USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

So, how is that "loss of AAA rating is all the evil Republicans' fault" thingy going? Anybody falling for that? No?

It would be slightly more believable if it weren't blindingly obvious Mr. "compromise and bi-partisanship" Obama had only discovered how "compromise" is a good thing after he lost his ability to ram things through congress after the midterm elections.
 
So, how is that "loss of AAA rating is all the evil Republicans' fault" thingy going? Anybody falling for that? No?

It would be slightly more believable if it weren't blindingly obvious Mr. "compromise and bi-partisanship" Obama had only discovered how "compromise" is a good thing after he lost his ability to ram things through congress after the midterm elections.
Given that the Republicans rejected their own plan and report that called for tax rate increases (see page 8 there sparky), yeah, it's their fault.

They were going to bring tax rate cuts to the table and it would have been a means to get more spending cuts. They didn't.
 
Last edited:
It helps to remember that inflation rates were in double digits during the first few years Reagan was in office. When corrected for inflation, tax revenues during this period show a rather clear dip.

Only at the very beginning of Reagan's term, before he turned the economy around and lowered inflation rates.

Here's a chart (from http://www.heritage.org/research/re...yths-about-taxes-spending-and-budget-deficits ) that shows inflation adjusted (i.e., real) tax revenues during that time:

http://www.heritage.org/static/reportimages/CA3A2E8DA1F365A2820416F00109FC10.gif?w=365&h=233&as=1

As you can see, revenues (in constant 2000 dollars) dipped from about $1.1 trillion to about $1.0 trillion from the start of the 1981 recession to mid-1983 … a 9-10 percent drop. But from then on they increased. Rather dramatically. It helps to keep that in mind too. ;)
 
As you can see, revenues (in constant 2000 dollars) dipped from about $1.1 trillion to about $1.0 trillion from the start of the 1981 recession to mid-1983 … a 9-10 percent drop. But from then on they increased. Rather dramatically. It helps to keep that in mind too. ;)
IIRC, about the time Regan raised taxes.
 
IIRC, about the time Regan raised taxes.

I sure wish you could learn to spell Reagan. It's not that hard.

And as noted to you previously, the recession began in July of 1981. Reagan cut taxes in August 1981. That's what turned the recession around. It wasn't until September 1982, when the recession was almost over, that he raised taxes. By then, the economy was already gearing up for a major expansion. There's an interesting table here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics , which sums up the effect of the various tax measures during the Reagan years, and shows that indeed, all told, the tax burden was reduced significantly by Reagan. So raising taxes a little is NOT what got the economy going. And the economy didn't fall back into recession (as it is now doing under Obama) when Reagan did finally increase certain taxes because the amount of those taxes ($214 billion over the next five years) was small potatoes in an economy that would grow over $1.5 TRILLION in that same 5 year period. And as also pointed out to you, there were a lot of other factors that led to the optimism that resulted in large GDP growth during the Reagan years. One is that, unlike Obama, he inspired small businesses … which generates the bulk of jobs in our economy. Another is that the US still was the world's leader in many technologies, including much of the electronic and software industry. That was the basis of the growth that even raising taxes could not depress. Whereas, we don't have that luxury now because what is our product? All that leftist universities have been churning out are Hollywood producers, actors, community activists, lawyers and leftists with political aspirations of making things *fair*. :rolleyes:
 
I sure wish you could learn to spell Reagan. It's not that hard.

And as noted to you previously, the recession began in July of 1981. Reagan cut taxes in August 1981. That's what turned the recession around. It wasn't until September 1982, when the recession was almost over, that he raised taxes. By then, the economy was already gearing up for a major expansion. There's an interesting table here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics , which sums up the effect of the various tax measures during the Reagan years, and shows that indeed, all told, the tax burden was reduced significantly by Reagan. So raising taxes a little is NOT what got the economy going. And the economy didn't fall back into recession (as it is now doing under Obama) when Reagan did finally increase certain taxes because the amount of those taxes ($214 billion over the next five years) was small potatoes in an economy that would grow over $1.5 TRILLION in that same 5 year period. And as also pointed out to you, there were a lot of other factors that led to the optimism that resulted in large GDP growth during the Reagan years. One is that, unlike Obama, he inspired small businesses … which generates the bulk of jobs in our economy. Another is that the US still was the world's leader in many technologies, including much of the electronic and software industry. That was the basis of the growth that even raising taxes could not depress. Whereas, we don't have that luxury now because what is our product? All that leftist universities have been churning out are Hollywood producers, actors, community activists, lawyers and leftists with political aspirations of making things *fair*. :rolleyes:

Reagan also dramatically increased spending (by 25 percent in 2 years). On what basis do you attribute the turn around in the recession to tax cuts? Might the increased spending have played a role? What about the decline in oil prices? And the policies of the Fed, which dropped interest rates after inflation was under control? When did the full impact of the Reagan tax cuts take effect? Was it before or after the end of the recession?

Not that tax cuts can't provide some economic stimulus on their own, but the tax cuts generally have a lower bang for the buck than does increased spending because people don't necessarily spend their tax cuts. Recoveries from downturns happen because demand increases, not because people have more money in their savings accounts.
 
Reagan also dramatically increased spending (by 25 percent in 2 years).

As I've noted many times previously on this forum, the sort of spending that Reagan increased was of a completely different character than the sort of spending Obama has increased. That different character is perhaps why Reagan's economy was not crippled by spending, but Obama's has been. :D

On what basis do you attribute the turn around in the recession to tax cuts? Might the increased spending have played a role?

Well, if you are claiming that government spending is the solution to economic growth, why hasn't it worked now? Why didn't it work for Hoover and FDR? That being the case, do you suppose that the fact that Reagan's term saw great economic growth is due to something other than any increase in government spending? ;)

Not that tax cuts can't provide some economic stimulus on their own, but the tax cuts generally have a lower bang for the buck than does increased spending

This is simply not true. What will it take for liberals to learn this lesson?

I have challenged folks of your persuasion to provide an example of a past recession that was deep, where the recovery wasn't dramatic and fast, even if the leader didn't increase government spending and taxes which you are claiming would hasten the recovery. You haven't. Claiming Reagan increased spending and taxes in the face of his recession as the cause of his recovery does not address that challenge. Not at all. Perhaps if Reagan had done nothing, the pace of recovery in his recession would still have been dramatic and fast. Because there are numerous historical examples (that I've already pointed out previously) where deep recessions recovered rapidly even without additional government spending and taxes. The data supports me, not you.
 
During the 1980s, two things happened that are often overlooked by those who wish to credit tax policy with any sort of economic improvement.

First, the microprocessor revolution got into full swing, resulting in huge productivity gains, especially in the area of industrial automation. Second, the early 1980s was period that saw a huge transition of women from home to work, which meant a dramatic increase in the workforce population even though there was no such growth in the overall population.

These two things together meant more people working, and each worker producing more.

Of course the economy grew. How could it not?

I challenge anyone to provide any meaningful correlation between any aspect of tax policy in the United States and any macroeconomic variable. Any aspect of tax policy would include income tax rates, capital gains tax rates, marginal tax rates, estate tax rates, or anything else that says how or how much taxation occurs. Macroeconomic variables would include GDP, unemployment, inflation, interest rates, changes in any of those, or any of the other statistics generally used to measure the collective health of the US economy. You can't do it, because there simply is no correlation.

You can cherry pick data and say that after this or that president raised or lowered taxes the economy got better or worse, but I can turn around and show you a different case where a different president did the same thing, and the results were opposite, or where a different president had the same result, but with completely different tax policies. We talk a lot about this stuff, but the data shows that the state of the economy has almost no relation to what the IRS is doing to us at any given time.

And if I'm wrong, prove it. It's simple data. Show it. I've asked for it often enough, and looked for it often enough, to convince me that it doesn't exist, but all you have to do is show me one such statistic, and you can prove me wrong.

Sadly, though, politicians will continue to claim that they have some sort of magic bullet that will jumpstart the economy, and incredibly, people will vote for them, especially if they are promising something for nothing.

So, since anyone who actually understands statistics can see that no correlation exists, why don't we give up trying to fix the economy by manipulating the tax code, and instead use the tax code to raise the money that we need to pay the bills. If we did that, maybe the world might have a little bit more confidence that we won't default on the debt.
 
As I've noted many times previously on this forum, the sort of spending that Reagan increased was of a completely different character than the sort of spending Obama has increased. That different character is perhaps why Reagan's economy was not crippled by spending, but Obama's has been. :D

Is that the best reply you can come up with? Reagan's spending had a "different character"? Because he was building ships and planes that would never be used in a war? LOL!!! Maybe the fact that the personal debt-to-income ratio was much higher in 2008 than in 1981 had something to do with why the economy is slower to rebound. Maybe it was because the 1981 recession was generated by the Fed's efforts to tame the double-digit inflation rather than a near-collapse of the entire banking system had something to do with the faster rebound in the 1980's.

Well, if you are claiming that government spending is the solution to economic growth, why hasn't it worked now? Why didn't it work for Hoover and FDR? That being the case, do you suppose that the fact that Reagan's term saw great economic growth is due to something other than any increase in government spending? ;)

Actually, it did work for Hoover and FDR. Though even FDR didn't fully buy into Keynesian economics until the recession of 1937. And Obama's limited stimulus program did have some benefits. But I guess that you didn't learn this from Fox News. The first 2 countries to try to stimulate their economies with increased spending during the Great Depression were Sweden and Germany. The first 2 countries to emerge from the Great Depression were Sweden and Germany.

Meanwhile, you have yet to present any evidence that the tax cuts rather than the increased spending was the driving force behind growth in the 1980's. The big decrease in taxes during the Reagan Administration, as the numbers you posted a few days ago showed, didn't occur until FY2003. This was after the recession was over. So to claim that the tax cuts were the prime cause that the recession ended needs some explaining.

This is simply not true. What will it take for liberals to learn this lesson?

Sure it is. I explained why it is. Maybe it's too complicated for you. Just like you can't figure out why looking at raw annual tax revenues without adjusting for inflation and population growth is meaningless. Or maybe you have data that shows that people spend all of their tax cuts rather than saving any of the money. Or using the money to pay off debts.

I have challenged folks of your persuasion to provide an example of a past recession that was deep, where the recovery wasn't dramatic and fast, even if the leader didn't increase government spending and taxes which you are claiming would hasten the recovery. You haven't. Claiming Reagan increased spending and taxes in the face of his recession as the cause of his recovery does not address that challenge. Not at all. Perhaps if Reagan had done nothing, the pace of recovery in his recession would still have been dramatic and fast. Because there are numerous historical examples (that I've already pointed out previously) where deep recessions recovered rapidly even without additional government spending and taxes. The data supports me, not you.

I've never said that raising taxes hastens the recovery. I've even said that tax cuts can provide some stimulus during recessions. Really, your inability to understand even simple points is amazing. However, I do find your new claim that govt. actions don't effect the recovery from recessions to be interesting. This seems to conflict with your earlier claim that Reagan's tax cuts ended the 1981-2 recession.

Hoover's 2+ years of doing nothing sure helped during the Great Depression, didn't it? The GDP started moving in a positive direction after Hoover took some small steps and FDR took some larger steps. Just a coincidence, I'm sure.

Let us know when you win the Nobel Prize in economics!
 
Last edited:
.....However, I do find your new claim that govt. actions don't effect the recovery from recessions to be interesting. ....
They won't effect "a recovery" this time. There are structural changes in effect, ending with a 40% reduction in spending.
 
....since anyone who actually uiderstands statistics can see that no correlation exists, why don't we givre up trying to fix the economy by manipulating the tax code, and instead use the tax code to raise the money that we need to pay the bills....
Because it can't raise enough money, and because it's broke and needs to be completely redone.

There is certainly a correlative signal, but to extract it you'd have to normalize five or ten time series each with a tax change midway and examine compared to a similar number of time series with no tax change midway to see what relation emerged.

Certainly, taking a complex multifactorial real world situation and claiming that a change in variable A leads to a change in B gets the student in Statistics 101 an "F".

The reason you cannot "use the tax code to raise the money you need to pay the bills" is that the deficit is way in excess of entire revenue from 1040 returns and is increasing.

1040 revenue is about $1T, and the deficit is $1.5T or so. A few percentage points change in collected tax would do what? Say 3% increase in collections. Since the CBO assumes an 8% increase in spending each year or about 400B, that 3% does no good at all.

Want to insure a change of administrations? Increase tax across the board 20%. That gets you $200B and that absorbs only HALF OF THE PROJECTED YEARLY INCREASE. Keep in mind that this presumes the Bush tax cuts expire. So in this case, future year new borrowing is 1.5T, 1.7T, 1.9T, 2.1T, 2.3T cumulated to

1.5T, 3.2T, 5.1T, 7.3T, 9.6T

added to 15T current and rounding

17, 18, 20, 22, 25T

Interest on these new amounts may be assumed to be something like...

2, 3, 4, 4, 4%

Interest only payment is...

340B, 540B, 800B, 880B, 1000B

And bingo....interest only is equal to entire stream of 1040 revenue.

That's checkmate.

Basically this means that there will be a correction in the spending, either planned and legislated or through a zeroing out of remaining value in the money supply. In either case, your argument about fixing things by raising taxes is rather moot.

It's pretty important to keep a real world frame of reference on the scale of the spending and the revenue, otherwise incorrect conclusions are reached.

This is pretty much a classic business work out or bankruptcy type situation. The ability to print money doesn't change that, you just have Gresham's Law in effect in the early stages, then Thier's law in the later stages.

Five years of increasing problems, ten years to fix back to a new type of normalcy. That's what I think we are looking at here.
 
Last edited:
Because it can't raise enough money, and because it's broke and needs to be completely redone.

I, personally, don't want to get into the question of whether tax increases or spending cuts or some combination is what is required to balance the budget. That wasn't my point. My point was that instead of trying to set tax policy based on some attempt to manipulate the economy by moving money around between public and private sectors, we should use the tax code to collect money to pay the bills. If the bills are really too high to do that, then lower the bills. (I don't accept that premise, but for the sake of argument, I'll go along. If you just can't get from here to balance without spending cuts, then certainly I want spending cuts.)


There is certainly a correlative signal, but to extract it you'd have to normalize five or ten time series each with a tax change midway and examine compared to a similar number of time series with no tax change midway to see what relation emerged.

There certainly is a correlative signal, but no one can actually find it?

I understand that I can't just pull up charts from wikipedia and point to it. However, guys who write PhD theses for their Economics degrees have access to lots of data, lots of statistical theory, and lots of computer time. If that "correlative signal" were present, they would have found it. They haven't. It isn't.

Note: There are short term effects. Any changes that are too sudden can muck up the works temporarily. I've seen those papers. They make sense and they are supported with data. However, in the long run, it just doesn't matter to the overall state of the economy.
 
Want to insure a change of administrations? Increase tax across the board 20%. That gets you $200B and that absorbs only HALF OF THE PROJECTED YEARLY INCREASE. Keep in mind that this presumes the Bush tax cuts expire. So in this case, future year new borrowing is 1.5T, 1.7T, 1.9T, 2.1T, 2.3T cumulated to
And the capacity for revenue? What is the measure of capacity? Isn't it GDP? What percentage of GDP is our debt?
 
.....certainly is a correlative signal, but no one can actually find it?

I understand that I can't just pull up charts from wikipedia and point to it. However, guys who write PhD theses for their Economics degrees have access to lots of data, lots of statistical theory, and lots of computer time. If that "correlative signal" were present, they would have found it. They haven't. It isn't......
I don't know that to be a fact, but I do know it would vary with different types of taxes. And there are many.

For example, I am confident we could show a correlation between excise tax rate on alcohol, as collected by the ATF, and total revenue collections.

I know that the issue is far more difficult with:

  • individual tax rates
  • capital gains tax rates
  • corporate tax rates
I also know that the basic economic forecast I provided in the last post is not materially affected by tax rates (EG it isn't 'highly sensitive' to tax rate changes).

NOTE: Previously I linked to a mid 1980s CBO study on the effects of raising or lowering the capital gains tax. Here's another from 2005:

.....Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released a paper called "Analyzing the Economic and Budgetary Effects of a 10 Percent Cut in Income Tax Rates". This paper considered the impact of a stylized reduction of 10% in the then existing marginal rate of federal income tax in the US .....[4]​
 
Last edited:
NOTE: Previously I linked to a mid 1980s CBO study on the effects of raising or lowering the capital gains tax. Here's another from 2005:


Here's a line from the introduction of that paper:

Because there is
little consensus on exactly how tax cuts affect the
economy, CBO based its analysis...

In other words, there's no actual date to support any of the assumptions, but we hope that the following is true.

There isn't any connection. Economic growth can occur with high taxes. Economic growth can occur with low taxes. If there were a connection, those PhD papers would cite the data that demonstrates the connection. They haven't. There isn't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom