Joey McGee
Banned
- Joined
- Feb 17, 2011
- Messages
- 10,307
No, this is completely backwards, if you go back, I made all of those points before this part of the thread even started. And just because you don't click on the links in my posts, doesn't mean I don't provide evidence.Indeed it is, except I have been throwing these arguments at you, not you at me. You have nothing, nor remotely proved anything.
Your second final post to me Alfie?I'll tell you what, after this post - which will be my final to you I will not re-engage with you until you provide to me two things. You can accept the terms or not, I really don't care:
Where have you been Alfie? I have posted this link a number of times, it reflects my thoughts on why I call AA a cult. It's not my fault you don't click on links. It is a destructice, freedom stealing environment that uses deceptive techniques and provides an environment for predators by allowing for mind control. And a whole lot of other things. I could go on and on about it for thousands of words, or you can just read who I agree with. I'm saying these things happen more often in AA than other groups because of it's structure, and the evidence supports that, unless you put your head in the sand.1/. Define cult.
Explain what constitutes a cult and what does not. Where AAs similarities lie but also where there are differences.
This would be a move away from your black and white thinking and might help.
Actually I have never said the words five percent. I've pointed to the Cochrane review, and about a dozen sources on AA horror stories and professional opinions. Have you ever realized why the Cochrane authors said that people should be told there is no evidence for effectiveness? Because people are being let down. It's immoral. If you say the program works you are saying an embarrassing lie that hurts people.2/. Show me studies of what other treatments there are and there success rates. You keep spouting about 5% and all, but what are the success rates for others?
Showing me evidence that it's called a self-help group doesn't change the fact that it's a format you can test scientifically, which is medical advice. If they are giving advice and counselling people on a medical condition, it's not just a "self-help" group?Sure it is.
The most popular type of self-help group is based on the Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), founded in 1935.
http://www.minddisorders.com/Py-Z/Self-help-groups.html
Like CBT? Like optimal thinking?
Sound sinister doesn't it?![]()

I don't claim to be able to help people with alcoholism.I will if you will.
Who cares what you've seen? The experiences of thousands of people is what I'm pointing to. Testimonies of "What I saw in AA" nature that are bloody everywhere on the internet saying all of the same things as me.I agree with you; that sort of thing really shouldn't happen. I'm sure it does, I have seen it too but not quite to the level in your hand-waving example.
Like Why I left AA
So obviously there are different meetings all over the world and some are worse than others. I never disputed this at all, I'm just pointing to problems, while you're defending your idealized version of AA, so this isn't even an argument anymore.
I have posted links to an entire free online book on AA horror stories that talk about how AA and the program itself leads to these problems. These problems start with the program and it's memetic nature and must be dealt with. Taken individually the frequency and commonality of these events paint a clear picture of a problem of pathologies in the AA system. You are the one handwaving the reality away by demanding I meet your standard of evidence which are denier standards. You don't even click on links to scientific studies and read them before criticizing them. Who's the handwaver. You tried to sell me a story that the Cochrane review used too small of a sample to be worth anything. Who is handwaving now.
That's absolutely crap. Bill W invented 13th stepping, this is his cult, and one day you're going to see it, if you just look.However that is not what "the program" or AA is supposed to be about. Neither is 13 step work etc. When these things happen it is because of individuals, not the fellowship.
Quote me making a black and white statement then Alfie, this is your straw man after all.But once again, you would tar all with the same brush. Black and white, all or nothing. I'm starting to think this is a problem for you.
Again, just because you don't click on my links isn't a point against me. This is in reference to me saying AA has a lot of anti-psychiatry, the fact you are disputing this is and saying I have no evidence is absolutely pathetic. It's just common knowledge that you are trying to handwave away by dismissing the way I give evidence for it. Your best is that AA has changed and the history is not the past, well great, don't be a jerk and try and malign me for pointing out the facts just to apologize and protect for your beloved group today.Got it: You have nothing.
What the hell are you talking about. What do you want, a scientific study on anti-medication beliefs in AA? Sorry, I don't have or need one. You'll have to check out my links and ask around and ask the old-timers about the history of those battles, read the books on AA, books.google.com will be fine, it's just a stupid fallacy saying I have no study. Handwaving to the core. If I just say that, that's fine, if I say it's common knowledge, and point to a tv show talking about it, that's a plus. To you, that's not evidence, that's not good enough, that's not something that's worth investigating further. I have posted several stories from people saying they spoke out about it at meetings because they felt pressured to give it up. So, they fact you are apologizing for that has now crossed the line into unacceptable. It happens, deal with it.Is this a meaure of the science you keep mentioning? LOL.![]()
Oh I don't think you meant that, I think you're overapologizing for the cult, but it's like, what, can't you just leave it at that? How can you even question that it's just plain a bad thing?Then you are so very very wrong it is not funny.
I understand that you and some people feel this way, I just think some people are jerks and abuse it or don't know what they are doing in the first place. Like the people who think they are counsellors after mastering AA-speak and getting a cheap piece of paper from the local community college. Seems like just going to a real college would prevent that.Challenging and questioning are also completely different tools at the disposal of the therapist. To conflate or confude them proves your lack of understanding.
Challenging is absolutely fundamental to almost any counselling session. Sometimes one needs to be cruel to be kind as well (not always).
Offering suggestions and providing evidence seems more interesting. Win-win seems more conducive to deprogramming and freedom. I'm very big on that whole mental freedom thing, getting people think rationally on the evidence so they can take care of themselves and not need a "program"
lol no you just invented a caricature of what I think you do for a living so you can invent a way to say something that will perhaps portray me as stupid. A repeating event in this thread it's like your old standby. It's just attacking the person's "ego" which is the classic conditioning of AA.But I repeat, I am counselling no-one here, I am not being paid, and I don't ever just give lip service.
Clients come to me for their problems; my job (in part) is to assist them in finding solutions or to advance their progress.
If that is the extent of your thoughts around what counsellors do, then I suggest you do a bit more research yourself.
I mean it, every time I talk to people in AA they attack my "ego". I'm just "too good" for you, or I just am obsessed with stupid things that don't matter because I need attention or I'm whining or no one helped me and I have resentments. It's utterly disgusting crap. They love to beat you down so they can build you up. Group of drunks...
Your nauseating pseudoargumentation is what prevents me from making the effortIn other words, you can prove nothing and your claims are ridiculous.
Got it.
By the way, I'd have thought it pretty easy to prove the sky is blue.![]()
Last edited: