gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
Of course it was. "Peak Oil" has been around for decades. If you'll recall, in the 70's we were going to be out of oil by 2000.

That's not how I remember it no. I'm English. That was the beginning of the boom time for North Sea Oil and I seem to remember people talking about oil running out in about 2040. Now we're in 2011 and there's a growing consensus that oil supplies peaked five years ago.
 
Logged out of my hotmail account and saw the news on MSNBC front page.
http://money.msn.com/investing/dow-plummets-market-dispatches.aspx?GT1=33002

The market rout was prompted in part by concerns that the Federal Reserve won't try to boost the economy again and the prospects of little -- if any help -- on the way from the federal government.
...
While gold fell back, investors bid hotly for Treasurys. The 10-year Treasury yield fell to 2.458% from Wednesday's 2.599%.

While market is taking it in the rear the Government bonds continue at extremely low rates.

Just when Government could truly make a difference for the entire economy, it chooses not to. Well, it's not like Keynesians didn't warn you.
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to get some details out of you about what you believe is wrong with my analysis (post #10 in this thread.) I didn't start this thread in order to receive vague psychoanalysis - I started it because I'm interested in people's opinions about where gold is going, and why. Your posts aren't enlightening me very much so far. :)

Gold is not "going" anywhere.

It is the major currencies that are moving, and they are all moving downward although at different rates.

To see this, review the value of gold vs other commodities.
 
Logged out of my hotmail account and saw the news on MSNBC front page.
http://money.msn.com/investing/dow-plummets-market-dispatches.aspx?GT1=33002



While market is taking it in the rear the Government bonds continue at extremely low rates.

Just when Government could truly make a difference for the entire economy, it chooses not to. Well, it's not like Keynesians didn't warn you.

Lol. Yes, government. Please prop up the phony stock market with more fiat money. Make sure you hike margin requirements on gold and silver too, to further manipulate that market. If my non-stock-owning countrymen who actually have to work for a living have to pay more for bread and milk, who cares! You and the Keynesians are *********** geniuses. Why didn't I think of that.
 
Last edited:
Gold is always a lousy investment in the long run, because it doesn't produce anything. Invest in a bunch of companies, and those companies will use your capital to employ people and buy machinery etc, to produce things and make a profit. Your capital grows because it is used to create more actual value.

Invest in gold, and it just lies around doing nothing. If stocks go down, you might lose less money with gold. If a lot of people are panicking, and you manage to sell when the panic peaks, you can certainly make a big profit. But as a long term investment, gold will always suck.

The underlying problem here is that there is a serious crisis of demand. There is a lot of investor money, because capital gains profits have been stellar over the last 30 years or so. But real wages have not increased much. A lot of the economic growth has been financed by debts--by the government simultaneously lowering taxes and increasing spending--but also private debts, housing loans and credit cards. With the financial crash a couple of years ago, private debts couldn't keep accelerating at the same rate. On top of that, unemployment rose sharply. Even people who still are not broke are cautious that they might lose their jobs.

I don't see a turnaround anytime soon, because there's no easy fix for the lack of demand. And politicians are not even acknowledging the problem. Best case, we could have a long, flat period, eventually seeing some growth. But this is going to hit wall street, and I'm not sure what will happen when wall street does not see any real growth for a long period. They are not used to that.
 
Gold is always a lousy investment in the long run, because it doesn't produce anything. Invest in a bunch of companies, and those companies will use your capital to employ people and buy machinery etc, to produce things and make a profit. Your capital grows because it is used to create more actual value.

Gold is value. It has a six-thousand year history as money. If you actually understod investing, you would understand that stock valuations right now are about a phony discount rate, not corporate profits. As the discount rate approaches reality, so too will equity, bond and real estate prices.

Invest in gold, and it just lies around doing nothing. If stocks go down, you might lose less money with gold. If a lot of people are panicking, and you manage to sell when the panic peaks, you can certainly make a big profit. But as a long term investment, gold will always suck.

No, gold preserves my purchasing power as fiat currencies get debased. I can almost guarantee my portfolio has smoked yours over the last ten years, and if not, then certainly on a risk-adjusted basis.

The underlying problem here is that there is a serious crisis of demand. There is a lot of investor money, because capital gains profits have been stellar over the last 30 years or so. But real wages have not increased much. A lot of the economic growth has been financed by debts--by the government simultaneously lowering taxes and increasing spending--but also private debts, housing loans and credit cards. With the financial crash a couple of years ago, private debts couldn't keep accelerating at the same rate. On top of that, unemployment rose sharply. Even people who still are not broke are cautious that they might lose their jobs.

I don't see a turnaround anytime soon, because there's no easy fix for the lack of demand. And politicians are not even acknowledging the problem. Best case, we could have a long, flat period, eventually seeing some growth. But this is going to hit wall street, and I'm not sure what will happen when wall street does not see any real growth for a long period. They are not used to that.

That's easy, just print more money, and give it to Wall Street. QE3, you know you want it!
 
Gold is value. It has a six-thousand year history as money. If you actually understod investing, you would understand that stock valuations right now are about a phony discount rate, not corporate profits. As the discount rate approaches reality, so too will equity, bond and real estate prices.
Gold has been utterly useless throughout most of history, it is not value at all. Adam Smith utterly debunked the "gold is value" theory. In the last decades, gold finally has some actual value in the electronics sector, but let's not overstate that.

Stock valuations in the short term are based on investors' moods and guesses. The reason why stocks gain in value over time, however, is precisely that corporates make profits. Gold never produces anything, so it does not gain value over time. The only way to make money by investing in gold is to out-guess the moods and guesses of other investors. It's purely a zero-sum game. Stocks on the other hand have a real increase in value, and on top of that there's a zero-sum game.
 
Gold has been utterly useless throughout most of history, it is not value at all. Adam Smith utterly debunked the "gold is value" theory. In the last decades, gold finally has some actual value in the electronics sector, but let's not overstate that.

Stock valuations in the short term are based on investors' moods and guesses. The reason why stocks gain in value over time, however, is precisely that corporates make profits. Gold never produces anything, so it does not gain value over time. The only way to make money by investing in gold is to out-guess the moods and guesses of other investors. It's purely a zero-sum game. Stocks on the other hand have a real increase in value, and on top of that there's a zero-sum game.

Ignorance is poverty. I'm a bit perplexed as to your extraordinarily ****** timing in hyping equities, and giving lectures on the long term suckitude of real money in light of a Dow -513 day and in spite of the blistering performance of the barberous relic, but I suppose not much surprises me these days. Buy those dips! QE to infinity and beyond.
 
Lol. Yes, government. Please prop up the phony stock market with more fiat money. Make sure you hike margin requirements on gold and silver too, to further manipulate that market. If my non-stock-owning countrymen who actually have to work for a living have to pay more for bread and milk, who cares! You and the Keynesians are *********** geniuses. Why didn't I think of that.

Bread and milk aren't costing more because of any money printing. Inflation is practically non-existent right now, and if a nice Keynesian package could be passed it would result in increased wages for the bread and milk consumers.
 
Bread and milk aren't costing more because of any money printing. Inflation is practically non-existent right now, and if a nice Keynesian package could be passed it would result in increased wages for the bread and milk consumers.

Hmm, lets see. Instead of bailing out banks, we could have handed every man, woman, and child in the US a check for $17,000. While that policy wouldn't be much less retarded than what actually happened, it would be a lot less regressive. In any case, it didn't happen, and it's not going to happen, because criminals control the printing press, and the tax system. Yet, your "solution" is more of the same.
 
They were when I last looked. Did they bounce up again? :D

No. But if Scrut didn't sell anything today, he didn't "lose" any money.

Everyone at work today was moaning about "the hit" that their 401(k)'s took. I finally asked one of them, "Did you cash out of your plan today?" They said no. "So," I asked them, "What exactly did you lose?"

They couldn't answer. They didn't seem to understand that while their 401(k) might not be worth what it was yesterday, they haven't "lost" any money unless they cash it in when it is worth less than they put into it. And only a pea-brain would do that. If you have $1000 worth of stock and the price drops to where it's only worth $500 you don't sell it then, you hang onto it until the price is somewhere above $1000. If you aren't ready to roll with the changes (and possibly get shafted in the deal, it happens), bury your money in a mason jar in the backyard.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom