The War on Drugs is Useless

McHrozni, have you actually looked at the rates of use before and after decriminalisation? In all the examples I'm aware of the actual usage rates dropped rather than increased.

And drugs would not be "more available", if anything the regulation that goes with a legalisation regeime would result in fewer users from the lower end of the age rage due to difficulty to purchase. Many examples of kids telling us it's easier to buy a hit of heroin than to buy a beer would point to that.

People should be careful to remember that legalisation does not mean "free for all". It means a carefully considered regulatory model with specific use requirements, age requirements, testing for influence when driving etc. If anything it would be a more restrictive model than the current one which allows people to go see the greasy dealer down the corner and buy whatever they want no questions asked. Not to mention the taxes generated to help problem users/addicts and the benefits gained from consistent purity of harder drugs like heroin and methamphetamines.

Look, I agree that we should be careful with what drugs we regulate and how, but the present system does not work. If the aim is to reduce the number of users, it's failed. If the aim is to reduce the numbers of deaths from improper or excessive use, it's failed. If the aim is to cost the society at large the least amount possible it's failed. How long will we keep up this prohibitionist experiment before we realise that the policy has failed in every metric we measure success by?
 
Many examples of kids telling us it's easier to buy a hit of heroin than to buy a beer would point to that.

Good point. When I was in high school, it was easier to get many illegal drugs than it was to get alcohol.
 

So you don't want the government to sell the dope, and you don't want the cartels doing it. So you want new companies to do it? Big Smack? Big Meth? Yeah, I'm pretty sure they won't be shady. Big Meth's election contributions ect. But doesn't solve the problem of the cartels. What are you going to do with the unauthorized dope sellers? You're still going to have to devote $19 billion a year to shutting them down.
 
Last edited:
I am saying that you don't know the effect would be.

And you do?

You're right. It is impossible to enforce a ban on alcohol. But it is also impossible to enforce a ban on illegal drugs. Or perhaps you know something the US government does not know?

Perhaps one thing yes - persecuting drug users is a waste of effort.

It is not impossible to enforce a ban on certain drugs. It is impossible to completely eradicate a drug, true, but it is possible to significantly reduce supply. The fact US government isn't doing it very effectively hardly shows it is impossible, don't you think?

100% of evidence says I am correct.

Really. Please point to a state that permitted use of hard drugs and saw usage drop as a result.

Perhaps a temporary one. The US government has been unable to put any permanent dents on supply. If you know how to do this, perhaps you should let them know.

I pointed out one option. Since drug use in US is more rampant than in some other countries, perhaps US should seek their counsel?

McHrozni, have you actually looked at the rates of use before and after decriminalisation? In all the examples I'm aware of the actual usage rates dropped rather than increased.

For the umpteenth time, decriminalization of drug use is something I support. I said that several times by now in this thread. The war on drugs isn't going well and some of it's aspects are badly planned, but that doesn't mean the entire effort is bad.

Look, I agree that we should be careful with what drugs we regulate and how, but the present system does not work. If the aim is to reduce the number of users, it's failed.

You don't know that, because you don't know the number of users that would be on the stuff if it was readily available.

If the aim is to reduce the numbers of deaths from improper or excessive use, it's failed.

Comparison to alcohol shows otherwise.

If the aim is to cost the society at large the least amount possible it's failed.

That is true.

And lastly, this:

People should be careful to remember that legalisation does not mean "free for all". It means a carefully considered regulatory model with specific use requirements, age requirements, testing for influence when driving etc. If anything it would be a more restrictive model than the current one which allows people to go see the greasy dealer down the corner and buy whatever they want no questions asked.

With the already existing trafficking network in place, wouldn't you say a significant black market would stay for these? If you ramp up taxes, black market could still find a niche for that, like with cigarettes. If the stuff were legal, smuggling it would be easier, allowing the black market price to drop.

Certainly, it could reduce the power of the criminal cartels over time. However if these cartels would just turn to provide the stuff legally, that wouldn't really help the issue.

McHrozni
 
So you don't want the government to sell the dope, and you don't want the cartels doing it. So you want new companies to do it? Big Smack? Big Meth? Yeah, I'm pretty sure they won't be shady. Big Meth's
election contributions ect.

No more shady than big alcohol or big tobacco.

But doesn't solve the problem of the cartels. What are you going to do with the unauthorized dope sellers? You're still going to have to devote $19 billion a year to shutting them down.

Yeah, just the same as illegal alcohol remained a huge problem after the end of prohibition. Oh, wait....
 
To be fair, illegal alcohol production, whilst small if not miniscule in number in most developed countries, is more of an issue in less developed or remote areas of developed nations.

Illegal manufacture and sale of tobacco is also still an issue in some countries and juristictions, but it's several orders of magnitude smaller than the legitimate market, mostly because quality is rubbish and tobacco is cheap even with taxation through the roof.
 
And you do?

I never said I did.

It is not impossible to enforce a ban on certain drugs. It is impossible to completely eradicate a drug, true, but it is possible to significantly reduce supply.

Short of patrolling every single mile of the border and searching every truck, plane, and cargo container that comes into the country, I don't see how. Too much money to be made.

The fact US government isn't doing it very effectively hardly shows it is impossible, don't you think?

That and the simple economics of the situation.

Really. Please point to a state that permitted use of hard drugs and saw usage drop as a result.

I was referring to the impossibility of effectively enforcing a ban.

I pointed out one option. Since drug use in US is more rampant than in some other countries, perhaps US should seek their counsel?

That doesn't prove that they have been successful in significantly reducing supply. It could just mean that the demand is lower.
 
I never said I did.

So you agree with me there is little reason to believe the drug abuse situation would improve if they were legalized. Thanks.

Short of patrolling every single mile of the border and searching every truck, plane, and cargo container that comes into the country, I don't see how. Too much money to be made.

That would be a bit awkward, although adequate border controls are a necessary part in this.

One interesting idea would be to eliminate cash from society. If all transactions were completely traceable, finding the dealers and evidence against them would be fairly easy. Drastic, true, but so is heroin available at any liquor store.

I was referring to the impossibility of effectively enforcing a ban.

Ah. Well, in that case, let me point to North Korea, which effectively enforces a ban. True, the price their society pays for it is worse than any drug problem, but clearly, it is not impossible to enforce such a ban.

That doesn't prove that they have been successful in significantly reducing supply. It could just mean that the demand is lower.

It could also mean that, yes. Could it be a mix of both?

Incidentally, dtugg, would you support drugs being available for free for anyone who wants them (with only age restrictions in place perhaps)? That would eliminate drug-related crime entirely, and suffering would be largely limited to those that want to use them. With mass production, the cost of that would be fairly low, and the reduced crime rate could make it well worth it in terms of money.
Would you agree? Why? Why not?

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Around and around in circles the discussion goes, where it will stop, nobody knows...
 
So you agree with me there is little reason to believe the drug abuse situation would improve if they were legalized. Thanks.

I didn't say otherwise.

That would be a bit awkward, although adequate border controls are a necessary part in this.

Yes it would. And would the huge cost in securing the borders and the costs to legitimate economy be worth it? I don't think so, and neither does the US government.

One interesting idea would be to eliminate cash from society. If all transactions were completely traceable, finding the dealers and evidence against them would be fairly easy. Drastic, true, but so is heroin available at any liquor store.

Maybe that would work. I suspect they would just find ways around it though.

Ah. Well, in that case, let me point to North Korea, which effectively enforces a ban. True, the price their society pays for it is worse than any drug problem, but clearly, it is not impossible to enforce such a ban.

OK. Let me amend that to "it is impossible to enforce an effective ban without cost to society being much worse than the drugs themselves."

It could also mean that, yes. Could it be a mix of both?

Maybe. Another possibility I didn't think about before is that maybe drug cartels focus more on the USA because of its proximity to the source, the ease of smuggling it into the USA given its huge borders and coastlines, and because Americans have more money to spend on drugs than people in most other countries.

Incidentally, dtugg, would you support drugs being available for free for anyone who wants them (with only age restrictions in place perhaps)? That would eliminate drug-related crime entirely, and suffering would be largely limited to those that want to use them. With mass production, the cost of that would be fairly low, and the reduced crime rate could make it well worth it in terms of money.
Would you agree? Why? Why not?

I would support this over the status quo, absolutely. I do think it would be better to just sell them and put "sin" taxes on them in order to help for for treatment. Though, obviously this tax couldn't be too high otherwise the black market would still exist.
 
So you agree with me there is little reason to believe the drug abuse situation would improve if they were legalized. Thanks.

Well, I would, provided that you accept that there is very little reason to believe the drug abuse situation would be worsened if they were legalised?
 
Has anybody mentioned quality control as a reason for legalization? As of now, there is none and this leads to many otherwise preventable deaths. Especially with heroin. There are actually two different ways that it can lead to an overdose. First, the user has no way of knowing the purity of the drugs, which can very widely. If a heroin user is used to taking heroin that is 40% pure but then gets some that is 80% pure, there is a good chance he will OD. The drugs may also contain other, more deadly active ingredients. FentanylWP (and its analogues) which is extremely potent, much more so than heroin, is sometimes mixed with heroin and an inactive cut to make the heroin seem much more potent.
 
The following pictures are taken from a park called Platzspitz, previously known as "Needle Park" in Switzerland. One of the pictures was taken when drug use was virtually legalized in the park. One of the was taken after the experiment was shut down. Try and guess which is which:

AAAA.jpg


800px-Z%C3%BCrich_-_Platzspitzpark_IMG_0374.jpg
 
Maybe that would work. I suspect they would just find ways around it though.

Probably, in time. Fighting against organized crime is a never ending story.

Maybe. Another possibility I didn't think about before is that maybe drug cartels focus more on the USA because of its proximity to the source, the ease of smuggling it into the USA given its huge borders and coastlines, and because Americans have more money to spend on drugs than people in most other countries.

That is undoubtedly a factor. So perhaps more effort on the source is needed? I know much is being done already, but could more be done?

I'm sure all policies could be improved, but the question is indeed by how much.

I would support this over the status quo, absolutely. I do think it would be better to just sell them and put "sin" taxes on them in order to help for for treatment. Though, obviously this tax couldn't be too high otherwise the black market would still exist.

Interesting. It might be cheaper to do away with the free treatment and allow anyone to drug themselves to death if they want, though. It would depend on how much would the actual costs of procurement be, but the treatment can be so expensive as not to be worth it. It would be another money drain, in all likelihood.

That said, the cost to the society could be enormous.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
The following pictures are taken from a park called Platzspitz, previously known as "Needle Park" in Switzerland. One of the pictures was taken when drug use was virtually legalized in the park. One of the was taken after the experiment was shut down. Try and guess which is which:
Your point being?
 
I wonder if rampant usage had anything to do with that being the only place to use with no risk. :rolleyes:

And besides, nobody is suggesting that anything like that be tolerated. It is not even legal to drink alcohol in public most places in the US.
 
Has anybody mentioned quality control as a reason for legalization? As of now, there is none and this leads to many otherwise preventable deaths.

This concern of yours strikes me as rather odd. Habitual drug users are slowly killing themselves anyway. If they kill themselves sooner, surely the damage to the society is lesser, no?

McHrozni
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom