God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

One at a time, if you don't want to appear foolish, unintelligent.


That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, and with Russell's teapot, when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence, they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.


And please oh please don't bring in parallel universes which we have no access to and they to us, and also they according to our fantastic but fake astrophysicists with sleight of the hand math have their each one peculiar to themselves only, laws of physics.


You ask: "So, now that I have accepted your proposition of a being who created this universe but is not contained by it what next? Where do we go from here?"


Where did I say that God is not contained in the universe according to my concept of the universe?


What I maintain is that God is a part and parcel of the universe and also transcendent to the universe.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, do more serious thinking, for example, do you see that the air in our biosphere is a part and parcel of your house and also is transcendent to your house?

As a matter of fact, for my own insight God in one state of his existence is identical to the universe, so that the universe in that state of God's existence is convertible with God.

You cannot comprehend that? Well, that is because you are self-blindered by an un-comprehending brain.




Yrreg

There's a god part sticking into the universe?
 
Distill your thoughts into one tough objection instead of so much useless prattle.


Try to see the biggest view of incompatibility among the components in my concept of God as namely:

The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.
​

Here, do it this way:

The
maker
of
everything
in
the
universe
that
is
not
God Himself.
​

See any word that in its conceptual import excludes any other word in its conceptual import?




Yrreg

Hilighted.
 
No evidence to the blind or with blindered eyes.


Tell me if you do ever have sired a baby, isn't the baby evidence of a father?



But you forgive me never seemed to have ever sired a baby, what with your faith in karma and reincarnation and nirvana which are all into never mama.



See, you guys are always into evasions, I am asking you guys to put the question of God's existence in abeyance, until we have come to agreement on a common concept of God.

But as is your routine of evasions, you run into the bush of demanding the proof of God's existence.


How illogical on your part, when we have not yet come to any agreed on concept of God.

That will be just into talking past each other's heads, and that has always been your trick or limitation of mental grasp on how to think productively.


You have noticed that your brethren who are fake astrophysicists are into parallel universes, which parallel universes cannot have access to us and neither we to them, and they are each into their own peculiar laws of physics, when they these fake astrophysicists with their sleight of the hand math should have just kept to the universe if they have any idea of honesty to reality where we are living in and are part and parcel of.

How evasive or naively limited in their capacity for logical thinking but not of deceit even just self-deceit.




Yrreg

Ok

God = man made concept.
 
Now, suppose you tell me where I said that the big bang is God?



And by the way, "It is a fact that there are foolish and unintelligent humans, yes, no?"


And if I call some posters here atheists that is as being foolish and unintelligent, it is in reference to their thinking about God or no God.

Or are you so absolutely certain that atheists are not all foolish and unintelligent in their thinking on the issue of God or no God, i.e. in their concepts of God and also in their practice of rational logical intelligent productive thinking?

That is your prerogative, but your prerogative is no reason why others do not also have the reciprocal and counter prerogative to think otherwise.


Okay, you can call me also foolish and unintelligent, if that is going to help you feel better.


I would not mind at all as to gripe if you put it an nth time in your next post that my ideas are foolish and unintelligent; because I know the worth of my ideas on the basis of non-foolishness and intelligence, and no one has convinced me otherwise, except etc.



Okay, let's all calm down, just call me foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your evaluation of my ideas, to get even with my evaluating you as foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your ideas.

But let us not sink to the depth of saying that someone is speaking through his a-hole.

Or calling someone a jackass.


Okay, no more will I use the words foolish and unintelligent on atheists, but I will just say you are naive and disingenuous; okay? when I see that your ideas are to my analysis naive and disingenuous.




Now, back to business: so, tell me where I said that the big bang is God?





Yrreg

I agree totally, I'd no more think of calling someone a jackass than I'd think to call them a bumfussling fool or a bloviating blowhard.
 
In other words ... the unique masks and personas a person can wear and display that the arena of the internet provides ?

If so ... I find the best place to begin is with a person's username and avatar:) It's says a lot I think ... and can be very telling :), esp in light of what they may or may not claim about themselves ...

The illusion of anonymity comforts a person's dissonance who creates a facade :)

Whatever masks we wear it's the contents of our posts that defines us.
 
That is most gentlemanly on your part, dlorde; yes let us proceed further.



At the cost of being accused of repetitiousness, let me just the same repeat the concept of God and the concept of the universe from yours truly, which you dlorde have agreed to accept for the purpose of this exercise, to prove the existence of God from the fact of the existence of the universe as evidence.

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

​


Okay, here we go, into the expedition to find evidence in the universe pointing to the existence of God corresponding to the concept as maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


The nose of man is a part and parcel of the universe, can you agree with me on that?




Yrreg



That was my post, yrreg. I was responding to dlorde, but the bulk of the post, including the agreement to use your definition of god (purely for the sake of moving this discussion along) was me. It even gives my name as the quoted poster.

I think the confusion here comes from how you quote multiple posts. It throws me off sometimes, too.



Thanks, I'm trying to follow your masterful example.


A 'possible concept' ? what does that mean in this context? Are you saying an actual entity cannot come into existence unless it's existence is possible?

Is God an actual entity?


More thinking - you are indeed a hard task master.


It sounds like he's gearing up for an bastard child of the ontological argument. We can conceive of something he defines as god, therefore the Christian god exists.





Now, yrreg. Some of us here have agreed to use your definition of god for the sake of argument. Can you please proceed to the next part of your script argument? Don't spend all your time raging at those who don't toe your party line. Just get on with your point.






ETA

And we're back to the nose. Can a penis be far behind?

I think it's already here:

There's a god part sticking into the universe?


Next thing you know, god will by masturbating guiltlessly. Or maybe that's where we came from. Would explain a lot...






P.S. One final thing caught my eye.

Where did I say that God is not contained in the universe according to my concept of the universe?

Weak Kitten said god was not contained by the universe, yrreg. Her definition is fully compatible with yours. Now get to the point, already!
 
Last edited:
That is what I notice time and again with atheists, they are either foolish or unintelligent, wanting to go into all kinds of objections against Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, and with Russell's teapot, when if they were possessed of a bit of practical wisdom and common intelligence, they should go to the God of Christians in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, that one where we who are into the issue of God or not God are living in and are part and parcel of.


You have failed to provide any evidence that there is more reason to believe in "the God of Christians" than to believe in any other Gods, gods, goddesses, divinities, deities, spaghettis, unicorns, tooth fairies, or Russell's teapot.

You have provided no evidence that your God is anything more than a fiction.
 
How about the concept of God in Pastafarianism:
The Flying Spaghetti Monster is the maker of everything in the universe that is not The Flying Spaghetti Monster Himself.​
All hail the FSM.
fsm_glee.gif
 
You see, reality is made up of two things: potential entities and actual entities.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.

Yrreg

Potential entities make up no part of reality.

Any concept (idea formed in the mind) is possible and has nothing to do with whether entities come into existence.
 
Now, suppose you tell me where I said that the big bang is God?
Here:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​
That describes the Big Bang. Does your god have other properties that we should know about?

And by the way, "It is a fact that there are foolish and unintelligent humans, yes, no?"
Is that the subject of this thread?

And if I call some posters here atheists that is as being foolish and unintelligent, it is in reference to their thinking about God or no God.
No, it is because you have no logical arguments to make that you become frustrated and descend to the level of attacking the arguer.

Or are you so absolutely certain that atheists are not all foolish and unintelligent in their thinking on the issue of God or no God, i.e. in their concepts of God and also in their practice of rational logical intelligent productive thinking?
No, I'm not certain that all atheists have used logic to arrive at their lack of belief in your favorite god. I am certain that you did not use logic to arrive at your belief in your favorite god. That's why you attack the arguer and not the argument rather than using logic to counter their arguments.

That is your prerogative, but your prerogative is no reason why others do not also have the reciprocal and counter prerogative to think otherwise.
You certainly have a prerogative to think as you wish. You don't have a prerogative to call people names simply because they disagree with you and you have no logical arguments to use.

Okay, you can call me also foolish and unintelligent, if that is going to help you feel better.
No, I decline to call you names. I think it is better to use logical arguments which you have no logical counter to and see your frustration come out in your name-calling.

I would not mind at all as to gripe if you put it an nth time in your next post that my ideas are foolish and unintelligent; because I know the worth of my ideas on the basis of non-foolishness and intelligence, and no one has convinced me otherwise, except etc.
I'm sure that nobody could convince you otherwise. "You can't reason someone out of a position that they haven't reasoned themselves into." You are a perfect example of that.

Okay, let's all calm down, just call me foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your evaluation of my ideas, to get even with my evaluating you as foolish and unintelligent on the basis of your ideas.
Yes, let's you calm down and start using logical arguemnts rather than your illogical name-calling.

But let us not sink to the depth of saying that someone is speaking through his a-hole.

Or calling someone a jackass.
Yes, let's you not do that either. Let's you start using logical arguments so that you won't be frustrated and start your name-calling again.

Okay, no more will I use the words foolish and unintelligent on atheists, but I will just say you are naive and disingenuous; okay? when I see that your ideas are to my analysis naive and disingenuous.
Yes, you will continue to call people names because you have no logical arguments to use. I think we all know that and it is good that you can admit it also. Do you think you could even try to use logical arguments or address the things that people ask you?

Now, back to business: so, tell me where I said that the big bang is God?
Here:
The maker of everything in the universe that is not God Himself.​




Now that I've imagined your concept of god is the same as the Big Bang, where do we go from here? Are you thinking that your god has other properties that we should know about?
 
Last edited:
Talk about God in His fundamental relation to the universe, in the Christian faith.
But in the Christian faith, God is much more than just the creator of the world. You are trying to have your cake and eat it, aren't you?

Don't waste time with other things about God by which other things without His being the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself, are worth zilch.


Do you comprehend my point?
No. Could you try saying it again, in English?

Ask yourself if you are an author what is the fundamental concept of an author in relation to his literary works?
I give in, please tell us.
 
Start with my concept of God, present your objections in logical statements.

One thing at a time.

Better, think over your objections against my concept of God, and connect them together to get to the real point you want to make, instead of throwing out so many things without any mutual linkage.

Yrreg

OK, but it seems a little off that you put many things out at once while wanting me to confine myself to one point at a time. I raised no more points than you did in the post to which I was responding.

The definition of God you have presented is not distinguishable as Christian, only as a male universe maker, but you keep bringing up his Christian nature when there's nothing in the definition that establishes that nature. I think you should leave Christianity out of it until you've done more to link the concept with Christianity. Otherwise you're treating your definition as really being 'the Christian God who is the maker of the universe', which is not nearly as simple a concept as the one you initially proposed.
 
It sounds like he's gearing up for an bastard child of the ontological argument. We can conceive of something he defines as god, therefore the Christian god exists.

That's what I used to think he was shooting for, too, but I've since concluded that all he really has is an odd sort of argument from authority: there is a concept of god, so let's see what the "god experts" who have been studying it for centuries think, and lo and behold, people who devote their lives to studying god also tend to be people who think or claim to think it exists.* Ergo Jesus! And if only us atheists would stop our guiltless masturbation long enough to look at the "obvious" we would agree, just like Anthony Flew did, don't you know! (Minor details like the fallacious nature of argument from authority, the inconvenient fact that most philosophers aren't believers and even the Christian philosophers of religion mostly content themselves with trying only to show that it's not inherently illogical to believe, how you get from "maker of the universe and everything" to Christianity while ignoring all the other religions, and why one elderly and possibly senile man's "conversion" to a lukewarm deism is breathtakingly significant while all the de-conversions of Christians don't... are left as an exercise for the spectators, because yrreg usually gets suspended long before he gets around to even pretending to address them.)

*Only true if you're limiting yourself to theologians.
 
...


A 'possible concept' ? what does that mean in this context? Are you saying an actual entity cannot come into existence unless it's existence is possible?

...
.
Descarte... in an inverted form...
"I thought myself and therefore, I do be here."
 
You see, reality is made up of two things: potential entities and actual entities.

An actual entity cannot come to existence unless there is a possible concept of it.


No. An actual entity exists whether or not anyone has a concept of it.

For example, the Galilean moons of Jupiter were first observed by Galileo in 1609 and 1610. Before this there was no concept of moons orbiting any planet other than the Earth. But the moons of Jupiter (and of Mars, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune) all existed long before this.
 
Now we want to come to agreement on the concept of the universe.


Here is my concept of the universe:
Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.​


Do you have your concept of the universe? so that we can work out together to come to the common concept of the universe we both can use to arrive at the existence of God from the universe as the evidence.



Yrreg

I would mostly agree with this, as long as we keep imagination inside people's heads.
 
I agree totally, I'd no more think of calling someone a jackass than I'd think to call them a bumfussling fool or a bloviating blowhard.
.
Now, don't tergiversate on this matter!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom