So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Steve and the rest of the SGU crew spoke in the latest podcast about asking Richard Dawkins on stage with them to talk about the Elevatorgate, good move, should be interesting :)
 
But that's not quite the argument. Do women not want to get their hands oily because of genetics or because of the society we've constructed.

I don't think we can blame society for every difference between the two. Do you think women would like weightlifting as much as men if it weren't for social training ?

There are a lot of women that would laugh at the description you provided.

Let 'em. At this point it's all opinion, and we have no way to tell how it would be if society were different.

Or perhaps we can. But that would require having data on societies in which such ideas weren't there.

and now they repair tanks, fly plains, inspect missiles...they do absolutely everything men do, and a lot of them enjoy it.

Sometimes they even, gasp, get their hands oily.

I didn't say that NO woman would want to do this, Trane. You know this, so why are you arguing against something I haven't said ? It doesn't follow that the SAME proportion of women as that of men would be interested in those activities. And I doubt it's all learned behaviour.
 
Crazy thought here - You aren't the only person I am talking about. With one exception, it's an amalgamation of attitudes.

You made up statements from other people and now you're saying they're amalgamations ? In what way ? The individual words were posted in this thread and you just cobbled them up together ?
 
There was a large survey in England some time back in which an athletic physique came out at the most attractive.

Define "athletic" ?

Why didn't you ask for stats for the chap who claimed that all men didn't find athletic women attractive, you know, as he is claiming to speak for all men?

I asked for statistics either way, because I wasn't aware of such a study. If you don't like to be the one who's asked, on a public forum, then maybe this isn't the place for you.
 
Native Americans were famously used to construct sky-scrapers because some percentage of them were not afraid of heights, and could work in exposed areas without safety gear. If I were working on those buildings, I would be completely terrified and I'd need safety gear.

I've heard that some Mohawks from the Kahnawake reservation near Montreal have done a lot of skyscraper work. Many ideas have been suggested as to why. The most plausible to me is that they grew up walking by putting one foot in front of the other, which is the best way to walk on a steel beam.

My fear and the request for safety gear are both perfectly reasonable. It's a legitimately dangerous activity, I could easily fall. Additionally, the fact that I experience fear in THAT situation, doesn't mean I'm a weakling scared of my shadow in all other aspects of life.

Well, then, that probably means that going into a second career as a skyscraper worker would be a bad idea.

Rebecca Watson, not me, felt afraid in that elevator. I've simply pointed out that this apprehension was not irrational. It was legitimate. I don't know why you're so intent on dismissing the perspective of women. Seems sexist to me.

People aren't dismissing the perspective of women. They're questioning the perspective of certain women. They're supposed to dismiss the perspective of other women. Is that sexist?

It seems that "we" are supposed to want particularly thin-skinned women, especially if all they do at skeptic conferences is talk about how tough it is to be a woman at a skeptic conference. Could you explain to me why "we" should want that?

"We" could find plenty of women, for example in churches. Do "we" want that kind of woman? Probably not. It's probably OK not to want a bunch of, say, seriously Methodist women on panels at skeptic conferences. Maybe "we" could make them feel comfortable by putting a lot of crosses around and opening ever day with a prayer to Jesus. Then "we" could get them.

I don't want to "dismiss" Rebecca Watson, but neither do I particularly want to see some absolute template for all women based on her. Skepticism should, of course, be open to women as well as men. Amongst those women, I'd kind of like to see some who are fearless enough to debate people and to go against people's deeply held beliefs, which requires a lot of self-confidence and independence. But that's the sort of woman whom "we" are supposed to get rid of.
 
For those who are new to this, here's a recap:

Rebecca said the following in this video (after about 4 mins):



Rebecca Watson said:
So, thank you to everyone who was at that conference who, uh, engaged in those discussions outside of that panel, um, you were all fantastic; I loved talking to you guys—um, all of you except for the one man who, um, didn’t really grasp, I think, what I was saying on the panel…? Because, um, at the bar later that night—actually, at four in the morning—um, we were at the hotel bar, 4am, I said, you know, “I’ve had enough, guys, I’m exhausted, going to bed,” uh, so I walked to the elevator, and a man got on the elevator with me, and said, “Don’t take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more; would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?”

Um. Just a word to the wise here, guys: Uhhhh, don’t do that. Um, you know. [laughs] Uh, I don’t really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I’ll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4 am, in a hotel elevator with you, just you, and—don’t invite me back to your hotel room, right after I’ve finished talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.

So, yeah. But everybody else seemed to really get it.


Richard Dawkins posted these on PZ's blog in the comments section:

Richard Dawkins said:
Dear Muslima

Stop whining, will you. Yes, yes, I know you had your genitals mutilated with a razor blade, and . . . yawn . . . don't tell me yet again, I know you aren't allowed to drive a car, and you can't leave the house without a male relative, and your husband is allowed to beat you, and you'll be stoned to death if you commit adultery. But stop whining, will you. Think of the suffering your poor American sisters have to put up with.

Only this week I heard of one, she calls herself Skep"chick", and do you know what happened to her? A man in a hotel elevator invited her back to his room for coffee. I am not exaggerating. He really did. He invited her back to his room for coffee. Of course she said no, and of course he didn't lay a finger on her, but even so . . .

And you, Muslima, think you have misogyny to complain about! For goodness sake grow up, or at least grow a thicker skin.

Richard


No I wasn't making that argument. Here's the argument I was making. The man in the elevator didn't physically touch her, didn't attempt to bar her way out of the elevator, didn't even use foul language at her. He spoke some words to her. Just words. She no doubt replied with words. That was that. Words. Only words, and apparently quite polite words at that.

If she felt his behaviour was creepy, that was her privilege, just as it was the Catholics' privilege to feel offended and hurt when PZ nailed the cracker. PZ didn't physically strike any Catholics. All he did was nail a wafer, and he was absolutely right to do so because the heightened value of the wafer was a fantasy in the minds of the offended Catholics. Similarly, Rebecca's feeling that the man's proposition was 'creepy' was her own interpretation of his behaviour, presumably not his. She was probably offended to about the same extent as I am offended if a man gets into an elevator with me chewing gum. But he does me no physical damage and I simply grin and bear it until either I or he gets out of the elevator. It would be different if he physically attacked me.

Muslim women suffer physically from misogyny, their lives are substantially damaged by religiously inspired misogyny. Not just words, real deeds, painful, physical deeds, physical privations, legally sanctioned demeanings. The equivalent would be if PZ had nailed not a cracker but a Catholic. Then they'd have had good reason to complain.

Richard


Many people seem to think it obvious that my post was wrong and I should apologise. Very few people have bothered to explain exactly why. The nearest approach I have heard goes something like this.

I sarcastically compared Rebecca's plight with that of women in Muslim countries or families dominated by Muslim men. Somebody made the worthwhile point (reiterated here by PZ) that it is no defence of something slightly bad to point to something worse. We should fight all bad things, the slightly bad as well as the very bad. Fair enough. But my point is that the 'slightly bad thing' suffered by Rebecca was not even slightly bad, it was zero bad. A man asked her back to his room for coffee. She said no. End of story.

But not everybody sees it as end of story. OK, let's ask why not? The main reason seems to be that an elevator is a confined space from which there is no escape. This point has been made again and again in this thread, and the other one.

No escape? I am now really puzzled. Here's how you escape from an elevator. You press any one of the buttons conveniently provided. The elevator will obligingly stop at a floor, the door will open and you will no longer be in a confined space but in a well-lit corridor in a crowded hotel in the centre of Dublin.

No, I obviously don't get it. I will gladly apologise if somebody will calmly and politely, without using the word **** in every sentence, explain to me what it is that I am not getting.

Richard


Then Rebecca got really angry and posted this on Skepchick:

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

Rebecca said:
So many of you voiced what I had already been thinking: that this person who I always admired for his intelligence and compassion does not care about my experiences as an atheist woman and therefore will no longer be rewarded with my money, my praise, or my attention. I will no longer recommend his books to others, buy them as presents, or buy them for my own library. I will not attend his lectures or recommend that others do the same. There are so many great scientists and thinkers out there that I don’t think my reading list will suffer.

Despite the fact that I’ve seen hundreds of comments from those of you who plan to do the same, I’m sure Dawkins will continue to be stinking rich until the end of his days. But those of us who are humanists and feminists will find new, better voices to promote and inspire, and Dawkins will be left alone to fight the terrible injustice of standing in elevators with gum-chewers.


-> CHAOS REIGNS.

At this point we don't even know whether Dawkins had seen the video in question before writing the posts or not. Steve and the rest of the SGU crew are planning to invite Dawkins on stage to clear up any misunderstandings, so we will have the chance to find out more about everything in a few days when they are discussing this issue live at TAM during SGU's presentation where Rebecca and Dawkins can talk this out in person.* Great move.

*Source: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=312
 
Last edited:
At this point we don't even know whether Dawkins had seen the video in question before writing the posts or not. Steve and the rest of the SGU crew are planning to invite Dawkins on stage to clear up any misunderstandings, so we will have the chance to find out more about everything in a few days when they are discussing this issue live at TAM during SGU's presentation where Rebecca and Dawkins can talk this out in person.* Great move.

*Source: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=312

I'm not entirely sure it IS such a 'great move'.

Hasn't this issue already received more than enough airplay?

I'm not belittling the topic of sexism - however given the raw sentiments out there and the crazy 'factions' that have formed up around the whole 'incident', I don't think there can be or will be a meaningful and lucid debate about the issue at TAM.

To be honest, to apply the same level of criticsm I have already towards Rebecca, insinuating pretty firmly that she has turned this into 'elevatorgate' as attention-seeking behaviour, I suggest that the SGU team could also be falling into the same attention-seeking trap.

I would far prefer to hear discussions & presentations about relevant skeptical talks, and lets NOT discuss this issue at TAM 9. Maybe in 3 months when cooler heads have (hopefully) prevailed. There will be enough chit chat and gossip about the whole thing on the casino floor.

If you follow Rebecca's twitter & facebook, you'll see that there is some really wacky crap going on out there. Someone has suggested they're going to attempt to 'cop a feel' of Rebecca at TAM. A bunch of her friends have said they're going to act as her 'bodyguards'. I mean - folks, this is going beyond circus and into a...

skeptics convention?
 
Steve and the rest of the SGU crew are planning to invite Dawkins on stage to clear up any misunderstandings, so we will have the chance to find out more about everything in a few days when they are discussing this issue live at TAM during SGU's presentation where Rebecca and Dawkins can talk this out in person.* Great move.

*Source: http://www.theskepticsguide.org/archive/podcastinfo.aspx?mid=1&pid=312

Oh, well, I'll just have to wait for the recording to come out; I'm on registration duty at that time.
 
I'm not entirely sure it IS such a 'great move'.

Hasn't this issue already received more than enough airplay?


I think it's a great opportunity to demonstrate how two intelligent human beings can get over simple or more complex misunderstandings or failures to communicate, or even to learn something new from each other. Controversies like this don't have to end in chaos. It's also an important topic, which I think suits TAM nicely.
 
Last edited:
I think it's a great opportunity to demonstrate how two intelligent people can get over simple or more complex misunderstanding or failures to communicate, or even to learn something new from each other. Controversies like this don't have to end in chaos. It's also an important topic, which I think suits TAM nicely.

Fair enough, but I'm pretty sure both Richard & Rebecca are quite capable of catalyzing such a discussion, if they both want to have the discussion in a public environment, without anyone else's assistance.
 
I had to take a break from (reading) this thread because I just can't come to grips with the reaction taking place.

I honestly can't even see the argument explaining what this guy in the elevator did that was wrong. He hit on her? Seemingly politely so? Am I to understand that I must now remain completely silent when alone with a woman on an elevator? (For the love of god, I understand not to mention cof*e*- shudders).

I figured I must be missing something, but I still can't find it.

And again, if you are independent enough to get yourself on an elevator, at 4:00am, alone, in a foreign country, then you are independent enough to deal with these (harmless) consequences.

I have a sneaky suspicion that this is a social thing, and that many are friends with Rebecca, and are pissed off that their friend is pissed off. This is understandable, but does not mean it is a good example of critical thinking.

This whole thing is utterly ******* ridiculous and IMO does a disservice to the advancement of equal treatment of women.
 
I won't take it as sarcasm. But yes, basically, because men who can do that are successful with women, and being successful with woman makes a man a dog. It's like the madonna/whore complex, except for men.

It's not just the ability to read body language and signals that makes a man a "dog", it's picking up on those signals and then using deception to get what he wants; pretending to be interested in more than casual sex, pretending to be monogamous when he's got multiple women he's lying to; that's a dog. It's hard to say how other's should feel but I find something to the effect of, "Listen, we are both going to be in different cities tomorrow, but I don't want to end the night..." I could respect that.
 
How about "If you have reason to believe that your request for sex might not be appreciated, don't ask a woman if she wants to have sex when that's the first thing you've ever said to her in her life?"

Define " a reason to believe.". I would consider a reason to believe to be a " No " as an answer, and one cannot get an answer without asking a question.

What your saying is very similar to " Don't ask for pepsi in a store if you think they may not have any." , how do i know if they do not have any without asking?
 
As a coda to your non-sarcastic question about men being dogs are losers, I have to say, this is completely opposite to the truth.

Actually propositioning women, maybe not as an opening but within a few sentences in, doesn't piss them off.

Even taking them in one's arms and kissing them, sometimes with no words exchanged, does not produce negative reactions.

But there's your qualifier, "maybe not as an opening sentence," this whole thing started as a proposition in the opening sentence. So what of that, without the qualifier. Do you think the proposition as the opening sentence might piss a few off?
 
Fair enough, but I'm pretty sure both Richard & Rebecca are quite capable of catalyzing such a discussion, if they both want to have the discussion in a public environment, without anyone else's assistance.


No doubt, but this is much more convenient, they are both under the same roof already and the topic is still hot. Richard lives in the UK remember? Talking in person is also better than a 1-on-1 public forum discussion which is what I have proposed earlier. I'm sure it will get recorded on video as well, so that's another bonus for us.
 
Last edited:
How about, "when I just gave a talk about how I don't like being objectified and sexualized at conventions, don't propose me to an activity that could easily be interpreted for sex in an elevator at 4AM after I just said I was tired and was going to bed"? Sounds reasonable to me, but it's a bit more long-winded. Guess it's easier to just strip down those annoying details so we can beat down on a simplified version of the "request"...


I do agree that this part was just idiotic. Dawkins was insensitive, perhaps a bit dense, regarding the original video, but Rebecca's reaction to that was just... dare I say, hysterical. Pity, cause I was completely on her side before that.

Wanting to have sex with someone is not objectification, not caring about someones feelings is objectification, you know treating them like an object. People do not politely ask their fridge if it wants to open so they can get food, people do not politely ask a knife if it wants to cut something.

"Objectification" to some people seems to be code for " Don't want to have sex with someone" and again, i refer you to my previous posts. Not all women are like the extreme example we are discussing, and it is silly to suddenly request a behavior that is harmless, ( in the way the guy did it. No harassment, no debate just a question.) be omitted because someone on the fringe of the fringe doesn't like it.

I really hate chewing gum, but i am not going to try and demand people stop chewing it solely because of myself. I can realize it is simply a pet peeve of mine, and deal with it. Watson, does not really seem to be able to do this.
 
That's not debatable. On the other hand, if she didn't like the feeling of being propositioned by a stranger in an elevator, is there really anything wrong with making that known publicly, to prevent that moment from happening again?

There is nothing wrong with her saying " Listen, for all men in the audience, don't ask me for sex the first time we meet" , a little weird and personal to use your speaking time to do, but not wacky.

But what she is doing si saying " Don't ask any woman" well sorry Lloth, but most women don't mind. Most women can simply deny the request if they want without issue, heck a good portion of women may not. She is taking a personal preference that she is in the minority of having, and demanding people follow it because, obviously, no woman could think differently from her.

If no women thought differently, heck if the majority of women didn't think differently, the " one night stand" would be a rare obscure occurrence. And as any of us knows, it is not.
 
I need to make a confession. It was never my intention for this to snowball into an issue that threatens the cohesion and good reputation of the skeptical community.

No I wasn't making that argument. Here's the argument I was making. The man in the elevator didn't physically touch her, didn't attempt to bar her way out of the elevator, didn't even use foul language at her. He spoke some words to her. Just words. She no doubt replied with words. That was that. Words. Only words, and apparently quite polite words at that.

If she felt his behaviour was creepy, that was her privilege, just as it was the Catholics' privilege to feel offended and hurt when PZ nailed the cracker. PZ didn't physically strike any Catholics. All he did was nail a wafer, and he was absolutely right to do so because the heightened value of the wafer was a fantasy in the minds of the offended Catholics. Similarly, Rebecca's feeling that the man's proposition was 'creepy' was her own interpretation of his behaviour, presumably not his. She was probably offended to about the same extent as I am offended if a man gets into an elevator with me chewing gum. But he does me no physical damage and I simply grin and bear it until either I or he gets out of the elevator. It would be different if he physically attacked me.

Muslim women suffer physically from misogyny, their lives are substantially damaged by religiously inspired misogyny. Not just words, real deeds, painful, physical deeds, physical privations, legally sanctioned demeanings. The equivalent would be if PZ had nailed not a cracker but a Catholic. Then they'd have had good reason to complain.

Richard

I was trying to quit smoking, Richard! I'm sorry!

I didn't mean anything by it!
 
Okay, "anywhere outside of a brothel"...?

No, I'm sure you'll think of some uncommon kind of situation that has no bearing on the circumstances of Watson's complaint. How about "within the context of an international meeting dedicated to intellectual issues, where people of backgrounds and cultures vastly different from yours are in attendance"? Is asking someone not to ambush women they've never met before with thinly-veiled requests for sex at a fracking TAM or atheist gathering reasonable then? If not, why not?



Why does it have to be? Guys are socially inept because they don't know any better. Usually they don't know that a given scenario is unacceptable until they try it, and the situation crashes and burns all over them. Given that, how is a preemptive warning possibly a bad thing? "Don't do X in situation Y." Noted. Right? They learn the same lesson without the humiliation. What's the downside here?

Besides, there's exactly as much evidence that the guy on the elevator was "socially inept" as there is that he chose to intentionally troll Rebecca after hearing her speech about not wanting to be hit on. In fact, when I saw Watson's video that's actually the first possibility that occurred to me.

The problem is, simply, that the majority of people would not care. People like sex, people like random sex, to modify actions based on the request of one fringe feminist is silly.

It seems to me, Watson is berating both men, and any woman who does not attach the appropriate emotional baggage to sex.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom