Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Yrreg. Do you realize that everyone but you is writing with conciseness and precision?


Yrreg doesn't realize there is anyone but him. Every conversation he has is between himself and some non-integrated part of his own ego.
 
:D [Where's the :lol: emoticon when I so desperately need it??]
You've GOT to be kidding! Have you read your own posts?

Look, yrreg, if you want to offer a proof of God's existence, then get on with it! You're not going to get a whole lot of "buy in" for your concept, which could apply to all sorts of non-godlike entities, but go ahead anyway and at least we might make some progress.

(And yes, this is my first yrreg thread.)

To be kind to you, we should let you know that what you've said above has been said before.

I mean, you're being reasonable, and not asking for anything impossible or extraordinary.

In fact, in this case, "impossible" would be getting Gerry to respond to your post.

"Extraordinary" would be his response making sense.

Just hang on, and play along when the mood strikes you. It's going to be a long thread. They always are... :p
 
Yrreg doesn't realize there is anyone but him. Every conversation he has is between himself and some non-integrated part of his own ego.
He's trying to convince himself, suppress the voices that tell him his xianity is nonsense.
 
We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.

We? Is there someone sitting next to you right now?


Because otherwise Christian theists would be producing proof, evidence, which you would insist not to be proof, evidence from your part.

You claim that you and other theists have this evidence; but as far as producing any proof that is tangible and convincing enough to remove all doubt? Nope, you haven't done that.

By the way, allow me to request that we just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, as namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Where is the evidence that proves God is the maker of everything? Where does this fundamental concept come from? In a book? What proof exists that seperates this book from fact or fiction?

To make the thread simpler.
Take heed of this advice: No long word salads or attempts to resemble an illiterate English major on your behalf...K?

So, please don't bring in the matter of God being this or that, just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.
Again, where does this fundamental concept derive from?


Gerry
 
Procedure to make you think and then verbalize precisely and concisely.

[...]

I am very glad to tell you that there are good, hard definitions of what constitutes proof sufficient to convince the scientific mind. Namely:

Any falsifiable hypothesis that is demonstrably, repeatedly and reliably supported by experiment.​

For example, one may hypothesize the existence of phlogiston - an element that exists in all things which is annihilated by fire. Then one may experiment by weighing things (wood, coal, Gary Shandling), burning them and weighing the remains. If the remains weigh less, the experiment is consistent with the existence of phlogiston. Phlogiston is scientifically proven to exist.

Then one burns iron. Iron does not lose weight when burned. Iron gains weight when burned. This is inconsistent with our definition of phlogiston. Repeated experiments by numerous people on iron confirm that it gains weight. More careful experiments which weigh both the solid and gaseous products of combustion show that wood gains weight as well. The existence of phlogiston, as defined, is not supported by experimentation. It no longer is scientifically proven.

[...]

Hypothesis: I have a nose on my face.

Test: If I have a nose, I should be able to see it. If I can see it, I have a nose. If I can't see it, I may not have one.

Results: After closing my left eye, I can see the right side of my nose. After closing my right eye, I can see the left side of my nose. By crossing my eyes and looking downward, I can see a nose just before becoming dizzy. By looking in the mirror, I see a nose.

Conclusion: Test evidence shows that I have a nose on my face. Schedule further testing by going out in public and listening for horrified screams.



Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

Now, give 5 concrete examples of what is evidence in not more that 100 words.

And also give 5 examples of what is proof in not more than 100 words.


That procedure will make you think carefully and verbalize precisely and also concisely.

Be systematic, first deal with evidence, and then with proof.


Suppose, you define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe, as I do with the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, for Christians.

When you examine everything in its fundamental concept in relation to the universe, then I guarantee you that you will be in a position to think better and more productively toward the advancement of genuine knowledge in your mind.


Here, I have already given to readers the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, I will give also my fundamental concept of the universe in relation to the universe for everyone who knows what is the universe coming from astrophysicists of the Big Bang theory:
The totality of material existence that started with the Big Bang.​


You also follow me, define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe for atheists. and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe for atheists, both in not more than 20 words.


I like to continue our exchange, you are receptive to serious thinking though emotively rattled, still ideas come forth however confusedly.


You will do atheists a great favor to define evidence and to define proof each in not more than 20 words.

And I can use your definitions as guidelines in formulating my evidence and my proof for the existence of God, defined in fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Recall the Latin axiom in regard to speech, from the speaker as to the listener and vice versa:

Sapienti pauca,​



Yrreg
 
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

Now, give 5 concrete examples of what is evidence in not more that 100 words.

And also give 5 examples of what is proof in not more than 100 words.


That procedure will make you think carefully and verbalize precisely and also concisely.

Be systematic, first deal with evidence, and then with proof.


Suppose, you define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe, as I do with the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, for Christians.

When you examine everything in its fundamental concept in relation to the universe, then I guarantee you that you will be in a position to think better and more productively toward the advancement of genuine knowledge in your mind.


Here, I have already given to readers the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, I will give also my fundamental concept of the universe in relation to the universe for everyone who knows what is the universe coming from astrophysicists of the Big Bang theory:
The totality of material existence that started with the Big Bang.​


You also follow me, define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe for atheists. and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe for atheists, both in not more than 20 words.


I like to continue our exchange, you are receptive to serious thinking though emotively rattled, still ideas come forth however confusedly.


You will do atheists a great favor to define evidence and to define proof each in not more than 20 words.

And I can use your definitions as guidelines in formulating my evidence and my proof for the existence of God, defined in fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Recall the Latin axiom in regard to speech, from the speaker as to the listener and vice versa:

Sapienti pauca,​



Yrreg

Unacceptable. You are yet to establish a valid basis for discussion. As already stated:

I require you to establish a set of guidelines or rules on the following:
  1. what do you define as evidence? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  2. what do you define as proof? Provide examples consistent with your definition
  3. specify the criteria by which any evidence will be rated for relevance and weight. Clearly document these in advance so that any contributors or spectators may impartially apply these criteria and arrive at the same conclusion.
  4. please provide information on your experience, skills, qualifications and knowledge relating to analysing and evaluating data, and synthesising conclusions. Attach examples of your prior work.
  5. Specify in advance the weight of evidence or proof that will empirically establish the proof of the god postulate that you have established, so that any participant or spectator may by inspection of the weight of evidence and proof, establish whether that threshold has been reached.
  6. Describe the process whereby evidence will be assessed as being "for" or "against" your case, noting that one could contrive to later reinterpret proofs to suit one's own preconceptions.
  7. Noting that we all have a real life somewhere, specify the timeframe in which this exercise is proposed to take place.
  8. Specify the roles and responsibilites that will be required to be assigned, for this exercise to be done in the required timeframe.
 
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

Now, give 5 concrete examples of what is evidence in not more that 100 words.

And also give 5 examples of what is proof in not more than 100 words.


That procedure will make you think carefully and verbalize precisely and also concisely.

Be systematic, first deal with evidence, and then with proof.


Suppose, you define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe, and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe, as I do with the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, for Christians.

When you examine everything in its fundamental concept in relation to the universe, then I guarantee you that you will be in a position to think better and more productively toward the advancement of genuine knowledge in your mind.


Here, I have already given to readers the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians, namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, I will give also my fundamental concept of the universe in relation to the universe for everyone who knows what is the universe coming from astrophysicists of the Big Bang theory:
The totality of material existence that started with the Big Bang.​


You also follow me, define the fundamental concept of evidence in relation to the universe for atheists. and also the fundamental concept of proof in relation to the universe for atheists, both in not more than 20 words.


I like to continue our exchange, you are receptive to serious thinking though emotively rattled, still ideas come forth however confusedly.


You will do atheists a great favor to define evidence and to define proof each in not more than 20 words.

And I can use your definitions as guidelines in formulating my evidence and my proof for the existence of God, defined in fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Recall the Latin axiom in regard to speech, from the speaker as to the listener and vice versa:

Sapienti pauca,​



Yrreg

Mister concison manages to convey the instructions for our 240 word assignment in a mere 370 of his own!

edit to add, for the more biblically inclinded: "For a dream cometh through the multitude of business, and a fool's voice is known by multitude of words."
 
Last edited:
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.


Gerry, you're going backwards. I told you that there were many, many different levels of proof and asked you which you preferred. You answered (eventually) that you were interested in proof to a scientific certainty. Now, you have gone back to talking about proof in general.

Do you wish to discuss scientific proof, i.e. the quantum of evidence needed to convince the mind of a scientific fact? Is that the level of proof you wish to set?

I can actually fulfill your assignment (though it seems petty), but YOU must first determine what level of proof you wish to discuss.


I like to continue our exchange, you are receptive to serious thinking though emotively rattled, still ideas come forth however confusedly.


Seriously, do you have a bicameral mind?
 
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Something that makes plain or clear which tends to prove or disprove.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

The act of testing or making trial of anything.

That's it...pretty simple Gerry..So why don't you get this party started?
 
Last edited:
A manifestation of god acting within the universe.

If you want to present evidence of god to an atheist, you need to make a statement like "If god exists then we should observe X happening, whereas if he doesn't exist we should observe Y happening, and when we look around, we find X happening rather than Y, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

What X and Y are depends on you and your conception of what god is and will do. As a purely hypothetical example, somebody might say :

"If god exists then we should observe that sick people become well more often if they are prayed for, whereas if he doesn't exist we should find that prayer makes no difference, and when we look around, we find sick people who are prayed for do get better more often than those who are not prayed for rather than them all getting better at the same rate, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

Only the actual fact is that this doesn't actually happen, and in truth prayer makes no difference at all.

But that would be evidence. Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple.

Eh, I doubt that. What with quantum physics and all. But my side-note would be that prayer has scientific roots and isn't a product of God.
 
Last edited:
Do it this way:

First define in not more than 20 words what is evidence.

Then define in not more than 20 words what is proof.

Now, give 5 concrete examples of what is evidence in not more that 100 words.

And also give 5 examples of what is proof in not more than 100 words.

Go back through all your previous threads, in which you made these same demands of us. These nit-picky requirements to limit the number of words we may use, or the number of examples we may cite.

We've played this game at your behest before, Gerry.

And we always win.

So, if you want to see this from us, just go dig up our previous answers.
You have them. You never use them. It's doubtful you read many of them, if any.

Not playing.
 
Eh, I doubt that. What with quantum physics and all. But my side-note would be that prayer has scientific roots and isn't a product of God.

I agree that prayer isn't a product of god, but of man.

For the rest, I think your side note slipped, fell, and bumped its metaphor on every step on the way down. I look forward to your explanation of the scientific roots of prayer...
:popcorn6
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom