Should Registration for the the Military Draft in the USA be Abolished?

The Militia Act of 1903 is what you'd need to repeal. If you think the draft is bad, get this:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_(United_States)#The_reserve_militia



Even after you're too old for the usual selective service system, if they really want to they can draft you anyway.

(edit)This is also why the "guns are only for the militia" argument gun control advocates use would really only keep guns away from women.

I may be being thick here, but when the constitution was written the militia were expected to bring their own gun.

These days I'm fairly sure you get given one.
 
I may be being thick here, but when the constitution was written the militia were expected to bring their own gun.

These days I'm fairly sure you get given one.

Well I don't buy the "they meant that only for the militia!" argument in the first place, just pointing out that "militia" is a bit more of an all-encompassing group than most people are aware. Either way I'd think the militia would want to practice marksmanship prior to being drafted so unless the govt is going to issue all American males a gun just in case... (pretty good idea actually)
 
Sorry to follow this derail, but. . .

just pointing out that "militia" is a bit more of an all-encompassing group than most people are aware.

So do you think when they wrote "well-regulated militia" the framers of the Constitution intended to write "people" or "all men" or even "citizens"? Seems like an odd mistake to presume.
 
So do you think when they wrote "well-regulated militia" the framers of the Constitution intended to write "people" or "all men" or even "citizens"? Seems like an odd mistake to presume.

Maybe all able-bodied men should be given firearms instruction? Many countries do this. Not that it matters, "the people" is the group granted the right to bear arms. I just wanted to segue in the "fun fact" about the sedentary militia while poking fun at a ludicrous anti-gun argument I've seen previously.
 
Supreme Court rejected that argument in 1919.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States
I'm not arguing the draft is unconstitutional. Congress is explicitly given the power to raise armies, and no explicit method is prescribed (or proscribed).

I'm simply saying the draft violates that principle enshrined in the thirteenth amendment that involuntary servitude shall no longer be tolerated.
 
Draft all the eligible family members of the Congress And Senate.

Draft all the eligible family members of the CEO's and managers of the top 20 defense firms.
I would say this ridiculous idea violates the equal protection clause of the fourteenth amendment.

No one should be compelled to military service simply because they were born into a certain influential family.
 
Selective Service registration has been in place for 30 years, and still no draft. I don't think it makes a big difference. If it ever comes to implementing the draft, we'll have the names ready. But even if there were no registration, we could still find them and draft them in a hurry.

Human beings, like all animals, do not evolve that quickly. 30 years is hardly one generation. Now, is it legal to draft people who have not registered? I am not so sure "draft them in a hurry" will work.
 
I would at least repeal the Solomon Amendment that makes receiving federal financial aid for college conditioned on providing proof of registration. Seems like a substantial intrusion for dubious benefit.

Since you are required by law to register for the draft, why is it bad for a college to check to see if someone has obeyed the law?
 
draft all the war-mongers.
this forum can supply cannon-fodder for quite a while.
send palin, bachmann, her closet-case hubby and glen beck too!

War mongers? If we are going to draft imaginary beings, why not draft the Jolly Green Giant? Have you seen how big he is? He could kick some serious butt !!

Hey, I know all too well how your think and see the world. I spent a recent weekend with my Liberal cousins. I just love how they blame everything bad in the world against their cartoonish characterizations of the Right ("war mongers" is just one of them). Yeah, the war mongers have started all the wars. If it wasn't for those damn war monger, Republicans, there would be no wars at all, right? Yes, its those damn war mongers. They are in cahoots with the Extra-Terrestrial aliens and were behind the JFK assassination and getting us into and starting all wars.

But wait a second. More wars and more bloody wars and longer wars have existed when our kindly Democrats have been in office. Damn reality!! It spoils all our fun.

Obama increased the troops a number of times in Afghanistan. But if Palin or any of the other damn Republicans were in office and did that, they would be "war mongers".
 
Last edited:
Draft registration doesn't hold the country together. All it does is make the population less free.

You say a lot of things that don't make any sense. You seem to believe in magic. If the country is attacked people will raise up and fight the enemy via magic.


There is no such thing as magic. The best decisions are not made by democratic process. Thinking that is so is akin to believe in magic. Magic is not real, man. (by the way, this is why we have the electorial college)


Democracy has its place in deciding things like "what movie are we all going out to see" or "what ice cream are we going to buy". But democracy does not work in real life-or-death scenarios like, "what antidote should we all inject into ourselves to save our lives". This is the same as believing a majority will decide when and if to go to war on its own.

But you seem to think that a people who need to raise up against an enemy will mostly do so when the need logically comes to pass. It won't. Human beings, in case you have not noticed, are not logical creatures. Your faith in them is a delusion.


What I am telling you is not just a matter of opnion. It is not contraversial. It is not even an argument. It is obvious. You are obviously wrong. It is obvious that our species is not intelligent enough to take care of itself and decide when and if to go to war. Want proof? We even KNOW that we are not an intelligent species. One simple proof is the fact that the word "medeocre" means both average and stupid at the same time. We are too stupid to go fight an enemy when we should. We need a draft.

The fact that we have been lucky with a volunteer military is a matter of just that: LUCK.
 
Last edited:
Draft registration doesn't hold the country together. All it does is make the population less free. Taxes do serve useful purposes, including supporting the military which I am all in favour of.


Imagine my concern. Make sure you imagine something really small.


Because Freedom should be defended. The draft is slavery, and I am against slavery.

As an enlisted person In the military, you have a job that you cannot be fired for. You have free housing and meals. You have free dental care and healthcare. If you shop on base, you do not pay taxes. You work alongside people who you become to regard as your brothers. NOT being in the military can be regarded as being more like slavery, my misinformed friend.

It does not make sense how you are FOR taxes while being AGAINST the draft.
 
Last edited:
As an enlisted person In the military, you have a job that you cannot be fired for.

False. Enlisted persons are eliminated involuntarily often enough, for a variety of reasons.

You have free housing and meals.

No, you don't. If you live in goverment provided quarters (rapidly dissapearing), you forfeit your housing allowance. If you eat "free" in the mess hall, you forfeit your subsistance allowance.

You have free dental care and healthcare. If you shop on base, you do not pay taxes. You work alongside people who you become to regard as your brothers. NOT being in the military can be regarded as being more like slavery, my misinformed friend.

Fine bit of glossing over!

A Soldier serves completely at the whim of the Army. Virtually every aspect of one's life is controlled to a greater degree than a civilians. What a Soldier is "free" from is individual choice.

It does not make sense how you are FOR taxes while being AGAINST the draft.

Why? Without necessarily sharing a blanket opposition to the principle of a draft, I don't see a contradiction in favoring some forms of taxation while opposing a draft.
 
Sorry to follow this derail, but. . .



So do you think when they wrote "well-regulated militia" the framers of the Constitution intended to write "people" or "all men" or even "citizens"? Seems like an odd mistake to presume.

What's the mistake? Historically the "militia" was comprised of all able-bodied adult male citizens capable of bearing arms. That's just what the word meant. Akhil Amar goes into a lot of detail on this in his excellent book The Bill of Rights.
 
Last edited:
False. Enlisted persons are eliminated involuntarily often enough, for a variety of reasons.

False. Only for crimes. You can sit around and screw up your job and be lazy etc. but you cannot be fired. If you freaking run off and kill someone on purpose, hell yeah you can get arrested. If you run off and do heroin and fail a drug test, hell yeah you can get arrested, but you cannot get fired. No enlisted man got kicked out of the military for poor job performance. That is what I mean by "fired". I don't mean dishonorable discharge, dude.

Disagree? Give a real example. Don't give vague generalizations. Don't give confused opinions showing you don't know specifics. I don't think you know what you are talking about. I do. I have first hand knowledge and experience.
 
Last edited:
False. Only for crimes. You can sit around and screw up your job. But you cannot be fired.


You are still mistaken. There are dozens of ways to "get fired" from the military without having committed a crime - including inefficiency (sitting around and screwing up your job).

Here are some of the reasons you may be fired from your job as a Soldier, none of which involve having committed a crime:

1. Get pregnant
2. Get lazy
3. Fail to perform your job to standards
4. Fail to pass physical fitness exams
5. Fail to get promoted
6. Get divorced with a child and fail to be able to ensure the child will be taken care of if you deploy.
7. Abuse alcohol while off duty and in a completely legal maner.
8. Get too far in debt.
9. Get too fat.
10. Be in the Army during a drawdown.
 
False. Only for crimes. You can sit around and screw up your job and be lazy etc. but you cannot be fired. If you freaking run off and kill someone on purpose, hell yeah you can get arrested. If you run off and do heroin and fail a drug test, hell yeah you can get arrested, but you cannot get fired. No enlisted man got kicked out of the military for poor job performance. That is what I mean by "fired". I don't mean dishonorable discharge, dude.

Disagree? Give a real example. Don't give vague generalizations. Don't give confused opinions showing you don't know specifics. I don't think you know what you are talking about. I do. I have first hand knowledge and experience.

You do not know what you are talking about!

In the military being lazy and screwing up your job is a criminal offense which can (and sometimes does) result in being forcibly discharged.

To be specific, Article 134 General article) of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) states it quite plainly:

Though not specifically mentioned in this chapter, all disorders and neglects to the prejudice of good order and discipline in the armed forces, all conduct of a nature to bring discredit upon the armed forces, and crimes and offenses not capital, of which persons subject to this chapter may be guilty, shall be taken cognizance of by a general, special, or summary court-martial, according to the nature and degree of the offense, and shall be punished at the discretion of that court.
 
False. Only for crimes. You can sit around and screw up your job and be lazy etc. but you cannot be fired. If you freaking run off and kill someone on purpose, hell yeah you can get arrested. If you run off and do heroin and fail a drug test, hell yeah you can get arrested, but you cannot get fired. No enlisted man got kicked out of the military for poor job performance. That is what I mean by "fired". I don't mean dishonorable discharge, dude.

Disagree? Give a real example. Don't give vague generalizations. Don't give confused opinions showing you don't know specifics. I don't think you know what you are talking about. I do. I have first hand knowledge and experience.


Ahh - added some after I had already responded.

It is absolute that a Soldier may be "fired" (if, by fired, you mean involuntarily seperated from service) for being lazy and/or screwing up on the job. It happens all the time, and this has been true continually since 1979.

Your contention that "no enlisted man got kicked out of the military for poor performance" is simply false. Indeed, it is such a common occurance that it calls into question whether or not you ever actually served, and completely refutes any pretense to expertise.

Real examples, as in the circumstances of someone that was actually "fired"? Or real examples of the enabling regulations? Either is simple enough, so I'll provide both.

I have personal knowledge of hundreds of discharges for inefficiency based on an inability to perform a critical job task to standard. These discharges happened throughout my career. Specifically, I have engineered the involuntary discharge of dozens of persons that failed to meet height/weight standards (AR 600-9), gotten pregnant (AR 635-200, ch 8), absued alcohol but broke no law while doing so (AR635-200, ch 11), and failed to perform job tasks (AR635-200, ch's 11 and 13).

As for whether or not I know what I'm talking about....look it up. The information is easily available for verification.

If you want to get in an experience measuring contest, whip it out. I am a retired Infantry Sergeant Major with more than a quarter century of active service in Infantry and Airborne units. I am currently employed on Ft Bragg (largest post in the US) as the Program Manager for the Centralized Barracks Program. Immeditaly prior to this job, I was the Fort Bragg Garrison XO. Frankly, none of this is terribly important - I can't imagine a career Soldier not knowing that enlisted persons can be "fired".
 
You do not know what you are talking about!

In the military being lazy and screwing up your job is a criminal offense which can (and sometimes does) result in being forcibly discharged.


To be specific, Article 134 General article) of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) states it quite plainly:

True enough - but potentially confusing. There need not be a crime in order to involuntarily eliminate a Soldier from service.

A Specialist (E4) that fails to make E5 (Sergeant) is eliminated upon reaching 8 years of service. This is true even if the Specialist was a Sergeant and gets reduced for inefficiency.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom