Jonathan h. Cole has uploaded a new videoclip!

Maybe i have to change the question. Why i have to defend?

So you are bad informed about the truth movement? I'll gues you have to spend more time to the truth movement. Because a lot of his points are based on researches from the truth movement. Good luck with it.

Just like you said, what you thought about an expert, thats exactly the definition.

You even have problems to watch the whole videoclip? LOL
How many questions do you now have?

Just show me the questions and i will try to answer.

But first things first, if you get rude to me or try to attack me as person, and not stick to the content. Like you first did. I will stop the conversation, and will ignore you like i did with a lot of debunkers here.

You do not have to defend the video, but if you are going to pomote a certain video (or point of view) then you should expect to see some questions about it especially if it is about something contraversial.

I have spent more than enough time with the truth movement. I think too much of the movement is based on hate and bigotry. When I questioned the facts I was presented with on forums devoted to alternate views (as opposed to those back by the US government) of the events on 9/11, I was libeled, harrassed, insulted and ulitmately banned. Most forums devoted to 9/11 "truth" are primarily interested in patting each other on the back with their version of what passes for fact. Other views no matter what are forbidden.

I have already shown you the questions, but here they are again.

1. Could you define the word (expert) and tells us (in your own words) why an expert in some field has something relevant to say about an event that is not within their area of expertise?

2. That video runs over 15 minutes, was that enough time to make some of the quotes that were mined a bit more lengthy? Was it necessary to cut them off so quick?

I think it is very ironic that you would expect respect from anyone in this thread after your rude behavior in post #9.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
You do not have to defend the video, but if you are going to pomote a certain video (or point of view) then you should expect to see some questions about it especially if it is about something contraversial.

I have spent more than enough time with the truth movement. I think too much of the movement is based on hate and bigotry. When I questioned the facts I was presented with on forums devoted to alternate views (as opposed to those back by the US government) of the events on 9/11, I was libeled, harrassed, insulted and ulitmately banned. Most forums devoted to 9/11 "truth" are primarily interested in patting each other on the back with their version of what passes for fact. Other views no matter what are forbidden.

I have already shown you the questions, but here they are again.

1. Could you define the word (expert) and tells us (in your own words) why an expert in some field has something relevant to say about an event that is not within their area of expertise?

2. That video runs over 15 minutes, was that enough time to make some of the quotes that were mined a bit more lengthy? Was it necessary to cut them off so quick?

I think it is very ironic that you would expect respect from anyone in this thread after your rude behavior in post #9.

Ranb

So next time, do not talk about defending, if u want to ask questions, or comment the videoclip, and its up to me, to answer it or not.
And i will always answer, if i see, you are respectful and seriously want a normal answer..

No you did not spend a lot of time at the truth movement, if it is, you would know, jonathan used a lot of different sources of researches for his videoclip.

Its impossible, to say that you have spend a lot of time. It could be, but then you spend to many time at loose change movies or something like that.
Just for an example, did you read the articles from the journal of 9/11 studies?

First of all, who is us???? I will answer, if you tell that to me, because i thougt i was talking to an individual.

These quotes are well-know, they have been quoted a thousand times.
But if you dont trust the quotes, ask me the quotes you dont trust and i will give you the source.

Its action reaction. Read at your own posts. Just like i said, if you dont respect me, i dont respect you. If you dont agree with it, then thats not my problem, then just leave the thread, or start trolling i dont really care.
 
It is easier to say "no I will not answer" instead of typing out several paragraphs of evasion.

You are worse than evasive and rude; you are boring. You and the video you are promoting are nothing new and both fail to be the least bit convincing of anything. If you were to put as much energy into providing answers as you do evading questions, then the people reading your posts might be a bit interested in learning more about what you (and the video) have to say.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
No you did not spend a lot of time at the truth movement, if it is, you would know, jonathan used a lot of different sources of researches for his videoclip.

Sorry, but those interviews about "exlosions" are all a bunch of wooi. The dim monk MacQueen should have known better.

Its impossible, to say that you have spend a lot of time. It could be, but then you spend to many time at loose change movies or something like that.
Just for an example, did you read the articles from the journal of 9/11 studies?

J.O.N.E.S. is just a lot of first impressions and some shoddy pseudiscience that the dweebs threw up on the walls to see wheter t anyone would buy it.
 
It is easier to say "no I will not answer" instead of typing out several paragraphs of evasion.

You are worse than evasive and rude; you are boring. You and the video you are promoting are nothing new and both fail to be the least bit convincing of anything. If you were to put as much energy into providing answers as you do evading questions, then the people reading your posts might be a bit interested in learning more about what you (and the video) have to say.

Ranb

If this is your last post, than i will say

Op to ignorelist!!!
 
Since nothing interesting is happening in this thread, I'll put out an ad: Anyone wanna meet up at Ground Zero on Saturday? My mother brought the whole family to New York for her sixtieth and it would be cool meeting a fellow Jrefer. Twoofers are welcome too.
 


Ok lets try to point by point this badboy. To assure no misrepresentation. And, I'm bored.

"lets listen to what some witnesses have to say"

- Another explosion
- Huge explosion that we all heard
- Devices that were planted in the building
- Explosion
- Explosion
- Another explosion

"all that evidence of explosions was quickly ignored or dismissed"

You know why they were ignored?

Because two 110-story towers, weighing at least 500,000,000 kg between them, falling in on themselves are going to be pretty loud. Might even be as loud as ... I duno ... explosives? Maybe loud enough that a few people mistakenly thought they heard explosives?

Next, the video quotes:

"the Intense fire caused the tower to collapse. It melted the structural steel. what the firemen might not have realized is that the gushing jet fuel was melting the steel"

And this fine quote was taken from the prestigious scientifically rigorous source know as "newsweek" :rolleyes:

The next few minutes seem to conflate the term melt with deform. There are few first hand fireman accounts of of molten metal, followed by a picture of what appears to be a large molten chunk of something, that is largely indistinguishable from just compressed rubble.

Iron rich sphere shown. Don't have a single clue why!

Next pic is of Bazants paper, I did'nt know that Bazant published his paper "Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse?" only two days after the event (seems awfully quick for a representative evaluation)

Video then states that the paper ignores newtons third law. But to apply newtons third law to a collapse as structurally complex as this would be foolish.

From 3:00'ish onward we have some random vocals that are easily proved silly, followed by a clip from the horizon documentary where the visualization leaves the core columns clearly standing during a pancake (or progressive) collapse. Then it points out the fact that the original NIST report does not model the conditions after collapse initiation were reached. As far as I can tell, that is a good point.

Next they quote:

"Many structural engineers believe that the weak points were the angle clips that held the floor joists between the perimeter walls and the core structure." Thomas Eager - 'Why did the world trade center collapse' - Science, Engineering and speculation.

They also show a MIT simulation that supports this, as well as a picture from FEMA, and additionally the American society of civil engineers.
Also apparently the holy bastion of engineering, a PBS documentary, also concurred with this :rolleyes:

This is all then shown to contradict with the NIST experts, who later concluded that the truss connections held firm.

The next bit is complete semantics over which direction buckling might happen. Outwards buckling, inwards, it doesn't really matter.

5:50 shows numerous building demolitions that show the bottom of a building being completely taken out, the top structure seems to fall a considerable distance but then catch itself under its own supports and not completely collapse.

From 6:00 topic is: melted steel and the source of sulfur. At 6:49 they quote: "It is concluded that sulfur emission ... were relatively small compared to those involving diesel fuel ... and CaSO4 in gypsum wallboard" F.R. Greening "Sulfur and the World Trade Centre Disaster" 2006.

Some pop sci crap from BBC blah blah ... at 7:12 they quote Greening admitting the above quote about sulfur creation "needs to be modified" as it was not accurate. Next quote some more outdated pop sci from skeptical enquirer (7:30).

Then a load of crap from the history channel and popular mechanics about oil fires which NIST says were not true (8:17).

Column 79 in WTC7 is brought up at 8:34 by NIST. Then the video shows NIST ruling out controlled demolition because they did not hear cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine. The video maker counters by showing highly anecdotal footage (9:00) from Barry Jennings. And then some footage of (firefighters?) in which the clip does seem to show a loud bang.

At this point [exactly half way through] I give up for tonight. Someone else can try to do the rest if they want, I'm tired.
 
Last edited:
I should point out the only real reason that I responded as above is that this video does seem to try to address the science and it does have an inordinate ratio of likes to disklikes for the number of views, if you extrapolate the likes to view count then you can tell this video is being accepted by a lot more people than your typical truther video.
 
What part of "NEWS"week confused you sir/ma'am?

This is great. They said it in Newsweek and Time, so there's no need to do science. In fact, why even both with science and engineering? Let's just ask Newsweek what they think. and if we don't like that, let's make a Youtube video for our friends.
 
I guess it was the NEWS they delivered to me.

Mainly that that "gushing jet fuel was melting the steel", rather than weakening it.

Before encarta got nuked by M$ it said the same thing about "melting".. it's not the professional vernacular I'd have preferred they used, but they aren't exactly full of engineers that regularly use the word "viscoelastic creep", or whatever to describe the effect of the heat. I'm not seeing much of a problem otherwise... magazines and news papers that aren't specifically catered to a professional engineering audience do this sort of thing all the time.
 
Last edited:
An idiotic video proves 911 truth is lost in a pit of ignorance. What is new? Got a Pulitzer yet, Marokkaan, it has been 10 years. Watergate took about a year to break and earn a Pulitzer, why is your movement filled with idiotic claims and delusional nonsense? You can't do much but publish idiotic junk. good job

Your name spelled checked says it all, why you prefer dumbed down nonsense over reality, failure over success, following others blindly instead of leading the way. Pushing lies instead of the truth. Unable to figure out what is nonsense, and what is reality. People pay a lot to have the delusions you have, and you have them for free. You are lucky.

It would be neat if you would comment in the OP for the idiotic drivel you post. Once again you are on topic, exposing another failure at understanding 911. I have to copy this idiotic video, the author will not want this to haunt his future if he regains the ability to function the real world.

Cole proves again he is a moron at the end. He has no clue the eutectic of the steel was explained. Must be a moron since he can't read or comprehend the reports already published years ago. Is this new stuff? What a dunce.
 
Last edited:
Having just watched the part of the video after the above I critiqued, I'm not sure I could reply to all the points in it. Some seem quite pertinent in fact. Would be great if someone else here could.
 
I should point out the only real reason that I responded as above is that this video does seem to try to address the science and it does have an inordinate ratio of likes to disklikes for the number of views, if you extrapolate the likes to view count then you can tell this video is being accepted by a lot more people than your typical truther video.

The like to dislike ratio is because they are preaching to the choir for the most part.
 
magazines and news papers that aren't specifically catered to a professional engineering audience do this sort of thing all the time.


Annoyingly yes they do, its the same in any area of science (cosmology, chemistry, engineering, physics). The media simplify things to the extent that the layman reads them and either a) draws erroneous conclusions from the article to support their world view and posts their findings here or b) draws erroneous conclusions about how wrong the side they disagree with is based on the articles simplification and posts it here. Thus this pop sci trend will forever continue.
 
I just watched the whole video and boy am I mad. Why are all those scientists lying to us? Do you think they work for the Illuminati? They're the same guys who laugh at us when we talk about chemtrails and weather control. So there you go. More proof that they really control the world. If only we could find out who was really pulling their strings. Larry Silverstein maybe.

And what's with that Dave Thomas guy? What makes him so important that he gets special mention in a Truther video? He's not the only guy who's written bad things about Truthers in those debunker magazines. Could Dave be an agent of the Illuminati? I think this is worth investigating.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom