Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Wait..are you saying the U.S. Supreme Court could possibly invalidate your ancient religious tradition and you'd be cool with it?

the SCOTUS could do no such thing.

I guess you didn't read what I wrote.
 
I'll let the Federal Appeals Court and SCOTUS decide that.

There's one of two ways to interpret this. You might be saying that you will allow the courts to decide what is moral, but that would be pretty ridiculous. I'll assume that was not your intent.

Or, you could be saying that the courts should rule on what is legal. As has been brought up before, this matter is already settled. Read the Wikipedia page for Reynolds v. United StatesWP. The first sentence on that page summarizes this issue perfectly.

Reynolds v. United States, 98 U.S. 145 (1878), was a Supreme Court of the United States case that held that religious duty was not a suitable defense to a criminal indictment.
 
Or, you could be saying that the courts should rule on what is legal. As has been brought up before, this matter is already settled.

well, then we shall see what happens if/when this law is passed and is immediately challenged in the Federal courts.

I don't think its gonna be as simple as "already settled".

;)
 
So circumcision has nothing to do with religious freedom. Glad we've sorted that out. You can one ditch your First Amendment "argument".

Nope. Not what I said, and not what that part of the conversation was even about.

Someone earlier asked me if it be alright to allow ONLY Muslims and Jews to circumcise their babies, and have no other reasons for doing so. I said I would be down with that. But upon further conversation, I have come to the conclusion that no LAW ban single out religion. And it was pointed out to me earlier that I had argued that it would be acceptable to only allow it for religious purposes.

I agree that no law shall single out religious exemptions for something. Either you allow all to do it, or none. Therefore, it should not be banned, and all can do it for whatever reasons they want, or have no reason whatsoever. Because the First Amendment still protects the rights of Muslims and Jews.

I have no idea how people can possibly make the argument that those opposed to the ban should not be allowed to use the First Amendment right of religion as a basis of argument.

Once again, think of the so-called "anti-burka law" over in France. Such a law should never be passed here, because of the First Amendment, protecting Muslim rights to wear religious garments. Even if said law was passed for a secular purpose, and targets everyone alike. First Amendment rights are still being violated, because of prohibiting the free exercise of Islam. To deny this is so is beyond ridiculously ignorant.

However, IF such a law were to be passed, you cannot make a religious exemption to the law. That would be discrimination against those who are not of the Islamic faith.

In other words, those who defend the Constitution can use the religious freedom argument to not passing a ban. But the law cannot exempt people from a particular law due to sex, creed, and/or race.

Quite a big difference from what you have said.

BTW, I shall really like to know: Why is that you guys are twisting words around so badly? Is it because I am not explaining myself well-enough? Are you afraid of the argument I am presenting and only obfuscating? Are you being willfully ignorant? Or are you just flat-out purposely being dishonest?

If it is because I am not being clear enough, I truly have no idea how to be any clearer. I am not one to be nasty. I am not one to have any hard feelings. I just want an honest discussion about something I feel could be a serious violation of First Amendment rights. I want to have an honest discussion about how I seriously think it is wrong to just butt in on private familial matters. I want to have an honest discussion about addressing your concerns you have in your views about violations of the babies bodies. I want to have a serious discussion about how we can possibly go about satisfying both of our views, without resorting to passing a ban. There has to be a better way than just up and passing a ban.

Quite honestly, I had no idea this was even such a hot-button topic, until I saw this thread, and just how fired up people are getting over it. The amount of dishonesty occurring just to score some talking point, without earning any points of merits for arguments' sake.

In any case, all I ask for is just some honesty here. I have a lot of respect for Dave already, for he is addressing the content of my posts, instead of speculating on what I think, what my opinions are, how I feel about circumcision, and so forth. An open, honest discussion is all I ask for, rather than seeing people trying to spin a web of deceit.

In which case, are there any rules we can establish to have such an honest and open discourse? These questions will likely get shouted down, and laughed out of here. I am kind of expecting that around here. Which is unfortunate, because there are a lot of highly intelligent people that I could learn a lot from that has nothing to do with waging a war of words and scoring superficial points. The whole reason I signed up here to begin with, is because this is my first year as a teacher, and to find out various different views other people may have on various different topics.

Now, I know I have not exactly been innocent myself in all of this. I have contributed just as much.....maybe more....to this disaster of a conversation as many of you. So I will make the utmost efforts of understanding thoroughly just what exactly you are saying, and to only address the content of your posts. I hope I receive the same kind of respect in kind.

Thank you to anyone who has read through this post, and to those who may give this some serious consideration. :cool:

~ Vin.
 
I am not sure of the foreskin, but I am certain the combination gland/foreskin is extremely sensitive, and as has been pointed out earlier removal of the foreskin appears to result in extreme desensitivation of the gland.



I cannot even begin to explain how utterly ridiculous that sounds.

Do you know of even a single case where a woman ended whatever would have turned into sex otherwise because the male was not circumcised and she thought that looked "gross" or "funny"? (As opposed to this being an indicator the guy simply failed to have the right religion, say.)

That aside: How many people would I need to find to tell you that some part of your body looked funny before you would happily chop off said body part?

And do you honestly think that that could ever be a good enough reason to allow parents to chop of said body parts of their children?

Are you seriously not aware of how utterly biased you are? Yes, I would consider myself fairly gross and funny looking if I woe up tomorrow and looked significantly different from what I look like today. If I woke up with a bigger nose I'd find that disturbing - but that honestly doesn't constitute a reason to modify any nose purely on the grounds that it is bigger or diferent than my own.

And yet again. I have to ask how you think Europeans manage to ever have sex? Woman should be fleeing bedrooms all over the place in hysterical giggles. Usually, they seem not to be doing that.

Yeah, you took my post too seriously. I was merely giving my opinion. Nothing more. Sorry if my opinion is not the same as yours (Not really).
 
Missing the point completely. If Nihilianth (and you as well for that matter) were consistent he would argue that circumcision would be allowable only for religious reasons so as not to violate your precious First Amendment. But in doing so he caught himself in a bind by creating a law which favors religion. His solution (open slather) takes the religious argument out of play.

I shall start anew and fresh with this post, to hopefully clear up any misunderstandings. :)

Here's the situation:

Have I been sueded that perhaps circumcision could be considered immoral? Yes.
Can I accept the fact that it is indeed immoral? Yes. Especially on non-religious grounds.

However, does that mean the law has to take morality into consideration? Absolutely not, as I think we have well established.

If the law cannot dictate morality, then the argument for forming a ban based on morality is gone.

Do I think it violates the baby's body? Personally I don't, if done for religious reasons especially. I still don't consider it to really be a violation of the baby's body in any case. I just don't consider circumcision to be that big a deal.

Can I respect the fact that other people may feel strongly that it is a violation of a baby boy's body? Absolutely, I can!

I can also respect the fact that it is somehow a violation of the babies' rights in question as well in other peoples' views. My own opinion on the matter is that it is not

Which puts us at an impasse here that can only be voted on by the citizens. And maybe enforced by the courts.

So, instead of waiting it out to see what happens IRL, let's have a little honest discourse, shall we?

First, I would like to establish a number of things I would like to see in a constructive conversation.

1. We are not talking about anything more extreme than circumcision here. We are not talking about human sacrifice, the removal of whole limbs, and the bodily destruction of people in general. It just doesn't make any sense, and goes back to covering ground which has been fought over far too much already.

2. We are not talking about anything so mundane as the cutting of hair, either for compromise sake.

3. Yes/no questions are very troublesome, and usually doesn't give an honest answer that is at the root of a situation. Please, be careful with these, and form them with care if you honestly feel as though it is a logical question. I would just like to see people not get so upset if they do not receive the answer they wanted, and start throwing around personal insults, and sarcasm. It is not constructive, and nobody learns anything.

4. "Framing." Bias framing has been a major issue I have had throughout this thread. I have pointed out the problems with the word "mutilation," and the use of a yes/no question. "Do you believe that mutilation of a child's genitals is ok?" As I have pointed out, "mutilation" can mean just about anything. If I say "Yes," then the counter response can easily be "so that means you can totally destroy the penis using whatever methods that are available!" If I said "no," then the counter response is "that means you must think [circumcision] should be illegal then! HAH!" See my point about yes/no questions, and framing using ambiguous terminology, and using extreme situations that is as bad as cutting off full baby limbs?

5. Logical fallacies. I have used many fallacies, and a number of other people have used them as well. I will strive to not fall into this practice. But nobody is perfect. Simple rule of thumb would be nice to consider: Don't assume you know what the person must have meant. Just point out the fallacy with a link and/or definition of said fallacy. No need for personal attack. Which leads me to my final point:

6. Personal attacks. Please attack the message, not the messenger. And attack the message without the use of sarcasm, if you will. Try not to assume a person meant something other than what they have posted.

Obviously, you can laugh these things off if you will, ignore them, or think I am a complete idiotic moron for pointing out the obvious. I am not naive enough to think people will think these are some ground-braking, amazing rules or anything. Just a few points I have noticed throughout this thread that has lead to the destruction of good, honest, civilized discussion.

Now, if you will, I shall being:

As I have said in the opening, if the law's purpose is not to dictate morality, then any questions of morality in this conversation has no bearing on the OP. The law is not meant to be twisted by the subjective opinions on society's morals. Case in point: The WBC. Obviously what they are doing is highly immoral by the vast majority of people in general no matter who you are, or where you are from. Even some of the Justices of the Supreme Court thinks their actions are highly immoral, as evidenced by some of what they have said in the transcripts. Obviously, the folks of the WBC would beg to differ. The court upheld the First Amendment rights of the WBC to protest during a funeral, so long as they observed the 300 feet rule. Which is exactly what they did.

Ok, I think the "morality" issue is pretty well resolved.

What we have next, are those of rights. Weighing one person's rights against another, and how society may benefit or be harmed by the practice in question, and how they may benefit or be harmed by a ban on said practice.

On the one hand, you have the rights of the parents as parents to decide what is best for their child. You also have the parents' rights of practicing a religious rite that is central to their religion, as is protected by the First Amendment. Which is something I personally hold dear. You must also remember just how strong their beliefs are to the point that they would be willing to suffer and die for these beliefs, no matter how ridiculous they must sound to you. They view your non-beliefs as equally ridiculous, and would love nothing more than to push their beliefs onto you. This is exactly what the First Amendment was created for. To protect all parties for and from religion at the same time.

On the other hand, you have the rights of a child to make their own decision about their own bodies when they get older. You also have the issue of reducing any pain and suffering it may cause the child, no matter how quickly it may pass and be forgotten.

On yet another hand, you have the interests in society at large, which is what laws outside of the Constitution are meant specifically for. There is over 200 years-worth of case law, as someone has pointed out a little while ago.

Whereas, the Constitution is meant to protect individuals, and spell out the powers of government, and the electoral process, you have laws that are passed later on outside of the Constitution which are meant to benefit society.

Now, how do we go about weighing each of these interests and rights? This is not such an easy prospect. Courts struggle making the correct decisions. So much so, that the Supreme Court even overturns the decisions it has made in the past with different justices at times! Which is the major problem I had with Scum's logical reasoning he was using earlier. He too two or three questions that were strictly yes/no questions that didn't give justice in the sheer weight between individual rights, and social benefits and harms and so forth.

So, how do you guys suggest we go about such a heavy discussion without resorting to low tactics which is only meant to confuse, obfuscate, and twist words around? Is this an acceptable beginning?
 
the SCOTUS could do no such thing.

I guess you didn't read what I wrote.

To be fair, of course they can. If they feel the rights of the parent's religion, and rights as parents do not out weight benefits to society, and the rights of the baby.

I just happen to agree with you that the courts likely will uphold the First Amendment, and parents' rights if it gets so far. Which I doubt it will.
 
I agree that no law shall single out religious exemptions for something. Either you allow all to do it, or none. Therefore, it should not be banned, and all can do it for whatever reasons they want, or have no reason whatsoever


Does the same apply when I want to amputate the little finger of my baby? I have no particular reason for doing it. The digit is healthy. If not, why not?
 
Does the same apply when I want to amputate the little finger of my baby? I have no particular reason for doing it. The digit is healthy. If not, why not?

Serious? I have made an effort here. The least you could do is meet me halfway.
 
Do I think it violates the baby's body? Personally I don't, if done for religious reasons especially. I still don't consider it to really be a violation of the baby's body in any case. I just don't consider circumcision to be that big a deal.

Circumcision is not a big deal when compared to amputating a limb, true. Amputating a limb is not a big deal when compared to amputating a head. Does that make amputating a limb acceptable?
Clearly not. The 'big dealness' of circumcision is ultimately irrelevant.
As for its not violating a baby's body if done for religious reasons: really? really? if I do it because I think it will look good, it is a violation, but if I do it because Yahweh thinks it will look good it is not a violation?
is this similar to trans-substantiation?


You seem to be amenable to reason: you have been prepared to change your position in the face of reason. We will get there! ;)
 
Serious? I have made an effort here. The least you could do is meet me halfway.

Halfway? Certainly. Amputate the little finger of the left hand ( or right hand if the baby is left-handed) at the first joint.
Why is that different from cutting off a bit of his penis?
 
Does the same apply when I want to amputate the little finger of my baby? I have no particular reason for doing it. The digit is healthy. If not, why not?

Your baby-finger-cutting cult hasn't been around long enough to become established and legitimized.

If the Jewish faith had never been, and someone created it tomorrow and mentioned slicing off the foreskins of infants, the F.B.I. would raid their compound by lunch time. But when it's Bronze Age superstition people are used to it gets a pass.

All of the stuff about pork, shellfish and foreskins were actually smart choices when we were primitives with little concept of hygiene or medicine; it's just that we're not living in mud huts anymore.
 
Circumcision is not a big deal when compared to amputating a limb, true. Amputating a limb is not a big deal when compared to amputating a head. Does that make amputating a limb acceptable?

This is true. Good point.

Clearly not. The 'big dealness' of circumcision is ultimately irrelevant.

I think it can be relevant. Not terribly so, but can have some effect on how you make a judgement call of whether something is acceptable or not. Spanking a kid is "not a big deal" either. It is a far cry from straight-up abuse. Parents are not allowed to punch their child in the face, for example. But they certainly are allowed to spank them.


As for its not violating a baby's body if done for religious reasons: really? really? if I do it because I think it will look good, it is a violation, but if I do it because Yahweh thinks it will look good it is not a violation?
is this similar to trans-substantiation?

Not hardly. That is not the argument I made, either. I didn't explain the caveat fully.

To make it clearer, you have convinced me that circumcision when done for aesthetic purposes, say, is less than moral. I think a case could very easily be made that it is immoral at best. A violation at worst. I lie somewhere in between the two in my own personal opinion. The problem is, it makes this argument rather subjective, does it not? I have a problem with people passing a law for their own subjective reasons. Or stopping a law from being passed for their own subjective reasons as well. Which is why I don't think this argument is very apt.

But if you TRULY believe that it is a violation of the body, then it is truly an argument that should be made in support of a ban. This is where true honesty must come in, and what makes a responsible citizen, responsible. ETA: But I am quite skeptical when some people make the claim that they absolutely believe it is a violation of the body. Perhaps it is unfounded. But it comes from living in a world where people tend to be less than honest about most things. Like greedy bankers, and someone who acts like a friend because they want your job, used car salesmen, and lawyers.

But when it comes to circumcision being done purely for religious reasons, I can accept it for being morally justified, and as a protection under the First Amendment. This carries quite a lot of weight, for it has the Constitution as it's basis for argument.


You seem to be amenable to reason: you have been prepared to change your position in the face of reason. We will get there! ;)

Yes, I can change my position in the face of reason. But you have to remember, it isn't going to be easy, because I am a rather fierce Constitutionalist. I also never consider a new law without some heavy consideration on how it impacts on Constitutional rights, impacts on society, and impacts on individuals.

I take the Constitution to be synonymous to individualism. 200 years of case law to be synonymous to society. Both are of equal weight.
 
Last edited:
Halfway? Certainly. Amputate the little finger of the left hand ( or right hand if the baby is left-handed) at the first joint.
Why is that different from cutting off a bit of his penis?

I rather think the pinky finger is quite a bit more useful than a piece of flesh that I remain unconvinced serves a whole lot of usefulness in opening doors up for living a full and happy life.

In other words: Cutting off the tip of the pinky finger limits the chances of that baby to become a professional baseball player someday. It limits their chances of becoming a fighter pilot. Or a fireman. In turn, this could have some impact on society as well. If there are too many people going around with the tip of their pinky missing, there will be less people available that can do such high-level and important jobs to the best and fullest of their abilities.

Not only that, but it limits the individual from the amount of jobs and careers they can choose. "The pursuit of happiness" factor, if you will.

ETA: Oh, and cutting off the tip of the pinky is not a religious practice. None that I am aware of.
 
Last edited:
Parents are not allowed to punch their child in the face, for example. But they certainly are allowed to spank them.

Parents should not be allowed to hit their children, any more than they should be allowed to cut bits off them.
None of this thread has been about what parents are allowed to do, it has been about what they should not be allowed to do.
 
Last edited:
Do I think it violates the baby's body? Personally I don't, if done for religious reasons especially. I still don't consider it to really be a violation of the baby's body in any case. I just don't consider circumcision to be that big a deal.

Would you extend such thinking to other religious practices?

Here in Australia there are some Indigenous tribes that practise circumcision along with subsincision for socioreligous reasons. Do you think that these practices would not be a violation of a person's body?


As an aside I'd just like to point out that you can more or less discuss this in the context of the US Constitution's First Amendment since you've pretty much ignored all case law that does not support your claim and section 116 of the Australian Constitution is basically the establishment clause of the first amendment just reworded.
 
Parents should not be allowed to hit their children, any more than they should be allowed to cut bits off them.

They're not allowed to spank children everywhere, but more to the point is what parents ought to do, as kerikiwi said.
 
Can someone on the pro-circumcision side please explain why this is relevant? I will concede that when a bill involves a restriction on a religious practice, those on the religious side tend to irrationally oppose it, and the likelihood of the bill passing becomes lowered.

Other than that, why does it matter? It has been demonstrated that legislators do have the power to criminalize activities that are promoted by various religions. It has been demonstrated that the religious nature of an activity does not suffice as legal or moral justification for said action. So what else you got?

From what I understand of how the USA handles religious freedom I think the religious groups affected would argue that simply prohibiting non-medical circumcision is a disproportionate measure. How that would stack up when the USA has laws that prohibits all types of female genital mutilation I don't know. I would also say this is the type of case that you do not want going to the supreme court given the ages of the justices currently serving as they will be of a generation that was brought up to consider the non-circumcised to be abnormal, and we see time and time again in these threads how difficult it is for folk to set that aside (and the cognitive dissonance they use to compartmentalise their approval of male genital mutilation).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom