I've come back, temporarily! Here's one more argument.
But firstly:
Congratulations Joobz, You've won an award! It's been given you by the author of the article on argument by outrage, the meaning of which you so grossly mangled. I wrote to him and told him.
Anyway, to the serious stuff. Those who've previously antagonised me need not read, since I won't read the responses of anyone who's made or implied a personal attack against me in this thread, whether they wish to be malicious or otherwise.
Yesterday evening, there was a programme on television which was part of a series called
Unreported World. The programmes are about terrible things that are happening in the world which aren't making the news.
Yesterday's programme was called
Liberia: Stolen Childhood
It was about how since the recent civil war in Liberia, a lot of children are being traumatised and injured by being raped. Hospitals have seen children as young as two. Children are often brought to hospital with internal injuries because of it, and some have even died.
I'll get to the point of talking about this in a minute. But here's a quote from the programme review. If you follow the link, you can watch the programme for yourself if you like.
Unreported World reveals how Liberia is facing a child rape crisis.
Six years after the end of a brutal civil war in which rape was routinely used as a weapon, children still face the daily fear of being attacked, and the West African country's hospitals are overwhelmed with child victims, a quarter of them under four years old.
In the Liberian capital, Monrovia, reporter Jenny Kleeman and director Matt Haan meet Mercy, a six-year-old girl who was abducted and raped by a stranger two weeks previously. Mercy is taking a course of drugs to try to stop her from contracting HIV. She lives in a safe house run by a Liberian charity, which is filled with other child rape victims. ...
The team visits a children's hospital run by the charity Médecins Sans Frontières. Elias Abi-Aad tells Kleeman that his unit saw 771 child rape victims in 2008 and in the first six months of 2009 had already seen 422 victims, but he estimates this is only a small fraction of the total number of cases in Liberia. Victims suffer serious medical problems as a result of their ordeal and the hospital saw three recent cases where children died as a direct consequence of rape.
Tikka, a nurse, tells Kleeman she thinks the crisis may be caused by Liberia's years of civil war, when both government forces and rebel factions terrorised communities by raping at will. Liberians had become used to living in a lawless and violent world, she says. ...
Liberia's civil war has left the country with a culture of impunity, and a culture where men want to have sex with very young girls. Until that changes, Liberia can't escape its tragic past.
I think the programme's available to watch for the next thirty days - I'm not quite sure, but some time anyway.
--------------
Now, these men clearly don't have the attitudes we might have to violence against children - that goes without saying. They probably don't find war repulsive but actually committed a lot of the atrocities during the civil war. What might stop them?
What If one thing that could stop them was fear of divine punishment? And what if that fear could best be instilled in them by reading the kinds of things we ourselves would find repulsive - things where Old Testament prophets warn of a greater power invading and conquering the land and carrying off prisoners and killing many,
because of sins like attacks on the people most vulnerable? What if they need to be scared before they'll stop? And what if the thing most likely to scare them is fear that a God with the power to bring invaders to crush their country might sit in judgment on them one day?
Here's an example of something in the Old Testament that sounds horrifying and disgusting; and yet who's to say it might not be just what's needed to scare them into changing their ways? Bear in mind that in most Western countries, this stuff might not be taken very seriously, but in Africa, the thought of God is often taken much more seriously:
Habakkuk chapter 1 (NLT)
1 This is the message that the prophet Habakkuk received from the LORD in a vision.
2 How long, O LORD, must I call for help? But you do not listen! "Violence!" I cry, but you do not come to save. 3 Must I forever see this sin and misery all around me? Wherever I look, I see destruction and violence. I am surrounded by people who love to argue and fight. 4 The law has become paralyzed and useless, and there is no justice given in the courts. The wicked far outnumber the righteous, and justice is perverted with bribes and trickery.
5 The LORD replied, "Look at the nations and be amazed! Watch and be astounded at what I will do! For I am doing something in your own day, something you wouldn't believe even if someone told you about it. 6 I am raising up the Babylonians to be a new power on the world scene. They are a cruel and violent nation who will march across the world and conquer it. 7 They are notorious for their cruelty. They do as they like, and no one can stop them. 8 Their horses are swifter than leopards. They are a fierce people, more fierce than wolves at dusk. Their horsemen race forward from distant places. Like eagles they swoop down to pounce on their prey.
9 "On they come, all of them bent on violence. Their hordes advance like a wind from the desert, sweeping captives ahead of them like sand. 10 They scoff at kings and princes and scorn all their defenses. They simply pile ramps of earth against their walls and capture them! 11 They sweep past like the wind and are gone. But they are deeply guilty, for their own strength is their god."
12 O LORD my God, my Holy One, you who are eternal - is your plan in all of this to wipe us out? Surely not! O LORD our Rock, you have decreed the rise of these Babylonians to punish and correct us for our terrible sins. 13 You are perfectly just in this. But will you, who cannot allow sin in any form, stand idly by while they swallow us up? Should you be silent while the wicked destroy people who are more righteous than they? 14 Are we but fish to be caught and killed? Are we but creeping things that have no leader to defend them from their enemies? 15 Must we be strung up on their hooks and dragged out in their nets while they rejoice? 16 Then they will worship their nets and burn incense in front of them. "These nets are the gods who have made us rich!" they will claim. 17 Will you let them get away with this forever? Will they succeed forever in their heartless conquests?
Ezekiel chapter 22 (GWT)
1 The LORD spoke his word to me. He said, 2 "Will you judge, son of man? Will you judge the city of murderers? Then tell it about all the disgusting things that it has done. 3 Tell it, 'This is what the Almighty LORD says: [Jerusalem,] you are the city that murders people who live in you. Your time has come. You dishonor yourself with disgusting idols. 4 You are guilty because of the people you have killed. You are dishonored because of the disgusting idols you have made. You have brought an end to your days, and you have come to the end of your years. That is why I will make you a disgrace to the nations and a joke in every land. 5 Those near and those far away will mock you. Your name will be dishonored, and you will be filled with confusion.
6 "'See how all the princes of Israel who live in you have used their power to murder people. 7 People in you hate their fathers and mothers. They oppress foreigners in you. They oppress orphans and widows in you. 8 You have despised my holy things and dishonored the day to worship me. 9 Some of your people slander. They want to kill people. People who live in you eat food sacrificed to idols at the worship sites on the hills, and they sin sexually. 10 Men have sex with their father's wives. … 11 Men do disgusting things with their neighbors' wives. Some men sexually dishonor their daughters-in-law. Other men who live in you have sex with their sisters, their father's daughters. 12 Other people take bribes to murder people. You collect interest and make excessive profits. You make profits by mistreating your neighbors. You have forgotten me, declares the Almighty LORD.
13 "'I will use my power against you because of the excessive profits you have made and the murders you have committed. 14 Will you still be brave? Will you remain strong when I deal with you? I, the LORD, have spoken, and I will do it. 15 I will scatter you among the nations and force you into other countries.
You get the picture. It isn't beyond the bounds of possibility that such Bible passages could scare people, like threats of earthly punishment wouldn't. I once read a book by a bishop in Uganda at the time when president Idi Amin was committing all his many atrocities. He said one day, a few men met him outside his church and seemed to be going to kill him. He said to them,
"In reality, you are in far more danger than me. If you kill me, I will go off to heaven; but when
you die, your soul could be in terrible danger."
He says it actually stopped them. In fact he says later, they even came to him and asked about Christianity.
Now, being an anecdote, that naturally doesn't prove a thing. But
what if such arguments resonate sufficiently with enough violent men in that part of the world to actually make a difference? Accounts of biblical atrocities disgust us; but what if for some men who've actually participated in war as aggressors, the horror of divine wrath in the shape of a more powerful enemy as a punishment for their horrific actions, and possible punishment after death as well, is just what will influence them to change their ways and stop hurting children and others?
Here's another anecdote. Again, of course it's impossible to prove anything by it; but what if it's an indicator that there might be many people with a similar mind-set who might be influenced to change dramatically?:
I once read a story by a black man in America who said he'd been so angry with the way black people had been treated he wanted to launch a campaign of terror/revenge by making bombs and putting them in the streets. But before he completed any plans, one of his friends spoke to him, saying he'd been reading the Bible. He said he'd been reading about how Israelites were taken into Babylon as slaves because Israel had been so sinful. He said he thought that maybe the fact that black people had been brought across as slaves from Africa was God's judgment for their sins. The man who'd been going to plant the bombs thought that might well be the case, so he decided not to after all.
*********
The possibility that people can be inspired to change their ways by the Bible is the reason that, no matter how often someone calls me stupid, no matter how often my opponents use the fallacy of argument by fatuous misrepresentation and simplification of the points I've made to mock me, and no matter how much I myself might think the argument that it's illogical that the God of the Bible could be loving given biblical atrocities holds water, I will speak up for the Bible.
Anyone who wants to convince me not to do so will have to do more than just appeal to emotion by putting gory details on here about exactly what might have been involved in the murder of a child. They will have to convince me that there is so little evidence that people could be scared by reading about divinely-ordered wars into changing their ways so they no longer harm others, that it isn't valid to use it as a reason for reserving judgment on the God of the Bible. In fact, they will have to convince me that there
is evidence that such biblical accounts have actually done harm in the modern day by inspiring atrocities.
I might stick around for a little while in this thread, but I won't read the posts of anyone who's antagonised me in it up until now, since the likelihood is that they'll only be doing it again, and I don't want to feel constrained to ignore them or to be nice to them after I've been provoked by them. So a few people here have lost any chance they would have had of influencing my thinking. too bad.
But perhaps I'll stay around for a little while to see if anyone else can do what I said would have to be done to convince me I'm wrong. To do so, you'll have to put concerns for pragmatism above those of ideology - i.e. stop talking about how biblical atrocities are just terrible, and give me some idea of the evidence on how the stories have influenced people over the years for good or bad. If you don't believe it's possible to collate convincing evidence on either side, I don't need to know you don't believe it's possible, so there's no need to tell me so.