YEC's and Evolution

AvalonXQ, it seems that you are a Young Earth Creationist. So perhaps the first stage in educating you would be to show you that the Earth is much older than you think it is. So out of curiosity what is the upper limit of age that your study of the Bible indicates?
 
So, no, I don't think we can get away from this. This is a fundamental question. Why kind of evidence will you accept? If you accept the observations I've cited, but reject the conclusions, presumably you have some basis for doing so. But given that you've admitted both that you're cannot run the tests yourself (post #27), but that you will not accept the conclusions unless you can run the tests yourself (post #230).

Avalon, please don't take drkitten's post as an insult, because I don't think it is intended in that way at all. It's not an attack.

As I've inquired in my own posts, we don't know how to debate this subject with you unless you can define what you will accept as evidence. We really need to know if you plan on doing the footwork yourself (since you have implied that this would be required for you to accept the conclusions.)

I won't make any assumptions at this point about your honesty or dishonesty. You can prove everyone honest by clearly stating your intentions about how you will pursue the evidence provided. If you cannot accept conclusions presented by numerous educated scientists, but if you also have no plans whatsoever to pursue the education necessary to draw your own informed conclusions... then why should anyone with any intellectual honesty wish to continue this discussion?

Please just let us know what you plan to do or hope to gain from the discussion.
 
volatile, one small correction. Radio Carbon dating is only good for roughly 50,000 years. Even many YEC's can live with this figure. There are many other radioactive dating methods that are used by geologists, C14 is pretty much in the realm of anthropologists, in the terms of the Earth's history that is very recent indeed.
 
I believe that Noah's flood happens as described in Genesis. Evidence that a worldwide flood is geologically or physically unreasonable, or other problems with the flood story, would be of great interest to me -- but I'm not sure how it fits into the evolution discussion.

Noah's flood is often used as a (demonstrably false) argument to explain some of the various geological features that actually prove both the old earth and evolution. The Grand Canyon, for example, is actually one of the best proofs of evolution out there. Within a hundred meters of the Bright Angel trailhead, for example, is a bed of exposed limestone that is filled with fossils of what are demonstrably sea creatures, most of which are extinct (a few of which have modern analogues).

So the first question : if the earth is young and unchanging, how did sea creatures get to an elevation of 8000 ft above sea level? The "obvious" answer that the YECs use is that they were carried there by the flood, which submerged all the mountains of the earth.

The only problem with this is that among the fossils at the Grand Canyon are also fossilized mud tracks and other things that show that the seabed that formed this limestone was relatively undisturbed, which is not compatible with a global flood. In other words, there was no flood during the time that the rocks were laid down.

The other question, of course, is the age of the rocks themselves. The limestone I'm talking about can be easily dated (by appropriately skilled geologists) to about 230 million years ago; the schist at the bottom of the canyon is about two billion years old.

How would you explain the existence and nature of the canyon from a YEC framework?
 
volatile, one small correction. Radio Carbon dating is only good for roughly 50,000 years.

I was about to make the same correction (that drkitten isn't relying specifically on carbon dating), but it's nice to see we're all fact checking each other. :)
 
volatile, one small correction. Radio Carbon dating is only good for roughly 50,000 years. Even many YEC's can live with this figure. There are many other radioactive dating methods that are used by geologists, C14 is pretty much in the realm of anthropologists, in the terms of the Earth's history that is very recent indeed.

Thank you! By "radiocarbon" I meant "radioactive dating" - I understand the difference but "radiocarbon" seems to be synecdochal!
 
Last edited:
Thank you! By "radiocarbon" I meant "radioactive dating" - I understand the difference but "radiocarbon" seems to be synecdochal!

Yes, that's a common mistake to make -- it never occurred to me that it could be a valid synecdoche, and hence my corrections thereof pedantic.
 
I believe that Noah's flood happens as described in Genesis. Evidence that a worldwide flood is geologically or physically unreasonable, or other problems with the flood story, would be of great interest to me -- but I'm not sure how it fits into the evolution discussion.

