Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

Who created God?


First, we have to work together on what is our mutually agreed on concept of God.


I have said time and again that my concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is that
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


I love to hear from you what is your concept of God.




Yrreg

I have no concept of god(s). I've heard from other people who believe in various god(s) and they will often list their favorite god's properties.

Does your god have any other properties than just creating the universe? If all it did was create the universe, we may as well just call it the Big Bang.

What is your concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster? I would really love to hear from you about that.
 
You are under the spell of fear, fear of concepts.

I get the feeling that what you really mean is that you want to force your definition on us.


In your other thread I gave my definition of God as: An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior. So, how do we come to an agreement as to the definition of God?


I would love to believe you, but history causes me to conclude that you have no interest in other people's definitions of God.



You are under the spell of fear, fear of concepts.


If I am forcing my concepts on you, why am I here asking you for your concepts?


First, you give your concepts and we will work out an agreed on concept of God, by which concept we will set forth to look for evidence, but don't forget to also have a concept of evidence which we will all agree on.


I hate to give this illustration: I am a shop-keeper and you are to all appearances a prospective buyer; I ask you if you have money, you say that I am forcing my concept of money on you, so I show you some dollar bills and ask you if you have some; then you get angry and say that I am looking down on you.

So, I say, sir, please leave for I have a busy day ahead; otherwise show me your money and I will bring down things for you to examine but not everything and only the kind you want to buy, for example, bread toasters.



Here, you give your definition of God:
An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.
​


That is no different essentially from my concept of God:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

If you will just bring in the venue of operation of this agent you and I call God.

You say nature, I say the universe understood as the totality of existence.



We are now into working out together for an agreed on concept of God, so that we will not be talking past our heads which is irrational and illogical.


So, what about this concept of God as already established by theists:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

Remember you are the one denying the existence of the God of theists, so you must be acquainted correctly with their concept of God, and not insist that they agree with your concept of God.


Anyway, you have the same essential idea of God as theists like myself, in God's fundamental relation to the universe of which nature is a part.

You say in effect that God is an agent, and I say God is a creator.



But I must tell you that you are under the spell of fear, fear of the concept of God as propounded by theists lke myself, namely:
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​




Yrreg
 
yrreg fears The Flying Spaghetti Monster, which he is part and parcel of

So, what about this concept of God as already established by theists:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
Fine. The Big Bang god then.

Remember you are the one denying the existence of the God of theists, so you must be acquainted correctly with their concept of God, and not insist that they agree with your concept of God.
Then give us their concept of god and stop asking atheists for theirs.

Anyway, you have the same essential idea of God as theists like myself, in God's fundamental relation to the universe of which nature is a part.
Your idea of god is a man-made construct? Ok.

You say in effect that God is an agent, and I say God is a creator.
Now you just need to provide evidence for what you say.

But I must tell you that you are under the spell of fear, fear of the concept of God as propounded by theists lke myself, namely:
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
You are under a spell of fear, fear of the concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster, which you are part and parcel of.




Start using logical arguments.

What is your concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster?
 
You are under the spell of fear, fear of concepts.


If I am forcing my concepts on you, why am I here asking you for your concepts?


First, you give your concepts and we will work out an agreed on concept of God, by which concept we will set forth to look for evidence, but don't forget to also have a concept of evidence which we will all agree on.


I hate to give this illustration: I am a shop-keeper and you are to all appearances a prospective buyer; I ask you if you have money, you say that I am forcing my concept of money on you, so I show you some dollar bills and ask you if you have some; then you get angry and say that I am looking down on you.

So, I say, sir, please leave for I have a busy day ahead; otherwise show me your money and I will bring down things for you to examine but not everything and only the kind you want to buy, for example, bread toasters.



Here, you give your definition of God:
An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior.
​


That is no different essentially from my concept of God:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

If you will just bring in the venue of operation of this agent you and I call God.

You say nature, I say the universe understood as the totality of existence.



We are now into working out together for an agreed on concept of God, so that we will not be talking past our heads which is irrational and illogical.


So, what about this concept of God as already established by theists:
Creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

Remember you are the one denying the existence of the God of theists, so you must be acquainted correctly with their concept of God, and not insist that they agree with your concept of God.


Anyway, you have the same essential idea of God as theists like myself, in God's fundamental relation to the universe of which nature is a part.

You say in effect that God is an agent, and I say God is a creator.



But I must tell you that you are under the spell of fear, fear of the concept of God as propounded by theists lke myself, namely:
God is the creator of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​




Yrreg

You're confusing disagreement with fear.

You asked for a concept, somebody gave you one, and you substituted it for one of your own.

That is NOT agreement.
 
Atheists do not fear any concept of gods, Yrreg; you really should drop this habit of assuming you know what other people are thinking. You are almost invariably wrong.

Let us say for the sake of argument that we understand your concept of God (which, by the way, is a concept of what God does rather than what God is). Now what? We understand that you have a concept of a God which created the universe but did not create itself. Having a concept of such a thing isn't evidence for its existence.
 
Your words represent your thoughts, if I can't know what you are thinking what...

Atheists do not fear any concept of gods, Yrreg; you really should drop this habit of assuming you know what other people are thinking. You are almost invariably wrong.

Let us say for the sake of argument that we understand your concept of God (which, by the way, is a concept of what God does rather than what God is). Now what? We understand that you have a concept of a God which created the universe but did not create itself. Having a concept of such a thing isn't evidence for its existence.



Your words represent your thoughts, if I can't know what you are thinking what about you in regard to my thoughts?


I know for a certainty that you want to convince me that God does not exist, and you know for a certainty that I am trying to show you that the universe is the evidence for God's existence.


But there is a big difference between you and me, I present my concepts but you don't.




Yrreg
 
I don't want to convince you that God doesn't exist, so once again you are wrong. I don't give a flying duck what you believe, as long as you don't insist I conform to your beliefs.

You present nonsensical concepts but you fail to see that I and others have presented concepts.

My concept of the universe is "everything that exists"
My concept of the Christian God is "a fictional character in an old book who behaves in an abhorrent way"
Foster Zygote also gave you a good concept of the Christian God "An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior"

So as you are wrong, both as to my intentions and on the fact that I have presented concepts, where does that leave you?
 
I put this question yesterday in Yahoo Answers:




What I got from people who love to answer questions are mockery, parody, and evasions.


Then this morning earlier I introduced this question:




What happened when I submitted the question?

Here:




Well, that is nothing new with Yahoo Answers, they even deleted my questions already out in the web and for some days open to everyone in the web; on other occasions they deleted my questions right away and when I demanded why they in effect beat about the bush.


The earlier question on equation of universe from nothing, it iwll be deleted from Yahoo Answers eventually.




Yrreg

So what exactly is it that you are asking for with this post? I'd be happy to try and answer without the use of "mockery, parody, and evasions", provided I have some knowledge in the area concerned. I don't approve of such techniques either.
 
In regard to the concept of God I have to correct atheists' mis-information.

You're confusing disagreement with fear.

You asked for a concept, somebody gave you one, and you substituted it for one of your own.

That is NOT agreement.




In regard to the concept of God I have to correct atheists' mis-information.


As regards concept of universe and concept of evidence, I do invite heartily atheists to work with me together to come to mutually agreed on concepts.



Here are my cncepts of universe and of evidence:

Universe: The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

Evidence: A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.

​


Now, here is my concept of God, which I want atheists to be properly informed about, otherwise they are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god

God: In His fundamental relation to the universe, the creator (I used maker before but it's okay if you want to revert to maker) of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​


That concept is in the Christian faith, but it is also found in other religious as also philosophical worldviews.




Yrreg
 
No it can't. The human mind can only imagine the words that say God can do all that. It can't imagine the actual doing of it. It's totally clueless as to how any of that might actually be done.

I disagree. You don't have to be able to know how a thing is done to imagine it being done. It's very easy for me to imagine a magician riding a motorcyle behind a curtain and driving a convertible out, but I can't begin to imagine how he'd pull it off. (Actually, that would make for a really cool trick. Has anyone ever done it?)

Ok, if yrreg isn't a Poe or an AI, he falls under the category of "I wonder what it would be like to meet this guy IRL? To sit down and discuss something over lunch? Does he speak the same way that he writes?"

Yrreg, what is your native language? Is it possible you can find someone fluent in English to translate?
 
God: In His fundamental relation to the universe, the creator (I used maker before but it's okay if you want to revert to maker) of everything in the universe that is not Himself.
​


That concept is in the Christian faith, but it is also found in other religious as also philosophical worldviews.




Yrreg

So your concept of god is the Big Bang.

What is your concept of The Flying Spaghetti Monster? (I was kidding about you fearing Her, she can't really hurt you. She was destroyed when She created the universe.)
 
Okay, let us work out our concepts for concurrence.

I don't want to convince you that God doesn't exist, so once again you are wrong. I don't give a flying duck what you believe, as long as you don't insist I conform to your beliefs.

You present nonsensical concepts but you fail to see that I and others have presented concepts.

My concept of the universe is "everything that exists"
My concept of the Christian God is "a fictional character in an old book who behaves in an abhorrent way"
Foster Zygote also gave you a good concept of the Christian God "An anthropomorphic construct of human imagination created to attribute agency to nature in an attempt to anticipate its behavior"

So as you are wrong, both as to my intentions and on the fact that I have presented concepts, where does that leave you?



Okay, let us work out our concepts for concurrence.

On your concept of universe as everything that exists, I ask you how it is if at all contrary to my concept of the universe?

The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


As regards your concept of God, you are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god.

Please leave Zygote out of your posts, he can speak for himself, and don't seek support by bringing in the name of Zygote.

Speak for yourself alone.



Now, where is your concept of evidence?




Yrreg
 
Yrreg,

You've painted yourself into a corner. According to your own definition of the universe,

Universe: The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

any deity that "can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse" is therefore part of the universe, couldn't have existed "before" the universe and must have created itself. Then, by defining god as creator of everything except himself, you've created a nice little paradox.

One of your definitions must be wrong. Either the universe doesn't contain everything that exists or god didn't create everything but himself. Assuming you can admit you were wrong about something, I'm betting you won't back down on your definition of god.
 
Okay, let us work out our concepts for concurrence.

On your concept of universe as everything that exists, I ask you how it is if at all contrary to my concept of the universe?

The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


As regards your concept of God, you are barking up the wrong tree at the wrong god.

Please leave Zygote out of your posts, he can speak for himself, and don't seek support by bringing in the name of Zygote.

Speak for yourself alone.



Now, where is your concept of evidence?




Yrreg

Gerry,
As you also asked the question of me previously, I can answer that for you.

Your concept of "evidence" is incorrect. Blunt, but true.

Here is a concept of "evidence" that aligns with its common usage and understanding: (qv Wikipedia)

"Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion. Giving or procuring evidence is the process of using those things that are either (a) presumed to be true, or (b) were themselves proven via evidence, to demonstrate an assertion's truth. Evidence is the currency by which one fulfills the burden of proof."

The bolded bit is what you keep missing - you are making assertions that are unsupported.
 
The issue now is to determine what is the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe.




Yrreg
I've actually always fancied the idea that the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe is indeterminate because it hasn't happened yet.

Basically, we have this situation:

Red Corner....
God
Yahweh
FSM
Giant Turtle
Mice
Zeus
Odin
Cthulhu

Blue Corner....
The Universe

So far, Gerry has not shown a way for any or all of the Red Corner to find their way to the Blue Corner.
"Go the blue" ?
 
You are woefully bereft of the distinction of concept and object.

Yrreg,

You've painted yourself into a corner. According to your own definition of the universe,
Quote:

Universe: The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.


​
any deity that "can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse" is therefore part of the universe, couldn't have existed "before" the universe and must have created itself. Then, by defining god as creator of everything except himself, you've created a nice little paradox.

One of your definitions must be wrong. Either the universe doesn't contain everything that exists or god didn't create everything but himself. Assuming you can admit you were wrong about something, I'm betting you won't back down on your definition of god.




Imaginable, that is, the concept.


Please always keep in mind the distinction between the concept and the actual reality which man seeks to find in the totality of existence which is the universe, corresponding to the concept.

Where is the concept? In the mind of man.

Where is man? In the universe which is the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.



Yrreg
 
Now, tell me how is your concept of evidence contrary to mine?

Gerry,
As you also asked the question of me previously, I can answer that for you.

Your concept of "evidence" is incorrect. Blunt, but true.

Here is a concept of "evidence" that aligns with its common usage and understanding: (qv Wikipedia)

"Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion. Giving or procuring evidence is the process of using those things that are either (a) presumed to be true, or (b) were themselves proven via evidence, to demonstrate an assertion's truth. Evidence is the currency by which one fulfills the burden of proof."

The bolded bit is what you keep missing - you are making assertions that are unsupported.



Here again is my concept of evidence:
A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.
​

You say:
Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion.
​


Now, tell me how is your concept of evidence contrary to mine?



Yrreg
 
As a matter of fact it has already happened, so you are behind the fact.

I've actually always fancied the idea that the pre-existing reality antecedent to the material universe is indeterminate because it hasn't happened yet.

"Go the blue" ?



As a matter of fact it has already happened, so you are behind the fact.

Or do you belong to the nothingness cosmology school where illogic rules in the nothingness of the origin of the universe?




Yrreg
 
Isn't it the common consensus here that the universe has always existed?

Isn't it the common consensus here that the universe has always existed?


Or do we have here folks who are of the conviction that the universe came forth from absolute nothingness?


The task now is to concur on a concept of the universe.

For my part:
The universe is the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom