Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
My personal experience from a multitude of angles is that the concept of "you don't really understand unless you've been there" is used more for excuses for not listening to good, solid advice from (again in this case) non-alcoholics or saying that non-alcoholics can have no constructive or thoughtful criticism or input into AA, either in whole or in part.

IOW, I have seen it used more for dismissing the "other" rather than ignoring that entirely and focusing on emulating successful behaviors, regardless of the source of those behaviors (if that makes sense). That's what I meant by being a barrier to treatment.
The one they like to use on the real "suppressive persons" is "You're too smart for your own good" which is a cult meme liberally applied to anyone not towing the party line. This is a common tactic in many cults. Here it's "if you don't listen to us and stop thinking independently you will die, ruin your life or go insane"

It does sound like I'm making this stuff up, doesn't it? It's insane.

This might have started out as decent advice to subject yourself to peer-review and stop acting like a know-it-all but it has mutated far away from that innocent usage, like everything does in cults that start out with good intentions...

"Yes, we were like you - far too smart for our own good." Bill W.
 
The one they like to use on the real "suppressive persons" is "You're too smart for your own good" which is a cult meme liberally applied to anyone not towing the party line. This is a common tactic in many cults. Here it's "if you don't listen to us and stop thinking independently you will die, ruin your life or go insane"

It does sound like I'm making this stuff up, doesn't it? It's insane.

This might have started out as decent advice to subject yourself to peer-review and stop acting like a know-it-all but it has mutated far away from that innocent usage, like everything does in cults that start out with good intentions...

"Yes, we were like you - far too smart for our own good." Bill W.

All I can say is my experience and yours differed.

Whenever I hear the cult thing thrown around in regards to AA, I always think of that Seinfeld episode where George hires the carpet cleaners who are really a cult, then gets miffed when they don't try to indoctrinate him. Maybe I'm George Costanza, and that's why I saw little of this type stuff. They didn't really want me :p
 
I am pointing out the heterogeneity of experiences across AA members, not trying to minimize one persons experience because my experience is different.


Alright, fair enough. You came across to me as saying that if one wasn't in AA, wasn't going regularly to AA, and wasn't active in AA (and I'm very much paraphrasing here so please keep that in mind) then one could not really say much in the way of pertinent or useful criticism. If I misread that, then feel free to correct my understanding.


The whole point is that the "AA experience", insofar as it even makes sense to talk about the or an "AA experience" is extremely diverse and that insisting that AA is religious because the "Primary Texts" use the word "God" or that one person related several anecdotes about bad experiences does appear to take into account the multiple possible experiences that people have with AA.


I think the argument goes beyond 'just because the Big Book says the word God.' We also take into consideration Bill W's vision for the future of his organization and how people have been quite faithful to keeping to that vision for eighty years now. There are sometimes contradictory statements made and not every group closes with the Lord's Prayer; true enough. The point being made is that AA views alcoholism as a spiritual disease which requires a spiritual solution. Without the Higher Power, it ceases to be AA. God as you know Him is the central tenet to this program. For many people in this thread and around the world who go to AA yet do not work the steps or believe in a Higher Power -- more Power to them! But they ain't doin' AA.

And the recent post made about the two groups in Canada which were booted from under the AA umbrella tends to bear this out.



Do you have any evidence that these treatments result in a statistically significantly increased recovery rate?


Yes. I personally have linked to a meta-study something like five or six times in this thread alone after I noticed another poster link it. The webpage was last updated about two years ago, so admittedly, it's not as fresh as I'd like. The last thing I personally recall is AlBell who had said something along the lines of that since this website promoted CBT and CBT ranked very high on the list of effective therapies, then therefore the meta-study was suspect. Nonetheless, no one that I remember seriously had critiqued these studies. Some aren't great, but at least there were some studies done and taken seriously.



That is problematic, not in least because "spiritual" is a poorly defined term.


With regards to AA, we can take Bill W's own definition of spirituality at least and go from there.



Ah, that makes sense.

FWIW, the meetings I went to were not like that at all. There was always someone there to say "we don't play dr. here" whenever someone would try to preach against therapy, medication, and outside avenues to sobriety in general.

I had many members tell me when I was new something along the lines of (paraphrase coming) "Do whatever you have to do to get sober - AA or not - but get sober." That's been my motto even after I stopped going to meetings. I'm not big on offering advice, but that is what I say when asked - try AA, try therapy, try rehab, try the latest cure you found on the internet if you want just try and don't quit.

Sheesh, that last part reads like something from a movie :o


Scriptwriter for Lifetime, are ya? :p




The one they like to use on the real "suppressive persons" is "You're too smart for your own good" which is a cult meme liberally applied to anyone not towing the party line. This is a common tactic in many cults. Here it's "if you don't listen to us and stop thinking independently you will die, ruin your life or go insane"

It does sound like I'm making this stuff up, doesn't it? It's insane.

This might have started out as decent advice to subject yourself to peer-review and stop acting like a know-it-all but it has mutated far away from that innocent usage, like everything does in cults that start out with good intentions...

"Yes, we were like you - far too smart for our own good." Bill W.


The phrase I heard most often was, "your best thinking got you here." Ummm... no.
 
Last edited:
All I can say is my experience and yours differed.
It's been the experience of a lot of people. So many, that it's important to talk about. So, many, that they start websites,blog,write books and articles about it. For some crazy reason the people who dismiss accusations of mind control and cult-like behavior have never looked into the billions of words written on the subject before they dismiss the concerns. I can't speak for the reasons why, but I know it took Paul Haggis 34 years before he even looked into the accusations against Scientology. He hadn't even heard the stuff before he just didn't look. So maybe that's the problem.

Whenever I hear the cult thing thrown around in regards to AA, I always think of that Seinfeld episode where George hires the carpet cleaners who are really a cult, then gets miffed when they don't try to indoctrinate him. Maybe I'm George Costanza, and that's why I saw little of this type stuff. They didn't really want me :p
Heh, that's funny, thanks for mentioning I'll download that for a laugh one day soon.
 
Last edited:
So far, you've told me I haven't a clue, and now this "blows your skirt up" bit of indignity.

I haven't attacked you personally, only your arguments.
Is this really the way you want to conduct your argument? With insults to my intellect and thinly-veiled sexist innuendo? Really? You couldn't stick with "whatever floats your boat," and avoid the tacky comment about my supposed skirts?

I'd suggest you back off from the personal crap, and stick to the argument.

Actually it was you who first tried to insult my intelligence; I simply responded in kind with the "no clue" crack (does the word 'superfluous' help remind you?)
As for sexist, you are kidding aren't you!? That is a term I use almost daily with both men and women in my life, no-one here takes offence. Perhaps you could lighten up a bit yourself. :p

And yet again, the question is: why do people insist that AA is not religious?

I don't. I simply say it can be if you want it to be. You clearly want it to be and that is your prerogative, I choose differently.


It isn't about what people choose, it isn't even about the people within the program, and it isn't about fitting my criteria.

Actually, that is exactly what it is.

Is it, or is it not a religiously oriented program?

It can be if you want it to be.
You keep asking the same question and expect a different result. :rolleyes:

And yet again, that's the people using the program, not the program itself.

Whose program? The suggested program or the one that I choose to adopt?

Evidence?

I do not know of a program that has better than "appaling recovery rates." Do you, or are you just ranting here? There are no good programs that have proven, studied, published success. If you have a link to one I would like to have it. Not arguing here, I would like to have it and pass it on to others.

I have been asking for this stuff for months, and yet ... nothing.

The only point to be addressed here is really not if it works, success or failure rates, how people choose to use AA, or any of that.

The point is whether or not AA is religious in nature. It is my opinion that it is. The Big Book and 12 Steps specifically mention upper-case God throughout. That makes AA a program with a religious bent, influence, overtone, etc.

And that is your opinion. Mine is that things like "suggested", "probably", as "you understand him" etc, allow me to have mine, and it differs from yours.

It has a religious bent, influence, overtone. I would say it is not a religion or a cult or worthless to athiests/agnostics, but that is only my personal anecdote of course.

I can agree with this.

I suppose the oft-said response to that would be something along the lines of, "only another addict can *truly* understand me!"

Now, I do understand there can be some value in that sentiment, but it's really more of a barrier to treatment and health than anything else.

I too can agree with a lot of this, however the "it takes one to know one" adage springs quickly to mind. Doctors, counsellor psychologists say to me quite regularly things like "I don't understand why can't they just stop"? In a way this confirms the saying.

There is some truth in it, but I agree that to make it an excuse for not getting treatment is an excuse, but is another thing altogether. Indeed it fits with the easier softer way thinking that every alcoholic looks for as they tackle their ambivalence and confusion about their problem.

Because, as has been mentionned more than once, it can't be people. So it can't be anything you want.

Probably? :rolleyes:

Er... I don't mean to be picky, but doesn't that kinda disqualify PEOPLE from being higher powers ?

Probably. :)

So... no human power can help you but you can pick a human power as your higher power which will help you ?

Probably.
 
Last edited:
Why I Left AA Stories

Just a smattering of the huge collection of horror stories available to everyone on the internet.

I think it was the third friend who committed alcoholic suicide because he believed his only options were jails, institutions, or death. They all had other options but had accepted the cult doctrine through repetitive brainwashing and the acceptance of the AA alternative reality.

Or, it could have been when my sponsor told me who I could talk to.

Or it could have been being attacked physically by mentally deranged AA members that didn’t like what I was saying.

All that matters now is that I know the truth, AA is dangerous.
I did feel extremely guilty about taking anti depresssants while in AA but luckily my sponser was on meds as well. It was our dirty little secret :)
But it's not on their website says Alfie! So insulting and hurtful...
I was feeling pretty miserable and I decided that I needed to do something else to help myself, and I joined a coed soccer team. I was excited abou this decision and thought my sponsor would be proud so I called her up to tell her and she ended up yelling at me. She said that I had absolutely no business making major decisions without first consulting her, because I cannot trust my own flawed thinking.

I've read and heard waayyy worse stories just locally. Ever heard of the (midtown group)?

But ohh noes! You alarmist zealots persecuting the misunderstood! :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Actually it was you who first tried to insult my intelligence; I simply responded in kind with the "no clue" crack (does the word 'superfluous' help remind you?)

I didn't say you were superfluous, and I never insulted your intelligence.

My exact words were: "Then they [the 12 "suggested" steps] are superfluous. Thank you for the response." Which was not only not directed towards you or your intellect, but was also polite.

You told me I haven't a clue. That's a personal dig at me, and not at all polite.


As for sexist, you are kidding aren't you!? That is a term I use almost daily with both men and women in my life, no-one here takes offence.

We live in different countries, with differing idiom. That phrase is not at all common here, I've never heard it, and it sounds sexist.

Perhaps you could lighten up a bit yourself.

Perhaps you can refrain from telling me how you think I should feel.
 
<snip>

The whole point is that the "AA experience", insofar as it even makes sense to talk about the or an "AA experience" is extremely diverse and that insisting that AA is religious because the "Primary Texts" use the word "God" or that one person related several anecdotes about bad experiences does appear to take into account the multiple possible experiences that people have with AA.

<snip>

This is the same for ALL religious organizations. Every person has their own anecdotal unique experiences. This is meaningless in determining the Religiosity of a particular organization.

The only way to empirically determine the Religiosity of a particular organization is to examine its Sacred Texts and Core Doctrines. AA's Sacred Texts and Core Doctrines are as religious as any other church (a church being a religious organization).

That's the short version.

Let me refer you back to this post for a deeper analysis: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7253716&postcount=3499


GB
 
I didn't say you were superfluous, and I never insulted your intelligence.

Really? I never said you said I was superfluous, but you most certainly endeavoured to insult my intelligence. I give and take a lot in these forums, it's part of the process; but I will rarely have a crack at someone who isn't trying it on with me first. It seems a lot to me like you were.

You also seem to have missed a large chunk of what you did say, as in ....

Apologies. I assumed you knew the definition of "superfluous," or if not, might look it up.

Definition of SUPERFLUOUS

1a : exceeding what is sufficient or necessary : extra
b : not needed : unnecessary


If the 12 steps are "suggested," and not required within the program, then they exceed what is sufficient. They are superfluous.

After all, you know someone who's been in the program for almost 5 decades, and he's never used them.

Funny, though, that AA's usually referred to as a "12-step program."
I'd have thought my meaning would be quite clear.

A lot of that sounds pretty sarcastic and insulting to to me. :rolleyes:

We live in different countries, with differing idiom. That phrase is not at all common here, I've never heard it, and it sounds sexist.

It isn't intended to be, not in the slightest, in no way shape or form was it intended to be sexist. It is a saying.

I am many things, but sexist isn't one of them.

Perhaps you can refrain from telling me how you think I should feel.

Is that a "perhaps" as in obligatory? Is it therefore superfluous? Or is it a "perhaps" like a "suggested", a "possible", something to consider thus making it optional? :)
 
Last edited:
Let's go to an acknowledged source, then, shall we?
How about "Alcoholics Anonymous," also known as "The Big Book."


"If you think you are an atheist, an agnostic, a skeptic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you." (page 181)

"To one who feels he is an atheist or agnostic such an experience seems impossible, but to continue as he is means disaster [...] To be doomed to an alcoholic death or to live on a spiritual basis are not always easy alternatives to face." (page 44)

"But [the newcomer's] face falls when we speak of spiritual matters, especially when we mention God, for we have re-opened a subject which our man thought he had neatly evaded or entirely ignored. We know how he feels. We have shared his honest doubt and prejudice. Some of us have been violently anti-religious." (page 45)

"Lack of power, that was our dilemma. We had to find a power by which we could live, and it had to be a Power greater than ourselves. Obviously. But where and how were we to find this Power? Well, that's exactly what this book is about. Its main object is to enable you to find a Power greater than yourself which will solve your problem.... [That] means, of course, that we are going to talk about God. Here difficulty arises with agnostics." (page 45)


[...]Yeah, first there is no "the program". Each person's program is individual to that person.

While the nature of each person's recovery is individual, I quote what you said to point out that the phrase "the program" is used by AA itself, on its own literature:

"This is A.A. ...an Introduction to the A.A. Recovery Program." --title of pamphlet.

"the A.A. program of recovery" --pgs 5, 17

"the program" pgs 16, 17

Thus, to insist that there is no such thing as "the program" is disingenuous, since A.A. uses the same term I use. In fact, that's where I learned the phrase. I didn't make it up.
 
Last edited:
It isn't intended to be, not in the slightest, in no way shape or form was it intended to be sarcastic and insulting.

I can accept that.
Can you see how I thought it might have been?

If so, I am happy to apologise and leave the sparring out of it.
 
Not everything in life is black and white - in actual fact most things are not. Those who see things as all or nothing often have a number of personal (or even personality) problems.

It is indeed fortunate that most of the worlds great thinkers do not confine themselves to these very limited perspectives.

lmao

So is AA cult-like or what Alfie?
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


The reason I pm'd Alfie is in another thread he stopped responding to me on the same issue, I figured it had happened again so I tried to be nice and apologize for that, to try and engender some rational conversation. But he turned it against me for some reason in this thread trying to make me look like an obsessed idiot.

The reason I freaked out the first time is that I told him a story of how AA doesn't take mental illness seriously and is anti-psychiatry, faith healing. He tried to say that the 12-step people had it right anyway, and this kind of cult woo just drives me absolutely insane.

In this thread some lady told a heartbreaking experience about her husband and Alfie the apologist responded with two really insensitive and weakly apologetic questions to her, which several of us commented was quite rude. If anyone deserves an apology it is that woman.

Alfie is interested in defending the program he loves with all his heart and he doesn't register who gets hurt along the way, and that's pretty much all this thread looks like it's ever going to be.

So the moral of the story is go find the horror stories for yourself if you don't believe me, people are being hurt by the program just like in all cults across the world and we ignore it at their peril.

That's why people wrote books like "AA Horror Stories" (free online) Because at this moment a lot of people are suffering from the indoctrination, and the apologists and accomodationalists have people hypnotized.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So is AA cult-like or what Alfie?

It's your claim mate and I certainly don't agree with it.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


The reason I pm'd Alfie is in another thread he stopped responding to me on the same issue, I figured it had happened again so I tried to be nice and apologize for that, to try and engender some rational conversation. But he turned it against me for some reason in this thread trying to make me look like an obsessed idiot.

If you were apologising, perhaps you should have done so. Far from it being an apology your pm was virtually pleading for me to read your opinions.

Why someone would need to pm me to get an opinion on something they posted is beyond me. And for me to recall another conversation in another thread some months ago is... well, I'd forgotten, as neither you nor the conversation made any impact; it was clearly not important to me.

The reason I freaked out the first time is that I told him a story of how AA doesn't take mental illness seriously and is anti-psychiatry, faith healing. He tried to say that the 12-step people had it right anyway, and this kind of cult woo just drives me absolutely insane.

Evidence?
Freaked out is an interesting term too. it sounds like domething a zealot woulld do.

In this thread some lady told a heartbreaking experience about her husband and Alfie the apologist responded with two really insensitive and weakly apologetic questions to her, which several of us commented was quite rude. If anyone deserves an apology it is that woman.

I do not believe I was rude to Nanny Ogg at all.

Alfie is interested in defending the program he loves with all his heart and he doesn't register who gets hurt along the way, and that's pretty much all this thread looks like it's ever going to be.

In your opinion. And you would be wrong.
What is wrong and hurtful is to blame AA for alcoholics who do not get better. Show me some other studies that show better results, less suicides etc etc. No program works with any degree of certainty - there is no foolproof cure and to suggest there is one is utterly dishonest. To suggest nothing works is also utterly dishonest. Different strokes and all that.

So the moral of the story is go find the horror stories for yourself if you don't believe me, people are being hurt by the program just like in all cults across the world and we ignore it at their peril.

Yawn.
Then go and find the millions of members who have got well and see what they think. 75 odd years and thousands and thousands of meetings worldwide suggests some success.

Because at this moment a lot of people are suffering from the indoctrination, and the apologists and accomodationalists have people hypnotized.

Actually people are suffering from their alcoholism.
AA didn't work for them and they had a bad experience. I do not for a second think that everyone in AA is pure of heart, some aren't. Interestingly that is true in any cross section of the population. Believe it or not, that was not AA that caused harm but other human beings. Perhaps you would blame the school for schoolyard bullies who break the school rules, the company for a bossy employer going against HR. These are human beings breaking the rules, not the company.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
lmao

So is AA cult-like or what Alfie?
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed off topic content


The reason I pm'd Alfie is in another thread he stopped responding to me on the same issue, I figured it had happened again so I tried to be nice and apologize for that, to try and engender some rational conversation. But he turned it against me for some reason in this thread trying to make me look like an obsessed idiot.

The reason I freaked out the first time is that I told him a story of how AA doesn't take mental illness seriously and is anti-psychiatry, faith healing. He tried to say that the 12-step people had it right anyway, and this kind of cult woo just drives me absolutely insane.

In this thread some lady told a heartbreaking experience about her husband and Alfie the apologist responded with two really insensitive and weakly apologetic questions to her, which several of us commented was quite rude. If anyone deserves an apology it is that woman.
Alfie is interested in defending the program he loves with all his heart and he doesn't register who gets hurt along the way, and that's pretty much all this thread looks like it's ever going to be.

So the moral of the story is go find the horror stories for yourself if you don't believe me, people are being hurt by the program just like in all cults across the world and we ignore it at their peril.

That's why people wrote books like "AA Horror Stories" (free online) Because at this moment a lot of people are suffering from the indoctrination, and the apologists and accomodationalists have people hypnotized.

1)
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed response to previously moderated content


2) That was a really appalling moment on that certain poster's part. It reeked of some of the worst AA zealotry I have ever seen, and was particularly nasty. Even Al Bell, who usually drops by to support that certain poster, seems to have disappeared.

AA really does a number on people, and that's fine if one is religiously inclined to begin with. In fact it may actually be much more helpful to Abrahamic Monotheists than it would be for others. Dick B, an AA historian and a Christian, says as much. I actually agree with most of what Dick B says because his historical analysis is right on the money.

He is far more credible than any "atheist" or "agnostic" AA Apologist could ever be, because his history is solid and he is honest.


GB
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So your so called "weazel words" are an attempt by our writer to not exclude anything; not perfect, but a fair job in my opinion.

Wrong.

They're an attempt to silence criticism by appearing reasonable. Unfortunately for them, if we take "probably" into account, then the whole "higher power" bit is irrelevant.

It's like saying:

1. No human power can help you.
2. Speak to God.

And after someone points out that it's religious, etc. as we've been doing here, they amend it to:

1. Probably no human power that you know of can, in all likelihood, help you most of the time, and we're not even sure about that.
2. Speak to God as you understand him. But it could be a rock.

As if no one understands that the added words don't change a thing.
 
You aren't on ignore, I am just choosing to ignore your nonsense.

I will do so again, however your post above is largely utter lies and I will not allow to pass unchallenged.

Why someone would need to pm me to get an opinion on something they posted is beyond me. And for me to recall another conversation in another thread some months ago is... well, I'd forgotten as neither you nor the conversation made no impact on my memory; it was clearly not important to me.

If you were apologising, perhaps you should have done so. Far from it being an apology your pm was virtually pleading for me to read your opinions.

Here's what I wrote Alfie

what do you honestly think about my post. privacy assured, just interested in rational debate.

I know i lose my **** sometimes, and I'm sorry for that earlier thread.

So to me, that's just trying to be nice. And the fact you forgot a conversation that you contributed thousands of words to isn't surprising to me seeing as it was about something you seem rather willing to forget/ignore.
 
Edited by kmortis: 
Removed previously moderated content and response to same


2) That was a really appalling moment on that certain poster's part. It reeked of some of the worst AA zealotry I have ever seen, and was particularly nasty. Even Al Bell, who usually drops by to support that certain poster, seems to have disappeared.
I rarely get angry at things I see posted on JREF but that seriously ticked me off.

AA really does a number on people, and that's fine if one is religiously inclined to begin with. In fact it may actually be much more helpful to Abrahamic Monotheists than it would be for others. Dick B, an AA historian and a Christian, says as much. I actually agree with most of what Dick B says because his historical analysis is right on the money.

He is far more credible than any "atheist" or "agnostic" AA Apologist could ever be, because his history is solid and he is honest.

GB
I agree with this perspective in many ways, but let them advertise as such. That woman lost her husband to these people, and a guy I knew that was secular and anti-religion his entire life was basically indoctrinated right into Christianity in a matter of years, eyes completely glazed over now.

I realized recently that the religion issue is almost a red herring. If it was a benign, beneficent, truly free religion, no one would care, we wouldn't need a giant thread detailing the problems. It does qualify as a destructive cult.

That said I still have several family in the program and I'm not exactly trying to rescue them. I explained the cult-aspects and dangers and they agreed. They no longer use AA-speak when talking to me about everyday issues because they know how silly that is. They know a lot more about psychology than they used to, they know they can learn more about it and benefit from it instead of trying to get all of their answers through the program (and talking to me about ALL of their problems in AA speak) They know more about the anti-medication, predation, mind control, etc issues that are common in AA., I think they are better for that. What more can I ask for?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom