Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
do you have a better explanation than God to our existence ?
I'm not sure why you think our existence requires an explanation, but even if it did, God (or any other supernatural being) wouldn't really work. You would then have to come up with an explanation for God's existence. Simply saying God just exists and doesn't require an explanation doesn't do anything for your argument, you could say the same about the universe.
 
Yes, I'd have to agree.... saying that there is no other reason you can think of other than God speaks to the limitations of your own mind, not to the existence of God. Perhaps you'd better investigate and research the beginnings of the universe, perhaps persue astrophysics, if you'd like to find that explanation. I'm not saying that an explanation already exists, only that this is the way to find out.
 
I'm not sure why you think our existence requires an explanation, but even if it did, God (or any other supernatural being) wouldn't really work. You would then have to come up with an explanation for God's existence. Simply saying God just exists and doesn't require an explanation doesn't do anything for your argument, you could say the same about the universe.

I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause. God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
 
Why does it need an explanation?

because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....
 
because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....

Not only do we not need to know "the reason for our existence," there doesn't even have to be a reason for our existence.
 
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause. God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
Not true, and not true again. You can't put in rules for the universe, when you have no way of knowing that the universe needed a cause, and you can't switch the rules for your favorite magic man, because......he's magic!!! God don't need to follow no stinkin' rules!

because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....

We don't need to know the reason for our existence. What's the benefit? We food, water, and air.

I live anything but a senseless life, without knowing about the origin of human kind.

If knowing the answer to this question were really so crucial, you'd think that your magic man could make sure that people knew the answer in no uncertain terms. It's also interesting that most people who've ever lived and answered the question have come up with a different answer than yours. Does that make their existence senseless? Or do they get points for at least asking themselves the question?
 
because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....

And what, pray tell, is the reason we are here, then? Let me guess, to unconditionally serve the will of some Creator? Seriously, dude, check the history of your own religion. It's just another Middle - Eastern authhoritarian derivative. It's purpose, historically, has been to give divine authority to a king, or a government of some sort. In modern times, the Christian Coalition has picked it up as a means to political power.

YOU ARE BEING MANIPULATED!
 
All national institutions of churches, whether Jewish, Christian, or Turkish, appear to me no other than human inventions set up to terrify and enslave mankind, and monopolize power and profit.

-Thomas Paine from "The Age of Reason"

How about them "Judeau Christian roots" the coalition keeps talking about?
http://www.earlyamerica.com/review/summer97/secular.html

True, I don't know what country you are in, but the point is no less valid if you are not a citizen of the U.S.A.... this type of religion is primarily a means to power. Do you have any idea how much Pat Robertson pays himself in his supposed non-profit organization?

(added)
Your statement was one of being lost without authority. Here is the reason for the authitative aspect of your religion.
 
Last edited:
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause. God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
The universe has a beginning the same way a round room has a corner.
 
because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....
Why does the concept of god provide any meaning for existence?
 
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause.
But did it begin to exist
God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
Do you reject Aquinas' argument that the universe might have a beginning and also be eternal?
 
do you have a better explanation than God to our existence ?

Since no one can make heads or tails of the sky-god theory, almost any other explanation is at least as good.

In fact, my theory that the Great Brown Chicken laid the universe like a gigantic egg so it could peck away at its inhabitants makes just as much sense.
 
because we need to know the reason of our existence.

Do we ? How do we even know there is one ?

If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind.

That's your opinion. Even without a "reason" for it all, I can find my OWN purpose in things. That alone counters your claim above.
 
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause. God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
If time begain at the Big Bang, there is no such thing as "before", no place for a magical being to have pre-existed. It it didn't, if there was such a thing as "before", then we don't know what was there, a precursor to this universe, a whole string of universes, who knows. There is absolutely no reason to insert a magical being into this knowledge gap just to make ourselves feel better.
 
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause. God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.
Again, how convenient for you and your so-called god, it is enternal, no proof needed, just come up with the idea and make it so. I so glad science doesn't work that way.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
because we need to know the reason of our existence.
Can you speak for yourself and not me, I don't need some magical being to be so I can be, it still does not tell me why I'm here, this so-called god hasn't told you why you here, or do you always hear voices and/or do you think that every thought you have is real.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....

If understanding the reason for your existence is so important, why do you believe in something that provides absolutely no explanation whatsoever?
 
I don't think so. There is a decisive difference. Our universe in fact needs a explanation, since it had a beginning, and therefor needs a cause.


So, if we lack this explanation, why hasn't the Unverse disappeared?

Maybe it's not all that necessary after all?


God as eternal, and uncaused being, doesn't need one.


God is a figment of your imagination. Make up whatever explanation rocks your boat.

Hazard a guess as to how much difference it makes.


because we need to know the reason of our existence. Why we exist, and are here. If you do want to live a senseless life, then you do not need to ask yourself about the origin of human kind. I in contrast think this is amongst a few others one of the very decisive questions....


I think I'll go with senseless. Leaves more time for important things like stamp collecting, gardening and eradicating the Hittites.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom