....since anyone who actually uiderstands statistics can see that no correlation exists, why don't we givre up trying to fix the economy by manipulating the tax code, and instead use the tax code to raise the money that we need to pay the bills....
Because it can't raise enough money, and because it's broke and needs to be completely redone.
There is certainly a correlative signal, but to extract it you'd have to normalize five or ten time series each with a tax change midway and examine compared to a similar number of time series with no tax change midway to see what relation emerged.
Certainly, taking a complex multifactorial real world situation and claiming that a change in variable A leads to a change in B gets the student in Statistics 101 an "F".
The reason you cannot
"use the tax code to raise the money you need to pay the bills" is that the deficit is way in excess of entire revenue from 1040 returns and is increasing.
1040 revenue is about $1T, and the deficit is $1.5T or so. A few percentage points change in collected tax would do what? Say 3% increase in collections. Since the CBO assumes an 8% increase in spending each year or about 400B, that 3% does no good at all.
Want to insure a change of administrations? Increase tax across the board 20%. That gets you $200B and that absorbs only HALF OF THE PROJECTED YEARLY INCREASE. Keep in mind that this presumes the Bush tax cuts expire. So in this case, future year new borrowing is 1.5T, 1.7T, 1.9T, 2.1T, 2.3T cumulated to
1.5T, 3.2T, 5.1T, 7.3T, 9.6T
added to 15T current and rounding
17, 18, 20, 22, 25T
Interest on these new amounts may be assumed to be something like...
2, 3, 4, 4, 4%
Interest only payment is...
340B, 540B, 800B, 880B, 1000B
And bingo....interest only is equal to entire stream of 1040 revenue.
That's checkmate.
Basically this means that there will be a correction in the spending, either planned and legislated or through a zeroing out of remaining value in the money supply. In either case, your argument about fixing things by raising taxes is rather moot.
It's pretty important to keep a real world frame of reference on the scale of the spending and the revenue, otherwise incorrect conclusions are reached.
This is pretty much a classic business work out or bankruptcy type situation. The ability to print money doesn't change that, you just have Gresham's Law in effect in the early stages, then Thier's law in the later stages.
Five years of increasing problems, ten years to fix back to a new type of normalcy. That's what I think we are looking at here.