If we are going to prove evolution, it is a good idea to disprove YEC theories along the way. I brought up the flood in particular as a contrast. The flood fails to explain the geographic distribution of life the way evolution can.

Say the ark landed in Turkey. The animals would have poured out and scattered randomly when the doors of the ark were opened. If that is the case, why did all of the marsupials ONLY travel to Australia? On the way there, why didn't a single marsupial remain behind in Asia and repopluate that area? Why did penguins ONLY go to the South Pole when then North Pole is closer and just as hospitable to them? Noah's flood has no answer.

Evolution explains geographic sorting by saying that some ancestral marsupial originated in Australia and diversified into the species we see today. Also, they are contained to that area because of the ocean.
 
Last edited:
Drkitten, let me ask you a question: can we definitively use the available evidence to show the date when rock with fossils in it would have had to be formed?
 
Yes, that's a common mistake to make -- it never occurred to me that it could be a valid synecdoche, and hence my corrections thereof pedantic.

Fair enough.

Now we have that cleared up, how about the substance of my post:

if you doubt the conclusions, on what logical basis can you not doubt the methodologies, or the datasets?

I'm sure you know that there are literally millions of articles, across fields as diverse as anthropology, archaeology, astrophysics, molecular biology and even linguistics which run counter to the YEC hypothesis. You doubt every single one of these author's (replicable, repeatable, checkable) conclusions but you do not doubt their methods or their data? I just don't understand on what basis you can make that claim.

Maybe we could focus on Dr Kitten's rock. That seems to be a sensible, small-scale and easy-to-focus-on example of the type of issues your YEC position faces. If you accept the data - that is, you accept the radioactive and other data which show an age older than YEC would allow - on what basis can you discard the conclusions?

See what I mean? It's simply not logically coherent to handwave all conclusions because you haven't done the footwork yourself, but at the same time to accept the data and methodologies and centuries of prior experiments upon which those conclusions are based. If you want to "do the footwork" on this rock, you're right back to questioning the validity of radioactive dating, which means you're going to have to go right back to first principles and get yourself a degree in nuclear physics, repeating as you go the experiments of Rutherford, Curie and the rest. Hell, you may even need to go back to the 18th century experiments establishing the atomic structure of matter. I mean - how far down the rabbit hole do you want to go?

We need to know this in order to take the discussion forward. What level of scientific evidence will you take as true? Do you accept radioactivity? The atomic structure of matter? DNA? At some point, we're going to have to commit to some basic level of common ground...
 
Last edited:
Dating of fossils is a bit more difficult than dating igneous or metamorphic rock. But there are ways to do it by inference. For example when you look at a certain strata you will find an assemblage of fossils that are unique to that time. If you go elsewhere in the world you will find a similar assemblage in a rock of the same age. Usually you can find igneous rock that will bracket the date of certain fossil assemblages, as time goes by we find more and more places that allow us to bracket these fossils, giving us a more and more accurate date. So for strata A we will find one spot in the world that may give an upper cap of 150 million years old and in another are we may find one that gives a lower cap of 135 million years. More searching elsewhere may give an even narrower upper and lower limit. Then for time in between that age can be estimated by studying current rates of sedimentation. Absolute ages are nice but not necessary to show evolution, what is more important is relative age. One thing about the Theory of Evolution that may seem to be a weakness, but is actually a strength is that if it was wrong you could find fossils out of order in the geologic column. With all of the millions of fossils found there have not been any. The evidence for evolution can be weighed, literally in the millions of tons. If you ask a YEC to propose a hypothesis of how fossils got to be the way they are found in the world all of their proposals are quickly shot down. Avalon, you may have noticed that YEC's take a strange approach to science. Instead of trying to find evidence for their hypotheses they try to disprove evolution. This is a major scientific mistake. Disproving someone else's theory does not prove your own.
 
Say the ark landed in Turkey. The animals would have poured out and scattered randomly when the doors of the ark were opened. If that is the case, why did all of the marsupials ONLY travel to Australia? On the way there, why didn't a single marsupial remain behind in Asia and repopluate that area? Why did penguins ONLY go to the South Pole when then North Pole is closer and just as hospitable to them? Noah's flood has no answer.
The Devil's advocate tells us that in fact the flood can explain everything. The Flood was a mgaical event with water coming from outer space and disappearing into nowhere. There is no reason why this god would not also have used magic to bring all the animals to the Ark and afterwards to wherever it pleased him. He could also have used magic to fit all the animals into the tiny Ark. The Flood story is about a supernatural event, and when magic is involved, anything goes.
 
It's amazing how many times Avalon has said in this thread that all s/he wants to do is to "discuss the evidence"--and yet never once has s/he actually engaged in any discussion of the evidence.
 
Drkitten, let me ask you a question: can we definitively use the available evidence to show the date when rock with fossils in it would have had to be formed?

Definitively?

Of course not. All scientific measurements have error bars associated with them; I can't tell you that that particular fossil was formed on May 23, 254,573,882 BCE -- and even if I could do that, you would be able to criticize me for not being able to tell you whether it was formed before or after lunchtime.

Since it typically takes hundreds or thousands of years for clay to compact into limestone, it's not clear that measurements of this precision are even meaningful.

And different rocks have different methods of dating that are appropriate for them. Dating limestone is actually rather difficult; it's much easier to date igneous rocks such as granite.

But, yes, igneous rocks can (generally) be dated with extreme accuracy and precision via radioactive isochron dating. I gave a link to the process of isochron dating earlier, so I won't bother to repeat it. I'll simply point out :

1) Igneous rocks, by definition, are formed by the cooling of melted magma and thus have a very clear formation date (as opposed to sedimentary rocks that accumulate over time).
2) The isochron method will give a very clear measure both of the age of the rock and of the uncertainty in the measurement of the age of the rock.
3) The isochron method can be applied repeatedly to the same sample of rock, using different sets of radioactive elements. This gives us the confidence of repeated consistent measures when five different independent analysis yield results in the same range.
4) There is no known way (short of experimenter error or active misconduct) that isochron methods can produce an older apparent than actual age. (There are a few ways that isochron methods can produce a younger apparent age -- for example, if the rock is partly melted and then rehardens).
5) The isochron method are based on very well-known and well-understood physical principles that are time-invariant (e.g. the half-life of U-238, which is known to within twenty-four parts in a thousand. ETA -- sorry, twenty-four parts in ten thousand.). (You may find some creationist papers that claim that radioactive half-lives can and do vary; the problem is that these are simply wrong, as can be shown by observation both of geological structures such as the Oklo reactor as well as cosmological observation of the distant past.)

So, "definitively"? No. Bowring could have screwed up. He could have screwed up on every measurement he took of the Canadian granite. He could have lied.

But assuming he did his lab work correctly, his findings are pretty darn secure.
 
Last edited:
It's amazing how many times Avalon has said in this thread that all s/he wants to do is to "discuss the evidence"--and yet never once has s/he actually engaged in any discussion of the evidence.

That is because that is the sure path to losing the argument if you are a YEC. All the evidence in the world supports evolution, geology, and astronomy. And all of the other hard sciences also. None of it supports the YEC view. The best they can do is to say "I question your interpretation of that evidence". That would be fine if there were only one or two points of evidence. It is a bit more difficult when there are millions of pieces of evidence that support the other side.
 
Drkitten, let me ask you a question: can we definitively use the available evidence to show the date when rock with fossils in it would have had to be formed?

Yes, of course. And the key is that no one method is used to check dating. We use many different methods to make sure they all concur with each other. When they don't, we know that there is an error, which isn't uncommon.

And when it comes to evolution, all the evidence from every field of study agrees with each other perfectly and we can make accurate predictions. We can predict exactly where to dig, how far down to dig, and what we will find there. Suck as Tiktaalik.
 
I'm pretty sure that Avalon has me on ignore, but somebody should ask Avalon what other scientific fields s/he adopts this radically skeptical attitudes towards. I mean, assuming for a moment that Avalon is not the world greatest polymath (a pretty safe assumption) one must logically conclude that s/he refuses to accept the theory of relativity (can't prove it independently), refuses to accept that we live in a heliocentric solar system (bet s/he can't prove that indepedently), refuses to believe in the germ theory of disease etc. etc. etc. Heck, even Newtonian physics is, presumably, an object of similar deep skepticism.

Come to that, I'll bet Avalon cannot independently prove the antiquity of any of the sources of the Biblical texts upon which s/he relies for an explanation of the universe. I'll be s/he has not independently performed any of the tests and has not independently verified any of the bibliographical and historical researches that go to prove that the Bible was not invented in, say, 1420AD.

And yet, oddly enough, I'll also bet that Avalon is quite happy to rely upon this knowledge without putting it all under the ban of "argument from authority." For some reason it will only be when scientific results conflict with his or her particular interpretation of the bible that this radical skepticism suddenly asserts itself.
 
It's amazing how many times Avalon has said in this thread that all s/he wants to do is to "discuss the evidence"--and yet never once has s/he actually engaged in any discussion of the evidence.

Like most creationists, Avalon is more concerned about discussing anything BUT the subject at hand. Pretending to be some kind of victim is a common excuse to avoid actual discussion. How can one defend such a position where they have absolutely no evidence for their position and who's position is simply the denial of evidence?

The usual excuse is "I have not seen enough evidence" to which one must ask, what is their requirement for evidence? What would be needed in order to be convinced of evolution? But I hardly doubt Avalon would bother addressing anything outside of claims of being a victim, and this post itself will be more fodder for such baseless claims and only further the agenda of avoiding the issues at hand by pretending any and everything is some kind of attack.
 
This isn't an atheist forum. It's a skeptics forum.

Well, I KNOW that! But do you really think that Avalon and 1stinchrist and poster of this sort REALLY see a difference? REALLY?

And as JCL pointed out Poe's law applies - I made a comment about fundies and yecs coming to forums like this to get sexual favors and sure enough I was barely off the mark, it's 20% of their grade.


Now a Personal note to Avalon,

Like many other fundi/yecs who have come here with the PRETENSE (apparently for a good grade) of making genuine inquiries about ToE you've gone down the same xian persecution syndrome, misrepresentation of the evidence and showing a total lack of courtesy by ignoring the honest straight forward question asked of you by more than patient posters!

Only after several pages of ignoring those questions did I post in a way that I suspect you referred to as impolite. I call your bluff as nothing but an outright lie and an EXCUSE not to answer the questions posed to you for nearly 4 pages by others here who were EXTREMELY courteous to you! You see, If you find my posts insulting or rude there is a very simple solution IGNORE them! This forum is not a homogeneous blob of ToE worshipping atheists. It's a forum of people who by and large share the same points of view on a certain number of topics. Otherwise we are a very cantankerous lot with attitudes that cover a wide range - whether we're talking about manners, religion, politics or DD or Starbucks has a better latte.


If you find my posts or anyone else's insulting, rude or lowering the debate IGNORE US, but as long as you continue to IGNORE, EVADE and outright LIE (IMHO) about answering the polite and legitimate questions asked of you by others, all you are doing is proving my point.


You're nothing but another one of the long line of uneducated - and I don't mean that as an insult, just that you haven't had the chance or the willingness to really invest the time to learn - xian fundies who comes here and ends up doing nothing but lying for jebus and then scurry away back to the flock about how you were persecuted on an atheist forum.
Prove me wrong - JUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS!
 
What makes geology an interesting science is that it in many ways is like putting together an enormous puzzle. You have to use science from many different domains to support your theories. For example there are certain deposits called "turbidites" which are coarser poorly sorted sandstones interlayered with fine shales. It took a bit of investigation into fluid dynamics, but the method of deposition was that of long periods of slow deposition of the shale with occasional events of flow of a mixture of sand carried from another source. In the 1900's a turbidite flow was indirectly observed. A series of cross Atlantic cables were snapped as a flow of sand and water occurred off of the coast of North America. As the flow advanced it broke on cable after another. Sand had built up in an area near shore until it catastrophically failed and flowed out to the deep sea bed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom