Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not confirmation bias, Al.

Look, if an actual social scientist began a study on these matters, the evidence for the study would be individual anecdotes, gathered, complied, and analyzed.

This is the data that goes into making the evidence.
 
As I see it based on what you've posted, your bad experiences that you blame on AA, would make it difficult for you to accept as 'evidence' any comments favorable to AA, but have no trouble accepting detractors anecdotes as 'evidence'.

And here of course the detractors volume of posts are far outweighing others' views.
 
As I see it based on what you've posted, your bad experiences that you blame on AA, would make it difficult for you to accept as 'evidence' any comments favorable to AA, but have no trouble accepting detractors anecdotes as 'evidence'.

And here of course the detractors volume of posts are far outweighing others' views.

I'm really only concerned with the religious question, which has been answered to my satisfaction. AA is a religiously oriented program. Period.

The rest is window dressing. The derails and side discussions really aren't pertinent. But the constant name-calling and claims of "dishonesty" are unfair and inaccurate.

I blame AA for its religious aspects that helped enable my abuser to keep on abusing. God is not accountable to anyone! As long as my abuser could fall back on such notions as, "My higher power isn't helping me yet; that's not my fault" or "you can't blame me for hitting you until you bleed, I'm powerless over alcohol," then he was being enabled by AA to continue.

I grant there are many whom it has helped.
That it helps a certain, undetermined number of people doesn't mean it never harms anyone.

By the way, that I have a certain attitude about it doesn't negate my argument. That's a fallacy, Al.
 
Last edited:
Joey, regarding AA and psychiatry, I wonder if you're familiar with a pamphlet that Bill Wilson wrote called "Let's Be Friendly With Our Friends"? Wilson discusses how, while AA members might be reject the mental health field (among other institutions), it's important to stay on good terms with these outside entities and educate them in AA, because they can provide the enormous amount of money and greater -- legitimizing -- outreach to funnel people into AA than individual AA members can. Wilson acknowledges to readers that these outfits (psychiatry, medical science, churches) are pretty useless as far as actually helping alcoholics, but the point of this tract is to encourage members to see these institutions as a resource for spreading the AA message.

There are some interesting quotes in there, and a little bit of the history of Marty Mann and Jellinek and how they turned a spiritual disease into a legitimate chronic illness.

http://www.aa.org/pdf/products/p-34_letsbefriendlywith.pdf
 
Joey's not been anymore dishonest than I have, which is to say, not at all.

Stop these personal attacks, please, both of you. I'd hate to see this thread tossed, or even moderated, but I've no problem asking for the moderation if I have to.

I agree, but Alfie has a point, Joey's making many assertions without evidence.

The cult comparasions are mean and baseless.
 
I agree, but Alfie has a point, Joey's making many assertions without evidence.

The cult comparasions are mean and baseless.

Not if that's truly his opinion. We're allowed to have opinions, and AA isn't a person, so its feelings aren't being hurt by his being "mean." :)

If AA members find his cult statements to be offensive, I'd wonder why they're bothering to take someone's opinion so close to heart, if they know better for themselves? blow it off, and keep on track with the more rational argumentation.

Joey's got a right to his opinion, Y'all got a right to disagree with it.
 
If they are being disruptive to the meeting they would (probably) be guided out for a quiet discussion outside, but that has happened with sober people too.

I have seen drunk people in meetings many times: "the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".

Stubby = beer.
375ml. 4.9% alcohol/vol

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=701&pictureid=4615[/qimg]



I think this would be a great idea.

Thanks!
 
Not if that's truly his opinion. We're allowed to have opinions, and AA isn't a person, so its feelings aren't being hurt by his being "mean." :)

If AA members find his cult statements to be offensive, I'd wonder why they're bothering to take someone's opinion so close to heart, if they know better for themselves? blow it off, and keep on track with the more rational argumentation.

Joey's got a right to his opinion, Y'all got a right to disagree with it.

I guess, but as a member of A.A. it comes across as an ad hom attack.

Also Joey should take your advice as well, he might interpret Alfie's remarks as attacks where I see them as rational arguments.

Alfie has his right to an opinion and you can all feel free to disagree with him. :)
 
Last edited:
I agree, but Alfie has a point, Joey's making many assertions without evidence.
What do you want? Me to invent you a time machine so you can go back and see it first hand? Did you read that pamphlet? Bill apologizes for it himself.

"Now this may seem to be a confession of the sins of AA and it some part it is. It is also a confession that, at one time or another, I have myself held many of these often short-sighted views and prejudices. But I do make haste to to add that what I've just said applies more to A.A.'s past than present"

Wow. Still saying the same apologies over 50 years later... Whatever they tried to do to prevent anti-psychiatry, it failed, because the faith healing nature and their belief was too strong. It took on a life of it's own. They believed in the program too much to "neuter" it by making it a responsible and accountable to science. Like Bill W said "we have little time for biochemists"

The cult comparasions are mean and baseless.
What's wrong with my evidence for the XXth time?
 
I'm really only concerned with the religious question, which has been answered to my satisfaction. AA is a religiously oriented program. Period.
It is for those who want it to be. Otherwise, no. Period.

The rest is window dressing. The derails and side discussions really aren't pertinent. But the constant name-calling and claims of "dishonesty" are unfair and inaccurate.
Adds to the lulz though.

I blame AA for its religious aspects that helped enable my abuser to keep on abusing. God is not accountable to anyone! As long as my abuser could fall back on such notions as, "My higher power isn't helping me yet; that's not my fault" or "you can't blame me for hitting you until you bleed, I'm powerless over alcohol," then he was being enabled by AA to continue.
And I blame you for blaming AA for your problems rather than blaming an alcoholic husband.

I grant there are many whom it has helped.
That it helps a certain, undetermined number of people doesn't mean it never harms anyone.
Perhaps. On balance the harm provided by drinking alcoholics so far outweighs damage caused by AA makes it a laughable comparison.

By the way, that I have a certain attitude about it doesn't negate my argument. That's a fallacy, Al.
What argument? AA has a religious orientation. Period. ???

You are of course entitled to your opinion, but it remains just that, opinion.
 
Joey, regarding AA and psychiatry, I wonder if you're familiar with a pamphlet that Bill Wilson wrote called "Let's Be Friendly With Our Friends"? Wilson discusses how, while AA members might be reject the mental health field (among other institutions), it's important to stay on good terms with these outside entities and educate them in AA, because they can provide the enormous amount of money and greater -- legitimizing -- outreach to funnel people into AA than individual AA members can. Wilson acknowledges to readers that these outfits (psychiatry, medical science, churches) are pretty useless as far as actually helping alcoholics, but the point of this tract is to encourage members to see these institutions as a resource for spreading the AA message.

There are some interesting quotes in there, and a little bit of the history of Marty Mann and Jellinek and how they turned a spiritual disease into a legitimate chronic illness.

http://www.aa.org/pdf/products/p-34_letsbefriendlywith.pdf

That really is some amazing material, thank you.

I liked this part, enjoy friends! It's a secured file, I had to type it out.

Later in 1937, the renowned physiologist Dr. Anton Carlson and a group of interested scientists formed a subsidiary body called the Research Council on Problems of Alcohol. This was to be a more inclusive effort. Some of us early New York A.A.'s went to their meetings-- sometimes to cheer and sometimes, I must confess, to jeer. (A.A. you see, then thought it had a monopoly on the drunk fixing business!

There are a lot of strange-sounding statements in there. I mean everyone knows Bill couldn't have been completely against psychiatry, he was all about giving alcoholics LSD at one point ;) The point is what the movement has lead to, and still leads to today, despite the best efforts of people over the years. Simple, the cult memetics are stronger than the people inside of the organization.
 
Last edited:
Joey, I think what's also significant about that is that Wilson was agreeing that these institutions are useless for alcoholics, but that they can and should be co-opted. He is not saying that psychiatry or medical science should be respected for any reason, and validates his member's rejection... He just finds it short sighted for people not to recognize the opportunity that these institutions present for furthering the AA message, as they can provide the resources, legitimization, and big piles of cash. It's incredibly cynical and opportunistic.
 
... the opportunity that these institutions present for furthering the AA message, as they can provide the resources, legitimization, and big piles of cash. It's incredibly cynical and opportunistic.
They can? Are they?

What resources? What legitimization? How much cash? Who, where, and when?
 
AlBell,

The courts, doctors, and people in the mental health fields routinely shunt people into AA or 12 Step treatment facilities (which then use AA as aftercare). How do you think that happened? A huge industry has grown up around AA (which serves as the poor, innocent, benevolent, completely unaffiliated revolving door of this relap$e factory). Having doctors, psychiatrists, judges, teachers, media and cultural icons promoting AA has definitely legitimized it. AA has pamphlets directed toward all kinds of professional people -- courts, media, clergy, doctors -- "educating" them about alcoholism, and urging them to send people to AA. This is an effort.

Do you seriously not see that Marty Mann left AA, releasing herself from the traditions, in order to devote herself to turning a "spiritual disease" into a legitimate one? Her efforts and wealth -- as outlined by Wilson in this pamphlet -- led to the "science" behind the bogus disease model, and led to the AMA's official declaration.
 
It sounded like the same old, Just Say No, blame the victim crap that has not worked ever.

You see, I don't care if you enjoy AA bashing, there's plenty of that in this thread. Constructive solutions would be better IMO, but no you don't have to have any. But it seemed like you went one step further and stated that there really isn't much of a problem with alchol and drug addicition, really. Just quit.

Help me out, if I misunderstand you.

If you are addicted to alcohol or anything else, you aren't a victim. You did it to yourself. It's your fault. Just as there's no sobriety god waiting for you to start going to meetings so he/she/it can remove your addiction, there's no boogie man lying in wait imposing addiction on you or anyone else. You did it to yourself.

And, yes, just quit. If you can't do it on your own, get some help. Real help, not AA religious faith healing. It's not my job to vet the programs or drug treatments for you.
 
If you are addicted to alcohol or anything else, you aren't a victim. You did it to yourself. It's your fault. Just as there's no sobriety god waiting for you to start going to meetings so he/she/it can remove your addiction, there's no boogie man lying in wait imposing addiction on you or anyone else. You did it to yourself.

And, yes, just quit. If you can't do it on your own, get some help. Real help, not AA religious faith healing. It's not my job to vet the programs or drug treatments for you.


:bigclap
 
...
It's not my job to vet the programs or drug treatments for you.

Second time you've said that, and I still don't know why. I'm not asking you to do anything for me, brother. Trust me on that one.

I think that it is easy to criticize, and hard to offer constructive solutions. Easier than both is denying there is a problem. I think you've chosen that path, but I could be wrong of course.

I do like the simplicity of your philosophy though.

If you are addicted to alcohol or anything else, you aren't a victim. You did it to yourself. It's your fault. Just as there's no sobriety god waiting for you to start going to meetings so he/she/it can remove your addiction, there's no boogie man lying in wait imposing addiction on you or anyone else. You did it to yourself.

I think I'll use it for:

Fat people - Just stop eating. You did this to yourself.
Poor people - Just get a job! You did this to yourself.
Homeless people - Get a House! And a job! You did this to yourself.

(I had to throw in a few things you could yell strawman about :D)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom