Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, you an AGW opponent and you work for an Energy company. No bias there then.

I worked with a guy who was a denier (he would call himself a skeptic), and I was a bit stunned at first to meet someone with these views. He preached he knew alot about the science as he had researched it and understood it and that there were serious flaws with the IPCC etc.

So I spent a few weeks researching his claims (which was when I found JRef). And of course I found them all to have been popular amoungst the denier population. Infact his arguments were to pretty much exactly the same as you find on any denier blogk. Funny that hu.

Now its a few years later and I've followede threads like this, found that AGW wasnt the only denier fix (911 truthers was fun) and I see the guy in a completely new light. He fitsthe profile completely and far from researching and coming to a conclusions based facts, I find he was just repeating the mantra.

I mean for example, I've followed and investigated the assertion that the models cannot be trusted, and have found it to be completely debunked. Yet, this guy would sit in the tea room - with a captured audience, and spunk this stuff off as if he discovered/uncovered the truth just last week and that we are all being lied to.

3bodyproblem - i've heard it all before, you're living in denial or on the moon, or someplace where physical reality changes every few minutes.

That was heart warming, but in denial of what? You just presented a long drawn out story and finished it with no supporting evidence. If I did that these guys would be all over me, but people like you, that just want to make their ad hom attacks, there's no critical thinking.

Again, what am I so called in denial of? I've given NASA's own word, the models don't reflect cloud cover with enough accuracy at this time. How did you debunk that?
 
That was heart warming, but in denial of what? You just presented a long drawn out story and finished it with no supporting evidence. If I did that these guys would be all over me, but people like you, that just want to make their ad hom attacks, there's no critical thinking.

Again, what am I so called in denial of? I've given NASA's own word, the models don't reflect cloud cover with enough accuracy at this time. How did you debunk that?
Firstly:
http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/04/models-dont-have-clouds.php

Secondly, from what I have read and understood, the models are there to try to predict what will happen based on various scenarios of human related CO2 emmissions in the future based on the very well understood science. They are not used to prove that AGW is a reality, but more to calculate possible outcomes based on various future possibilities that could occur by our actions based on the known science.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-global-warming.htm

The mounting (mounds of) evidence, - not the models- and underlying science, (and there appears to be a lot of it), is why there is huge consensus for AGW.

Look up denialism, you will find a common practice is to cherry pick an individual aspect of the argument, often out of context, then make the extrodinary leap of discrediting (ignoring) every other piece of evidence.

Even within this thread various people have pointed out why your position is one of denialism rather than skeptic.

Heres some more:

http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/03/models-are-unproven.php
http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_tar/?src=/climate/ipcc_tarwg1/figspm-4.htm
 
Firstly:
http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/04/models-dont-have-clouds.php

All of the Atmospheric Global Climate Models used for the kind of climate projections reported on by the IPCC take the effects of clouds into account. You can read a discussion about cloud processes and feedbacks in the IPCC TAR.

Secondly, from what I have read and understood, the models are there to try to predict what will happen based on various scenarios of human related CO2 emmissions in the future based on the very well understood science. They are not used to prove that AGW is a reality, but more to calculate possible outcomes based on various future possibilities that could occur by our actions based on the known science.

http://www.skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-global-warming.htm

The mounting (mounds of) evidence, - not the models- and underlying science, (and there appears to be a lot of it), is why there is huge consensus for AGW.

Look up denialism, you will find a common practice is to cherry pick an individual aspect of the argument, often out of context, then make the extrodinary leap of discrediting (ignoring) every other piece of evidence.

Even within this thread various people have pointed out why your position is one of denialism rather than skeptic.

Heres some more:

http://scienceblogs.com/illconsidered/2006/03/models-are-unproven.php
http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_tar/?src=/climate/ipcc_tarwg1/figspm-4.htm
 
So no example where I've denied anything. Awesome.

Of course I knew you'd fail to do so because I don't "deny" anything. All I've ever said is that I've been around this issue for a while and reacting to alarmism should be kept in check. The science doesn't support the overreactions this issue tends to invoke in people. There's still more to discover and more we need to get a handle on before we can start tp make a concerted effort and know what effect it will have on the climate.

Right now we are making token efforts. We don't know what, if any effect it will have on the climate. It will most likely be positive, but to what extent simply can't be known.
 
3B
would you like to clarify that for our general edification??

I believe it was a in statement I made to bitpattern about yet unknown forcings? Or was it about clouds? Beats me, it was a talking point to initiate discussion.

edit: see post 200 and lomillers "99%" as an example. he obviously made up that figure to use as a discussion point. Shall we hold him to the same standards when citing numbers? Somehow I doubt you will simply because his agenda is the same as yours.
 
Last edited:
Once again we see the biggest source for skepticism, the lies alarmists pepetuate against anyone falling outside their own set of beliefs.

And we see once again who the true deniers are. Alarmists who refuse to admit what the scientists do freely. The science is still incomplete as a comprehensive examination of the past, current and future climate.
 
And we see once again who the true deniers are. Alarmists who refuse to admit what the scientists do freely. The science is still incomplete as a comprehensive examination of the past, current and future climate.

So, because science is never "complete" and new research is always being done (in any field), does that mean no conclusions can ever be reached? That sure slows down the level of scientific advancement, doesn't it?
 
So, because science is never "complete" and new research is always being done (in any field), does that mean no conclusions can ever be reached? That sure slows down the level of scientific advancement, doesn't it?

No, it accelerates it. Especially where it involves very importatnt issues like climate change.

It's alarmists taking what we currently know and saying 'Thanks, we've got enough, good job" that kills it in its tracks.

The conclusions seem fairly obvious at this point, bring CO2 emissions down to 0. Falling short of that, which we most certainly will, we can't know what effect our limited curtailing of emissions will have. This is what ends up killing world wide efforts like Kyoto.
 
3b
, in 15 years the level will be back to X ppm
macdoc asked
would you like to clarify that for our general edification??
Dodging again likeis the sun closer in winter or summer?.a simple question you've ducked and avoided

what exactly do you mean by

the level will be back to X ppm
Please educate us???
You made a statement - back it up... :popcorn1
 
It's the "God of the gaps" argument, dusted off and given a new coat of whitewash.

I suppose it was the God of gaps that didn't put a man on the moon in the 30's? The God of gaps that didn't see heart transplant surgery common place after the invention of anesthesia? The god of gaps that kept hybrid down until 75 years after they were first proposed? The god of gaps allowing H1N1 to claim lives today?

Sometimes the technolgy lags behind the theory that makes it possible. It's only because we ignore alarmists we don't blunder into things we don't yet understand or aren't capable of doing. The current level of research and model predictions still warrant a certain degree or reservation. Don't be fooled into thinking $7/ gallon gasoline and increased taxes in the western world are going to have any effect on the climate.

Any effort to reduce CO2 beyond that which we are already heading towards demands "extraordinary proof". Proof that does not yet exist.
 
I suppose it was the God of gaps that didn't put a man on the moon in the 30's? The God of gaps that didn't see heart transplant surgery common place after the invention of anesthesia? The god of gaps that kept hybrid down until 75 years after they were first proposed? The god of gaps allowing H1N1 to claim lives today?

Sometimes the technolgy lags behind the theory that makes it possible. It's only because we ignore alarmists we don't blunder into things we don't yet understand or aren't capable of doing. The current level of research and model predictions still warrant a certain degree or reservation. Don't be fooled into thinking $7/ gallon gasoline and increased taxes in the western world are going to have any effect on the climate.

Any effort to reduce CO2 beyond that which we are already heading towards demands "extraordinary proof". Proof that does not yet exist.

That doesn't even match your arguments - simply word salad. Your argument that we don't know enough to know anything is what is at question here. This is not a matter of the March of Technology.
 
That doesn't even match your arguments - simply word salad. Your argument that we don't know enough to know anything is what is at question here. This is not a matter of the March of Technology.

No, I never said we don't know "nothing". I said we don't know enough to warrant the alarmism rampant on the internet. I said the models have too much uncertainty in them to begin to measure our efforts to make corrections.

I also said misrepresentation by alarmists is the reason for the growing skeptical movement. Misrepresentation like saying things people didn't say to try and make some point. :rolleyes:
 
No, it accelerates it. Especially where it involves very importatnt issues like climate change.

It's alarmists taking what we currently know and saying 'Thanks, we've got enough, good job" that kills it in its tracks.

The conclusions seem fairly obvious at this point, bring CO2 emissions down to 0. Falling short of that, which we most certainly will, we can't know what effect our limited curtailing of emissions will have. This is what ends up killing world wide efforts like Kyoto.

If conclusions can never be reached, because the science isn't "settled", then nothing is ever accomplished for science is never "settled". For science to make any progress conclusions have to be found with the available evidence. Sure, conclusions reached when tomorrow's new evidence is introduced may contradict today's, but if you choose to live by the rule that nothing can be gained from from incomplete science then you're at a stalemate.

If all those bright people who study the topic find that with the existing evidence, even while fully acknowledging the existing unknowns (like unpredictable variables), it suggests a conclusion in support of global warming, how reasonable is it to argue they are wrong because of the acknowledged unknowns?
 
I've cut out another big swathe of posts and sent them to AAH. Admittedly, this was a quick scan. I read every post but not in great depth and not looking to see if it quoted other posts. I looked for uncivil parts, things that were just talking about other posters and off-topic comments. I'm sure I missed some. I'm sure some of the ones I sent had some valid points.

But this is the second mod-box of this thread, a thread that seems to have been created to avoid the moderated thread that is pretty much on the same topic. Don't think that hasn't escaped our notice.

I don't see the point of creating a second moderated thread, so let this be a stern warning to cut out the personal attacks and other stuff mentioned above, or this thread will simply be closed and perhaps sent to AAH in its entirety. It is likely that infractions and suspensions will be handed out. So think before you hit the "Submit Reply" button.

To those of you who think they got AAH-ed unfairly, I apologize. This was done with a hatchet, not a scalpel.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
3b
The creation of doubt is an artifact of the lies and misrepresentation alarmists continue to bring to the discussion,

such as??
Specifically??

You like grand pronouncements - you do not provide any support for them however.
Nor answer questions put to you about your posts/
Let's see your sources for this accusation :popcorn1
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom