Drkitten, let me ask you a question: can we definitively use the available evidence to show the date when rock with fossils in it would have had to be formed?
Definitively?
Of course not. All scientific measurements have error bars associated with them; I can't tell you that that particular fossil was formed on May 23, 254,573,882 BCE -- and even if I could do that, you would be able to criticize me for not being able to tell you whether it was formed before or after lunchtime.
Since it typically takes hundreds or thousands of years for clay to compact into limestone, it's not clear that measurements of this precision are even meaningful.
And different rocks have different methods of dating that are appropriate for them. Dating limestone is actually rather difficult; it's much easier to date igneous rocks such as granite.
But, yes, igneous rocks can (generally) be dated with extreme accuracy and precision via radioactive isochron dating. I gave a link to the process of isochron dating earlier, so I won't bother to repeat it. I'll simply point out :
1) Igneous rocks, by definition, are formed by the cooling of melted magma and thus have a very clear formation date (as opposed to sedimentary rocks that accumulate over time).
2) The isochron method will give a very clear measure both of the age of the rock
and of the uncertainty in the measurement of the age of the rock.
3) The isochron method can be applied repeatedly to the same sample of rock, using different sets of radioactive elements. This gives us the confidence of repeated consistent measures when five different independent analysis yield results in the same range.
4) There is no known way (short of experimenter error or active misconduct) that isochron methods can produce an
older apparent than actual age. (There are a few ways that isochron methods can produce a younger apparent age -- for example, if the rock is partly melted and then rehardens).
5) The isochron method are based on very well-known and well-understood physical principles that are time-invariant (e.g. the half-life of U-238, which is known to within twenty-four parts in a thousand. ETA -- sorry, twenty-four parts in ten thousand.). (You may find some creationist papers that claim that radioactive half-lives can and do vary; the problem is that these are simply wrong, as can be shown by observation both of geological structures such as the Oklo reactor as well as cosmological observation of the distant past.)
So, "definitively"? No. Bowring could have screwed up. He could have screwed up on every measurement he took of the Canadian granite. He could have lied.
But assuming he did his lab work correctly, his findings are pretty darn secure.