I have already done that once. Do you really want me to continue the humilation. I really am starting to think there is a problem with you.
See? I ask you to quote me, back up all the crap and rhetoric you say just because I'm a big meanie who doesn't worship your AA masters, and you only have more rheroric...
You said "anti-psych" on more than one occasion and I have proven that already.
You have no idea what you're talking about. Just give up your pointless attacks.
If your nebulous "they" means AA, you now need to prove that AA is anti-medication today, which you can't do.
Alfie still doesn't understand the difference between a general tendency and memetic organism and an official position in an organization? Whatever I tried to educate him. Anyone can go find stories of people still being told this in meetings, I have quoted several recent ones. It's gotten a lot better over the last 15 years I have said this
repeatedly. But only after a lot of personal battles inside the program..
If you mean some undefined small number of members, I will concede the point. Who is "they" exactly?
Aplologetics. Answer my question. (4th, 5th time you let it go unanswered?) Why is it impossible to discipline sponsers and groups who are giving anti-psychiatry advice today? Why is it "not possible" in your eyes?
You introduced that word only after I proved you to be a liar.
Quote it, prove it, you make this up because you're a sore loser, just like when I made fun of you for laughing at a wikipedia source... and when you tried to say my study had a small sample... lol
Bill doesn't say that here...
or here...
or here...
Really?
It doesn't read quite that way to me. Which bit says that exactly. Where does Bill say "AA started out as anti-psychiatry", which is what you said he said.
No, you just don't understand evidence, other people probably do, if someone else, doesn't clearly see that's what Bill is saying, I'll respond. But to you? lol I'm sick of explaining things to you that other people plainly see.
Now this was written in 1958 I think, and AA was 20 years old or so. We have had now another 50 plus years and AA is over 75 years old; you are clutching at straws if you think this proves diddly squat
It doesn't prove your ridiculous straw man that it's on their website, no...
when we consider that you also said:
You are furiously backpedalling again. There is no past tense in this statement, yet you would have us believe this has been your only point.
I think you are quite possibly the most dishonest poster I have ever come across.
Yeah, barely making some sense finally and quoting me actually, great!. You have misunderstood I said in
that post "told him a story about how AA doesnt't take mental illness seriously" I was speaking offhand, in general I'd already clarified by that point what I my position was, so you don't get to go back and cherry pick an offhand statement to straw man me! They have a
tendency and the story I was explaining was
textbook, as in what the patient needs is some spiritual experience, when they really needed to go to the doctor, because the reason they were acting out was because they were in denial of their alcoholism, and you have to hit rock bottom. No, the patient needed to be educated about their real condition, that was my story, and you suggested that maybe the AA people were right! Which is also classic AA crap, suggesting it was "resentments" making me think that version of the story! So whatever, if that makes me a liar, call me pinochio.
Correct, a typo, my bad
So is CBT quackery (or whatever it was you said)?
You still don't make any sense.
I'm not the most dishonest poster, I'm the person most openly disdainful of AA you've come across maybe, the only person willing to talk about midtown group and all of that horrible crap that needs to be talked about that you'd rather call a "few bad apples" or whatever.