The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

I've posted links to the Gallup Polls for 1939 and TWO THOUSAND speeches for the war period. You have dribbled on your bib and farted.

You are not talking about the state of the military, which was the subject under discussion; you are back to talking about your earlier premise. I am not surprised you had trouble following the progression - or lack thereof - given the masterful grasp of argumentation and facts you have displayed since then.

Moving straight to the above level of discourse, rather than pretending to want a discussion, would have proved more efficient for both of us. It would have allowed me to return to work and you to your chocolate milk and Power Rangers reruns all the sooner.
 
You are not talking about the state of the military, which was the subject under discussion; you are back to talking about your earlier premise. I am not surprised you had trouble following the progression - or lack thereof - given the masterful grasp of argumentation and facts you have displayed since then.
Really? You don't find any information on the state of the military at either of my sites?
Moving straight to the above level of discourse, rather than pretending to want a discussion, would have proved more efficient for both of us. It would have allowed me to return to work and you to your chocolate milk and Power Rangers reruns all the sooner.
*pat, pat, pat*
 
Sorry, but you are mistaken about Casablanca being shot before Pearl Harbor.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casablanca_(film)

Warner's was always very anti Nazi. "Confessions Of A Nazi Spy" in 1939 was the first openly Anti Nazi film made by a major Hollywood studio.
A number of Anti Nazi films had additional scenes shot very quickly after Pearl Harbor to address The US's entry into the war.

Yeah, oops on the Casablanca thing. I forget how quickly the studios released material back when they controlled the entire industry from production to distribution to presentation. [.derail]
 
Here's 1939.

The protocols will come later.

Thanks!

:ETA: Cool reading, it will take time.

Interesting how the South and Upper Income disapprove of FDR.

Question Survey 148 # 8 is interesting:
Should the Constitution be changed to require Congress to obtain the approval of the people in a national vote before the United States could take part in a war overseas?

Yes................................ 58%

No................................ 42

Survey #148-B Question #8c

Should we send our army and navy abroad to help England and France?

Yes................................ 17%

No................................ 83
Survey #167-S Question #2a

Should we send our army and navy abroad to fight Germany?

Yes................................ 16%

No................................ 84

Survey #167-S Question #3

If it looks within the next few months as if England and France might be defeated, should the United States declare war on Germany and send our troops abroad?

Yes................................44%

No................................ 56

Ten per cent expressed no opinion.
Survey #171-A Question #6a

What should be the policy in the present European war? Should we declare war and send our army and navy abroad to fight Germany?

Yes................................ 5%

No................................ 95
 
Last edited:
Gawdzilla, I'd be curious to see some of those "everything short of war" questions evolve over the months from, say, '39 to 'Nov of '41.

I don't know that you're proving they weren't isolationist, unless you include "for certain definitions of isolationist". They are clearly, in the early years of the war in Europe, not in favor of going out and fighting, but they're equally clearly in favor of helping in any way just short of declaration of hostilities.

I don't know if that's a fair statement, but I think you might find that the poll results show an increasing willingness to go to war as it became obvious that England was able to hold out, and that Japan was saber rattling in the East. And that's pretty much how history tells the story, isn't it? I haven't actualy heard anyone say that America just didn't care what was happening, so much as that it just didn't have a stomach for another war,.... yet.
 

Dynamic process and all that.

Still trying to figure out a previous comment (from somebody, not worth tracking it) on this meta-discussion, however.
What does it matter if 73% of the public didn't understand statistics in those days? Most of the public never hears anything about statistics other than "according to Gallup Polls", but the polls aren't created for the public's use, are they?
 
Dynamic process and all that.

Still trying to figure out a previous comment (from somebody, not worth tracking it) on this meta-discussion, however.
What does it matter if 73% of the public didn't understand statistics in those days? Most of the public never hears anything about statistics other than "according to Gallup Polls", but the polls aren't created for the public's use, are they?

I think it may have been a joke. Certainly most people don't know how to judge statistics, which is why the sample base is important.

Currently most organizations use random phone surveys, which at this time do not include cell phones, so that is a sample bias, etc...
 
I think it may have been a joke. Certainly most people don't know how to judge statistics, which is why the sample base is important.

Currently most organizations use random phone surveys, which at this time do not include cell phones, so that is a sample bias, etc...

Okay, joke, fair enough.

As for the sampling, it's the best they had at the time, so we can't toss it out because it isn't perfect. As you noted, we're still not perfect on these things.
 
As for the sampling, it's the best they had at the time, so we can't toss it out because it isn't perfect. As you noted, we're still not perfect on these things.


I wouldn't suggest the data should be tossed out, only that the sample bias be considered.

If the raw data is still available, it might be interesting to go back and reweight the samples to better reflect the population. I'd certainly be interested in seeing how the poor and minorities felt about the war compared to the middle class and the wealthy. I'd also love to see whether opinions are skewed by education.
 
That was 1939. The Fall of France and the possiblity that Germany could win changes a lot of minds.

I wasn't the one that posted them as proof of my proposition.
 
The war starts in 1939 the statistics present in this post seem to indicate that some people in the US were not interested in pursuing the European war.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6290947&postcount=67

Now I am assuming that after the fall of France and the battle of Britian, the numbers change.

1940 is up.

I would present this as an attitude check:

DECEMBER 30, 1940

EUROPEAN WAR

Interviewing Date 12/1-6/40

Survey #225-K Question #5

If you were asked to vote on the question of the United States entering the war against Germany and Italy, how would you vote — to go into the war or to stay out of the war?

Go in.............................. 12%

Stay out............................ 88

Three per cent expressed no opinion.

By Region

Go In Stay Out

New England........ 13% 87%

Middle Atlantic...... 13 87

East Central......... 10 90

West Central......... 9 91

South............... 17 83

West................ 14 86

Interviewing Date 12/18-23/40

Survey #226-K Question #1

Which of these two things do you think is the more important for the United States to try to do — to keep out of war ourselves, or to help England win even at the risk of getting into the war?

Keep out...........................40%

Help England....................... 60

Two per cent expressed no opinion.

By Region

Help

Keep Out England

New England........ 38% 62%

Middle Atlantic...... 38 62

East Central......... 46 54

West Central......... 46 54

South............... 25 75

West................ 35 65
Again, no sane person wants to get into a war, but the percentages for helping England certainly don't support "strongly isolationist". But please do look at the whole year, not just this one poll.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom