Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do chips contain a mind altering addictive substance?

That comparison wasn't very good, but you know that.

Of course they do. Salt, fat, etc. Chips contain substances that make my brain go "ooh, good !" And anything that makes you go "ooh, good !" can be addictive. There's a reason why I can't seem to stop.

Rather than tell me what you think I know, why don't you answer my point ?

Speaking of obtuse, what about "powerless over alcohol" do you not understand?

Nothing. But if you're powerless against alcohol, then you can never be the person who solves your drinking problem. What part of that don't you understand ?

Nevermind, you compared the ingestion of potato of chips to the consumption of alcohol so I see where the problem is.

Yes, I must be a complete idiot. Why don't you explain all this to me in a way a complete idiot can understand ?
 
Actually it's not.
While I can see how the word powerlessness might cause some confusion, once one moves into the steps they will realise that this powerlessness is simply admitting total defeat.
For too long the alcoholic fought to control their (dare I say it) disease. They tries many time to control it, tried toi stop, made gazzillions of promises etc only to pick itup again.

It's a bit like the average punter taking on a prizefighter; they will never win, they will never beat him. Yet time and again they get back in the ring thinking they can try again. They are powerless to do anything but admit defeat and walk away.

That is the meaning of powerlessness. Rather than read the one sentence on the wall of a meeting, I would recommend p[eople have a look at the step in it's entirety to understand what the line actually means.

So in other worlds "powerless" doesn't really mean what it's supposed to mean. You're powerless but not really. You need a higher power but not really.

How long are you going to twist and swerve like this, apologising for things that are crystal clear ?
 
Yes we know, by your definition Weight Watchers, Girl Guides and Jenny's weekly aerobics class are all religious too. :rolleyes:

You're a little late to the party Jack, this has been discussed ad nauseam, I'm not willing to ride that Merry-Go-Round again, maybe you can find another sadist who will, I doubt it though.

As soon as Girl Guides and Jenny's aerobic class start turning their lives over to some god, relying on Him to fix their weight gain and cookie sales; pray to Him; confess their sins to each and each other; and start recruiting other members like a bunch of Moonies at the airport; I'll classify them as a religion, too.

Also...

I think you're under the impression that I'm here trying to debate you. That would be wrong. I don't argue with people about their religion, because it's pointless. I'm here on a dare, to see how long I can subject myself to the delusion and nutbar crazy we've been reading from here over the past few months. I thought I could last a week, but it looks like I'm gonna lose. It's a lot like staring into the sun or listening to a Sarah Palin speech. Sooner rather than later you gotta turn away because it's just too painful.
 
Last edited:
Speaking of obtuse, what about "powerless over alcohol" do you not understand?

Nevermind, you compared the ingestion of potato of chips to the consumption of alcohol so I see where the problem is.

So alcohol is your higher power.
 
I have asked you to quote me and you never do.. Go back and find where I said "AA is anti-psychology"

I have already done that once. Do you really want me to continue the humilation. I really am starting to think there is a problem with you. :rolleyes:

They have a lot of pseudoscience and folk psychology and but being against accepted psychology is a separate thing. They often against medication that's my claim.

You said "anti-psych" on more than one occasion and I have proven that already.
If your nebulous "they" means AA, you now need to prove that AA is anti-medication today, which you can't do. If you mean some undefined small number of members, I will concede the point. Who is "they" exactly?

Correcting your misconceptions isn't you winning points, like you thought it was when I said it was "effectively". Delusional wishful thinking is all.

You introduced that word only after I proved you to be a liar.

I quoted it in this post

Bill doesn't say that here...


or here...

and here's the pamphlet for complete context.

or here...

He's admitting they were anti-psy while trying to say they'll be good now, it's in the past, while still apologizing for their spiritual solution woo.

Really?
It doesn't read quite that way to me. Which bit says that exactly. Where does Bill say "AA started out as anti-psychiatry", which is what you said he said.

Now this was written in 1958 I think, and AA was 20 years old or so. We have had now another 50 plus years and AA is over 75 years old; you are clutching at straws if you think this proves diddly squat when we consider that you also said:

"AA doesn't take mental illness seriously and is anti-psychiatry"

You are furiously backpedalling again. There is no past tense in this statement, yet you would have us believe this has been your only point.

I think you are quite possibly the most dishonest poster I have ever come across.

c r b t? You mean CBT? If you do I don't understand, please explain.

Correct, a typo, my bad
So is CBT quackery (or whatever it was you said)?

So in other worlds "powerless" doesn't really mean what it's supposed to mean. You're powerless but not really. You need a higher power but not really.

How long are you going to twist and swerve like this, apologising for things that are crystal clear ?

In other worlds, you might be right. Is that the world your god lives in?

You are missing the colour, cut and design of the crystal, and I am not surprised.
Read the step in full and get an insight. You are looking at the overview only, not the detail.

So alcohol is your higher power.

If chips are yours. :)

Are you going to respond to me regarding whether you believe there is a genetic factor in alcoholism or not?
 
Last edited:
Ah, a much more succint way of saying what I was trying to say.

And saying that doesn't have to mean much, really.

I've gotten drunk in my life, because there is a point where, when drinking, I no longer make the smart decision and stop. (I do eventually before I pass out, but long after the point where stopping would prevent the hang over the next morning.) The issue is whether I can spot that point in advance and stop as long as I still can. I can always spot that point and in the vast majority of cases i decide not to go there.
 
In other worlds, you might be right.

You really have gone off the deep end now, Alfie, if you think this was clever. Don't think anybody's missed the fact that you dodged my point.

Is that the world your god lives in?

I don't have a god. AA does.

You are missing the colour, cut and design of the crystal, and I am not surprised.

"Crystal" ? What the hell are you talking about ?

Read the step in full and get an insight. You are looking at the overview only, not the detail.

You are making less and less sense.
 
As soon as Girl Guides and Jenny's aerobic class start turning their lives over to some god, relying on Him to fix their weight gain and cookie sales; pray to Him; confess their sins to each and each other; and start recruiting other members like a bunch of Moonies at the airport; I'll classify them as a religion, too.

The Girl Guides of Canada have removed all reference to "god" and "higher power" in their literature and program. They are now a truly secular organization and guess what? . . . Their membership increased significantly.

They had changed their references, like AA, from "God" to "a higher power" and even "God as we know him" but that didn't change anything in the eyes of the public. So they removed the reference to god completely. They didn't just claim to be inclusive, they actually took action.

I think it's pretty good evidence that religion of the type AA pushes is a barrier to many people.
 
Belz... said:
Not what I said, but it is not surprising that your recapitulation of my argument would lack any subtlety.

Wait...wait. Here:

You said:
Yes, you are contending that an alcoholic has a choice to continue drinking after the first drink.

And then to:

Me said:
So now you're contending that an alcoholic CANNOT have any control over whether or not they drink ?

You say:

You said:
Not what I said

Then what the hell ARE you saying ?

Do you really not understand the difference between "after the first drink" and "whether or not they drink"?

In the former case, the subject has had at least one drink, whereas, in the latter case the, the subject has had no drinks at all. Yes, the "alcoholic" can control his or her drinking by choosing not to drink at all, but, once he or she has one drink, it is very difficult, if not impossible, for him or her to stop until he or she has become intoxicated.

Such a "loss of control" has been observed in rats that have had prolonged exposure to ethanol and then been abstinent for some time:

From controlled drug intake to loss of control: the irreversible development of drug addiction in the rat

Wolffgramm and Heyne (1995) said:
The development of drug taking from controlled intake to drug addiction was studied by means of an animal model. Outbred rats had continous free access to water and drinking fluids containing different concentrations of a drug for 7–9 months. After an abstinence period of 4–9 months, the drug was offered again (retest). Previous ethological classification of each rat and changes of housing conditions were used to study the modifiability of drug taking. With ethanol and the μ-agonistic opiate etonitazene, two stages followed each other. Controlled drug intake was adjusted to situational and individual variables. Social isolation of the rats raised the intake of ethanol and opiate. Dominant rats took less drugs than subordinate ones, but, in contrast to the latter, increased drug consumption after social disturbances. The adjustment of drug taking to social variables, was accompanied by changes in the dopaminergic and GABAA-ergic neurotransmission and by altered responses to acute drug administrations. Further, place preference, associated with reinforcing stimuli was modulated by subchronic sensitization/desensitization of dopaminergic transmission. Controlled drug intake lasted for 6–8 months, after which a spontaneous increase of drug consumption was found which latently continued during abstinence periods of 1 month. In the retest after abstinence, drug intake of these rats was strongly increased compared with both their previous consumption and that of drug-naive controls. Since drug taking could no longer be modulated by gustatory, environmental or individual factors (loss of control), it was considered as addictive. Addiction appeared to be specific to the kind of the drug. It persisted for the rest of the rat's life. After long periods of abstinence, ethanol-addicted rats revealed a completely altered pattern of response to self-administered alcohol compared with controlled drinkers. Their dopaminergic D1-transmission was irreversibly altered. Drug addiction only developed when the rat had free choice between water and drug-containing solutions. Long-term forced administration of ethanol or opiate, only led to physical dependence bot not to addiction. Some applications of the animal model are discussed, concerning the assessment of risk factors, the intake of drug combinations, residual neurochemical changes and concepts of treatment.

The concept of "loss of control" is also corroborated by brain imaging in humans:

The addicted human brain: insights from imaging studies

Volkow et al (2003) said:
Imaging studies have revealed neurochemical and functional changes in the brains of drug-addicted subjects that provide new insights into the mechanisms underlying addiction. Neurochemical studies have shown that large and fast increases in dopamine are associated with the reinforcing effects of drugs of abuse, but also that after chronic drug abuse and during withdrawal, brain dopamine function is markedly decreased and these decreases are associated with dysfunction of prefrontal regions (including orbitofrontal cortex and cingulate gyrus). The changes in brain dopamine function are likely to result in decreased sensitivity to natural reinforcers since dopamine also mediates the reinforcing effects of natural reinforcers and on disruption of frontal cortical functions, such as inhibitory control and salience attribution. Functional imaging studies have shown that during drug intoxication, or during craving, these frontal regions become activated as part of a complex pattern that includes brain circuits involved with reward (nucleus accumbens), motivation (orbitofrontal cortex), memory (amygdala and hippocampus), and cognitive control (prefrontal cortex and cingulate gyrus). Here, we integrate these findings and propose a model that attempts to explain the loss of control and compulsive drug intake that characterize addiction. Specifically, we propose that in drug addiction the value of the drug and drug-related stimuli is enhanced at the expense of other reinforcers. This is a consequence of conditioned learning and of the resetting of reward thresholds as an adaptation to the high levels of stimulation induced by drugs of abuse. In this model, during exposure to the drug or drug-related cues, the memory of the expected reward results in overactivation of the reward and motivation circuits while decreasing the activity in the cognitive control circuit. This contributes to an inability to inhibit the drive to seek and consume the drug and results in compulsive drug intake. This model has implications for therapy, for it suggests a multi-prong approach that targets strategies to decrease the rewarding properties of drugs, to enhance the rewarding properties of alternative reinforcers, to interfere with conditioned-learned associations, and to strengthen cognitive control in the treatment of drug addiction.

This information is not hard to find given that there are free online journal databases, so I am surprised that those arguing against the disease model of alcoholism/addiction have not at least made an effort to address the vast amount of research support the disease model and phenomena such as "loss of control" that has been done.
 
I have already done that once. Do you really want me to continue the humilation. I really am starting to think there is a problem with you. :rolleyes:
See? I ask you to quote me, back up all the crap and rhetoric you say just because I'm a big meanie who doesn't worship your AA masters, and you only have more rheroric...
You said "anti-psych" on more than one occasion and I have proven that already.
You have no idea what you're talking about. Just give up your pointless attacks.
If your nebulous "they" means AA, you now need to prove that AA is anti-medication today, which you can't do.
Alfie still doesn't understand the difference between a general tendency and memetic organism and an official position in an organization? Whatever I tried to educate him. Anyone can go find stories of people still being told this in meetings, I have quoted several recent ones. It's gotten a lot better over the last 15 years I have said this repeatedly. But only after a lot of personal battles inside the program..
If you mean some undefined small number of members, I will concede the point. Who is "they" exactly?
Aplologetics. Answer my question. (4th, 5th time you let it go unanswered?) Why is it impossible to discipline sponsers and groups who are giving anti-psychiatry advice today? Why is it "not possible" in your eyes?
You introduced that word only after I proved you to be a liar.
Quote it, prove it, you make this up because you're a sore loser, just like when I made fun of you for laughing at a wikipedia source... and when you tried to say my study had a small sample... lol
Bill doesn't say that here...
or here...
or here...
Really?
It doesn't read quite that way to me. Which bit says that exactly. Where does Bill say "AA started out as anti-psychiatry", which is what you said he said.
No, you just don't understand evidence, other people probably do, if someone else, doesn't clearly see that's what Bill is saying, I'll respond. But to you? lol I'm sick of explaining things to you that other people plainly see.
Now this was written in 1958 I think, and AA was 20 years old or so. We have had now another 50 plus years and AA is over 75 years old; you are clutching at straws if you think this proves diddly squat
It doesn't prove your ridiculous straw man that it's on their website, no...
when we consider that you also said:

You are furiously backpedalling again. There is no past tense in this statement, yet you would have us believe this has been your only point.

I think you are quite possibly the most dishonest poster I have ever come across.
Yeah, barely making some sense finally and quoting me actually, great!. You have misunderstood I said in that post "told him a story about how AA doesnt't take mental illness seriously" I was speaking offhand, in general I'd already clarified by that point what I my position was, so you don't get to go back and cherry pick an offhand statement to straw man me! They have a tendency and the story I was explaining was textbook, as in what the patient needs is some spiritual experience, when they really needed to go to the doctor, because the reason they were acting out was because they were in denial of their alcoholism, and you have to hit rock bottom. No, the patient needed to be educated about their real condition, that was my story, and you suggested that maybe the AA people were right! Which is also classic AA crap, suggesting it was "resentments" making me think that version of the story! So whatever, if that makes me a liar, call me pinochio.
Correct, a typo, my bad
So is CBT quackery (or whatever it was you said)?
You still don't make any sense.

I'm not the most dishonest poster, I'm the person most openly disdainful of AA you've come across maybe, the only person willing to talk about midtown group and all of that horrible crap that needs to be talked about that you'd rather call a "few bad apples" or whatever.
 
Last edited:
A simple, updated re-wording of some (not all, just some) of AA's verbiage would work wonders and hurt no one.

If instead of "became powerless," why not something more like, "gave up our power to alcohol" in a sense of being willing to reclaim that power? Just as one example. It puts the responsibility squarely and unambiguously on ourselves, where it belongs in most cases. I don't see how this could hurt AA, and do see where it could help the people in it.
 
A simple, updated re-wording of some (not all, just some) of AA's verbiage would work wonders and hurt no one.

If instead of "became powerless," why not something more like, "gave up our power to alcohol" in a sense of being willing to reclaim that power? Just as one example. It puts the responsibility squarely and unambiguously on ourselves, where it belongs in most cases. I don't see how this could hurt AA, and do see where it could help the people in it.

Uh....did you just ignore the research I posted?

The best evidence is that people are actually powerless over alcohol once they become addicted: they simply cannot stop drinking after they start once they have become sensitized to alcohol.
 
Do you really not understand the difference between "after the first drink" and "whether or not they drink"?

In the former case, the subject has had at least one drink, whereas, in the latter case the, the subject has had no drinks at all. Yes, the "alcoholic" can control his or her drinking by choosing not to drink at all, but, once he or she has one drink, it is very difficult, if not impossible, for him or her to stop until he or she has become intoxicated.

Such a "loss of control" has been observed in rats that have had prolonged exposure to ethanol and then been abstinent for some time:

From controlled drug intake to loss of control: the irreversible development of drug addiction in the rat



The concept of "loss of control" is also corroborated by brain imaging in humans:

The addicted human brain: insights from imaging studies

This information is not hard to find given that there are free online journal databases, so I am surprised that those arguing against the disease model of alcoholism/addiction have not at least made an effort to address the vast amount of research support the disease model and phenomena such as "loss of control" that has been done.


AA doesn't believe in the disease concept either, especially in light of these studies that were done that you quote. The AA World Organization could have easily added notes to the big book or even running commentary to supplement what Bill W wrote 50-some odd years ago, but they don't. The AA World Organization even goes out of it's way to print in the preamble (which I've quoted before in this thread and I'm paraphrasing here) "we won't change what works."

So thank you for posting links to those studies. I'm grateful that there are alternatives to AA (some also free) which take advantage of our increased knowledge of addiction and how it affects humans.
 
Uh....did you just ignore the research I posted?

The best evidence is that people are actually powerless over alcohol once they become addicted: they simply cannot stop drinking after they start once they have become sensitized to alcohol.
But you admitted that they are powerful over the first drink.. As Rasmus put it

"Once I start drinking I am powerless to stop until I pass out" is a completely different claim.

There are people who literally believe that when they are sober they involuntarily go use drugs or alcohol. Not as in "I couldn't stop after the first one" but as in "I woke up, went to the store, bought a bottle, started drinking, involuntarily" It sounds insane but people actually think this. Do you think this?
 
Uh....did you just ignore the research I posted?

The best evidence is that people are actually powerless over alcohol once they become addicted: they simply cannot stop drinking after they start once they have become sensitized to alcohol.


So where's the evidence that demonstrates that alcoholism is a spiritual problem that requires a spiritual solution?
 
So where's the evidence that demonstrates that alcoholism is a spiritual problem that requires a spiritual solution?

The discussion has deviated from the AA program to whether alcoholism ca better be described as a matter of "personal responsibility" or a matter of "loss of control". The preponderance of recent research indicates that it is the latter.
 
But you admitted that they are powerful over the first drink.. As Rasmus put it



There are people who literally believe that when they are sober they involuntarily go use drugs or alcohol. Not as in "I couldn't stop after the first one" but as in "I woke up, went to the store, bought a bottle, started drinking, involuntarily" It sounds insane but people actually think this. Do you think this?

It has been demonstrated through research that there is such a thing as "loss of control", so I don't see the logic in insisting that alcoholism is merely an issue of "personal responsibility".
 
It has been demonstrated through research that there is such a thing as "loss of control"
I am not familiar with this research, can you please make a solid case or at least point me in the correct direction? (No spoonfeeding necessary, I'm actually willing to work hard and do research and read between the lines ;) )

Imagine this "Yes, I lost control and got out of bed, walked down the street, forgot my wallet, went home and got it, walked to the liquor store, bought some whiskey and chugged it in the parking lot, completely involuntarily..." Do you believe me? :rolleyes:

Dude if that happens to anyone they need to go directly to the psychiatry ward because they are a danger to society. You're literally walking around sober doing things you can't control? Scary!

so I don't see the logic in insisting that alcoholism is merely an issue of "personal responsibility".
because there's no evidence it's not a choice despite the urges, cravings and loss of control after the first drink, so you're basically enabling people to become deluded like they are out of control.

South Park nailed it in their AA-bashing episode "Bloody Mary", when Stan's dad gets in a wheelchair and acts like an invalid drinking all the time, even going to the bleeding virgin mary statue for a faith healing! Oh man between penn and teller and south park, truly hilarious AA bashing.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom