Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

How about a New York Times article? See http://www.cayce.com/nytimes.htm

the source isn't credible
Dr. W. H. Ketchum, who was attending a meeting of the National Society of Homeopathic Physicians
and theres no extraordinary claim here
Homeopathy is still quackery, and its reliant on Cayces claim of "no knowledge" when awake

compare whats said for Cayce with any member of the public at the time who claimed to be able to perform quackery while awake ?
and again, your evidence is from the A.R.E.

Please explain what you mean by documentation, as in the examples you list above.

Do you mean documentation by contemporaries at that time in history? Books written by the individual themselves? Other?
Specifically anyone testifying to extraordinary ability with extraordinary evidence who did not rely on a woo biased source to reach a conclusion
So any reports from the A.M.A. apart from the one that helped his conviction for fraudulent practice ?
 
Last edited:
How about a New York Times article? See http://www.cayce.com/nytimes.htm

That's a good example. The only information we have comes from someone who profits from the story - Ketchum. We only have his say-so that he is a respected doctor or that other doctors found the story fascinating. And even if the other doctors were fascinated, it would still only be on the say-so of Ketchum.

The kind of documentation you'd expect to find would be case reports or letters published in medical journals or direct quotes from named physicians.

Linda
 
the source isn't credible

and theres no extraordinary claim here
Homeopathy is still quackery, and its reliant on Cayces claim of "no knowledge" when awake

compare whats said for Cayce with any member of the public at the time who claimed to be able to perform quackery while awake ?
and again, your evidence is from the A.R.E.


Specifically anyone testifying to extraordinary ability with extraordinary evidence who did not rely on a woo biased source to reach a conclusion
So any reports from the A.M.A. apart from the one that helped his conviction for fraudulent practice ?

Thank you. That wasn't clear to me from the examples you used.

That's a good example. The only information we have comes from someone who profits from the story - Ketchum. We only have his say-so that he is a respected doctor or that other doctors found the story fascinating. And even if the other doctors were fascinated, it would still only be on the say-so of Ketchum.

The kind of documentation you'd expect to find would be case reports or letters published in medical journals or direct quotes from named physicians.

Linda

Yes, odd considering the many physicians Cayce is said to have interacted with.
 
Thank you. That wasn't clear to me from the examples you used.
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/field_guide_to_critical_thinking/
Csicop has a field guide for critical thinking which includes rules for evidence
in summary they are
Falsifiability
It must be possible to conceive of evidence that would prove the claim false.

Logic
Any argument offered as evidence in support of any claim must be sound.

Comprehensiveness
The evidence offered in support of any claim must be exhaustive — that is all of the available evidence must be considered.

Honesty
The evidence offered in support of any claim must be evaluated without self-deception.

Replicability
If the evidence for any claim is based upon an experimental result, or if the evidence offered in support of any claim could logically be explained as coincidental, then it is necessary for the evidence to be repeated in subsequent experiments or trials.

Sufficiency
The evidence offered in support of any claim must be adequate to establish the truth of that claim, with these stipulations:
the burden of proof for any claim rests on the claimant,
extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence, and
evidence based upon authority and/or testimony is always inadequate for any paranormal claim

These rules are universal for critical thinking no matter what the claim is, they are rarely, if ever mentioned or adhered to when someone pushing the claim is laying out their paranormal sales pitch

;)
 
Last edited:
How about a New York Times article? See http://www.cayce.com/nytimes.htm

How about reading the original article so you can see what the A.R.E. deliberately cut out and added from their edit which they spoon fed you
http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9C06EFD71239E433A2575AC0A9669D946196D6CF
;)

I notice on neither occaison any mention was made as the Akashic records
and the testimony of the real newspaper article doesn't mention the claimed ability of the A.R.E. that he absorbed books by sleeping on them either, just the opposite in fact.

Here we see myth making in progress
 
Last edited:
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/field_guide_to_critical_thinking/
Csicop has a field guide for critical thinking which includes rules for evidence
in summary they are












These rules are universal for critical thinking no matter what the claim is, they are rarely, if ever mentioned or adhered to when someone pushing the claim is laying out their paranormal sales pitch

;)


That list is similar to much of what I've come across, though is nice and brief.

Until you specified "non-woo-biased source" I wasn't sure what type of documentation you were getting at based on the examples you provided. Edgar Cayce has had books written about him by several of his contemporaries, including Gladys Davis, his stenographer, and David Kahn, a friend and business associate. As Rodney pointed out, there were also articles published in newspapers at the time. Davis and Kahn were believers, so would not count as "non-woo-biased" sources, and evidently that isn't what you are looking for.

Along the lines of what fls/Linda was saying, there is very little, if any, actual documentation from medical doctors and nothing in the medical journals that I know of.

Would it have been an easy matter for a physician back then to get an article about Cayce published in a medical journal? Would such a thing involve considerable risk to his/her reputation?

Also, was Dr. House an MD or an osteopath? I can't recall, but he was the one who worked in Cayce's hospital for a time.
 
Last edited:
That list is similar to much of what I've come across, though is nice and brief.

Until you specified "non-woo-biased source" I wasn't sure what type of documentation you were getting at based on the examples you provided. Edgar Cayce has had books written about him by several of his contemporaries, including Gladys Davis, his stenographer, and David Kahn, a friend and business associate. As Rodney pointed out, there were also articles published in newspapers at the time. Davis and Kahn were believers, so would not count as "non-woo-biased" sources, and evidently that isn't what you are looking for.

Along the lines of what fls/Linda was saying, there is very little, if any, actual documentation from medical doctors and nothing in the medical journals that I know of.

Would it have been an easy matter for a physician back then to get an article about Cayce published in a medical journal? Would such a thing involve considerable risk to his/her reputation?

Also, was Dr. House an MD or an osteopath? I can't recall, but he was the one who worked in Cayce's hospital for a time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_the_American_Medical_Association
Its not vetted by the A.M.A. so anyone could publish anything they liked in it without any fear to their own credibility
I can only find one mention of the JAMA regarding Cayce and funnily enough its a claim made by the A.R.E.
According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, “The roots of present day holism probably go back 100 years to the birth of Edgar Cayce.”
well they would say that wouldn't they, what they don't mention is that the article that said that was entitled
Holistic Health or Holistic Hoax?
and rather than covering Cayce in glory actually exposes his medicine as fraudulent and religious in nature

and the wiki article on Holism says
The term holism was introduced by the South African statesman Jan Smuts in his 1926 book, Holism and Evolution.[1] Smuts defined holism as "The tendency in nature to form wholes that are greater than the sum of the parts through creative evolution."[2]

So another case of selective editing from the A.R.E.
are you getting it yet ?
;)
 
Last edited:
Would it have been an easy matter for a physician back then to get an article about Cayce published in a medical journal? Would such a thing involve considerable risk to his/her reputation?

Also, was Dr. House an MD or an osteopath? I can't recall, but he was the one who worked in Cayce's hospital for a time.

To quote myself and answer my own questions :p

Dr. Thomas House was a general practitioner "with aspirations to become the county health commissioner." So his eventual support of Cayce is something of an endorsement.

As far as publishing on Cayce, I did find this quote: "In an interview many years later, Dr. Ketchum said he followed the reading's suggestion, his patient recovered, but he never told the family about Cayce "because in that day and time it wasn't healthy to mention such a weird proposition as that!"

So perhaps it was not all that easy.
 
To quote myself and answer my own questions :p

Dr. Thomas House was a general practitioner "with aspirations to become the county health commissioner." So his eventual support of Cayce is something of an endorsement.

As far as publishing on Cayce, I did find this quote: "In an interview many years later, Dr. Ketchum said he followed the reading's suggestion, his patient recovered, but he never told the family about Cayce "because in that day and time it wasn't healthy to mention such a weird proposition as that!"

So perhaps it was not all that easy.

now whos cherry picking evidence
:p
Cayce was active for almost 4 decades
not one medical journal article ?
there should be hundreds
;)
 
To quote myself and answer my own questions :p

Dr. Thomas House was a general practitioner "with aspirations to become the county health commissioner." So his eventual support of Cayce is something of an endorsement.

As far as publishing on Cayce, I did find this quote: "In an interview many years later, Dr. Ketchum said he followed the reading's suggestion, his patient recovered, but he never told the family about Cayce "because in that day and time it wasn't healthy to mention such a weird proposition as that!"

So perhaps it was not all that easy.

But again, you are depending solely upon the say-so of those who stand to profit. How is that an answer to your question?

The case reports could easily be written up as the effect of a novel treatment - this sort of thing is not unusual or 'unhealthy'.

Linda
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journal_of_the_American_Medical_Association
Its not vetted by the A.M.A. so anyone could publish anything they liked in it without any fear to their own credibility
I can only find one mention of the JAMA regarding Cayce and funnily enough its a claim made by the A.R.E.
To be fair, the AMA isn't a reliable "vetting"(I think you mean Peer Review) organization. The AMA is a Physician's Trade Group so it tends towards protecting physician interests and public health as its primary goals. Sometimes the protecting physician part makes them biased.

JAMA is a well respected journal but the idea of proper peer review and quality control back then was suspect and not up to current standards.

Either way it is telling that Cayce did not have any significant Case Reports mentioned anywhere in any respected journals of the time. Case reports have a relatively low standard for publishing. Interesting cases or treatments are all that is needed.
 
now whos cherry picking evidence
:p
Cayce was active for almost 4 decades
not one medical journal article ?
there should be hundreds
;)

Just looking at things from all angles. :)

But again, you are depending solely upon the say-so of those who stand to profit. How is that an answer to your question?

The case reports could easily be written up as the effect of a novel treatment - this sort of thing is not unusual or 'unhealthy'.

Linda

OK, noted, thank you.

As for the first part, well, yes, that's true. For that matter, everything we know about Cayce was written by someone who stood to profit, including Cayce himself. Too much time has passed and it has become difficult, if not impossible, to verify the claims.
 
As for the first part, well, yes, that's true. For that matter, everything we know about Cayce was written by someone who stood to profit, including Cayce himself. Too much time has passed and it has become difficult, if not impossible, to verify the claims.
It's possible. Tests his so-called treatments. How many claimed treatments actually work?
 
Rodney mentioned the book The Outer Limits of Cayce's Power earlier in the thread. That book is specifically about Cayce's failures, documented by his sons.

Except he calls them "errors" and seems to think they're evidence of Cayce's claims being valid, presumably by way of the criterion of embarrassment.

I think, rather, these egregious failures are positive proof that Cayce could not do what he claimed to be doing (the farsight business, in particular).
 
It's possible. Tests his so-called treatments. How many claimed treatments actually work?
yup as per
Replicability
If the evidence for any claim is based upon an experimental result, or if the evidence offered in support of any claim could logically be explained as coincidental, then it is necessary for the evidence to be repeated in subsequent experiments or trials.
 
It's possible. Tests his so-called treatments. How many claimed treatments actually work?

Actually, I think that is all that Rodney wants - resources devoted to the testing of his treatments.

Are you willing to do this?

Linda
 
Actually, I think that is all that Rodney wants - resources devoted to the testing of his treatments.

Are you willing to do this?

Linda

Gee, I don't know if he wants to wait til he gets cancer and then see if eating wood cures him, especially in a powdered form as according to epidemiologists, wood dust can give you cancer
http://www.numberwatch.co.uk/cancer list.htm
http://www.official-documents.gov.uk/document/cm71/7162/7162.asp
http://www.lhc.org.uk/members/pubs/factsht/46fact.htm
this is especially true of hardwoods, and Ash is a hardwood
:p
 
Last edited:
By all means let's divert time and money investigating the curative properties of gelatin rather than promising modern treatments!
</sarcasm>

ETA: By the way, doesn't the A.R.E. have money? According to their site:

ARE said:
Edgar Cayce's Association for Research and Enlightenment, Inc. (A.R.E.®), is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1931 by Edgar Cayce (1877-1945), to research and explore transpersonal subjects such as holistic health, ancient mysteries, personal spirituality, dreams and dream interpretation, intuition, and philosophy and reincarnation.

So what exactly do they mean by "explore"? Apparently not a rigorous investigation that might falsify the claims by Cayce and his believers.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I think that is all that Rodney wants - resources devoted to the testing of his treatments.

Are you willing to do this?

Linda
Can't. I stopped doing clinical research a few years back and just concentrate of teaching residents now. I really doubt that I could get it past the IRB...unless I get a ton of cash through the NCCAM :D

Damn...I have ethics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom