from now on, and nobody with an IQ high enough to be posting anything on a discussion forum should bring it up. It does not make sense for the site author to try to build a case that the slaughter of the Amalekites somehow wasn’t comparable to historical genocide ((because it wasn’t ideological, retributive, developmental, or despotic, because the Amalekites weren’t targeted because they were a member of a particular group, and so on.)
Then the author wanders off into discussing how this incident might be used to try to “prove that God didn’t exist” because God can’t perform an unjust act, God ordered the killing of children, that can never be a just act, so this means that God really CAN perform an unjust act and there’s your contradiction. So the author finds the problem in the part where the killing of children supposedly could NEVER be an unjust act—in other words, there might be exceptions!! Incredibly creepy.
Next, the site author offers what they describe as “the meat of the issue.” It is not. Not for one second. The real meat of the issue is so simple and obvious that it’s incredible to think anybody would write such a long essay when a five-year-old should have known this. To prove I’ve read this thing, however, I’m going to analyze what was said, although it’s a stupid waste of time.
What was the timing of the events surrounding the judgment of the Amalekites?
Israel sins against God in Numbers 14, God allows the Amalekites to attack them, God makes a prophecy that Israel will someday destroy them, and after 40 years of wandering, God reminds them that it’s time to fulfill the prophecy. There’s a bit of PR about the Amalekites in the Bible, most of it not great, but as the site author reasonably asks, Do we have any reason to believe that this “Israelite-version” of the history is reliable, and not just the ‘song of the conquering victors’, who have violently stolen the land from the innocent Amalekites and naturally leave such ‘crimes’ out of their literature? The author says yes, but there’s no reason to believe this is true. The author admits there’s no extra-biblical records of the Amalekites at all, although he/she weakly offers “evidence” (which we don’t know is true) about supposed negative traits of other tribes in the same region and the same era (with no explanation, AGAIN, of how on earth this justified what the Israelites did to the Amalekites. AGAIN, this nonsensical tactic would not fly for one millisecond in any court of law.)
Then, the author moves on to:
But doesn’t this event fit the anti-biblical pattern of “punishing the children for the sons of the parents”?
(yes, that’s actually what it literally says. Clearly, the SINS of the parents is what’s meant. Freudian slip/?)
Basically, the arguments just become more and more offensive from here on out. The author pretty much says that in reality, children DO suffer for the sins of the parents. We then get some silliness about how what is supposedly being said in the Old Testament is that children are being punished for sinning in the same
way as their fathers rather than being themselves sinless and having the sins of their fathers visited upon them, which is then equated with the idea of a people sinning in the same way as their rulers have sinned. This argument really has nothing to do with anything, even though the author tries to say that the
current set of Amalekites (who were slaughtered by the Israelites) somehow were sinning in the same way as the
previous set of Amalekites (who killed the previous set of Israelites hundreds of years before), even though this was never proven.
Then, we get;
But aren’t individuals supposed to be punished for their OWN misdeeds ONLY, and not the misdeeds of others? (Deut 24:16, 2 Kings 14:1)
The author actually states: “Absolutely, but we need to not make the assumption that the killing of the dependents was a punishment on them, as opposed to a consequence of the punishment on the fathers. Morally, there is a huge difference.”This was followed by a number of Biblical examples where people’s descendants were punished for what their ancestors did, such as (2 Sam 1.14ff), .(I Kings 2.31ff), and (I Kings 2.36), and some horrible arguments about how because children suffer the consequences of what their parents do anyway, that somehow makes it all right, but I have a difficult time believing that the site author actually was crazy enough to write this, frankly.
Here is the heart of the problem, the real “meat of the argument:
The original argument
was that God commanded inexcusable crimes in the Bible—for example, telling Israel to slaughter Amalekites because other Amalekites had killed other Israelites hundreds of years ago. The author just brings up a lot more examples of God doing the exact same thing in other situations and makes it very, VERY clear that these things happen because God wants them to happen. To try to argue against the criminal behavior commanded by God by bringing up even more examples of the criminal behavior commanded by God is insane. Nobody in their right mind should be making this argument. The rest of the argument is evil and sick, and I hope this author is not allowed around children.
The author ends up with the weakest argument yet:
But why couldn’t the Israelites just ‘ignore’ the Amalekites?
Because they were evil, etc., but the problem is that the author is relying on the
Israelites’ version of what they were, and he/she’s already admitted that there are no extra-Biblical sources on this.
Then, of course, we come to the worst part of all. I will analyze this in detail, but again, a detailed analysis is completely unnecessary. The real solution can be summed up in one sentence, and at the end, that’s what I’ll do. However, here’s the one important thing to keep in mind when it comes to this author’s analysis of why it supposedly made so much sense to kill off all the women and children. This analysis is being made purely and solely in terms of practical history, of the actual, literal history of two peoples called the Israelites and the Amalekites. Got it? Good.
So, if the Amalekite aggression virtually required the elimination of the warrior-class, what practical options for survival remained for the women/kids?
Just to put this in perspective, here’s exactly how the author began this section:
Well, if this analysis is correct so far, we are faced clearly with the problem I pointed out earlier--the widows and fatherless kids, in the desert. This is, as pointed out above, a situation that the Amalekite warriors put their families in--NOT the Israelites per se.
Next, we’re told that the Israelites’ only options for the women and children were:
1. Take them back as slaves (or to be sold as slaves)
2. Take them back and turn them over to social relief programs/processes in Israel.
3. Leave them there in the desert to their fate
4. Kill them there in the desert
The author analyzes why it was not “practical” for Israel to keep all those women and children as slaves (no resources to assimilate all these people) and coolly notes that God didn’t create a miracle that could have saved all those lives because, well, God just doesn’t do miracles to solve problems that way.
On to #2. The author states that there were no social relief programs in the ancient world that could have possibly handled that number of people.
Then #3. The author argues that this would mean either prolonged and agonizing death or being captured by foreign slave traders, which would be worse.
As for #4… you’re not even going to believe this… the author spends several paragraphs presenting lots of historical data on how people prefer quick deaths over long, drawn-out ones or foreign slavery, and how this “moral difficulty was forced on the Israelites by the Amalekite warrior aggression.”
We are swiftly steered away from pondering how this might apply to such issues as ‘death with dignity” or advanced directives by the author insistently reminding us that only
God has the power to decide on “euthanasia”.
Then, we get:
But if we visualize the horror of the scene—mothers watching children be killed, and children watching their mother be cut down—surely this cannot be ‘right’?!
Again, the site author engages in the most disturbing moral relativism imaginable. We are told that well, yes, this is disturbing, but just compare it to
that! (completely made-up and extra-Biblical stories about apocryphal things the Amalekites supposedly did.)
And;
But doesn’t the “justice of the biblical god” in this situation look more like the most horrific of war crimes?
This is probably the most common-sense question yet asked, but the author naturally doesn’t really answer it. First, he/she dithers about how God actually was too lenient in not doing anything about the Amalekites for hundreds of years after they originally attacked the Israelites; then there’s some nonsense about how the main thrust of the command to kill was against the warriors and the women and children just happened to be killed as part of their “property”, and then we once again get the argument that killing that “property” was actually the most merciful thing to do.
As a penultimate argument, we get:
But if the biblical god was indeed omnipotent, then it would seem he could have done many things rather than slaughter so many people. And if he couldn't have done anything else, wouldn’t this show then that He is NOT omnipotent? (aren’t we back to “God is either good OR omnipotent—but not BOTH” kind of arguments?)
It’s worth also quoting the rest of the main argument here:
The major problem with this is theological, concerning the omnipotence of God.
The omnipotence argument can be sketched out like this:
a. God can do all things
b. Accordingly, God could have resolved the issue by some other means that extermination of the group.
c. God DIDN'T use a different method than the one involving extermination.
Therefore either:
d. God is omnipotent, but cruel (because He chose extermination rather than other presumably less-violent paths)
or . God is not necessarily cruel, but He is NOT omnipotent either(because He couldn't come up with non-cruel alternatives)
There’s no way out of this, which is why the author can’t find one. First he/she makes a very weak argument, which is that for God, “omnipotence normally doesn't 'play' in historical settings.” God sets up the rules, so he just has to stick to them. He supposedly decides that he’s not going to behave as if he’s omnipotent, and so he doesn’t interfere. In the author’s words, the main thing is “the principle of God holding up the law of moral consequences (within social and cultural contexts of connections and community).” But for one thing, the author has
already portrayed God as omnipotent all over this argument. For instance, he/she has already said that God was “too lenient” with the Amalekites, ‘allowing” them to “infiltrate” Israel for hundreds of years before commanding the Israelites to destroy them. Of course, we could just look at the main sentence of this argument. “It would seem he could have done many things rather than slaughter so many people.” If God had the power to slaughter all of these people to begin with, then how can this simply be “God holding up the law of moral consequences”? Why did we get a history lesson about the disturbing practical realities of the lives of nomadic peoples in the desert several thousand years ago if the central point is supposed to be the omnipotence of God? Isn't God supposed to be
better than his human creations? Morally
above us?
And of course, this is far, FAR from the biggest problem. In one way, of course, the biggest problem is the same one I’ve been saying all along: talking about how Atrocity A somehow cancels out Atrocity B is just nuts. In another way, you could say that the real problem is the insane argument that the slaughter of the Amalekites somehow represents the “law of moral consequences “, no matter what kind of inane codicil is added to the statement. But the biggest problem of all—I’ve saved it for last.
Finally, we end up with this:
But isn’t this using a “you gotta see the Big Picture” approach, to avoid accepting responsibility for clear ethical atrocities in the lives of specific individuals?
The author does something just bizarre here, and it reveals what’s really going on with this entire essay. She/he poses the main question
as faced by God in this situation as being: “ In the case of the innocents here, we are facing a moral dilemma that essentially consists of "do we kill them swiftly?" or "do we let them die, slowly, painfully, and agonizingly?"--which is more merciful, given no other alternatives exist?” The ‘lifeboat scenario” is presented (some people may be familiar with this—it’s a classroom exercise often given in ethics classes. You’re the captain of a lifeboat, if you don’t throw someone overboard, everyone dies, how do you decide who to throw overboard, yada yada yada. )
And after a summary of the entire essay, here’s what we end up with:
So, as in the emotionally-churning alternatives of the Lifeboat, I am forced to say (with heavy heart, but probably not nearly as heavy as God's was that day--judgment has always grieved God--He knows all about the sorrow of governance, believe me) that the swift death of the innocents, in the context of a certain and much-more-suffering death in the desert, was the most merciful and least tragic course of action...
The author has
equated themselves with God, and has made God not only human but into the worst
kind of human. That’s why the God presented in this essay, the God who “had no choice” but to slaughter all the Amalekites—the men, the women, and the children—is not divine, but human. This idiocy is not only offensive and disgusting beyond all description, but, as bizarre as the word may sound, blasphemous. It pulls God down to a level lower than the worst human being. God is made into the serial killer of the universe. This is why this makes me so sick and offends me in a way that I can’t even describe. This is more destructive to Christianity and to faith than any kind of atheism or disbelief or secularism could ever be.