Ban circumcision in San Fran???

That you were entirely unawre of that until you participated in this thread, entering with the fixed opinion that circumcision was a religious practice in Christianity, speaks volumes.

I note also, from earlier in the thread, that Nihilianth seems to believe that the Battle of Britain was still going on at least until 1942, and possibly until 1947. While irrelevant to the topic, this suggests a rather poor general educational level.

Dave
 
Somehow you would be wrong, because I already have, to a certain extent.

The Catholic diocese I grew up in, in the 80s and 90s at least, did many, many circumcisions as a religious practice.

and the Vatican has no official stance on it any longer.

Sorry, are you saying that a priest conducted the circumcision as a religious practice? If not who in the diocese and how? I was an altar boy, and many of my relatives were priests and nuns. I have never, ever heard of this. What was the ceremony called?

If you can source this, fair enough. Personally I think you have made this whole thing up.
 
Lionking, he seems to have everyone posting refutations of his nonsense on ignore. I doubt you'll get an answer.

Rolfe.
 
I note also, from earlier in the thread, that Nihilianth seems to believe that the Battle of Britain was still going on at least until 1942, and possibly until 1947. While irrelevant to the topic, this suggests a rather poor general educational level.

Dave


Why do peple quote my typos before I spot them?

I hadn't spotted that, Dave. He does seem to have a poor level of general reading, judging by the number of points various posters have had to correct him on.

Rolfe.
 
By definition, the deliberate removal from the body of healthy tissue that cannot regenerate constitutes "harm". If you don't agree that randomly snipping little bits off someone's body that won't grow back is a form of harm, then I think it's your understanding of language that's the problem.

Dave

harm (härm)
n.
1. Physical or psychological injury or damage.
2. Wrong; evil.
tr.v. harmed, harm·ing, harms
To do harm to.

dam·age (dmj)
n.
1. Harm or injury to property or a person, resulting in loss of value or the impairment of usefulness.
2. damages Law Money ordered to be paid as compensation for injury or loss.
3. Informal Cost; price.
v. dam·aged, dam·ag·ing, dam·ag·es
v.tr.
To cause damage to.
v.intr.
To suffer or be susceptible to damage.

1. Damage or harm done to or suffered by a person or thing: escaped from the accident without injury; a scandal that did considerable injury to the campaign.
2. A particular form of hurt, damage, or loss: a leg injury.
3. Law Violation of the rights of another party for which legal redress is available. See Synonyms at injustice.
4. Obsolete An insult.

I dunno. I don't think I am missing anything. Again, it is rather subjective. "Harm, Injure, and Damage," all seem to suggest, according to thefreedictionary, that all three terms suggest a result of some sort of impairment.

A superficial cutting off of a little bit of skin is hardly "impairment." Seems as though my grasp of the English language is perfectly fine.
 
A superficial cutting off of a little bit of skin is hardly "impairment." Seems as though my grasp of the English language is perfectly fine.

The skin removed has nerve endings and experiences sensations. Its removal impairs those sensations, as they can no longer be felt at all. So there's an impairment, meaning that there is harm.

You lose.

Dave
 
FWIW:

San Francisco Circumcision Ban Unconstitutional, Professor Says

San Francisco can have its proposed circumcision ban, or it can have the First Amendment. But it can't have both. That's the opinion of Peter Keane, dean emeritus at Golden Gate University School of Law and a constitutional law professor.
(...)
But what if religious rituals are barbaric or exploitative? Anti-male circumcision activists liken the practice to female circumcision; Schofield uses the term "genital mutilation" repeatedly.

In order for the circumcision ban to move forward, "the court could say the state's interest would outweigh the free exercise of religion," notes Keane. "If I'm an Aztec and my religion says I have to go high atop a pointed building and tear out someone's heart -- that's nice, but there's a murder statute that trumps that. But in terms of state interest in preventing the foreskin of male infant from being detached -- that interest is very, very minor. You can't make any type of medical necessity argument regarding it. There may be some debate relating to whether or not it's desirable for other reasons later on -- sexual pleasure as someone grows older, those kinds of things. But the interest is so marginal, the state does not have the right" to trump freedom of religion.

http://blogs.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2010/11/san_francisco_circumcision_ban_1.php

I would imagine there may be constitutional law professors who disagree.

IANAL.
 
It's down to personal opinion on whether this is "very very minor", or not.

I'm with "not", personally.

Rolfe.
 
It purifies your soul, and marks you as a [....] Christian, and is the first step in the process of serving God.


I just noticed this one, from yesterday.

Could he be more wrong? This is the guy who says he is a Christian, and you'd think should know about these things. The Christian denomination he says he was brought up in only ended its condemnation of the practice quite recently.

We still can't get any sense out of him about this mythical Catholic diocese he claims performs circumcisions as a religious rite.

I think he's making it up as he goes along. I see the reference yesterday to "a child" has now become twins, too.

Rolfe.
 
Just reviewing Nihilianth's presentation of the case for circumcision as a religious requirement within Christianity. Caveat. I gave up after a few pages.

It is being raised in a household of parents who have a certain belief, and would like their children to follow in that belief. And since Christians [....] are in the business of "saving souls," it is entirely appropriate they raise their children in such a way to hopefully save their own kids' souls.
Parents strongly belief it is a necessary part in the spiritual life of the child. And the spiritual life is just as important as the physical life. Usually even more so.


According to the parents, it has the potential to set the child up with a life-long commitment to God, and the saving of the child's soul if they decide to stick with said religion throughout their lifetime. [....] damnation in the fiery pits of hell for eternity is quite a bit worse than a lifetime of morbid obesity, to say the least.


No, you are effectively targeting [....] Christians, and is a form of religious persecution. Atheists and agnostics don't go around circumcising their sons. Not that I know of, anyway.


Catholics, for instance, which is the largest denomination in Christianity, [....] happen to be committed to circumcision.


I aim only to defend the right to practice religion, and to present the views of what those religious people have, and just how strongly(impossible to convey!) they truly believe in God, and the "proper" way in which to raise their children based on this strong belief, and as parents making decisions for the well-being of their child.


Well, as we know, Christians in general AND CATHOLICS IN PARTICULAR are not committed to circumcision. They don't believe it has the slightest bearing on the saving of souls, or is in any way part of the spiritual life. In fact, CATHOLICS "don't go around circumcising their sons". Until quite recently the Catholic church actively condemned the practice.

Nihilianth has no clue what view even the people of his own religion have. Is this a good basis for a sensible discussion, really?

ETA: Missed a good one.

Christians believe they are upholding the old Jewish laws and traditions, as symbolized by circumcision.

modern-day Christians, they just simply stick with the practice of circumcision,

I was going off of what my wife's family has said on the subject. (They are RELIGIOUS! Lemme tell ya! lol.)


Nihilianth's wife's "RELIGIOUS" family is so damn ignorant of their own religion they never heard of the Council of Jerusalem. Wikipedia even has a whole article about the circumciision controversy in early Christianity. It happens to mention that Coptic Christians do practice circumcision, but Nihilianth has never claimed to be Egyptian, or even Orthodox. He says he's Catholic, which seems to be the only Christian denomination that ever actually banned circumcision.

With a level of ignorance like this, what can we say?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
It would be unethical to circumcise an adult without his permission, but when you do it to him as a baby, then it becomes OK?

from what I understand of the law, parents can indeed do things to their children, that the children vocally say they do not want.

-braces.

-ear piercings.

-short haircuts.

-go to church and take the sacrament.

yup, there are lots of things parents can force their children can do, that one could not force upon an adult.
 
See, that may be your opinion, but if you reside in the United States of America, that opinion is factually wrong. Please refer to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Nowhere does it say it allows you to impose YOUR free speech over the body of your baby. Actually I am pretty sure that if somebody started mutilating female genitalia , the law would smack them down hard. And if not, then it is morally wrong, and would also allow female genital mutilation as well as many other type of mutilation.

baby might not be adult, but they have human right too.
 
I can see your point about comparing a haircut to circumcision. But my question is: If you can ban circumcision, where does "banning" decision-making for parents end? Where does it end in overtunring our Constitutional rights, as Americans? (Assuming you are American. But since we are talking SF, we are talking about the USA.)

I know that is a slippery slope argument, and they can be logically fallible, but this is a legitimate concern.

Other problems:

1. There is no evidence it provides adverse health affect.

2. There is no evidence it adversely affects a male's ability to function in society.

3. There is no evidence it adversely affects a male's ability to function in bed.

4. There is no evidence it is any less pleasurable.

5. There is no evidence that males who have been circumcised, really care all that much later in life if they don't have a foreskin.

The same could be said for cutting people ears... That still don't make it a good argument. Any mutilation of part of a body , even if that body part is not functionally relevant to the being, is still an adult imposing its choice and mutilating a kids, and the kid later on being unable to reverse the choice the adult made. And that is the point.

You have freedom of speech and brainwashing your kid with your religion. But as soon as you mutilate their body, you are on the same level as female circumcision folk in north Africa (which by the way majorly do it as a cultural things, much less as a forbid-girl-getting-pleasure things).
 
Somehow you would be wrong, because I already have, to a certain extent.

The Catholic diocese I grew up in, in the 80s and 90s at least, did many, many circumcisions as a religious practice.

and the Vatican has no official stance on it any longer.

None of the catholic I know of, and i repeat NONE at all, were *EVER* circumcised , except for medical reason.

As for the official catholic chruch position:

Historically, the Roman Catholic Church denounced religious circumcision for its members in the Cantate Domino, written during the 11th Council of Florence in 1442.[27] This decision was based on the belief that baptism had superseded circumcision (Col 2:11-12),[28] and may also have been a response to Coptic Christians, who continued to practice circumcision.[citation needed] The modern Roman Catholic Church maintains a neutral position on the practice of non-religious circumcision, and has never addressed the issue of infant circumcision specifically.

Emphasis mine.

On the other hand, it make easy to recognize US porn from otehr country porn...
 
angrysoba said:
In fact, this is something of an argument against circumcision is it not?

No one in their right mind would agree to it.

No one would do it if they had the choice.
Evidence?

I don't need evidence because I was using hyperbole.

The point is that this is a corollary of what Thunder said when he pointed out that it was not something most eighteen year olds would put themselves through if they could suffer it when they are eight days old.

My point is that Thunder concedes that it is something he'd never want to knowingly put himself through. So, he is arguing that it is better to put a baby through something when they are small and helpless than it is to put a grown man through even though he is big and tough.

I pointed out that this concedes the point that it is painful and further want to know why it is necessary at all.
 
from what I understand of the law, parents can indeed do things to their children, that the children vocally say they do not want.

-braces.

-ear piercings.

-short haircuts.

-go to church and take the sacrament.

yup, there are lots of things parents can force their children can do, that one could not force upon an adult.

I'm happy enough to say that parents shouldn't get their children's ears pierced and can happily say that it ticks all the relevant boxes that I earlier made about male circumcision.

The others on the list you provided are bad analogies.
 
From that wiki article about circumcision in Christianity.

In a late letter he [Paul] warned Christians to beware of the mutilation, saying that Christians were the true circumcision because they worshipped in the Spirit of God.


http://www.blueletterbible.org/lang/lexicon/lexicon.cfm?Strongs=G2699&t=KJV

Note that interpretation of Paul's letter to the Galatians. ".... as though he would say, keep your eye on that boasted circumcision, or to call it by its true name, concision or mutilation."

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Aha! So was my suspicion correct? That circumcision was dropped by Christianty re: James-Paul?


Pretty much, it appears. Not hard to find out, either. Nihilianth didn't bother.

coptic christians still insist on circumcision.


So it appears. I didn't know that. I was in Egypt about six weeks ago and met lots of Coptic Christians (one of them even gave me a holy picture as a keepsake), but somehow, it didn't come up in conversation....

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom