Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well Dymanic, you are right that the phrase "AA is Spiritual but not Religious" does not appear in the literature. But I'm not sure why you feel it is important to point that out. A lot of Non-theist AAers use that phrase, and they are wrong.

But given some of the self-contradictory statements in the Big Book, it's not surprising that non-theist AAers are confused.

From the foreword to the Second Edition (as it remains in the 4th edition):
Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization.
This Statement isn't true, but it's one of the phrases that conveys the mistaken impression that AA is "Spiritual but not Religious to some non-theists.


From the 12 Traditions (as stated in the 4th edition):
2.—For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authority—a loving God as He may express Himself in our group conscience.
A Religious statement that belies the claim in the foreword to the second edition.

I've already posted the obviously Religious 12 Steps ad infinitum. We both know they are Religious even though you pretend not to.

So let's analyze some other material.


From the appendices (as taken from the 4th edition):
SPIRITUAL EXPERIENCE

The terms “spiritual experience” and “spiritual awakening” are used many times in this book which, upon careful reading, shows that the personality change sufficient to bring about recovery from alcoholism has manifested itself among us in many different forms.

Yet it is true that our first printing gave many readers the impression that these personality changes, or religious experiences, must be in the nature of sudden and spectacular upheavals. Happily for everyone, this conclusion is erroneous.

In the first few chapters a number of sudden revolutionary changes are described. Though it was not our intention to create such an impression, many alcoholics have nevertheless concluded that in order to recover they must acquire an immediate and overwhelming “God-consciousness” followed at once by a vast change in feeling and outlook.

Among our rapidly growing membership of thousands of alcoholics such transformations, though frequent, are by no means the rule. Most of our experiences are what the psychologist William James calls the “educational variety” because they develop slowly over a period of time. Quite often friends of the newcomer are aware of the difference long before he is himself. He finally realizes that he has undergone a profound alteration in his reaction to life; that such a change could hardly have been brought about by himself alone. What often takes place in a few months could seldom have been accomplished by years of self-discipline. With few exceptions our members find that they have tapped an unsuspected inner resource which they presently identify with their own conception of a Power greater than themselves.
Most of us think this awareness of a Power greater than ourselves is the essence of spiritual experience. Our more religious members call it “God-consciousness.” Most emphatically we wish to say that any alcoholic capable of honestly facing his problems in the light of our experience can recover, provided he does not close his mind to all spiritual concepts. He can only be defeated by an attitude of intolerance or belligerent denial.

We find that no one need have difficulty with the spirituality of the program. Willingness, honesty and open mindedness are the essentials of recovery. But these are indispensable.
It is here we also find the weaselly "having our cake and eating it" phrasing which gives the non-theist member of AA the mistaken impression that AA is "Spiritual but not Religious."

Then there is the chapter We Agnostics, which opens by telling non-theist members they need to be open to "Spiritual Experiences":
Chapter 4 We Agnostics:

In the preceding chapters you have learned something of alcoholism. We hope we have made clear the distinction between the alcoholic and the non-alcoholic. If, when you honestly want to, you find you cannot quit entirely, or if when drinking, you have little control over the amount you take, you are probably alcoholic. If that be the case, you may be suffering from an illness which only a spiritual experience will conquer. To one who feels he is an atheist or agnostic such an experience seems impossible, but to continue as he is means disaster, especially if he is an alcoholic of the hopeless variety. To be doomed to an alcoholic death or to live on a spiritual basis are not always easy alternatives to face. But it isn't so difficult. About half our original fellowship were of exactly that type. At first some of us tried to avoid the issue, hoping against hope we were not true alcoholics. But after a while we had to face the fact that we must find a spiritual basis of life —or else. Perhaps it is going to be that way with you. But cheer up, something like half of us thought we were atheists or agnostics. Our experience shows that you need not be disconcerted.
At this point the Non-theist might reasonably assume that he or she can get the Spirituality without the Religion. Though the language is clearly directing the non-theist reader to alter his or her views.

A paragraph or so later we begin to see where this is leading:
Lack of power, that was our dilemma. we had to find a power by which we could live, and it had to be a Power greater than ourselves. Obviously. But where and how were we to find this Power?
Well, that's exactly what this book is about. Its main object is to enable you to find a Power greater than yourself which will solve your problem. That means we have written a book which we believe to be spiritual as well as moral. And it means, of course, that we are going to talk about God.
BOOM! There it is, now we're gettin' real, movin' on from "Spirituality" to "Religion."

Now we're gonna talk about God (with a Capital G). To continue:
Here difficulty arises with agnostics.
You think!!??? ;)

Moving on:
Many times we talk to a new man and watch his hope rise as we discuss his alcoholic problems and explain our fellowship. But his face falls when we speak of spiritual matters, especially when we mention God, for we have re-opened a subject which our man thought he had neatly evaded or entirely ignored.
Now it really starts to get gritty. Spiritual yes, but look how his face falls, "especially when we mention GOD." So we find a clear admission that we are moving from "Spiritual but not Religious" into obvious Religious Territory.


Then we move on into a spectacularly condescending view of non-theists, which questions the psychological unsoundness of the unbeliever:
We know how he feels. We have shared his honest doubt and prejudice. Some of us have been violently anti-religious. To others, the word "God" brought up a particular idea of Him with which someone had tried to impress them during childhood. Perhaps we rejected this particular conception because it seemed inadequate. With that rejection we imagined we had abandoned the God idea entirely. We were bothered with the thought that faith and dependence upon a Power beyond ourselves was somewhat weak, even cowardly. We looked upon this world of warring individuals, warring theological systems, and inexplicable calamity, with deep skepticism. We looked askance at many individuals who claimed to be godly. How could a Supreme Being have anything to do with it all? And who could comprehend a Supreme Being anyhow? Yet, in other moments, we found ourselves thinking, when enchanted by a starlit night, "Who, then, make all this?" There was a feeling of awe and wonder, but it was fleeting and soon lost.

Then the chapter continues, reasserting for emphasis, that only the non-theist's "prejudice" prevents us from recognizing that the "Power Greater than Ourselves" is actually GOD (with a Capital G):
Yes, we of agnostic temperament have had these thoughts and experiences. Let us make haste to reassure you. We found that as soon as we were able to lay aside prejudice and express even a willingness to believe in a Power greater than ourselves, we commenced to get results, even though it was impossible for any of us to fully define or comprehend that Power, which is God.
Now how could that POSSIBLY be religious? :rolleyes: (it is religious by the way)


Oh, but now the Weaseling starts. Shifting tacks, the Chapter begins vacillating on just what sort of God He is:
Much to our relief, we discovered we did not need to consider another's conception of God. Our own conception, however inadequate, was sufficient to make the approach and to effect a contact with Him. As soon as we admitted the possible existence of a Creative Intelligence, a Spirit of the Universe underlying the totality of things, we began to be possessed of a new sense of power and direction, provided we took other simple steps. We found that God does not make too hard terms with those who seek Him. To us, the Realm of Spirit is broad, roomy, all inclusive; never exclusive or forbidding to those who earnestly seek. It is open, we believe, to all men.
Okay, so now we are WAY beyond "Spiritual but not Religious." God is Universal, we can have whatever concept of Him (Capital H) that we like.

"But wait" the non-theist might ask..."what if we conceive of God as Doorknob (or a Volleyball :p )? Could we claim 'Spiritual but not Religious' now?"

No, God is Broad, but He (with a Capital H) is a "Creative Intelligence, a Spirit of the Universe underlying the totality of things." No doorknob, no volleyball, just God, the Creator of the Universe, a Male Supernatural Deity.

This is the Big Reveal.

Then there are more condescending Straw Man attacks on the psychological character of non-theists:
Besides a seeming inability to accept much on faith, we often found ourselves handicapped by obstinacy, sensitiveness, and unreasoning prejudice. Many of us have been so touchy that even casual reference to spiritual things make us bristle with antagonism.

Then we are told that our bad non-theistic way of thinking (the implication being that this is what led to Alcoholism) must be abandoned:
This sort of thinking had to be abandoned. Though some of us resisted, we found no great difficulty in casting aside such feelings.

Then, if this doesn't beat all, we are told that the Alcoholism was ACTUALLY GOOD for us bad thinking non-theists, as it leads us to GOD:
Faced with alcoholic destruction, we soon became as open minded on spiritual matters as we had tried to be on other questions. In this respect alcohol was a great persuader. It finally beat us into a state of reasonableness. Sometimes this was a tedious process; we hope no one else will prejudiced for as long as some of us were.

Then sections of the chapter go on to make claims about the "logic" that leads us to God and the "vanity" of our previous way of thinking:

The reader may still ask why he should believe in a Power greater than himself. We think there are good reasons. Let us have a look at some of them.
The practical individual of today is a stickler for facts and results. Nevertheless, the twentieth century readily accepts theories of all kinds, provided they are firmly grounded in fact. We have numerous theories, for example, about electricity. Everybody believes them without a murmur of doubt. Why this ready acceptance? Simply because it is impossible to explain what we see, feel, direct, and use, without a reasonable assumption as a starting point.

Everybody nowadays, believes in scores of assumptions for which there is good evidence, but no perfect visual proof. And does not science demonstrate that visual proof is the weakest proof? It is being constantly revealed, as mankind studies the material world, that outward appearances are not inward reality at all. To illustrate:

The prosaic steel girder is a mass of electrons whirling around each other at incredible speed. These tiny bodies are governed by precise laws, and these laws hold true throughout the material world, Science tells us so. We have no reason to doubt it. When, however, the perfectly logical assumption is suggested that underneath the material world and life as we see it, there is an All Powerful, Guiding, Creative Intelligence, right there our perverse streak comes to the surface and we laboriously set out to convince ourselves it isn't so. We read wordy books and indulge in windy arguments, thinking we believe this universe needs no God to explain it. Were our contentions true, it would follow that life originated out of nothing, means nothing, and proceeds nowhere.
Instead of regarding ourselves as intelligent agents, spearheads of God's ever advancing Creation, we agnostics and atheists chose to believe that our human intelligence was the last word, the alpha and the omega, the beginning and end of all. Rather vain of us, wasn't it?
This is no mere "Spiritual" argument!!! It is a full throated Theistic, Religious argument.

And we don't need to look much further for MORE evidence of the Religious Foundation of AA's Principles:
We, who have traveled this dubious path, beg you to lay aside prejudice, even against organized religion. We have learned that whatever the human frailties of various faiths may be, those faiths have given purpose and direction to millions. People of faith have a logical idea of what life is all about.
So not only are we non-theists being told that we need ORGANIZED RELIGION, we are also subjected to that classic Sophistic argument of the Religious, the ontological conflation of Faith and LOGIC! :eye-poppi

The next classic religious Argument is the Martyr Complex of Theists who turn history on its head and claim that it is non-theists who are intolerant, AFTER THOUSANDS OF YEARS OF RELIGIOUS DOMINATION!!!
Actually, we used to have no reasonable conception whatever. We used to amuse ourselves by cynically dissecting spiritual beliefs and practices when we might have observed that many spiritually-minded persons of all races, colors, and creeds were demonstrating a degree of stability, happiness and usefulness which we should have sought ourselves. Instead, we looked at the human defects of these people, and sometimes used their shortcomings as a basis of wholesale condemnation. We talked of intolerance, while we were intolerant ourselves. We missed the reality and the beauty of the forest because we were diverted by the ugliness of some its trees. We never gave the spiritual side of life a fair hearing.

The chapter continues on in this vein for a bit, reinforcing the previous assertions. There are a few more choice passages:
When we saw others solve their problems by a simple reliance upon the Spirit of the Universe, we had to stop doubting the power of God. Our ideas did not work. But the God idea did.

Here is some more ontological trickery, putting Faith on the same level as Logic:

Logic is great stuff. We like it. We still like it. It is not by chance we were given the power to reason, to examine the evidence of our sense, and to draw conclusions. That is one of man's magnificent attributes. We agnostically inclined would not feel satisfied with a proposal which does not lend itself to reasonable approach and interpretation. Hence we are at pains to tell why we think our present faith is reasonable, why we think it more sane and logical to believe than not to believe, why we say our former thinking was soft and mushy when we threw up our hands in doubt and said, "We don't know."

Then there is more reinforcement going over the same arguments restated with different examples, and employing the sort of sophistry that only another True Sophist could appreciate (I wonder who that might be :rolleyes: ). Finally leading us to the story of an Atheist Alcoholic who was saved by God:
In this book you will read the experience of a man who thought he was an atheist. His story is so interesting that some of it should be told now. His change of heart was dramatic, convincing, and moving. Our friend was a minister's son. He attended church school, where he became rebellious at what he thought an overdose of religious education. For years thereafter he was dogged by trouble and frustration. Business failure, insanity, fatal illness, suicide these calamities in his immediate family embittered and depressed him. Post-war disillusionment, ever more serious alcoholism, impending mental and physical collapse, brought him to the point to self-destruction.
One night, when confined in a hospital, he was approached by an alcoholic who had known a spiritual experience. Our friend's gorge rose as he bitterly cried out: "If there is a God, He certainly hasn't done anything for me!" But later, alone in his room, he asked himself this question: "Is it possible that all the religious people I have known are wrong?" While pondering the answer he felt as though he lived in hell. Then, like a thunderbolt, a great thought came. It crowded out all else:

"Who are you to say there is no God?" This man recounts that he tumbled out of bed to his knees. In a few seconds he was overwhelmed by a conviction of the Presence of God. It poured over and through him with the certainty and majesty of a great tide at flood. The barriers he had built through the years were swept away. He stood in the Presence of Infinite Power and Love. He had stepped from bridge to shore. For the first time, he lived in conscious companionship with his Creator.
Thus was our friend's cornerstone fixed in place. No later vicissitude has shaken it. His alcoholic problem was taken away. That very night, years ago, it disappeared. Save for a few brief moments of temptation the though of drink has never returned; and at such times a great revulsion has risen up in him. Seemingly he could not drink even if he would. God had restored his sanity.
What is this but a miracle of healing? Yet its elements are simple. Circumstances made him willing to believe. He humbly offered himself to his Maker then he knew.

Even so has God restored us all to our right minds. To this man, the revelation was sudden. Some of us grow into it more slowly. But He has come to all who have honestly sought Him. When we drew near to Him He disclosed Himself to us!

We know EXACTLY where Chapter 4 leads us...to Chapter 5 How It Works:
Remember that we deal with alcohol, cunning, baffling, powerful! Without help it is too much for us. But there is One who has all power that One is God. May you find Him now! Half measures availed us nothing. We stood at the turning point. we asked His protection and care with complete abandon.

Here are the steps we took, which are suggested as a program of recovery:

So there you have it, the RELIGIOUS CONTEXT for what follows, THE RELIGIOUS 12 STEPS.

So Dymanic, you are so right--that the "Spiritual But Not Religious" Mantra is NOT in the Big Book--that you are WRONG, WRONG, WRONG!!!!!

The WHOLE PROGRAMME, in its FULLNESS is RELIGIOUS, and by definition Religious is ALSO Spiritual.

This is not ONE MAN'S OPINION, this IS the PROGRAMME.


GB
 
Last edited:
I didn't read it all, too long at this time of night on Christmas Eve.
What I did notice however is that you listed things in the wrong order, the big book came first and the fourth edition explanation came later. The latter helps explain the spiritual aspect and confirms there is a difference in same. You even highlighted parts:

Most of our experiences are what the psychologist William James calls the “educational variety” because they develop slowly over a period of time. ... snip .... With few exceptions our members find that they have tapped an unsuspected inner resource which they presently identify with their own conception of a Power greater than themselves.

Well I never!
A power greater than themselves that seems to come from within!
Not only that, one of their own conception.;)

Most of us think this awareness of a Power greater than ourselves is the essence of spiritual experience. Our more religious members call it “God-consciousness.”

And it is only the "more religious" that call it "god consciousness". I suppose the rest call it spirituality or something similar.
It also sounds a lot like members can choose whatever the hell they like. Imagine.
 
Last edited:
I didn't read it all, too long at this time of night on Christmas Eve.
What I did notice however is that you listed things in the wrong order, the big book came first and the fourth edition explanation came later. The latter helps explain the spiritual aspect and confirms there is a difference in same. You even highlighted parts:



Well I never!
A power greater than themselves that seems to come from within!
Not only that, one of their own conception.;)



And it is only the "more religious" that call it "god consciousness". I suppose the rest call it spirituality or something similar.
It also sounds a lot like members can choose whatever the hell they like. Imagine.

Get back to me when you have something intelligent to say that indicates you have read and understood my post.

GB
 
Your claim about AA members is probably true. Most of the ones who claim AA is "spiritual but not religious" probably don't know what those words mean.
What do any words mean, if that is treated independent of the way people use them? Since Wittgenstein, the use theory of meaning has come to be the most widely accepted approach, but there are alternatives. Some pages back, I posted a link to an article discussing various theories of meaning. Did you bother to look at any of that? If you're going to continue to base your arguments on the claim that people aren't using words properly, you might want to learn a little more about what it is you're arguing and what it would take to make the case.

However, it is just a claim you make with no evidence.
The admissibilty of hearsay evidence varies from one country to another, one venue to another, one type of proceeding to another. Is there a generally accepted standard here? Do you even dispute the claim that the SBNR meme is very widespread among AA members? The OP didn't. And one more thing: Do you understand what I am referring to as the "streetlight fallacy"?

Another possiblity is that AA members, as a group, are especially gullible and easily led through propaganda and never give a thought to whether it is true or not.
I'm happy to see this willingness on your part to explore possibilities, rather than to stand on the assertion that there cannot be any possibilities other than the explanation that anyone who says AA is not religious is simply lying. What you have just proposed is in fact not far from what I myself argued in an earlier post:
I would also allow that there may be some significant number of AA members who, despite invoking the SBNR meme to describe their own beliefs, would turn out on close examination to be holding beliefs that actually do meet those requirements. [...] It might also be that some of them are just mistaken, having simply never given much thought to exactly how to distinguish between the "spiritual" and the "religious" (which, to be fair, is somewhat more difficult that it might appear on a first glance). Yet another possibility is that they might be attempting to describe a difference they perceive in the role their religious beliefs play in their lives by comparison with others who share the beliefs but not the experience of recovery.



AA cannot in all honesty make the claim that they are inclusive of all alcoholics.
I don't know that AA ever made any such claim to begin with -- and it seems impossible to achieve anyway. Do you disagree with the arguments I've made that by the use of language like "GodAsWeUnderstoodHim", AA excludes those religious fundamentalists for whom that degree of flexibility would be completely intolerable (what with the constraint imposed by the First Commandment and all)?
 
Meaning is determined in large part by context. The Context of AA's literature as it stands today is just as clear as when it was first published.

GB
 
What do any words mean, if that is treated independent of the way people use them? Since Wittgenstein, the use theory of meaning has come to be the most widely accepted approach, but there are alternatives. Some pages back, I posted a link to an article discussing various theories of meaning. Did you bother to look at any of that? If you're going to continue to base your arguments on the claim that people aren't using words properly, you might want to learn a little more about what it is you're arguing and what it would take to make the case.

And as soon as you show that AAers as a group tend to be up on all the philosophers you list, I will see your argument as being possible.

Now, you are saying that words can mean anything and I would say that there is some validity to that, people tend to not be precise in their meanings of words BUT, and it is a huge BUT, that doesn't support your claim, it supports mine.

Someong saying their "dog" is a "quail" doesn't make their dog a quail. It simply means that they have misused the word "quail" and anyone knowing the meaning of the word "quail," and seeing their dog, would know that they had made a mistake and they actually meant "dog."

And that is the point that I have been making here. If AAers claim that the program is spiritual and not religious, they obviously have made a mistake. On the other hand, you are making the argument that the mistake is correct. If your claim is right, words can mean anything and therefore mean nothing . . . which is the point I made eons ago.

The admissibilty of hearsay evidence varies from one country to another, one venue to another, one type of proceeding to another. Is there a generally accepted standard here? Do you even dispute the claim that the SBNR meme is very widespread among AA members? The OP didn't. And one more thing: Do you understand what I am referring to as the "streetlight fallacy"?

I don't see what the differences in hearsay acceptability in various countries has to do with this discussion. It is irrelevent.

Yes, the SBNR meme is very widespread in AA. There is no disputing that and that doesn't cause any issues. The issue is "what is meant by SBNR?" and with a little bit of investigating, one realises that what is meant is "AA is a religious organization."

Like I said, if we follow your line of reasoning no church, or religion, is a religious organization no matter what their literature say, or practices show.

I'm happy to see this willingness on your part to explore possibilities, rather than to stand on the assertion that there cannot be any possibilities other than the explanation that anyone who says AA is not religious is simply lying. What you have just proposed is in fact not far from what I myself argued in an earlier post:

I think the majority have never even considered the idea beyond "the big book says it isn't, so it isn't."

I don't know that AA ever made any such claim to begin with -- and it seems impossible to achieve anyway. Do you disagree with the arguments I've made that by the use of language like "GodAsWeUnderstoodHim", AA excludes those religious fundamentalists for whom that degree of flexibility would be completely intolerable (what with the constraint imposed by the First Commandment and all)?

AA has made that claim. They said all one needs to be a member is a desire to stop drinking and yet we have heard from people posting in this thread that that isn't the only requirement. if they belong to certain groups, they are required to suspend their beliefs in order to belong.

And it isn't religious fundamentalists that see it as religious, it is the general public, just like the GGoC found out. They polled the general public because they truly believed they had dealt with the issue of their being a religious organization and were shocked when they vast majority still saw them that way, even with the word games they played with their literature.
 
And as soon as you show that AAers as a group tend to be up on all the philosophers you list, I will see your argument as being possible.
Studying philosophy is no more necessary to using language than studying aeronautical engineering is to riding in an airplane.

Now, you are saying that words can mean anything...
I am saying that the meanings of words are defined by the way people use them. That's not the same thing.

people tend to not be precise in their meanings of words...
You have it completely backwards. Words themselves tend not to have precise meanings independent of specific contexts and specific purposes. Another way of stating it is that it is within specific contexts and for specific purposes that words aquire precise meanings.

If AAers claim that the program is spiritual and not religious, they obviously have made a mistake.
Would you care to clothe that bare assertion with some actual arguments? Do you feel that they are making a semantic error, or a conceptual error, or both, or what?

I don't see what the differences in hearsay acceptability in various countries has to do with this discussion.
You seem to have a knack for spotting the background yet missing the figure. The statement was merely staging for the question: "Is there a generally accepted standard here?"

They said all one needs to be a member is a desire to stop drinking and yet we have heard from people posting in this thread that that isn't the only requirement. if they belong to certain groups, they are required to suspend their beliefs in order to belong.
Repeating that lie a thousand more times still won't make it true. AA does not require its members to either accept or reject any beliefs. The literature is quite explicit in this regard.

And it isn't religious fundamentalists that see it as religious, it is the general public, just like the GGoC found out.
In this context, the phrase "the general public" would seem to specifically refer to those who do NOT have direct experience with AA. If you really want the truth about something, would you say that polling people who don't have any direct experience with it is really the best approach?
 
Studying philosophy is no more necessary to using language than studying aeronautical engineering is to riding in an airplane.

I'm glad you understand that but it leads to the question of why you keep bringing up obscure and minor points from long gone philosophers and claiming that AAers as a group know and understand them?

I am saying that the meanings of words are defined by the way people use them. That's not the same thing.

So, a person who says that AA is spiritual but not religious is right even if AA is religious? Whatever.

Another way of stating it is that it is within specific contexts and for specific purposes that words aquire precise meanings.

I agree. The scientific meaning of "theory" is completely different than the common usage. However, if you look at AA and its literature, that isn't happening. They are obviously using the dictionary definitions of "spiritual" and "religious" which is what makes them a religious organization.

On the other hand, AA members often have their own definitions of those words but, they are not all the same. Whereas, the scientific definition of "theory" is pretty universal among scientists, the definition of "spiritual' and "religious" is not universal among AA members.

As well, I never hear an AA member give a definition for those two words prior to saying AA is not religious. They always say that AA is not religious and then start making up definitions and twisting facts to make their case. Never can the activities and literature of AA stand on its own merit. They always claim that the reason I think it is religious is because "I just don't understand." That is special pleading.

Would you care to clothe that bare assertion with some actual arguments? Do you feel that they are making a semantic error, or a conceptual error, or both, or what?

All of the above with some dishonesty thrown in. (The arguments have already been made, in htis post and other previous ones.)

The statement was merely staging for the question: "Is there a generally accepted standard here?"

A generally accepted standard for what, hearsay? Of course, hearsay is something that has not been told to you directly. Or do you mean, validity of hearsay? It doesn't matter. In this case we can test the claim so it doesn't matter if you "heard it first, second, or third hand.

Repeating that lie a thousand more times still won't make it true. AA does not require its members to either accept or reject any beliefs. The literature is quite explicit in this regard.

For someone who is so hung up on context you certainly like to ignore it when it suits your purpose. Taken in context, there is far more evidence to show AA is religious than to show it isn't. As stated earlier, the ratio is several hundred to one in favour of it being religious.

In this context, the phrase "the general public" would seem to specifically refer to those who do NOT have direct experience with AA. If you really want the truth about something, would you say that polling people who don't have any direct experience with it is really the best approach?

I would say that in this case, yes it is. Almost 100% of the general public knows a religious organization when they see it. It doesn't take a "special" person to understand. If people don't know the difference between a religious and non-religious organization should they really be allowed to cross the street alone?

You seem to think that this is such an important thing that only a truly "qualified" person, with a lot of knowledge of AA and acceptance of AA doctrine can make the call. It isn't. This is child's play. Anyone with an understanding of the meaning of religious and access to AA literature can tell if the organization is religious.

Your entire argument is nothing more than special pleading.
 
I'm glad you understand that but it leads to the question of why you keep bringing up obscure and minor points from long gone philosophers and claiming that AAers as a group know and understand them?
Can you quote a post where you see me doing that?

They are obviously using the dictionary definitions of "spiritual" and "religious" which is what makes them a religious organization.
They are using commonly accepted definitions of those words to express the idea that AA is not a religious organization. It's a claim regarding facts, not semantics.

On the other hand, AA members often have their own definitions of those words but, they are not all the same. Whereas, the scientific definition of "theory" is pretty universal among scientists, the definition of "spiritual' and "religious" is not universal among AA members.
I have argued that the definition of "religious" is much more universal than the definition of "spiritual", the latter being nearly as open to individual interpretation (i.e., individual application) as is the case with "beautiful", or "fun".

They always claim that the reason I think it is religious is because "I just don't understand." That is special pleading.
I can't presume to speak for these unnamed people to whom you refer, but it may be that "they" are simply saying that you don't understand the facts -- and that is not special pleading.

Taken in context, there is far more evidence to show AA is religious than to show it isn't.
We were discussing the claim that AA requires its members to accept or reject certain beliefs. As that happens not to be true of AA, and as it happens to be true that religious organizations in general do tend to require this, then taken in context it seems to work better as evidence that AA is not religious.

Anyone with an understanding of the meaning of religious and access to AA literature can tell if the organization is religious.
You have demonstrated that that is not the case.
 
Can you quote a post where you see me doing that?

Yes.

They are using commonly accepted definitions of those words to express the idea that AA is not a religious organization. It's a claim regarding facts, not semantics.

Using the same argument, we could prove that AA is an association of wife beaters. Are you saying it really is?

I have argued that the definition of "religious" is much more universal than the definition of "spiritual", the latter being nearly as open to individual interpretation (i.e., individual application) as is the case with "beautiful", or "fun".

The religious part is the issue. AA literature makes AA a religious organization, specifically, the words "God" and "Higher Power."

I can't presume to speak for these unnamed people to whom you refer, but it may be that "they" are simply saying that you don't understand the facts -- and that is not special pleading.

You have spoken for those people in the past but now you don't feel able to . . . nice dodge.

Claiming that I do not understand the facts whent he facts are right there in the big book and other AA literature, is the exact definition of "special pleading."

We were discussing the claim that AA requires its members to accept or reject certain beliefs. As that happens not to be true of AA, and as it happens to be true that religious organizations in general do tend to require this, then taken in context it seems to work better as evidence that AA is not religious.

This is a claim often made in this thread but with no evidence available to support that claim, the claim has no merit. It has been shown that AA believes a Higher Power is necessary and insists their members adopt one.

You have demonstrated that that is not the case.

Hey, I can't take the credit. The OP is the one who brought you, Alfie, and AlBell out. Of course, you have all shown that you do not understand the meanings of those simple words and have nothing but a cursory understanding of AA literature so, we can't really say my argument applies to you.
 
It is obvious you and several others here have no idea what an actual religious meeting involves and entails.

Special pleading. Your only argument is a fallacy of logic . . . I'm not surprised.
 
Yet you decline to do so. That's going to make it hard for me to point out the errors you made in reaching that mistaken conclusion (but perhaps that's just the way you'd prefer things to be).

Using the same argument, we could prove that AA is an association of wife beaters.
Unless you'd care to explain how we could use the same argument to prove that, I'm going to have to dismiss that statement as pure gibberish.

AA literature makes AA a religious organization, specifically, the words "God" and "Higher Power."
And specifically NOT the words, "AA is not a religious organization", or "Alcoholics Anonymous is a fellowship of men and women who share their experience, strength and hope with each other that they may solve their common problem and help others to recover from alcoholism", or "AA is not allied with any sect, denomination, politics, organization, or institution...", etc, etc. It's called: "cherry picking".

You have spoken for those people in the past but now you don't feel able to . . . .
Exactly where in the past have I spoken for these specific people you mention having encountered?
nice dodge
And what exactly do you feel that I dodged?

Claiming that I do not understand the facts whent he facts are right there in the big book and other AA literature, is the exact definition of "special pleading."
No. A simple dispute over facts most decidedly is not special pleading. This is worse than the gaffe you made above with regard to Occam's razor. Creating the impression that you are a critical thinker appears more important to you than actually being a critical thinker, else you would surely take the trouble to actually understand these phrases before invoking them.

This is a claim often made in this thread but with no evidence available to support that claim, the claim has no merit.
The relevant passages from AA literature have been presented here innumerable times. Do you really need to see that evidence again?
 
Yet you decline to do so. That's going to make it hard for me to point out the errors you made in reaching that mistaken conclusion (but perhaps that's just the way you'd prefer things to be).

You asked if I could, not if I would.

Unless you'd care to explain how we could use the same argument to prove that, I'm going to have to dismiss that statement as pure gibberish.

We just make up our own definition of 'wife beater" so that it means "member of an AA meeting" and presto, AA is a wife beater's association.

It's the opposite, but the same, as what you are doing. You are making up your own definitions in order to exclude AA members, I made up mine to include them as wife beaters. Presto, they are now non-religious wife beaters.

And specifically NOT the words, "AA is not a religious organization", or "Alcoholics Anonymous is a fellowship of men and women who share their experience, strength and hope with each other that they may solve their common problem and help others to recover from alcoholism", or "AA is not allied with any sect, denomination, politics, organization, or institution...", etc, etc. It's called: "cherry picking".

Of course you are cherry picking. You left out most of the 12 steps and the major portion of the Big Book.

What I have been doing is looking at all the literature in its entirety. The statement "AA is not a religious organization" is the only one saying it is not a religious organization and it is outweighed by the hundreds/thousands that flat out state, or imply, that it is.

Exactly where in the past have I spoken for these specific people you mention having encountered?And what exactly do you feel that I dodged?

In your post, about the middle of this page.

No. A simple dispute over facts most decidedly is not special pleading.

This is not a dispute over facts. You claim that AA members do not understand the correct meaning of the word religious but you supply no evidence. It is not a fact, it is an unsupported claim.

The special pleading comes in when you, or AlBell, claim I "just don't understand."

This is worse than the gaffe you made above with regard to Occam's razor. Creating the impression that you are a critical thinker appears more important to you than actually being a critical thinker, else you would surely take the trouble to actually understand these phrases before invoking them.

I made a mistake? Get out of here! Well, if it's true, you better mark it on your calendar, it doesn't happen often. :p

By the way, I don't think I mentioned Occam's Razor and I certainly wouldn't have made a mistake with what it means.

The relevant passages from AA literature have been presented here innumerable times. Do you really need to see that evidence again?

You are correct, all the relevent passages have been presented ad nauseum and you are out passaged several hundred to one. Your cherry picking doesn't hold any weight here.
 
Last edited:
You asked if I could, not if I would.
You make a claim. I ask you to support it. You decline. Here at the JREF forum, won't is generally treated as functionally equivalent to can't.

We just make up our own definition of 'wife beater" so that it means "member of an AA meeting" and presto, AA is a wife beater's association.

It's the opposite, but the same, as what you are doing. You are making up your own definitions in order to exclude AA members, I made up mine to include them as wife beaters. Presto, they are now non-religious wife beaters.
The opposite, but the same. Is this an example of what passes for logic in qayakland? And how do you reconcile that with the wording of the post you were responding to, which explicitly states: They are using commonly accepted definitions of those words?

The statement "AA is not a religious organization" is the only one saying it is not a religious organization and it is outweighed by the hundreds/thousands that flat out state, or imply, that it is.
There being so many examples and all, it should be easy to find one single instance of AA literature "flat out stating" that AA is a religious organization.

In your post, about the middle of this page.
I'm afraid you'll have to be more specific than that, because "about the middle of this page" is taken up entirely by one of GB's exercises in argument by visual assault. You know, qayak, I'm starting to see a pattern here: You say I said something, and when asked to show where I said that, you start dodging all over the place. Is that the kind of JREF poster you really want to be?

You claim that AA members do not understand the correct meaning of the word religious but you supply no evidence.
Here we go yet again. I'm so eager to see the next entry in your strawman parade that I won't spoil the moment by asking you to provide a quote indicating that I have ever once made any such claim.

The special pleading comes in when you, or AlBell, claim I "just don't understand."
The claim is: you don't understand what the facts are.

By the way, I don't think I mentioned Occam's Razor and I certainly wouldn't have made a mistake with what it means.
You are making every possible mistake in your investigation. Making claims the evidence doesn't support, cherry picking evidence, violating Occam's Razor, etc., et., etc.
Your choice of words there suggests that you consider Occam's razor to be an inviolable principle rather than a mere heuristic.

You are correct, all the relevent passages have been presented ad nauseum and you are out passaged several hundred to one.
Not one single passage from AA literature has been presented here which indicates that AA "requires" anything from its members beyond "a desire to stop drinking" -- not the least reason being that no such passages exist.
 
You make a claim. I ask you to support it. You decline. Here at the JREF forum, won't is generally treated as functionally equivalent to can't.

You didn't ask me to support it, you asked me if I was able to cite the post. I replied "Yes."

Anywhere I have ever been that is an asked and answered question. Now, if the first question was not the one you meant to ask, you are free to ask another but please stop lying about what was said.

The opposite, but the same. Is this an example of what passes for logic in qayakland? And how do you reconcile that with the wording of the post you were responding to, which explicitly states: They are using commonly accepted definitions of those words?

I knew you would be hung up on that because that's what you do when you have nothing else. Let me break this down for you:

The "same" part is that we both changed definitions to make them what we need them to be to support our argument. You changed "religion" and I changed "wife beater."

The "different" part is that you used your new definition to exclude AA members in your group and I used my change to include them in mine.

Hence, the same but different.

There being so many examples and all, it should be easy to find one single instance of AA literature "flat out stating" that AA is a religious organization.

You are correct, it was and they were shown to you. You made some long, and irrelevent, apologetic posts for them but all your arguments were destroyed by Tinyal, GB and myself, along with others who have periodically dropped into the thread.

Logic would dictate that you should be re-examining your position but you seem to think that simply repeating something that has already been debunked, will eventually make it true. (It won't by the way.)

I'm afraid you'll have to be more specific than that, because "about the middle of this page" is taken up entirely by one of GB's exercises in argument by visual assault. You know, qayak, I'm starting to see a pattern here: You say I said something, and when asked to show where I said that, you start dodging all over the place. Is that the kind of JREF poster you really want to be?

That's ironic coming from you. You often ask for a cite that was in the very section of your post that I responded to. Alfie uses the same tactic. I know the error both you and he are making. You both want the rest of us to be wrong so much that you don't actually read and understand our statements in context, you simply hit "quote" and start typing anything that comes into your mind.

Once again, just read through your posts after GB's very informative post and you will find the citation you want. By the way, you should read those posts by GB because as, as we have heard from some of the AAers who dropped in to give their opinion, those are the posts, along with Tinyal's, that made them aware of just how religious AA is.

Here we go yet again. I'm so eager to see the next entry in your strawman parade that I won't spoil the moment by asking you to provide a quote indicating that I have ever once made any such claim.

It's on the previous page.

The claim is: you don't understand what the facts are.

And as stated before, it is just a claim there is no evidence to support it. Claiming that I don't understand the facts because I have a different view of them than you do, is special pleading.

Your choice of words there suggests that you consider Occam's razor to be an inviolable principle rather than a mere heuristic.

No, when I said violating Occam's Razor in that post I was specifically referring to your practice of argument where, when someone has shown your point to be wrong, you add a bunch more assumptions, variables and contingencies which you think support it. When that too is shown wrong, you add yet more.

Not one single passage from AA literature has been presented here which indicates that AA "requires" anything from its members beyond "a desire to stop drinking" -- not the least reason being that no such passages exist.

That has already been proved false. Your argument here is simply an invincible ignorance fallacy.

The invincible ignorance fallacy is a deductive fallacy of circularity where the person in question simply refuses to believe the argument, ignoring any evidence given. It is not so much a fallacious tactic in argument as it is a refusal to argue in the proper sense of the word, the method instead being to make assertions with no consideration of objections.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom