Evidence of God's existence

Status
Not open for further replies.
I suggest that he has some doronshadmi-like characteristics, most important of which is imperviousness to critique.

Take 'doronshadmi', change two (or three) letters, and you have my new proposed name for Bill.

"Impervious to critique" is an interesting claim.

The most vociferous critique of my "thought experiment" I have encountered is that I am not allowed to call my scenario a "thought experiment".

Wow, that's a real intellectual argument.

If you review my scenario you will find that there are two fundamental critiques to be made which actually address my scenario:

1) An environment with laws which differ from the laws of our universe is not possible.

2) A random event is not possible in any environment.

I don't recall that either of these critiques have ever been presented.

The debate tactics that have been brought against my scenario have basically been pathetic.
 
More excuses for your failures.
Please take responsibility for your failures instead of playing little rhetorical tricks.
Your "Thought Experiment" is a failure. It tests nothing and is based on nothing.
Most definitely. But imagining things based on nothing isn't "physics".
Why? Are you claiming it is based on physics?
No, no, no Bill. How did you?
(And what a clumsy attempt at throwing a Red Herring. Its as if you dishonestly tried one of your many rhetorical tricks in a lame attempt at covering up your unparsimonious nonsense...why is that?)
Why are you blaming me for the epic idiocy of your "thought experiment"?
You are demanding others use many unsupported concepts to even make your unsupported concept semi-coherent. What do people call that?
You did? Wow. I feel so honored to be allowed to defend YOUR own claims against your own incompetent concepts that you don't even understand.
Oh yes, I'm still waiting:
1)You to justify how your made up "imagination is experiment" is the same as a Thought Experiment as used by philosophers and scientists.
2)You to provide an actual Thought Experiment that you claimed to have done.
3)You to justify how your fantasy based imagination(ie making crap up) is equivalent to the usefulness of Thought Experiments.
Thinking? Where? Are you using your own made up definitions again?
Yes. Only because the MATH makes sense.
What's your excuse?
"It wouldn't be so dark where you are if you tried thinking outside of the box.". Very cute.
Why would I want to base my thinking on making crap up, pure conjecture and has no basis on anything?

You should add this to your little list of Pax Platitudes:
If you don't know something is true to begin with don't waste your time thinking about it.
 
You are right. I screwed up and forgot the negation. Allow me to try again.


No, this is simply linguistic sleight of hand. Remember the constraints that you placed? Those that do not permit random objects, events or beginnings. Here: [imagine quote here]​

No, I don't remember that at all.
And I'm pretty sure you don't either.

Hmmm ... It turns green?

I screwed up. I should have said the kind of stone that doesn't turn water green.
 
"Impervious to critique" is an interesting claim.

The most vociferous critique of my "thought experiment" I have encountered is that I am not allowed to call my scenario a "thought experiment".

Wow, that's a real intellectual argument.

If you review my scenario you will find that there are two fundamental critiques to be made which actually address my scenario:

1) An environment with laws which differ from the laws of our universe is not possible.

2) A random event is not possible in any environment.

I don't recall that either of these critiques have ever been presented.

The debate tactics that have been brought against my scenario have basically been pathetic.


Who's talking about your 'scenario'? I didn't bother to read it.

I made a general remark about you, your posts, your posting style, and your apparent thought processes.
 
No, I don't remember that at all.
And I'm pretty sure you don't either.

I do. Expand to view the full post:
Not all experiments validate a hypothesis.



You come up with a reasonable description of a thought experiment and tell me why the scenario below doesn't fit.

Hypothesis: A something-from-nothing event of random parameters might have randomly occurred which resulted in the what we call the Big Bang.

Experimental Thoughts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.

If it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy then it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass.

If it has none of the laws of physics that exist in our universe, particularly the law of conservation of energy and mass, then there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event.

If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.

Conclusion:
This environment is a possible explanation for the existence of our universe.

The relevant parts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.​

There you have it. "Devoid of absolutely everything" (etc.) does not permit random objects, events or beginnings.
 
Last edited:
Who's talking about your 'scenario'? I didn't bother to read it.

I made a general remark about you, your posts, your posting style, and your apparent thought processes.

My bad. I misinterpreted what you said as not a complete waste of time.
I forgot about that great argument where everything can be refuted by being so vague it is not possible to counter it.
Congratulations, you raise your own standard of irrelevance.
 
I do. Expand to view the full post:


The relevant parts:
Imagine an environment without any universe.

Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.

If it is absolutely devoid of everything then it is non-temporal, non-spatial, without matter, without energy.​

There you have it. "Devoid of absolutely everything" (etc.) does not permit random objects, events or beginnings.

Didn't you notice that when you stopped at half an anal-ysis you ended up with a half-assed result.
 
Didn't you notice that when you stopped at half an anal-ysis you ended up with a half-assed result.

No, I read it through. And I commented on the latter part as well. Your thought experiment is quite similar to a sleight of hand trick, regardless of whether you realize it or not.

You are not presenting one environment, you are presenting two slightly different ones. The former is devoid of everything, while the latter is not.

The thought experiment only 'works' as long as people don't realize that the first environment (in which nothing exists) is being swapped out for the second environment (in which object, events and so on exist).

It does not work, if only you are a little pig-headed and stubbornly stick to the stipulations of the earlier parts of the thought experiment when you finally arrive at the latter parts.

IOW, if you are not willing to let go of
Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.​
when you arrive at
If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.​
There are constraints. And you yourself placed them!
 
What property of 'devoid of absolutely anything' does not permit random objects, events, or beginnings?

I'd think it'd be much more relevant to ask 'What property of 'devoid of absolutely anything' does permit random objects, events or beginnings'.
 
What property of 'devoid of absolutely anything' does not permit random objects, events, or beginnings?

"Devoid of absolutely everything" is a description. Now you decide whether the phrase accurately describes an enviroment where objects do exist or whether it does not. I wouldn't think it does, at all. I would also think that it is nonsensical to ask somebody to read the first line of an empty book to you.

I don't know what you are driving at with asking for a property though.
 
I'll let you do your own research on unfalsifiable theories of the universe:
Multiple universes, cyclical universe, Big Freeze (heat death), Big Bounce, Big Crunch, etc.

Thanks for that reply. It confirmed my original hypothesis about you.
 
No, I read it through. And I commented on the latter part as well. Your thought experiment is quite similar to a sleight of hand trick, regardless of whether you realize it or not.

You are not presenting one environment, you are presenting two slightly different ones. The former is devoid of everything, while the latter is not.

The thought experiment only 'works' as long as people don't realize that the first environment (in which nothing exists) is being swapped out for the second environment (in which object, events and so on exist).

It does not work, if only you are a little pig-headed and stubbornly stick to the stipulations of the earlier parts of the thought experiment when you finally arrive at the latter parts.

IOW, if you are not willing to let go of
Imagine that this environment is devoid of absolutely everything.​
when you arrive at
If there is no constraint that prevents a something-from-nothing event then a random object can randomly begin to exist.​
There are constraints. And you yourself placed them!

First, even your analysis was accurate then the conclusion would be that after our universe existed then another could not.

Secondly, you must have missed my analogy.
If you drop an non-interacting object into a pool of water it does not affect the properties or lack thereof of water because the object does not become part of the water.

The appearance of a universe in the environment does not change the capacity of the environment for random events because the universe is not part of that environment and does not interact with it.

Most of my naysayers, instead of working through the experiment to see where it goes, start at the conclusion, assume it is wrong, then work backwards to find a problem, and of course they find one that way.

You just jumped around til you got confused and blamed it on magic.
 
I'd think it'd be much more relevant to ask 'What property of 'devoid of absolutely anything' does permit random objects, events or beginnings'.

Of course you would think that since you wouldn't have to do any thinking.
And restating a question as if hasn't already been answered multiple times makes it sound like a legitimate dodge.
 
"Devoid of absolutely everything" is a description. Now you decide whether the phrase accurately describes an enviroment where objects do exist or whether it does not. I wouldn't think it does, at all. I would also think that it is nonsensical to ask somebody to read the first line of an empty book to you.

I don't know what you are driving at with asking for a property though.

Is it nonsensical to ask someone if it is possible to write the first line in an empty book, to continue your analogy?
 
Is it nonsensical to ask someone if it is possible to write the first line in an empty book, to continue your analogy?

In this case, there is no book. No pen. No nothing.

If there's some sort of underlying principle to the universe, whether it's dimensionless (spaceless, timeless), lawless, matterless and energyless, it's NOT nothing, still.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom