Joey McGee
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2011
- Messages
- 10,307
The one they like to use on the real "suppressive persons" is "You're too smart for your own good" which is a cult meme liberally applied to anyone not towing the party line. This is a common tactic in many cults. Here it's "if you don't listen to us and stop thinking independently you will die, ruin your life or go insane"My personal experience from a multitude of angles is that the concept of "you don't really understand unless you've been there" is used more for excuses for not listening to good, solid advice from (again in this case) non-alcoholics or saying that non-alcoholics can have no constructive or thoughtful criticism or input into AA, either in whole or in part.
IOW, I have seen it used more for dismissing the "other" rather than ignoring that entirely and focusing on emulating successful behaviors, regardless of the source of those behaviors (if that makes sense). That's what I meant by being a barrier to treatment.
It does sound like I'm making this stuff up, doesn't it? It's insane.
This might have started out as decent advice to subject yourself to peer-review and stop acting like a know-it-all but it has mutated far away from that innocent usage, like everything does in cults that start out with good intentions...
"Yes, we were like you - far too smart for our own good." Bill W.