Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
By what logic? Did you not read the article?

I did. And it repeatedly referred to the "cult-like aspects" of AA with definitively pronouncing it as a cult.

What I am saying is that most groups that form with an express purpose, including the JREF, display cult-like aspects, because without an at least implicitly agreed-upon set of principles those groups ultimately disband.
 
I did. And it repeatedly referred to the "cult-like aspects" of AA without definitively pronouncing it as a cult.
That's your criticism? :p The final paragraph does call it a cult, but goes about it in a most sensitive way. This is because if you call A.A. a cult people lose their minds. It was a smart move to keep that until the end and answer the question in that way if the point was to reach anyone still in the cult...

What I am saying is that most groups that form with an express purpose, including the JREF, display cult-like aspects, because without an at least implicitly agreed-upon set of principles those groups ultimately disband.

That doesn't make any sense. There are accepted standards for what mind control is and what a cult is. That happens to be the site of the world's leading cult expert, there's a lot for you to poke around on there. :)
 
Last edited:
Asked and answered multiple times.

By the way, what is your obsession with fecal matter?

You're the one who believes a turd in the toilet is a higher power.


ETA:Or are you denying that anything can be a higher power?
 
Last edited:
That's your criticism? :p The final paragraph does call it a cult, but goes about it in a most sensitive way. This is because if you call A.A. a cult people lose their minds. It was a smart move to keep that until the end and answer the question in that way if the point was to reach anyone still in the cult...

It says that AA uses some of the methods of a cult, but AA also lacks other aspect of a cult.

That doesn't make any sense. There are accepted standards for what mind control is and what a cult is. That happens to be the site of the world's leading cult expert, there's a lot for you to poke around on there. :)

*yawn*

One thing that AA lacks that cults have is a strong, central leader that members recognize as a leader. If you're going to declare AA cult because it has some cult-like aspects, why not also declare that AA is not a cult because it lacks some cult-like aspects?
 
Asked and answered several times before.

Saying that anything can be your higher power leads you logically to believing in turds in the toilet as higher than you.
 
Last edited:
It says that AA uses some of the methods of a cult, but AA also lacks other aspect of a cult.

This is your opinion, it's not what the article says, which is " Is AA a mind control environment? The answer is yes. AA uses all of the methods of mind control, which are also the methods used by cults."


*yawn*

One thing that AA lacks that cults have is a strong, central leader that members recognize as a leader. If you're going to declare AA cult because it has some cult-like aspects, why not also declare that AA is not a cult because it lacks some cult-like aspects?
What? The entire thing was created by Bill Wilson! He channelled a 15th century monk to help him write the 12 and 12, he stole the cult aspects from another cult called the Oxford Group, he is treated like a reverential figure in the movement when he should be known as the crank he was. Not to mention a bad role model. Heh, it doesn't matter you'll just find something else to nitpick about. The pathological aspects of mind control and manipulation are there. There are countless members of 10, 20, 30 years who will explain to you why it is a cult, how hard it was to leave the group. But like I said in my first post, it's pointless to try and explain the cult designation to a defender, it's only useful for talking about it seriously with others, it's too emotional of a word.
 
Last edited:
Joey, indeed the AA program is identical in nearly every way to a cult - I've been saying so for a very long time. I, however, don't tend to concentrate on that aspect, as I find it unproductive.
What I do concentrate on is the bastardized religious nature of AA, how much of it came from the dangerous Oxford group practices, the very strong evidence that AA simply doesn't work (with a success rate of no more than 5% - that is, a 95% failure rate), and the massive interconnect between AA and the treatment center monopoly, which is making alot of people very rich.
These are the things I typically talk about, in one form or another, even within AA meetings & conferences (as you know, I still attend AA myself).
To simplify my views, I don't really care that AA is a cult - I care that it's ineffective, that it works in collision with gov't entities to promote christianity, and that all the money spent (for instance, at treatment centers) would be far better spent on techniques that actually show results and/or studies to identify what does work. AA and it's associated groups is a massive waste of resources and causes more harm than good.
A link on how well AA fits the definition of a cult http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult.html
 
Joey, indeed the AA program is identical in nearly every way to a cult - I've been saying so for a very long time. I, however, don't tend to concentrate on that aspect, as I find it unproductive.
It can be incredibly counter-productive. But if you don't realize that it is mind control, how are you supposed to deprogram and move on with your life? It is a catch 22, so I think people being silent about it is an even greater risk. But certain people at certain times definitely do not need to hear the facts about it's cult history.
What I do concentrate on is the bastardized religious nature of AA, how much of it came from the dangerous Oxford group practices,
Do you mean the one where they sat silently as a family with pad and paper to write down the thoughts that God is channelling them? Gives a whole new meaning to "improve our conscious contact with God" it's soooo stupid...
the very strong evidence that AA simply doesn't work (with a success rate of no more than 5% - that is, a 95% failure rate), and the massive interconnect between AA and the treatment center monopoly, which is making alot of people very rich.
People just don't get this. I have family in the program, I say "there are alternatives to AA" and despite years of membership they say "I have never heard of such a thing" What? Well it's drilled into your head that it's the only way for so long I guess...
These are the things I typically talk about, in one form or another, even within AA meetings & conferences (as you know, I still attend AA myself).
To simplify my views, I don't really care that AA is a cult - I care that it's ineffective, that it works in collision with gov't entities to promote christianity, and that all the money spent (for instance, at treatment centers) would be far better spent on techniques that actually show results and/or studies to identify what does work. AA and it's associated groups is a massive waste of resources and causes more harm than good.
A link on how well AA fits the definition of a cult http://www.orange-papers.org/orange-cult.html
It is commendable that you are evidently trying to effect change from the inside. Things do get better over time, and the existence of so many internal critics is important. But all too often wee see results like what happened in Toronto this week. So sad, in the story one of the men was crying over it! It just kind of kicked me in the gut... Stay well
 
Asked and answered several times before.

Well, you're half right. It's has been asked several times but it has never been answered. All the answers thus far have demonstrated the ridiculousness of the claim.
 
Sure they are, but being the honest poster you are (snigger), I thought you would be able to find it for them (snort). I have looked and looked and guess what? I can't find it.

They have been pointed out to you on numerous occasions and yet you still can't fing the posts. A newcomer would think you are not being honest. Of course, I'm not a newcomer and so I know you aren't.

Giggling like a school girl isn't helping your case.

Given my efforts, perhaps you would do us all a favour and provide this evidence you lie claim you have. :rolleyes:

Nobody else seems to be having a problem. At some point Alfie, you have to consider that the problem lies with you. I would think that someone claiming to be a professional counsellor would know that but that claim has never been verified although you stated you would provide the evidence at the very beginning of the thread. Your lies are catching up to you.

The truth is,

You wouldn't know the truth if it bit you in your donkey.

Put up or shut up. :)

Read the thread for once.
 
*yawn*

One thing that AA lacks that cults have is a strong, central leader that members recognize as a leader. If you're going to declare AA cult because it has some cult-like aspects, why not also declare that AA is not a cult because it lacks some cult-like aspects?

Wrong. AA has that just as any cult does. AA also has a dead guy as a god figure just like religions/cults do.
 
What part of turd in a toilet is a "higher power" don't you understand?

Then what the hell is your problem?

Just because something can be a "Power greater than oneself" doesn't mean that anyone would pick it as their "Power greater than oneself". As long as what you pick has ability to inspire in you the feelings that you previously felt you lacked, you are free to pick it as your PGTO.

If you can honestly say that a "turd in the toilet" inspires you to better yourself, you can choose it as your PTGO. My suspicion is that you picked a "turd in the toilet" because it is associated with feelings of disgust and revulsion rather than anything that could be remotely considered positive. Therefore, it would be absurd to think that such a thing could inspire anyone to recover. That, however, is not the point so much as the fact that a PTGO allows one to conceive of oneself in a way in which one had previously thought impossible.

In sum, your PTGO can literally be anything that you want it to be. People, though, generally try to pick something that changes their perception of themselves in a positive way. Therefore, objects that are associated with extreme feeling of disgust and revulsion are avoided.
 
Well, you're half right. It's has been asked several times but it has never been answered. All the answers thus far have demonstrated the ridiculousness of the claim.

Except that the answer "Anything can be the 'Power greater than oneself'" has been routinely and deliberately ignored by those asking the original question.
 
As usual on this thread, there's a lot of generalization extrapolated from personal anecdote.

The following post demonstrates the problem with those sorts of arguments, especially when stacked up against Objective Facts:

Is the religiousity of AA a falsifiable proposition?

YES!

What would accomplish that? Evidence of people not praying? How many would it take? And how could we know for sure that they weren't praying? A person whose lips weren't moving might be praying silently, and, conversely, a person might be mouthing words without actually meaning any of it -- is that still praying? If I happen to mention God once or twice immediately after having dropped a hammer on my toe, does that constitute adequate evidence that I am a theist?

Your Honour, I am NOT attempting to convict Dymanic of being a Theist. But I WILL prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he belongs to a Religious Organization known by the name of Alcoholics Anonymous.

How will I do that you ask? The same way I can prove beyond a Reasonable Doubt that many non-praying/praying silently/word-mouthing/God mentioning once or twice (especially after dropping hammers on their toes) people belong to other Religious Organizations such as The Catholic Church, The Nation of Islam, Vedic sects of Tantric Hinduism, The Southern Baptist Church, The Anglican Communion/ The Unitarian Universalists and many others far too numerous to mention.

Your Honour, I cannot rely on the word of individual adherents, as their own personal views vary widely from those who merely attend to demonstrate propriety without actually believing in either the doctrines and/or the Deity of their chosen Religious Organization, to those that Fundamentally believe that every word of their sacred texts must be taken as Literal Truth.

Thus, as with any religious organization, I must rely on the words of their Sacred Texts, and the Historical Record of the Organization, the Biographies of the founders and the texts of the Founders Letters and Ancillary Writings, and Legal Precedence including the upholding of the Second Circuit's decision by the US Supreme Court establishing the the Religiosity of AA.

Your Honour, I have submitted to you numerous briefs over the course of 61 pages of this thread containing this evidence, as has Tinyal and other members of our legal team.

<snip>
Glad to also have confirmation that I have not misrepresented your position with the above analogy:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant's fingerprints are all over the murder weapon, therefore you have no choice but to find him guilty".

Finally your Honour, the opposition attorney has deliberately misrepresented our case using specious analogies, and has deliberately discounted all the relevant evidence.

He claims that all we have are Fingerprints.

Yet as the submitted briefs have shown, our legal team also has DNA evidence, Ancillary Forensic Evidence, the Testimony of the Founders, the Historical Record, and Legal precedence.

GB

ETA: I will seek through the thread for my posts which back up my assertions regarding the evidence. That will be forthcoming if not immediately.
 
Last edited:
You're the one who said anything could be a higher power.

Have I somehow contradicted myself? I said your turd could be your HP (or PGTY) and it can, I just personally don't see how.

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.


In the meantime, have you dropped the pretense that you have evidence that AA "does harm" and that it (AA) says it is "the only way".

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for Rule 0.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom