God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Well, I guess I just have to wait for X to appear here again.

.​
Well, I guess I just have to wait for X to appear here again.



As soon as she comes back and agrees to what I think she wants to be clear about, then I will or we will proceed to her next comment.

In the meantime, I will just reproduce below my argument for the thesis that
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.
​
Removed breach of Rule 6. Do not spam the same stuff over and over again and do not use over-large fonts in a disruptive manner.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL



When X finally will not come back to this thread anymore, I will presume that she has resigned from this thread, then I will invite another poster here to give his comments about my argument, but please step by step, point by point, not by tsunami approach.





Yrreg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another one that believed that argumentation is like fighting a war: if you have enough arguments you can still win the war in spite of heavy casualties (arguments "killed in action").

In this case, arguments just fade on their own inconsistency, and argumentation only proves that the person is just fighting some kind of war.
 
Last edited:
Yrreg, I do not believe a nose has a specific beginning and end. As Dunstan pointed out, any point you specify is arbitrary. Does a nose begin at birth? At some point in fetal development? At conception? When the mother's egg is released?

Yes, you can say at certain points of time that "there is no nose" and "there is a nose", but is there really a point when you can definitively say, "The nose starts .... NOW!"?

Loki's wager is right in the middle of your face.

(And to move on to your next point, how can you have actions happening "before" time even exists?)
 
Okay, I will just give the link.

.​
Well, I guess I just have to wait for X to appear here again.



As soon as she comes back and agrees to what I think she wants to be clear about, then I will or we will proceed to her next comment.

In the meantime, I will just reproduce below my argument for the thesis that
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.
​
Removed breach of Rule 6. Do not spam the same stuff over and over again and do not use over-large fonts in a disruptive manner.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL



When X finally will not come back to this thread anymore, I will presume that she has resigned from this thread, then I will invite another poster here to give his comments about my argument, but please step by step, point by point, not by tsunami approach.





Yrreg


Okay, I will just give the link and the date and time of my post where I already gave my argument for the thesis,
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.​


Here, for posters who keep on gratuitously insisting that I have not presented my proof that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, see:
So, before you complain again that I have not given my proof, see post #407.



You see, readers here, posters hostile to me can just keep on insisting that I have not given my proof, in order to tire me out if not for anything more sinister in his heart and mind.




Yrreg
 
The existence of the universe is evidence only for the existence of the universe.

Your assertion that it is proof of a god is unevidenced, and referring to your assertion as a proof does not make it one. I do not say this to tire you out but to point out the error in your thinking.
 
Okay, I will just give the link and the date and time of my post where I already gave my argument for the thesis,
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.​



Yrreg

Nope, the universe is the evidence for The Flying Spaghetti Monster. In creating the universe The Flying Spaghetti Monster was annihilated, becoming part and parcel of the universe.

yrreg is part and parcel of The Flying Spaghetti Monster!

How do you feel about the evidence that you are part and parcel of The Flying Spaghetti Monster, yrreg?
 
Okay, I will just give the link and the date and time of my post where I already gave my argument for the thesis,
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.​


Here, for posters who keep on gratuitously insisting that I have not presented my proof that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, see:
So, before you complain again that I have not given my proof, see post #407.



You see, readers here, posters hostile to me can just keep on insisting that I have not given my proof, in order to tire me out if not for anything more sinister in his heart and mind.




Yrreg

That's not "proof", that's an argument, and we've already pointed out the flaws in it.

"5 Wherefore everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence."

You offer no support for this assertion, and it doesn't follow from any of the previous premises.

Then you assert this:

"7. There is an agent which I call God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself."

Again without evidence or any supporting argumentation.
 
"She"? :boggled:

Guess again.


I have not abandoned this thread. I have a job. I'm an Engineer-in-Training (it's a North American thing). I work. I'm busy. I occasionally post from work, when I have 2 minutes here and there. But part of my job right now is introducing process changes to a whole lot of parts, which involves me spending considerable amounts of my time on the floor overseeing trials. By considerable, I mean more than the 50% I normally spend on the floor. I started at 0700, it is now just past 1700. I managed to bold down a bag of chips and a Root Beer in lieu of lunch. I don't get breaks, and being on salary I don't get overtime, either.

But I'm supposed to be here for your convenience?

I don't think so.

When have I ever attacked you for posting on a different schedule than me? I know you're not Canadian, so I don't expect you to post the same timetable as me. Further, I extend you the courtesy of assuming you have a life outside of this forum, and don't expect instant responses. I would appreciate it if you did the same, and didn't try to project motivations on to me.



Finally, to address your latest posts, I have already given my reasoning for assuming a geometric basis to your "beginning and end of the nose" example. I made it clear in subsequent posts (after your protestation that you meant a temporal basis) that such a change only removes one fallacy from a sub-conclusion which rests on three fallacies. Ultimately, nothing changes and your argument is still fatally flawed. I honestly cannot understand why you nitpick on that one insignificant point, ignoring the fatal flaws in your "proof".

And I have not insisted that you have not given your "proof" since you provided it. I have pointed out it's flaws, though.
 
Okay, I will just give the link and the date and time of my post where I already gave my argument for the thesis,
The universe is the evidence for the existence of God.​


Here, for posters who keep on gratuitously insisting that I have not presented my proof that the universe is the evidence for the existence of God, see:
So, before you complain again that I have not given my proof, see post #407.



You see, readers here, posters hostile to me can just keep on insisting that I have not given my proof, in order to tire me out if not for anything more sinister in his heart and mind.




Yrreg
I hate to break it to you, but if your argument is not persuasive (and clearly yours is not), repeating it does not improve it. In fact, the opposite effect is achieved. Your strategy is not meeting with success.
 
First we must have a mutually agreed on the concept of evidence.

The existence of the universe is evidence only for the existence of the universe.

Your assertion that it is proof of a god is unevidenced, and referring to your assertion as a proof does not make it one. I do not say this to tire you out but to point out the error in your thinking.


First, of course we have to agree on what is evidence.


Without a concurring concept of evidence, the target of evidence, and how evidence works, it is useless for you to assert God does not exist.

I do have a ccncept of evidence, and accordiing to my concept of evidence, God exists.


Here is my concept of evidence:
A Fact known by man leading him to know another fact.​



And here is the evidence for God's existence, the fact of the existence of the universe.

How does the fact of the existence ascertain the fact of God's existence?

Here, in the universe there are realities which have a beginning and an ending to their existence, wherefore they do not bring themselves to existence, therefore God exists as their creator.


What evidence or your concept of evidence do you have to ascertain that God does not exist?




Yrreg
 
And here is the evidence for God's existence, the fact of the existence of the universe.

How does the fact of the existence ascertain the fact of God's existence?

Here, in the universe there are realities which have a beginning and an ending to their existence, wherefore they do not bring themselves to existence, therefore God exists as their creator.


The existence of the Universe is the evidence that your god exists because the Universe has a beginning and end and you believe your god doesn't?

Nonsense.

What evidence or your concept of evidence do you have to ascertain that God does not exist?


The lack of any objective evidence to the contrary.
 
First, of course we have to agree on what is evidence.


Without a concurring concept of evidence, the target of evidence, and how evidence works, it is useless for you to assert God does not exist.

I do have a ccncept of evidence, and accordiing to my concept of evidence, God exists.


Here is my concept of evidence:
A Fact known by man leading him to know another fact.​



And here is the evidence for God's existence, the fact of the existence of the universe.

How does the fact of the existence ascertain the fact of God's existence?

Here, in the universe there are realities which have a beginning and an ending to their existence, wherefore they do not bring themselves to existence, therefore God exists as their creator.


What evidence or your concept of evidence do you have to ascertain that God does not exist?




Yrreg

Wait, so because atheists say that there is no evidence for the existence of god, that somehow means that atheists have the wrong definition of the word "evidence"?
 
Here is my concept of evidence:
A Fact known by man leading him to know another fact.​



Yrreg

Here is my evidence that yrreG is part and parcel of The Flying Spaghetti Monster:

1. The Flying Spaghetti Monster created the universe and was destroyed in making it.

2. The universe exists.

3. The Flying Spaghetti Monster no longer exists.

4. No other gods have ever existed.

5. The universe is now part and parcel of The Flying Spaghetti Monster.

6. yrreG is part and parcel of The Flying Spaghetti Monster.

Ha ha! Gotcha!

Now you try using that same logic, yrreG. Oh wait, you already did.
 
Well, if you insist on nonsense who am I to argue with you?

The existence of the Universe is the evidence that your god exists because the Universe has a beginning and end and you believe your god doesn't?

Nonsense.




The lack of any objective evidence to the contrary.



Well, if you insist on nonsense who am I to argue with you?


But tell me because I am talking about the universe as the evidence for God's existence, do you have a concept of what is evidence?

And do you have a concept of God?

And do you have a concept of universe?




Yrreg
 
Well, if you insist on nonsense who am I to argue with you?


But tell me because I am talking about the universe as the evidence for God's existence, do you have a concept of what is evidence?

And do you have a concept of God?

And do you have a concept of universe?




Yrreg

Gerry,
Please explain your definition of evidence. You are not using the word in any way defined by dictionaries or normal usage.
 
Concept is a thought in the mind of man.

Yrreg, Define 'concept' first.



Concept is a thought in the mind of man.


But please look up the terms "senus aienti and sensu neganti," because when I say that concept is a thought in the mind of man I am not saying that only man has concepts.



Yrreg
 
And here is the evidence for God's existence, the fact of the existence of the universe.

How does the fact of the existence ascertain the fact of God's existence?

Here, in the universe there are realities which have a beginning and an ending to their existence, wherefore they do not bring themselves to existence, therefore God exists as their creator.
That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Just because things have beginnings and endings does not mean that a creator exists, nor does it mean that the Christian God is that creator.
What evidence or your concept of evidence do you have to ascertain that God does not exist?
It's your claim that God exists, it's your burden of proof. This means it's up to you to provide evidence, and the fact that things exist, or that the universe itself exists, is not evidence for a creator or for a god.

I assert (not claim) God does not exist because there is no evidence of any god. If you have convincing, testable, reliable evidence of a god then present it. What you have presented so far is a poor restatement of the Kalām Cosmological argument, which is easily refutable.
 
Last edited:
That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Just because things have beginnings and endings does not mean that a creator exists, nor does ir mean that the Christian God is that creator. It's your claim that God exists, it's your burden of proof. This means it's up to you to provide evidence, and the fact that things exist, or that the universe itself exists, is not evidence for a creator or for a god.

I assert (not claim) God does not exist because there is no evidence of any god. If you have convincing, testable, reliable evidence of a god then present it. What you have presented so far is a poor restatement of the Kalām Cosmological argument, which is easily refutable.

Agatha,
Hear hear! (and Thank You - saved me a post of frustration!)

Gerry,
The ball is in your court and always has been. We're sitting on the other side of the net for you to eventually hit a ball over, and you're complaining that it's our fault that your balls keep hitting the net. /End of tennis metaphor
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom