Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

From the A.R.E. website
http://www.edgarcayce.org/health/database/health_resources/ultraviolet_light_therapy.asp
which was also discussed earlier in the thread
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=5692818&highlight=animated#post5692818
Rodney stated that he'd require evidence that this therapy has been discredited before he believed it didn't cure cancer
:D
No, I inquired whether what Cayce said regarding animated ash aiding in curing cancer has been discredited. For example, according to Cayce Reading 1070-1, given for a man suffering from lung cancer:

"This is only to be applied every other day, you see, in a manner that there may be loosened those influences that will allow more oxygen to act upon the blood stream; thus making for a purification in same that will aid in establishing help for the system."

Has animated ash been shown to be ineffective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer? If so, please supply a citation.
 
Has animated ash been shown to be ineffective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer? If so, please supply a citation.

the mind just boggles at the stupidity of that statement, youre a perfect sheep member for the A.R.E.
:rolleyes:
 
the mind just boggles at the stupidity of that statement, youre a perfect sheep member for the A.R.E.
:rolleyes:
Translation: I don't have a shred of evidence regarding whether animated ash is ineffective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer.
 
Translation: I don't have a shred of evidence regarding whether animated ash is ineffective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer.

Rodney, do you not understand why asking that is so mind numbingly stupid ?

really, or is this just a poor attempt at sarcasm because you finally realise that you are the only one here stupid enough to carry on being conned by the A.R.E. after we've publically displayed all the evidence that hes a fraud

If you get cancer Rodney, what treatment would you seek for it ?

and why do you think the A.R.E. posted this notice
Note: The above information is not intended for self-diagnosis or self-treatment. Please consult a qualified health care professional for assistance in applying the information contained in the Cayce Health Database.
underneath the article about animated ash ?

is it
1. because animated ash is a cure for cancer
2. because animated ash isnt a cure for cancer and making people think it is would get them sued
take your time
:p
 
Last edited:
The yield for effective cancer treatments seems to be less than 3 in 10,000 when screening unselected substances. (Estimate from the NCI cancer screening program which has screened 400,000 drugs and has 129 drugs are undergoing or have completed further testing (some portion of which will be found to be ineffective on clinical testing) http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/nci/drugdiscovery.)

If the prior probability that animated ash is an effective cancer treatment is 0.0003, without any information which would alter that probability this would be a poor strategy if one is attempting to find an effective cancer treatment.

Linda
 
Has animated ash been shown to be ineffective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer? If so, please supply a citation.

Why is this not a fair question?

If Rodney asks for a citation supporting the claim that animated ash is not effective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer, is this not a reasonable request on a skeptics forum?

Unless I misunderstand, otherwise it seems we are expected to settle for: "Because Cayce said it, and we think most of what Cayce said was rubbish, that's why." Which, of course, isn't any more "evidence" against than stating that animated ash IS effective in curing cancer "because Cayce said so" is evidence for.
 
Why is this not a fair question?

If Rodney asks for a citation supporting the claim that animated ash is not effective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer, is this not a reasonable request on a skeptics forum?

Unless I misunderstand, otherwise it seems we are expected to settle for: "Because Cayce said it, and we think most of what Cayce said was rubbish, that's why." Which, of course, isn't any more "evidence" against than stating that animated ash IS effective in curing cancer "because Cayce said so" is evidence for.

I can see youre still partly brainwashed then
:D
if animated ash was a cure for cancer, which group has the burden of proof ?

is it

1. the A.R.E./Edgar Cayce who are claiming it is
2. medical professionals who have never heard of it

it might help to read this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_burden_of_proof

so really, what the only relevant question should be

Q. why hasn't the A.R.E. provided any proof in the last 60 years that animated ash has any effect on cancer

youd think they would right, think of the millions of people who would be grateful and the billions of dollars that the A.R.E. would have made from this miracle cure. Then remember, they have a disclaimer on the page stating that they have no confidence in their own claim
;)
 
Last edited:
Why is this not a fair question?

If Rodney asks for a citation supporting the claim that animated ash is not effective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer, is this not a reasonable request on a skeptics forum?

Unless I misunderstand, otherwise it seems we are expected to settle for: "Because Cayce said it, and we think most of what Cayce said was rubbish, that's why." Which, of course, isn't any more "evidence" against than stating that animated ash IS effective in curing cancer "because Cayce said so" is evidence for.

What's wrong with stating that the prior probability is similar to that of any other unselected substance?

Linda
 
ok we can approach this from another angle and see if you get it

I say that swallowing dog faeces whole which have been heated to an average 37.5 C will aid the immune system in curing cancer

Now I demand to know why the A.R.E. hasn't disproved my claim
because according to your stance, as they haven't it might just be true

right ?

:D
 
Last edited:
Why is this not a fair question?

If Rodney asks for a citation supporting the claim that animated ash is not effective in increasing oxygen and assisting the immune system in fighting cancer, is this not a reasonable request on a skeptics forum?
No. The burden of proof is on the claimant as you are well aware of.
The plausibility of a claim is based on prior knowledge and the existing evidence to support the claim.

In this case "ash" has no plausibility in treating cancer and the Cayce followers are apparently to lazy and cowardly to perform an appropriate study to "prove" their claim.
Unless I misunderstand, otherwise it seems we are expected to settle for: "Because Cayce said it, and we think most of what Cayce said was rubbish, that's why." Which, of course, isn't any more "evidence" against than stating that animated ash IS effective in curing cancer "because Cayce said so" is evidence for.
No. Because nothing Cayce has said even remotely supports taking any of his garbage seriously.
 
I can see youre still partly brainwashed then
:D
if animated ash was a cure for cancer, which group has the burden of proof ?

is it

1. the A.R.E./Edgar Cayce who are claiming it is
2. medical professionals who have never heard of it

it might help to read this
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_burden_of_proof

so really, what the only relevant question should be

Q. why hasn't the A.R.E. provided any proof in the last 60 years that animated ash has any effect on cancer

youd think they would right, think of the millions of people who would be grateful and the billions of dollars that the A.R.E. would have made from this miracle cure. Then remember, they have a disclaimer on the page stating that they have no confidence in their own claim
;)

No, this has nothing to do with me being brain-washed. I understand about burden of proof but that wasn't what I was getting at.

Yes, you would think the A.R.E. would be interested in testing the claims Cayce made over the last 60 years. I agree with this.

What's wrong with stating that the prior probability is similar to that of any other unselected substance?

Linda

Nothing. :) Your post sort of cross-posted with mine and I didn't see this until afterward, but still I would have asked the question about why Rodney's question was unreasonable.

ok we can approach this from another angle and see if you get it

I say that swallowing dog faeces whole which have been heated to an average 37.5 C will aid the immune system in curing cancer

Now I demand to know why the A.R.E. hasn't disproved my claim
because according to your stance, as they haven't it might just be true

right ?

:D

Yes, with no evidence either way, this just might be true. Bizarre, and not something I would personally want to try, but possibly true.

Is it likely to be true? To the best of my knowledge, no. But can I say with 100% certainty that it isn't? No.

No. The burden of proof is on the claimant as you are well aware of.
The plausibility of a claim is based on prior knowledge and the existing evidence to support the claim.

In this case "ash" has no plausibility in treating cancer and the Cayce followers are apparently to lazy and cowardly to perform an appropriate study to "prove" their claim.
No. Because nothing Cayce has said even remotely supports taking any of his garbage seriously.

You're right, I know the burden of proof is on the claimant.

However, I think it is incorrect for us to boldly state that animated ash does not assist in the way Cayce claimed it did without evidence to back that statement up.

Better to say something similar to what you just said: Ash has no plausibility in treating cancer that we know of, and the burden of proof is on the A.R.E. That seems a much fairer statement.

Rodney was asking whether or not animated ash as a treatment had been discredited. It seems the answer to that is no. Not, "No, what a ridiculous claim." Or no, "How can you be so stupid as to believe such a thing." Or no "And it isn't up to us to disprove, it's up to the A.R.E." Just no.

I am interested in the reasons why the things Cayce said are untrue. I'm not interested in emotional arguments or Cayce bashing. If animated ash seems implausible, I want to know why. If it's been discredited, I want to know that, too.
 
Nope youre still not getting it are you

who is the burden of proof on ?

when youve answered that correctly you'll suddenly see why Rodneys question is ridiculous
 
Last edited:
The yield for effective cancer treatments seems to be less than 3 in 10,000 when screening unselected substances. (Estimate from the NCI cancer screening program which has screened 400,000 drugs and has 129 drugs are undergoing or have completed further testing (some portion of which will be found to be ineffective on clinical testing) http://www.cancer.gov/cancertopics/factsheet/nci/drugdiscovery.)

If the prior probability that animated ash is an effective cancer treatment is 0.0003, without any information which would alter that probability this would be a poor strategy if one is attempting to find an effective cancer treatment.

Linda
Have any of Cayce's cancer remedies ever been subjected to a controlled test? If not, your numbers have no relevance to the issue at hand.
 
Nope youre still not getting it are you

who is the burden of proof on ?

when youve answered that correctly you'll suddenly see why Rodneys question is ridiculous
You're the one who asked: "btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was?"

To which a true skeptic would respond: Assuming that Cayce's animated ash treatment can be equated to "eating raw wood", no one knows -- it's never been subjected to a controlled test.
 
Have any of Cayce's cancer remedies ever been subjected to a controlled test? If not, your numbers have no relevance to the issue at hand.
Have any of Cayce's cancer remedies ever been subjected to a controlled test? If not, your claims have no relevance to the issue at hand.
 
To which a true skeptic would respond: Assuming that Cayce's animated ash treatment can be equated to "eating raw wood", no one knows -- it's never been subjected to a controlled test.
No. A skeptic would say:
"Based on modern biology, physiology, medicine and the fact that Cayce is an irrelevant nutjob who has the credibility of any random nobody; I can say confidently that his claim concerning "animated" ash is harmful nonsense and is unlikely to be any benefit the the patient until the irresponsible true believers actually have the balls to test out these claims themselves.

I can also clearly say that anyone continuing to push this so-called "treatment" is is unethical and irresponsible and deserves to be called so."
 
You're the one who asked: "btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was?"

To which a true skeptic would respond: Assuming that Cayce's animated ash treatment can be equated to "eating raw wood", no one knows -- it's never been subjected to a controlled test.

yes that was sarcasm, sorry you missed that.
I'm not asking that of you anymore, I already know you didn't bother and won't bother to think critically about anything that Cayce says, we've already seen more than enough evidence from you that you haven't got a clue that you've been conned, despite the fact that I have shown you that the A.R.E lie and continue to lie for profit

:p
 
You're the one who asked: "btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was?"

To which a true skeptic would respond: Assuming that Cayce's animated ash treatment can be equated to "eating raw wood", no one knows -- it's never been subjected to a controlled test.
I still can't believe this thread is still going on.

Rodney, if I may ask ... has a single person since Cayce's death ever tried this animated ash recipe as the sole treatment for their cancer? If so, what was the result?
 
You're the one who asked: "btw did you check out if eating raw wood is a cure for cancer yet as Cayce claimed it was?"

To which a true skeptic would respond: Assuming that Cayce's animated ash treatment can be equated to "eating raw wood", no one knows -- it's never been subjected to a controlled test.

That was kind of the point I was trying to make, too.

I guess we will all have to agree to disagree on this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom