My close encounters of the 9/11 "truther" kind

BStrong

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jun 14, 2011
Messages
13,087
Location
San Francisco
Mods – If this is the wrong forum I apologize, and please move to the correct location.

A little background is in order.

I’m not a scientist, engineer, architect or fireman, I wasn’t at ground zero.

What I am is an old guy who has spent his life in one sort of uniform or another for over 30 years, left the Army as an E-6 , have three MOS’s (military occupational specialty) under my belt and have served and worked in many parts of the world, including the Middle East – in order, Saudi, Lebanon, Afghanistan and Iraq. I have professional hands-on experience with all types of military explosives and explosive ordnance, both U.S. and foreign. My second MOS, 89D. denotes Explosive Ordnance Disposal qualification. I’m familiar with all types of explosive use and employment both military and civilian.

Service in the military is a long family tradition, and I have friends and family serving now in both combat and other billets world-wide.

After 9/11, the only thing I was thinking about was re-enlisting.

Both the Army and Marines turned me down – prior service related disability (hearing) The Marine recruiter was more respectful.

I was able to hire on as a contractor with Dyncorp, and worked 6 months in Afghanistan and six months in Iraq 2003-2004.

Here’s where the story starts.

When I returned in 2004, my family threw me a Welcome Home party in the spring – nice BBQ, great food, all the standard goings on.

One of the young kids in the family, the daughter of one of my cousins’ cornered me. She was attending college at the time, and to the best of my knowledge, had only been out of the CONUS on a spring break trip vacation or somesuch . She wanted to take the opportunity to inform me about the unjust war, etc. etc. contractors bad, etc. Pretty much sop for college kids in my experience. I treat such nonsense as I would my neighbor’s dog barking – annoying, but who cares?

What she also went into did surprise me – 9/11 was an “inside job.”

I managed to get her to articulate what she “knew” about this, and pretty much everything we’ve seen from truthbots over the years she got into, except her version was the hijackers were fall guys that were conned into carrying out the attacks by agents for Bush, missile hit the Pentagon, flight 93 shot-down, etc.

When she got into controlled demolition I finally had to call a time-out – I asked her if she knew what I did for a living, and what I had been doing for the last 12 months – she acknowledged that she did. I then tried to get her to explain what she knew about any type or method of controlled demolition, and what she knew about explosives. That didn’t take long. She knew nothing about either subject, but she had read on the internet…

I called cease and desist at that point. I told her what I knew about the subject matter in general, and the nature of explosives and explosive devices in particular that made her theory improbable.

She quickly lost interest, and mumbled something along the lines of being “brainwashed” by my time in the Army…

Her Dad had overheard most of the end part of the discussion, and informed me “don’t take it personal, she thinks she’s runnin’ the U.N”

First encounter with a “truther.” They assert, they get offended, they leave.

2006:

At the time I was involved in a long time relationship with a woman who was employed by an evironmental science engineering company.

They had been contracted for a job that involved the development of a subdivision that had once been a live fire artillery range, and as it turned out during the building phase, the range hadn't been cleared as had been represented during the permit phase - I hired on with that company as a consultant wrt the unexploded ordnance.

This company was/is quite successful, and the company sop was to throw parties for the staff on a regular basis.

At one of these parties, I'm introduced to the son of one of the engineers as the companies' "explosives guy" and ti's suggested that he talk to me about his "theory"

Kid - 20 something, Safeway employee, lives at home.

You can probably guess where it goes, kid is a devotee of Alex Jones...and tells me to watch the vids etc. on youtube.

I explain to him in the kindest possible way that he's fallen for a false consruction based on popular fiction reality, not real-world reality.

During the course of our conversation the kid siphons 4 beers.

He goes away unsatisified.

If it stopped here, no big deal.

Party goes on, I do a little cooking, guy talk with the boys, all sop.

Next thing I know, my girlfriend wants to leave NOW. She hustles me out of the party as fast as possible, we don't even say goodbye to everybody.

What happened? My girl won't tell me.

I get a phone call from the kid's mom apoligizing for what happened...no details, just wanted to apoligize.

I talk to my girlfriend and she spills (what turned out to be only partially) the truth.

Kid was "rude" to her, and she thought I'd hurt the kid.

I tell her that I'd hope she'd know me better than that, I'd never use force against somebody based on their rudeness or simple speech.

All as well.

I find out much later that the kid had actually taken upon himself to not only be rude to my girl, he also made some (still unspecified) direct threats against both my girl and I.

Second encounter - truther asserts, is offended, leaves, then makes threats - to a woman not even involved in the discussion.

There's a third enounter in 2010, but you folks get the idea.

Combine my first person experiences with my online encounters, and this is why I can't engage truthers in serious discussion.

The posters here that can engage in debate with these types have my admiration - I can't bring myself to give any truther even a minimum amount of respect, given their delusional beliefs, and their manner of communication.
 
What surprises me is the absolute refusal to listen to anyone with experience and credentials that doesn't agree with them.

There are many things that I don't have the foggiest idea about that are often subjects of discussion.

If I don't know anything about a subject, but am interested in it, I'll research the subect, preferably with someone I know that has expertise in the field - even then I'm more inclined to keep my mouth shut than spout off.

In the case of truthbots, it seems that the less they know, they more they spout off.
 
Mods – If this is the wrong forum I apologize, and please move to the correct location.

A little background is in order.

I’m not a scientist, engineer, architect or fireman, I wasn’t at ground zero.

What I am is an old guy who has spent his life in one sort of uniform or another for over 30 years, left the Army as an E-6 , have three MOS’s (military occupational specialty) under my belt and have served and worked in many parts of the world, including the Middle East – in order, Saudi, Lebanon, Afghanistan and Iraq. I have professional hands-on experience with all types of military explosives and explosive ordnance, both U.S. and foreign. My second MOS, 89D. denotes Explosive Ordnance Disposal qualification. I’m familiar with all types of explosive use and employment both military and civilian.

Service in the military is a long family tradition, and I have friends and family serving now in both combat and other billets world-wide.

After 9/11, the only thing I was thinking about was re-enlisting.

Both the Army and Marines turned me down – prior service related disability (hearing) The Marine recruiter was more respectful.

I was able to hire on as a contractor with Dyncorp, and worked 6 months in Afghanistan and six months in Iraq 2003-2004.

Here’s where the story starts.

When I returned in 2004, my family threw me a Welcome Home party in the spring – nice BBQ, great food, all the standard goings on.

One of the young kids in the family, the daughter of one of my cousins’ cornered me. She was attending college at the time, and to the best of my knowledge, had only been out of the CONUS on a spring break trip vacation or somesuch . She wanted to take the opportunity to inform me about the unjust war, etc. etc. contractors bad, etc. Pretty much sop for college kids in my experience. I treat such nonsense as I would my neighbor’s dog barking – annoying, but who cares?

What she also went into did surprise me – 9/11 was an “inside job.”

I managed to get her to articulate what she “knew” about this, and pretty much everything we’ve seen from truthbots over the years she got into, except her version was the hijackers were fall guys that were conned into carrying out the attacks by agents for Bush, missile hit the Pentagon, flight 93 shot-down, etc.

When she got into controlled demolition I finally had to call a time-out – I asked her if she knew what I did for a living, and what I had been doing for the last 12 months – she acknowledged that she did. I then tried to get her to explain what she knew about any type or method of controlled demolition, and what she knew about explosives. That didn’t take long. She knew nothing about either subject, but she had read on the internet…

I called cease and desist at that point. I told her what I knew about the subject matter in general, and the nature of explosives and explosive devices in particular that made her theory improbable.

She quickly lost interest, and mumbled something along the lines of being “brainwashed” by my time in the Army…

Her Dad had overheard most of the end part of the discussion, and informed me “don’t take it personal, she thinks she’s runnin’ the U.N”

First encounter with a “truther.” They assert, they get offended, they leave.

2006:

At the time I was involved in a long time relationship with a woman who was employed by an evironmental science engineering company.

They had been contracted for a job that involved the development of a subdivision that had once been a live fire artillery range, and as it turned out during the building phase, the range hadn't been cleared as had been represented during the permit phase - I hired on with that company as a consultant wrt the unexploded ordnance.

This company was/is quite successful, and the company sop was to throw parties for the staff on a regular basis.

At one of these parties, I'm introduced to the son of one of the engineers as the companies' "explosives guy" and ti's suggested that he talk to me about his "theory"

Kid - 20 something, Safeway employee, lives at home.

You can probably guess where it goes, kid is a devotee of Alex Jones...and tells me to watch the vids etc. on youtube.

I explain to him in the kindest possible way that he's fallen for a false consruction based on popular fiction reality, not real-world reality.

During the course of our conversation the kid siphons 4 beers.

He goes away unsatisified.

If it stopped here, no big deal.

Party goes on, I do a little cooking, guy talk with the boys, all sop.

Next thing I know, my girlfriend wants to leave NOW. She hustles me out of the party as fast as possible, we don't even say goodbye to everybody.

What happened? My girl won't tell me.

I get a phone call from the kid's mom apoligizing for what happened...no details, just wanted to apoligize.

I talk to my girlfriend and she spills (what turned out to be only partially) the truth.

Kid was "rude" to her, and she thought I'd hurt the kid.

I tell her that I'd hope she'd know me better than that, I'd never use force against somebody based on their rudeness or simple speech.

All as well.

I find out much later that the kid had actually taken upon himself to not only be rude to my girl, he also made some (still unspecified) direct threats against both my girl and I.

Second encounter - truther asserts, is offended, leaves, then makes threats - to a woman not even involved in the discussion.

There's a third enounter in 2010, but you folks get the idea.

Combine my first person experiences with my online encounters, and this is why I can't engage truthers in serious discussion.

The posters here that can engage in debate with these types have my admiration - I can't bring myself to give any truther even a minimum amount of respect, given their delusional beliefs, and their manner of communication.

If you look across the forum and the internet you'll find that that pattern holds for any True Believer in anything be it 911 conspiracy, UFO's, gods, pre-cog dreaming just to name a few. The reason is when a person has found the TruthTM they can only conceive that

a. you haven't heard the TruthTM or

b. you have heard it but choose to deny it.

They simply can't grasp that they could be wrong.

How they react depends on their personality type, some will wistfully consign you to hell, others will get mad and aggressive and start accusing you of being an agent of the Devil or a paid shill of Big Gov, the NWO, or whatever their particular bogeyman is.
 
I have no expertise other than that i am a long time study of these kinds of scams and hustles as my step-father who raised me was into all the "woo" of the past. I'm with ya on this one... I thought i was almost alone here in feeling this way.

I have had similar situations as yours, over and over with these conspiracy kooks every time i've encountered them. I even have one of them, a guy i barely knew, who has been stalking me, threatening me and harassing me for 3 years now because I didn't let him force his "truth" on me when he went into a drunken, insulting rant one day about 911 trying to convert me.

I can not bring myself either to give any respect to them as i find what they do so offensive and foul on so many levels.

For sure, there are many here have far more patience then I.
 
Last edited:
.........Combine my first person experiences with my online encounters, and this is why I can't engage truthers in serious discussion.

The posters here that can engage in debate with these types have my admiration - I can't bring myself to give any truther even a minimum amount of respect, given their delusional beliefs, and their manner of communication.


I can relate although I have yet to meet in person a real 9/11 truther. What got me started on this whole thing was a few remarks my adult son (age 30 at the time) made in 2007. That was the first and last time he ever talked about it with me. I didn't even know there was any controversy about 9/11 at the time although I had vaguely been interested about something I had heard concerning the much exaggerated Flight 93 debris field but assuming it had been shot down if true was no big deal to me.

But over 4 years later I have become increasingly impatient with some truthers, especially when they regurgitate issues that are hot buttons to me. For instance, the Lone Ranger poster when he threw out the missing $2.3 trillion nonsense of 9/10/2001, and even after he was shown documentation that those facts had been discussed publicly previous to that date, he still considered it to be a factor in the inside job. More recently in the Reasonable Doubt thread when the first item mentioned was Lloyde England's "virtual confession" - well, I just don't have what it takes to be respectful of any member of JREF who believes that video presented a "confession", much less take an active part in such a discussion. I'm happy and proud of those who can and do because someone still needs to address the lies and craziness for the benefit of all of the new impressionables just coming to the internet.
 
Tomorrow I'm going to ask permisson from the participant to tell his story of a truther encounter, one based more on comedy than anything else - I'll give you a preview, look up the old comedy routine "Niagara Falls" or "Slowly I turned" - I wasn't there, but the story as I was told it is funny beyond words.
 
Last edited:
My encounters have been in the university and might be considered something like "truther lite." There's one guy I was friends with who was taking classes with me in fall 2008 who believed flight 93 was shot down but not due to some bizarre cover up (he didn't believe in the CD theory either). He's quite a bit older than me; I'm 24 almost, he's easily in his 60's, very nice guy though.

Second instance was in my universities' old gaming room in 2009 (they've since converted it into a Chili's food area). One guy believed that the media manipulated footage of the planes hitting the towers... When I asked if he thought no planes were used, he said no... bizarrely. He claimed that for some unknown reason the media just manipulated the video footage.

Third time is with a friend of mine earlier this year who thinks the thermite experiment videos by "Cole" show a practical means of getting thermite into the buildings and claims it's possible for it to have been used but thinks the controlled demolition ideas themselves are bone **** crazy.

Gotta say, my own encounters were kinda weird to say the least..
 
I came across some of the earliest truther stuff online not long after 9/11, when I was looking for information about the structure (used to be a structural engineer). There was a site which now seems to be gone (might have been on geocities?) where they laid out a pretty comprehensive "theory" of the day's events. One of their more bizarre claims was that the tower floors were not actually supported by long span bar joist trusses, but by hefty steel beams. It later became known as the "no truss theory", which never seemed to gain much steam. Their "analysis" of the tower structure was one of the more humorous things I've seen.

As for truthers in person, I think the only one I've come across was one of my son's HS (14 year old) classmates. We had to give him a ride home one day, and he started talking about how people heard explosives in the WTC during the collapse, and how it couldn't have collapsed without being intentionally demolished, etc. I just winked at my son, shook my head, and kept driving.

BStrong, thank you for your service. Your family is brave as well to endure you being in such danger time and again. :)
 
...
In the case of truthbots, it seems that the less they know, they more they spout off.

Case in point: tmd. Is currently more prolific than any truther I have seen here in a long while; at the same time fails much more catastrophically at everything he lays his hand at than most.
 
Only life truther interaction to date was with my autistic Nephew a few years back. he started on about CDs etc and I put him straight (I'm the clever uncle who does all the cool high tech jobs and hobbies) and advised him to be very careful with what he believes on the internet. I think I snipped it in the bud with him as he has never mentioned it since and he is not as gullible now as he used to be.

There were some at the "march to restore Sanity" last year (ironic or what!) and I was tempted to have fun with them but I had a long drive home and they were not getting much attention anyway.
 
I came across some of the earliest truther stuff online not long after 9/11, when I was looking for information about the structure (used to be a structural engineer). There was a site which now seems to be gone (might have been on geocities?) where they laid out a pretty comprehensive "theory" of the day's events. One of their more bizarre claims was that the tower floors were not actually supported by long span bar joist trusses, but by hefty steel beams. It later became known as the "no truss theory", which never seemed to gain much steam. Their "analysis" of the tower structure was one of the more humorous things I've seen.

As for truthers in person, I think the only one I've come across was one of my son's HS (14 year old) classmates. We had to give him a ride home one day, and he started talking about how people heard explosives in the WTC during the collapse, and how it couldn't have collapsed without being intentionally demolished, etc. I just winked at my son, shook my head, and kept driving.

BStrong, thank you for your service. Your family is brave as well to endure you being in such danger time and again. :)

Thanks for the kind words.

Oystein - you're one of the posters I refered to in my op - you present a clear point of discussion when engaging the truthbots.

Salud.
 
This reminds me of something several months ago, when I was visiting a friend of mine I hadn't talked to in a long time. This is a guy I've known since high school (19 years ago), and I'd say he's one of my best friends. He was about to start in on a CD spiel regarding the WTC, and I just said flat out "if you continue this conversation, I will just go home."
I then suggested he look for the annotated "Loose Change" video (the one with the corrections of course) and I haven't heard any Truther nonsense from him since.
 
I didn't really know much about the twoofers until a couple years ago. I knew there were conspiracy theories but I didn't pay any attention to them. In summer 09 I started a new job and had my first encounter with a true woo supporter. Every September I wear my "Never Forget" pin with the towers on them, one guy I worked with and considered a friend began spewing no-planer crap at me, he was relentless. He blatantly accused me of lying, that I wasn't there and didn't see a plane. He harassed me constantly, posted truther propaganda in my mailbox and never left me alone at work. It got so bad I felt like quitting my job, luckily he left first. He knows where I live and still bothers me occasionally, he doesn't come to my home regularly like he used to and I see no reason why I should move house just because of some insane idiot.
 
Dash80 said:
He knows where I live and still bothers me occasionally, he doesn't come to my home regularly like he used to and I see no reason why I should move house just because of some insane idiot.
Dash, what does he say when he comes by your house? I mean, why has he zeroed in on you to harass? because you where there? Does he think you are just going to blurt out that you are a paid government shill? :boggled:
 
What surprises me is the absolute refusal to listen to anyone with experience and credentials that doesn't agree with them.

There are many things that I don't have the foggiest idea about that are often subjects of discussion.

If I don't know anything about a subject, but am interested in it, I'll research the subect, preferably with someone I know that has expertise in the field - even then I'm more inclined to keep my mouth shut than spout off.

In the case of truthbots, it seems that the less they know, they more they spout off.
It'a a matter of being closed to information that contradicts what they believe, and want to believe, it's quite common with woosters of all types; biblical literalist xians don't want to know about the errors and contradictions in the bible, believers in homeopathy don't embrace studies that show it doesn't work, holocaust deniers actively avoid facts about the holocaust, et cetera, et cetera.
 
The first introduction I had to truther BS was via the Pentacon video (I think that's what it was called at least); an online friend had seen it and wanted my opinion on it, since she considered me more in the know due to being in the military. I watched it all the way through and came back and told her it was stupid beyond words; bear in mind this was at a time when I wasn't as well versed in the various "theories" out there, but even then, without knowing what I know now, I could see the ridiculous claims for what they were. I'll admit that there were some things in the video I wondered about, and that's what got me started on searching info, which eventually led me here. All my questions were being answered here, and I was able to determine that all 9/11 CT's were pretty much bunk thanks to the more knowledgeable posters here. I've stayed for the company, but 9/11 CT's no longer occupy as much of my time as they used to; pretty much every question there is has been asked and answered, and it gets tiresome debunking the same nonsense over and over again.
 
It'a a matter of being closed to information that contradicts what they believe, and want to believe, it's quite common with woosters of all types; biblical literalist xians don't want to know about the errors and contradictions in the bible, believers in homeopathy don't embrace studies that show it doesn't work, holocaust deniers actively avoid facts about the holocaust, et cetera, et cetera.

In discussions of creationist woo, true believers' inability to even recognize contrary information has been given a Name: "Morton's Demon."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom