Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

there you have it, Gelatin is a catalyst for the absorbtion of vitamins by "the glands", so the following for which gelatin is recommended

must all be conditions caused by vitamin/glandular deficiency. That must be why they give you green Jello in hospital
:D
Actually, there is often a reason they do not give you red jello in a hospital ... like before a colonoscopy for instance. It can be confused with blood ... does that make you feel comfortable knowing that an MD can confuse jello with blood? LOL
 
Actually, there is often a reason they do not give you red jello in a hospital ... like before a colonoscopy for instance. It can be confused with blood ... does that make you feel comfortable knowing that an MD can confuse jello with blood? LOL
It makes me comfortable knowing that they know it can be confusing so don't put it in a diet, Edgar would probably suggest that you rub it in your hair to cure your piles or something
:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
It makes me comfortable knowing that they know it can be confusing so don't put it in a diet, Edgar would probably suggest that you rub it in your hair to cure your piles or something
:rolleyes:
Well to be fair, Edgar knows that it worked 12,000 years ago in Atlantis ... :) If you want to argue with that, it's all written in the Hall of Records under the Sphinx. You just have to know how to answer the riddle of the sphinx, which you can learn from watching the Never Ending Story with an ARE dvd player .... :)
 
Well to be fair, Edgar knows that it worked 12,000 years ago in Atlantis ... :) If you want to argue with that, it's all written in the Hall of Records under the Sphinx. You just have to know how to answer the riddle of the sphinx, which you can learn from watching the Never Ending Story with an ARE dvd player .... :)

Cayces claims for a Hall of Records under the Sphinx were debunked
By his number one son Hugh Lynn

Hugh Lynn and I talked after the work for him was over and I remember he felt quite satisfied with our work, and of the opinion that his father's best work was in healing people and not in archaeological predictions. I had the distinct feeling Hugh Lynn was quite satisfied there was no Hall of Records anywhere under the Sphinx."

get that, his best work was in healing people, which theres no evidence he ever did from an unbiased source, which if it was true would be overwhelming. Whats actually true is that most of his remedies were baloney (or gelatin)
IMO his best work is as a figurehead for a woo organisation that makes its money from gullible people like Rodney.

I've met a few A.R.E. members before, they all have that smug superiority that comes from being spoon fed cherry picked evidence without the critical thought present which would allow them to analyse it
 
Last edited:
Cayces claims for a Hall of Records under the Sphinx were debunked
By his number one son Hugh Lynn



get that, his best work was in healing people, which theres no evidence he ever did from an unbiased source, which if it was true would be overwhelming. Whats actually true is that most of his remedies were baloney (or gelatin)
IMO his best work is as a figurehead for a woo organisation that makes its money from gullible people like Rodney
;)
I know the Hall of Records exist because I've sensed them and have seen them psychically after eating jello and focussing on Bill Cosby in a vision (get it ... jello ... Bill Cosby .... cheezy I know) :)
 
What the hell is "animated" ash? Does it have anything to do with Yggdrasil, the world tree? Also, oh holy crap, I can't believe they're still suggesting this for cancer patients. I mean, nice disclaimer at the bottom, but that's some seriously dangerous stupidity there.
According to http://www.miracle2.net/resourcespage4.asp -- "Animated ash was a form of bamboo that was reduced to activated charcoal by means of a partial vacuum electrical carbon arc process." This company suggests an updated version of that treatment. Are you saying it's been discredited, or only that it seems illogical to you?
 
According to http://www.miracle2.net/resourcespage4.asp -- "Animated ash was a form of bamboo that was reduced to activated charcoal by means of a partial vacuum electrical carbon arc process." This company suggests an updated version of that treatment. Are you saying it's been discredited, or only that it seems illogical to you?

That website is a woo health store, Animated Ash is just ash thats taken from a live tree, rather than dead wood
animated is a word, not an ingredient
animated - full of life, action, or spirit; lively; vigorous.

so theres nothing to discredit, see there goes that lack of any critical thought I mentioned. You just stated that eating wood as a cure for cancer needs to be discredited
perfect little A.R.E. cultist arent you, don't question, just follow.

if you got cancer Rodney, what would you do ?
:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
just want to point out here that discussing wether or not Edgar was a good fraudulent doctor is off topic
;)
Then I'm sure you will enjoy this on-topic Cayce prediction, which was given to a stockbroker on April 6, 1929. (Reading 137-117). The stockbroker requested an interpretation of a disturbing dream he had regarding warring factions on the Federal Reserve Board:

6. (Q) How are these factions divided?
(A) Materially, these are divided between those that would hold the Federal Reserve board as the criterion for activity and those that would use the moneys in the various centers for activity as related to the market. As individuals, these are members not so much of the board - for the board (Federal Reserve Board) is itself divided upon the issue; individuals who have had an IDEAL as to the functioning of the board being on the one side and those that would USE the ABILITIES of the board on the other, and these are fostered - EACH side - by money powers. BUT, were these to be allowed to run without a check in EITHER direction, there must surely come a break where it would be PANIC in the money centers - not ONLY of Wall Street's activity but a closing of the boards in many centers, and a re-adjustment of the actual specie and moneys in these centers. Then, while these variations and these changes may be expected - hence high and low quotations will continue for MANY moons - while these adjustments are being made - INDUSTRIALS, as has been given, being the leads in the high and low variations, rather than those of some other commodities.
__________________________________________________________________________

You may have read in a history book about a little bit of "PANIC in the money centers" in October 1929.
 
I agree. When looking specifically at cases where the diagnosis has been uncertain, the patient satisfaction drops to 90 percent.
Are you therefore concluding that a typical doctor outperforms Cayce by 90 to 85 percent?
 
Then I'm sure you will enjoy this on-topic Cayce prediction, which was given to a stockbroker on April 6, 1929. (Reading 137-117). The stockbroker requested an interpretation of a disturbing dream he had regarding warring factions on the Federal Reserve Board:

6. (Q) How are these factions divided?
(A) Materially, these are divided between those that would hold the Federal Reserve board as the criterion for activity and those that would use the moneys in the various centers for activity as related to the market. As individuals, these are members not so much of the board - for the board (Federal Reserve Board) is itself divided upon the issue; individuals who have had an IDEAL as to the functioning of the board being on the one side and those that would USE the ABILITIES of the board on the other, and these are fostered - EACH side - by money powers. BUT, were these to be allowed to run without a check in EITHER direction, there must surely come a break where it would be PANIC in the money centers - not ONLY of Wall Street's activity but a closing of the boards in many centers, and a re-adjustment of the actual specie and moneys in these centers. Then, while these variations and these changes may be expected - hence high and low quotations will continue for MANY moons - while these adjustments are being made - INDUSTRIALS, as has been given, being the leads in the high and low variations, rather than those of some other commodities.
__________________________________________________________________________

You may have read in a history book about a little bit of "PANIC in the money centers" in October 1929.

are you trying to say thats some form or prophecy and that he predicted the wall st crash, perhaps you can point me to the phrase "crash" anywhere in that or even, anywhere in that where he predicts anything happening at all, its meaningless gibberish ?
the phrase "panic in the money centres" could be applied to anything at any time,
this is a news headline from last week
EUROPE PANIC-STRICKEN; GREAT EXCITEMENT IN ALL THE MONEY CENTRES. PRICES DROP IN LONDON, PARIS, AND BERLIN--BIG FAILURES FEARED--THE MILITARY PREPARATIONS.
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=9F04E7DC1538E533A25757C0A9649C94669FD7CF
how do you know that Cayce wasn't speaking specifically about that Rodney ?
dont answer that, allow me, you are cherry picking "words" and "sentences" and then looking for an event in history to match it up to, when theres no required context anyone can be a prophet from doing the same thing. Being vague is a psychic standard. It allows the faithful to shout "Hit" after the fact
and you have no system of balance, how many other readings did Cayce make in the same period that havent been magically linked to a real event by a lack of critical thinking (yet) ?

and it was written by a loon too, whats with all the CAPITALS ?


if the Wall street Crash hadnt happened, youd be claiming he was talking about Black Monday (1987) instead
 
Last edited:
Actually, there is often a reason they do not give you red jello in a hospital ... like before a colonoscopy for instance. It can be confused with blood ... does that make you feel comfortable knowing that an MD can confuse jello with blood? LOL

Not true. Before a colonoscopy they make you fast and then drink a gallon of GoLightly (or similar) to flush everything out.
 
Are you therefore concluding that a typical doctor outperforms Cayce by 90 to 85 percent?

Seeing as you have presented no evidence of any succesful treatment by Cayce at all thats not difficult is it,

youre the one here telling people to see if eating wood is a good cancer cure because Edgar said so, does that not seem a little unwise to you at all ?

:confused:
 
Are you therefore concluding that a typical doctor outperforms Cayce by 90 to 85 percent?

I conclude that Cayce's claims are unsubstantiated. There is no evidence that he could do what he claimed, and there is evidence that he couldn't.

On top of that, there is no need for the paranormal explanation, and Occam's Razor suggests that you don't create unnecessary entities (which is what the paranormal explanation does).

Let's cut through all this blather about how many lawsuits we might expect, or how many satisfied "customers" we might expect. These things are irrelevant.

Do you believe Cayce had paranormal abilities? If so, the burden of proof is on you. What is the evidence that leads you to believe he has paranormal abilities? (Or do you believe in these abilities regardless of or in spite of the evidence?)
 
Do you believe Cayce had paranormal abilities? If so, the burden of proof is on you. What is the evidence that leads you to believe he has paranormal abilities? (Or do you believe in these abilities regardless of or in spite of the evidence?)

I offered to show Rodney before how the A.R.E. are currently lying to people but he wasnt interested (made the same offer to two other A.R.E. members and they werent interested either) its akin to telling a fundementalist Xtian that they're in the wrong religion.
 
Last edited:
are you trying to say thats some form or prophecy and that he predicted the wall st crash, perhaps you can point me to the phrase "crash" anywhere in that or even, anywhere in that where he predicts anything happening at all, its meaningless gibberish ?
the phrase "panic in the money centres" could be applied to anything at any time,
this is a news headline from last week

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=9F04E7DC1538E533A25757C0A9649C94669FD7CF
how do you know that Cayce wasn't speaking specifically about that Rodney ?
dont answer that, allow me, you are cherry picking "words" and "sentences" and then looking for an event in history to match it up to, when theres no required context anyone can be a prophet from doing the same thing. Being vague is a psychic standard. It allows the faithful to shout "Hit" after the fact
and you have no system of balance, how many other readings did Cayce make in the same period that havent been magically linked to a real event by a lack of critical thinking (yet) ?

and it was written by a loon too, whats with all the CAPITALS ?


if the Wall street Crash hadnt happened, youd be claiming he was talking about Black Monday (1987) instead
Try this reading on for size. It was given for the same stockbroker on March 5, 1929. The stockbroker stated that he had a dream about a bull following his wife, and he "got the impression regarding the market that we ought to sell everything, including the box stock." Cayce's interpretation: " . . . a warning as respecting an individual account - which would mean not only this special individual but many others - and that their accounts during this turmoil as will come by these many changes, as will be seen in a downward movement of a long duration, gradually sliding off, with fitful conditions of sudden rises and drops - that the body must be mindful of how individuals' accounts are taken care of from day to day. Not allowing, then, those that apparently even are VERY safe, too much latitude. As to the activities of self, as is indicated in the impression that the body should dispose of all those held - even those in box - would signify the great amount of change as would come." (Reading 137-115)

P.S. The capitals were recorded by Cayce's secretary, when Cayce emphasized a word.
 
Do you have an alternative treatment? If so, then it can be said that "with friends like you, who needs enemas!'.

(sorry, I couldn't resist)
:)
The enema of my enema is my friend ... ;)

Not true. Before a colonoscopy they make you fast and then drink a gallon of GoLightly (or similar) to flush everything out.
The red dye in red foods (i.e. popsicles, jello, etc) can leave behind a residual coloring which tint the colon wall and appear like blood. Not consuming them is part of the colonoscopy pre-prep in general, regardless of the use of GoLytely ...
 
Try this reading on for size. It was given for the same stockbroker on March 5, 1929. The stockbroker stated that he had a dream about a bull following his wife, and he "got the impression regarding the market that we ought to sell everything, including the box stock." Cayce's interpretation: " . . . a warning as respecting an individual account - which would mean not only this special individual but many others - and that their accounts during this turmoil as will come by these many changes, as will be seen in a downward movement of a long duration, gradually sliding off, with fitful conditions of sudden rises and drops - that the body must be mindful of how individuals' accounts are taken care of from day to day. Not allowing, then, those that apparently even are VERY safe, too much latitude. As to the activities of self, as is indicated in the impression that the body should dispose of all those held - even those in box - would signify the great amount of change as would come." (Reading 137-115)

P.S. The capitals were recorded by Cayce's secretary, when Cayce emphasized a word.
Wow. What a pile of word salad nonsense. His "prophecy" says absolutely nothing. I'm really unimpressed if this is the best these huckster followers produce.

BTW:
Who is this stockbroker and what corporation now bears his name?
Why didn't Cayce use his superpowers on the stockmarket on himself to make millions?
 
Last edited:
According to http://www.miracle2.net/resourcespage4.asp -- "Animated ash was a form of bamboo that was reduced to activated charcoal by means of a partial vacuum electrical carbon arc process." This company suggests an updated version of that treatment. Are you saying it's been discredited, or only that it seems illogical to you?

Ash is ash no matter how it was produced.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom