Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
LOL



It should also be underlined that in the available studies all the interventions appeared to improve at least some of the outcomes considered.

"Improve some of the outcomes" for “all the interventions”, that sounds a lot to me like there is er... some improvement (I assume that means the treatment helps in AA too? Hmm?:rolleyes:)

Good point, given that committing suicide also improves some of the outcomes, it stops you drinking, it must also be an effective treatment and churches aren't religious as they also help atheists.
 
What is your point?
That we need science-based treatment for alcoholism and the money and energy spent on that. End the choke-hold AA has on the industry. It doesn't work, it needs to become common knowledge so that people can focus on an eternally progressive, science-based treatment based on innovations in psychology and biology.

Thanks for playing. :)
This isn't a game Alfie you can't prove to me your program works. You can't have a conversation with me about improving patient outcomes because you're denying the facts about what needs to change and what doesn't work about it. There are so many positive things that you could do within the framework of A.A. and change, I don't imagine it's actually going to disappear.

Plain Language Summary
The available experimental studies did not demonstrate the effectiveness of AA or other 12-step approaches in reducing alcohol use and achieving abstinence compared with other treatments
There are limitations to every meta-analysis, that's not an argument, this is the best we have. Aren't you concerned that there is a potential for increased well-being for patients that science can teach you?
 
Last edited:
That we need science-based treatment for alcoholism and the money and energy spent on that.
What do you think rehab clinics offer, and I'd guess the more expensive and exclusive the more sciency they become. The recovery rates with them aren't good either.

End the choke-hold AA has on the industry. It doesn't work, it needs to become common knowledge so that people can focus on an eternally progressive, science-based treatment based on innovations in psychology and biology.
When will you (or anyone) offer the sciency alternative at no more cost than AA?

There are limitations to every meta-analysis, that's not an argument, this is the best we have. Aren't you concerned that there is a potential for increased well-being for patients that science can teach you?
See comment above.
 
What do you think rehab clinics offer,
"The Rehab Clinics"? Who's that? There are hundreds of private clinics with a multitude of different strategies and flavors, many of them are woo. And private clinics are majority 12-step. Do you have the data on the ratios? I really don't care, one is too many.
and I'd guess the more expensive and exclusive the more sciency they become
:rolleyes: really deep argumentation you're laying on me here. What is this because some clinics are ripoffs this is an argument against anything I have said?
The recovery rates with them aren't good either.
A lot of them are woo. The best success rates use a combination of cognitive behavioural therapy (scientifically verified techniques) and naltrexone etc. There are obviously many clinics with proven rates of success although that is an entirely different question. What are you trying to say that we shouldn't have that conversation because AA is free and already entrenched?
When will you (or anyone) offer the sciency alternative at no more cost than AA?
pffft there are lots of free alternatives to AA. The fact it is free is not an argument for anything. A free, top-notch program is possible, and eventual. My government pays for 12-step treatment centers, 4-6 weeks, we could easily lobby them and take that money if we had a positive meta-analysis. But science progresses one funeral at a time, to be brutal.
 
Last edited:
That we need science-based treatment for alcoholism and the money and energy spent on that.

I agree.

End the choke-hold AA has on the industry.

While I don't agree with your "choke-hold" comment without evidence, who will provide these alternatives?

It doesn't work, it needs to become common knowledge so that people can focus on an eternally progressive, science-based treatment based on innovations in psychology and biology.

It seems to work just as well (or poorly) as anything else on offer. What model would you suggest? What innovations? What evidence do you have?

This isn't a game Alfie you can't prove to me your program works.

I didn't realise that was my job. Interestingly, you can't prove it doesn't.

You can't have a conversation with me about improving patient outcomes because you're denying the facts about what needs to change and what doesn't work about it.

What facts are these?

There are so many positive things that you could do within the framework of A.A. and change, I don't imagine it's actually going to disappear.

Sure.

There are limitations to every meta-analysis, that's not an argument, this is the best we have. Aren't you concerned that there is a potential for increased well-being for patients that science can teach you?

Such as?

You seem to be making arguments against things I have never said.

"The Rehab Clinics"? Who's that? There are hundreds of private clinics with a multitude of different strategies and flavors, many of them are woo. And private clinics are majority 12-step. Do you have the data on the ratios? I really don't care, one is too many.

Do you have any data on this? You seem to spray a lot of opinion here, I don't see any facts.

A lot of them are woo. The best success rates use a combination of cognitive behavioural therapy (scientifically verified techniques) and naltrexone etc.

I might believe this, but where's the evidence?

There are obviously many clinics with proven rates of success although that is an entirely different question.

Again, I can believe this but where is the evidence?

What are you trying to say that we shouldn't have that conversation because AA is free and already entrenched?

No, I think he is saying AA is readily available and forms one of a multitude of services on offer. You cannot place everyone in rehab.

pffft there are lots of free alternatives to AA.

How many? Where and when? How often? Do they work better or worse than AA. Where is the evidence?

The fact it is free is not an argument for anything. A free, top-notch program is possible, and eventual. My government pays for 12-step treatment centers, 4-6 weeks, we could easily lobby them and take that money if we had a positive meta-analysis. But science progresses one funeral at a time, to be brutal.

Exactly, so until you have thse other alternatives what do we use? Until we can place every alcoholic who is contemplating change into a rehab and/or or on naltrexone and/or force them into CBT (which seem to be your ideal answers) what do you suggest?

Perhaps the government has done some homework themselves and found that these 12 step rehabs are somehow as effective as anything else, are the best available, the cheapest, etc?

Like I said, you are making a lot of assumptions about me. You seem to have no idea what I do for a living, what my views are and you are arguing with me directly against points I have never made.
 
Last edited:
"The Rehab Clinics"? Who's that? There are hundreds of private clinics with a multitude of different strategies and flavors, many of them are woo. And private clinics are majority 12-step. Do you have the data on the ratios? I really don't care, one is too many.

:rolleyes: really deep argumentation you're laying on me here. What is this because some clinics are ripoffs this is an argument against anything I have said?

A lot of them are woo. The best success rates use a combination of cognitive behavioural therapy (scientifically verified techniques) and naltrexone etc. There are obviously many clinics with proven rates of success although that is an entirely different question. What are you trying to say that we shouldn't have that conversation because AA is free and already entrenched?

pffft there are lots of free alternatives to AA. The fact it is free is not an argument for anything. A free, top-notch program is possible, and eventual. My government pays for 12-step treatment centers, 4-6 weeks, we could easily lobby them and take that money if we had a positive meta-analysis. But science progresses one funeral at a time, to be brutal.

You are playing defense, when you need to be playing offence. You don't need to respond to trick questions and Sophistry.

There are some people on this thread who prefer this debate to be evidence free. The ambiguity of results based arguments allow them to keep it this way.

There is only one way to demonstrate the Falsehood of their primary claim (that AA isn't religious). Which is to show them their own Religious Documents. They have no response to that except sophistry; ergo, you win the debate (but they will never admit that they have been pwned).

The fact that they will not bring evidence to counter my recent posts just proves my point. They do not have such evidence.

GB
 
Last edited:
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog...because-its-form-cognitive-behavioral-therapy

if we look closely at AA, we see that despite its spiritual underpinnings and focus on working the 12 Steps, it is a very behaviorally oriented process. For example, one of the core recommendations that AA makes is to change people, places, and things. In other words, to change one's routines, repertoires, and actions. Interestingly, this echoes the advice of Dr. Arnold Lazarus (who in 1958 was the first person to introduce the terms "behavior therapy" and "behavior therapist" into the professional literature) who often tells his clients to "do things differently and do different things."

Since it is a central tenet of CBT that thought and action can (and do) influence emotions and even brain chemistry, it is no surprise that changing what we think and how we act can have a powerful impact on how we feel, even to the extent of loosening the grip of powerful addictions.

Even the surrendering to a higher power aspect of AA is firmly rooted in a behavioral soil in that AA members frequently say "pray like everything depends on God, but act like everything depends on you," and "fake it ‘til you make it." Both of these bits of advice closely mirror the cornerstone of CBT, namely that how you act so shall you think and feel. For example, people who conquer fears, phobias, and even obsessive compulsive anxiety, do so by refusing to act afraid despite their fearful feelings and anxious thoughts. Over time, this leads to genuine shifts in thinking and feeling so that they come into alignment with the non-fearful behavior. Hence, people fake it (not being anxious or phobic) until they make it (getting over their fears).
And all free, with a multitude of world-wide locations.
 

Does Alcoholics Anonymous Work Because it's a Form of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?

Dr Lazarus provides no evidence that AA actually works. Therefore his Titular Question is based on a Fallacy.

But his article does highlight why I dislike CBT too. It does not have the Religious Language and Doctrines of AA, but it is still a form of mind control.

GB
 
While I don't agree with your "choke-hold" comment
I know several towns where everything is AA and the government pays for AA and they have forced people into AA with no alternative in places? That's worse than a choke hold... It's about 80-90% 12-step in centers around the world. That's going to be changing.
without evidence, who will provide these alternatives?
The practitioners of science/evidence-based medicine and evolutionary medicine who are taking over modern medicine. It will be the opposite of some dudes making stuff up.
It seems to work just as well (or poorly) as anything else on offer. What model would you suggest? What innovations? What evidence do you have?
I would suggest a comprehensive approach, meaning an organization that applies the best of what we know and can prove while also spearheading the search for knowledge. The recovery movement needn't be fragmented. Every patient should have the opportunity to learn this knowledge and be encouraged to know it, not folk wisdom and memes (cult language - R.Lifton) Take just one example, the remarkable success of naltrexone and tailored talk therapy plus the 2008 result from NIH that taught us it works better on people with a certain gene variant. Screen everyone for that variant and for suitability for that intervention. Everyone. This will be inexpensive soon. Put everyone through standardized care just like any medical condition in a hospital. There are more examples obviously but I only need one good one to show something is drastically wrong and opportunities are being wasted. AA is notoriously anti-naltrexone. As long as they keep brainwashing people with their made up stupidity people with that gene variant aren't going to get the opportunity to have 20 sessions some pills and get their life back, they are going to spend the rest of their life going to meetings. The horror of this to me is just unspeakable. I cannot allow people to brainwash vulnerable victims of mental illness into a lifelong commitment to a faith healing cult when there are greener pastures mere clicks away on the internet.
I didn't realise that was my job. Interestingly, you can't prove it doesn't.
If you promote AA it is. I said it was controlled, you didn't read the study, they controlled against no treatment, yadda yadda, join the revolution while it's young Alfie.
What facts are these?
Just read the study Alfie. I know it's disturbing to you but they controlled against no treatment.
You seem to be making arguments against things I have never said.
If you're defending AA as an organization which I think the world would be much better off if it ceased to exist, I'm arguing against what I perceive as their default position. There are exceptions to every rule in AA, that's been the defenders refuge for years, but it's not about anything but facts now so that's over.
Do you have any data on this? You seem to spray a lot of opinion here, I don't see any facts.
What? You honestly need data on the fact that there are many approaches and private companies that do alcoholism therapy? Or on the fact that 12-step dominates rehab centers?
I might believe this, but where's the evidence?
Again, I can believe this but where is the evidence?
I only need one so centers that offer naltrexone and talk therapy and possibly even screenings for that gene variant. Actually anyone can check themselves for that gene varient using various internet services. It's pretty cheap nowaways and rapidly getting chearper.
No, I think he is saying AA is readily available and forms one of a multitude of services on offer. You cannot place everyone in rehab.
Well it certainly seems to have pissed a lot of people off for no good reason other than to maintain its cult blueprint. Also handed out billions of sentences of bad advice and lies about reality. Also supported anti-psychiatry in a devastating way for a long time and still does in many places. Yes, it has problems that the meetings that are held at the Center For Free Inquiry don't have.
How many? Where and when? How often? Do they work better or worse than AA. Where is the evidence?
Just because there is no other meetings in that small town of 40,000, doesn't win AA any points. There are only Christian churchses in lot of those towns too.

None of the proven science and treatment that you won't learn or receive in AA matters to my main argument, that AA prevents people from accessing that science because it doesn't test itself, it doesn't integrate the best of science, and it resists innovation and science and serves as a conduit for extreme woo. That's the only problem in the first place.

If we take AA claim by claim though, we can show that a great deal of it is wrong or counter to what we know. We can also show it fails to integrate anything modern because it has never changed. (well in a sense the old-timers are scarier)

What about the delusion that you can never drink again. That's up for some people to decide and is undoubtedly true for some. But a lot of people get out of AA and just drink normally after. And thank their lucky stars they got out of a cult. Some people scared the bejesus out of them that they would die, end up in jail or worse.

Exactly, so until you have thse other alternatives what do we use?
You don't get it, we need to first get rid of all the ways AA is objectivly harmful, a massive cult deprogramming is in order.
Until we can place every alcoholic who is contemplating change into a rehab and/or or on naltrexone and/or force them into CBT (which seem to be your ideal answers)
no they are my single, simplistic, argument winning examples of what AA fails to integrate because it is a stupid cult.
what do you suggest?
Pure science-based medicine using all available science and evidence. Few are even trying or able to come close to this right now but it's already too late too many people are aware of everything I am saying.
Perhaps the government has done some homework themselves and found that these 12 step rehabs are somehow as effective as anything else, are the best available, the cheapest, etc?
Then they are idiots because I've shown it doesn't work, is harmful, and antiscience.
Like I said, you are making a lot of assumptions about me.
Like what? I'm arguing against the default positions that are against AA having influence or dominance. You seemed irrationally unwilling to read that study I would have thought you'd be riveted. But of course it says exactly what you don't want it to say. Randomized controlled with no treatment.
You seem to have no idea what I do for a living
I do what should that matter to the conversation anyway?
 
Last edited:
You are playing defense, when you need to be playing offence. You don't need to respond to trick questions and Sophistry.

There are some people on this thread who prefer this debate to be evidence free. The ambiguity of results based arguments allow them to keep it this way.

There is only one way to demonstrate the Falsehood of their primary claim (that AA isn't religious). Which is to show them their own Religious Documents. They have no response to that except sophistry; ergo, you win the debate (but they will never admit that they have been pwned).

The fact that they will not bring evidence to counter my recent posts just proves my point. They do not have such evidence.

GB

I know, I was thinking the exact same thing. Really his post was an attempt to muddy the waters. But I'm just not even trying any more. I've already showed it's a cult, it's harmful and it's getting in the way of the progression of humanity. Everything else is just an example of wasted time. I just feel sorry for the people who go to 3 or 4 meetings a week for the rest of their lives because they are afraid they'll die or they have been brainwashed that it's a good thing. And at the top of the pyramid there's old Bill, seance in the dark, talking to Boniface... hideous. There is an endless list of positive things that could happen to the recovery movement. Hopefully any further conversation can center around the future.
 
Last edited:
I've already showed it's a cult, it's harmful and it's getting in the way of the progression of humanity. ....Hopefully any further conversation can center around the future.
Since you've declared victory, you should start a thread to discuss those future efforts.
 

Quoting Psychology Today with an erroneous citation on Lazarus as coining "behavior therapy" when it was done earlier by Ogden Lindsely at this time:
Lindsley, O. R., & Skinner, B. F. (1954). A method for the experimental analysis of the
behavior of psychotic patients. American Psychologist, 9, 419-420.
Shows you need better sources. AA is nothing like behavior therapy, even if you toss the cognitive BS in it.
 
Last edited:
Quoting Psychology Today with an erroneous citation on Lazarus as coining "behavior therapy" when it was done earlier by Ogden Lindsely at this time:
Lindsley, O. R., & Skinner, B. F. (1954). A method for the experimental analysis of the
behavior of psychotic patients. American Psychologist, 9, 419-420.
Shows you need better sources. AA is nothing like behavior therapy, even if you toss the cognitive BS in it.

Nice Catch. The Headline alone was enough for me to dismiss it as non credible journalism.

Psychology Today as a magazine is the equivalent of USA Today as a newspaper; which is to say they're alright in presenting the news of the day, but it's mostly fluff, and very little research. Even the Discovery Channel is better, and that's not saying much.

However, there is one thing CBT has in common with AA, and that is they are both Behaviour Modification therapies, i.e. Mind Control.

The main difference being that AA has a Religious Behaviour Modification plan (which basically just makes people more religious), and CBT is based on empirical evidence instead of woo.

GB
 
Quoting Psychology Today with an erroneous citation on Lazarus as coining "behavior therapy" when it was done earlier by Ogden Lindsely at this time:
Lindsley, O. R., & Skinner, B. F. (1954). A method for the experimental analysis of the
behavior of psychotic patients. American Psychologist, 9, 419-420.
Shows you need better sources.
Yeah, I don't doubt it; this was just first of many from google.

Thanks.


AA is nothing like behavior therapy, even if you toss the cognitive BS in it.
Nothing like? Rather a strong statement; at least some people disagree.
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.

Generally I don't argue from anecdote, but will sometimes employ them to illustrate a point.

I think your illustration belongs in a museum of Fine Art. :)


GB
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.

Two questions for you:

- How many meetings did you attend?
- Is your ex happy in his sobriety?
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.
I'm so sad to hear more and more of these cases. A six-pack? The reward system got rewired, rewire it back to nature, it's not hard, exercise, nutrition, good works of charity, study some science about psychology and addiction, you'll be fine. You know, basic stuff. Classic story of cult recruiting of a vulnerable person. I know a guy who never let his kids go to christian schools, never set foot in a church, but a few years in A.A. he got up to be saved at some service somewhere. This guy used to be my shining example of how the program can make you stupider than you were before (classic problem of cults, rewiring the mind to belief handicaps critical thinking biology) and recently I find out he's been saved. Well, it's just par for the course that's all I can say.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom