God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

It is irrational and illogical on your part if you have no idea of evidence.

That makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. Just because things have beginnings and endings does not mean that a creator exists, nor does it mean that the Christian God is that creator. It's your claim that God exists, it's your burden of proof. This means it's up to you to provide evidence, and the fact that things exist, or that the universe itself exists, is not evidence for a creator or for a god.

I assert (not claim) God does not exist because there is no evidence of any god. If you have convincing, testable, reliable evidence of a god then present it. What you have presented so far is a poor restatement of the Kalām Cosmological argument, which is easily refutable.


See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7751551#post7751551 for evidence of God's existence in the universe:

Post 531 First we must have a mutually agreed on the concept of evidence.


Yrreg said:
Originally Posted by Agatha
The existence of the universe is evidence only for the existence of the universe.

Your assertion that it is proof of a god is unevidenced, and referring to your assertion as a proof does not make it one. I do not say this to tire you out but to point out the error in your thinking.
​


First, of course we have to agree on what is evidence.


Without a concurring concept of evidence, the target of evidence, and how evidence works, it is useless for you to assert God does not exist.

I do have a ccncept of evidence, and accordiing to my concept of evidence, God exists.


Here is my concept of evidence:
A Fact known by man leading him to know another fact.
​

And here is the evidence for God's existence, the fact of the existence of the universe.

How does the fact of the existence ascertain the fact of God's existence?

Here, in the universe there are realities which have a beginning and an ending to their existence, wherefore they do not bring themselves to existence, therefore God exists as their creator.


What evidence or your concept of evidence do you have to ascertain that God does not exist?

.​

.​


The above quote might be deleted, so just read the link.





That is why we have to agree on what is evidence, because evidence is our bridge to the existence of God.



You don't want to admit my evidence but you don't have any concept of evidence, so it is irrational and illogical on your part: to deny my evidence for the existence of God but you have no idea of what is evidence.




I have been presenting that evidence since November 5, 2011, but no one seems to be reading it, and even much earlier passim.




Yrreg
 
Even if I accept your rather odd definition of evidence, the existence of the universe is not evidence for a creator, nor that the creator (if it exists at all) is the Christian God.

Let me try to break it down so you can see where you are missing steps from "universe exists" to "therefore God".

The universe exists, most people will agree on that.

First you need to show evidence that the universe had a beginning.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe has a beginning, you have not shown any evidence that it was created.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe was created, you have not shown any evidence that the creator was any kind of god.

Even if you show evidence that it was created by a god, you have not shown any evidence that the god in question is the Christian God.

You need to work on those steps, providing evidence (not assertions) for each step as you go.
 
Last edited:
But tell me because I am talking about the universe as the evidence for God's existence [...]


So anyone can make up any old thing and claim that it exists because the Universe exists? And you don't see how completely useless your standard of evidence is?
 
It is crucially important that we have a common concept of evidence.

Yrreg, "the universe exists, therefore God" is not evidence.




Why the random full stops in the right hand margin?

.​

.​

The universe is the evidence of God's existence, that is what I say, and specially everything in the universe that has a beginning and an ending.

Please, we must come to an agreed on concept of evidence, otherwise you will be saying it is no evidence but you don't have any idea of evidence.


About that extreme right period mark, it is not random but designed by me, it is just for putting a space between lines I want to put a space in between so that things don't look so cluttered up -- if there is no design from me to thus effect a space between lines of text, then the robot here has been programmed to close up any empty paragraph space effected by the user of the message editing box.





Yrreg
 
About that extreme right period mark, it is not random but designed by me, it is just for putting a space between lines I want to put a space in between so that things don't look so cluttered up -- if there is no design from me to thus effect a space between lines of text, then the robot here has been programmed to close up any empty paragraph space effected by the user of the message editing box.





Yrreg


So how did you manage to get those five lines of space between the end of your post and your username? I don't see any full stops there.
 
.​

The universe is the evidence of God's existence...


No, it isn't. You have failed to fill in the gaps in your reasoning that Agatha has pointed out:
Even if I accept your rather odd definition of evidence, the existence of the universe is not evidence for a creator, nor that the creator (if it exists at all) is the Christian God.

Let me try to break it down so you can see where you are missing steps from "universe exists" to "therefore God".

The universe exists, most people will agree on that.

First you need to show evidence that the universe had a beginning.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe has a beginning, you have not shown any evidence that it was created.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe was created, you have not shown any evidence that the creator was any kind of god.

Even if you show evidence that it was created by a god, you have not shown any evidence that the god in question is the Christian God.

You need to work on those steps, providing evidence (not assertions) for each step as you go.
 
As usual we have to agree on a concept of the universe.

Even if I accept your rather odd definition of evidence, the existence of the universe is not evidence for a creator, nor that the creator (if it exists at all) is the Christian God.

Let me try to break it down so you can see where you are missing steps from "universe exists" to "therefore God".

The universe exists, most people will agree on that.

First you need to show evidence that the universe had a beginning.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe has a beginning, you have not shown any evidence that it was created.

Even if you can show evidence that the universe was created, you have not shown any evidence that the creator was any kind of god.

Even if you show evidence that it was created by a god, you have not shown any evidence that the god in question is the Christian God.

You need to work on those steps, providing evidence (not assertions) for each step as you go.



As usual we have to agree on a concept of the universe.


Do you have a concept of the universe?


Here is my concept of the universe:
The totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​


If you find that concept too huge, then you cannot grasp the concept of God from me as also with all Christians, in His fundamental relation to the universe:
God is the creator (I used maker before but it's okay if you want to revert to maker) of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


And here again and again and again is my concept of evidence:
A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.​



So, you have now again and again and again my concepts of universe, God, and evidence.


As regards God I have to tell you again and again and again: you have to acquaint yourselves all you atheists with the concept of God as propounded by theists of the Christian faith: because you are denying their God, so you have to get acquainted with their concept of God, not they getting acquainted with your concept of God.

And please don't bring in that canard that there are other gods, etc. etc. etc., because you are in a thread from a Christian theist, whose concept of God in His fundamental relation to the universe is
God is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​


As regards my concept of universe and of evidence, that is where we can work out most crucially to come to mutually accepted concepts of respectively universe and evidence, but you have already my concepts.


Still as regards my concept of God if you want some addition or revision or deduction, just let me know, but keep in mind that I am talking about God in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe.



Yrreg
 
Man is not part and parcel of the universe; you are still using that idiom incorrectly despite being corrected several times.

The universe is everything that exists. This is the same as your definition but without the misuse of language and without the repetition.

As I said above, and you quoted it so I have to assume that you read it, you are missing the steps between "the universe exists" and "therefore a creator God".

It is of no use to simply assert that the universe is evidence for God, you have to show evidence of the universe beginning, evidence that it was created, evidence that the creator was the Christian God. Otherwise all you are doing is a poor presentation of the Kalām Cosmological argument.
 
I really don't know how the program works, but sometimes it works, so to make sure...

So how did you manage to get those five lines of space between the end of your post and your username? I don't see any full stops there.



I really don't know how the program works, but sometimes it works, so as to make sure when I really want space to intercept between lines of text, I use the extreme right period mark.

How do I know when it does not work?


When I do a preview of my post and the empty space gaps I introduced are closed up by the robot.


No, please, I have no sinister agenda with those extreme right period marks.

Don't be apprehensive that I am going to spring a GOTCHA on you.

I only do that if you examine that thread whatever where I sprang that Gotcha on people is when people are so conspicuously obviously clearly and ignorantly inconsistent with their thoughts.


I came to a website from an astrophysicist talking about how the universe came forth from nothing, at the start of his write-up he keeps harping on nothing at all, absolutely nothing, then he slips in (wait, I will look up that writer's website)...


Ah, here it is his definitions of nothing, and my interactions with him.

http://www.thekeyboard.org.uk/Where universe from.htm


Definition of nothing.
The use of the word 'nothing' has a very special meaning in this context, unlike our every day use of the word. It means here quite literally nothing, the complete absence of everything. By definition then nothing must be an infinite void.

[…]

A new definition.
We will retain the description of nothing that we had before, as an infinite void, keeping it exactly as it was, except for one change. We will now allow it to contain the universe.
Our new definition of nothing will now read: nothing is an infinite void, nothing else can exist except for the universe that is contained within it.

[...]

.​



I emailed him to notify him that he has committed an inconsistency, he answered me back stating that I am talking crap.

In my latest contact with him I wrote in his guest-book and so far the man has not deleted my guest entry, but he has got to have his last word:

http://guestbook.sparklit.com/entries.spark?gbID=59304&gbaction=viewResponses


Pachomius aka Yrreg said:
Posted On: November 11, 2011 10:31:05 AM

: Pachomius
: pachomius2000(@)yahoo.com.sg


Comments: Please draw up a glossary of terms you use or mention in your website.

I am sure that as you work on this glossary, you will get more insights into the questions you seek to answer, and thus have better answers for your readers, because the terms which you will define in your glossary must be coherent non-contradictory in their meanings which you will give to them as you use them in your website.


Pachomius

*****************************

EDITOR: I was not aware that I had used any terms that required explanation, indeed, my site is all about presenting things in as clear and simple a way as possible. Anyone having problems understanding terms I have used have clearly come to the wrong site.

*****************************

.​



Enjoy!





Yrreg
 
Clearly you are not responsive to my request for you to present your concept of...

Man is not part and parcel of the universe; you are still using that idiom incorrectly despite being corrected several times.

The universe is everything that exists. This is the same as your definition but without the misuse of language and without the repetition.

As I said above, and you quoted it so I have to assume that you read it, you are missing the steps between "the universe exists" and "therefore a creator God".

It is of no use to simply assert that the universe is evidence for God, you have to show evidence of the universe beginning, evidence that it was created, evidence that the creator was the Christian God. Otherwise all you are doing is a poor presentation of the Kalām Cosmological argument.



Clearly you are not responsive to my request for you to present your concept of evidence.


How can you keep insisting that in effect there is no evidence when you have no idea which you can present on what is evidence.



So, you can go on and on and on and on that I have no evidence, and I will just tell you that you have no idea of evidence.



Did I give here the illustration about the guy taking up the time of the shop-keeper and the latter asks him whether he has money, but he gets angry instead of producing some dollar bills.





Yrreg
 
I only do that if you examine that thread whatever where I sprang that Gotcha on people is when people are so conspicuously obviously clearly and ignorantly inconsistent with their thoughts.

Yrreg

More evidence that you only read your own posts.
 
The Oxford Dictionary defines evidence as "the available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid", which seems to me to be a perfectly good definition.

The existence of the universe does not indicate anything about whether the Christian God exists or not; so is not in and of itself evidence for the existence of the Christian God.
 
That is why we have to agree on what is evidence, because evidence is our bridge to the existence of God.

You don't want to admit my evidence but you don't have any concept of evidence, so it is irrational and illogical on your part: to deny my evidence for the existence of God but you have no idea of what is evidence.


But, Gerry, I presented you with a long list of evidence that conformed to all of your requirements and you flat-out ignored it.

My post answering you was here: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=7309207#post7309207

So, you've already had the opportunity to discuss what is and is not evidence. I gave you five examples, as you asked. They were in the form that you personally made up, as you asked. And you never responded.

Please pick up from my post and explain exactly how I've misunderstood the concept of "evidence."
 
Yrreg, can you please tell me when the song "99 bottles of beer on the wall" begins and ends.
 
So, you can go on and on and on and on that I have no evidence, and I will just tell you that you have no idea of evidence.


Evidence, when analyzed by independent objective observers, would lead those observers to the same conclusion. It is not true that the existence of the Universe is evidence for the existence of your god.
 
Evidence, when analyzed by independent objective observers, would lead those observers to the same conclusion. It is not true that the existence of the Universe is evidence for the existence of your god.


I don't think that's a necessarily true property of evidence.

Evidence is anything that tends to make a statement more or less true. Evidence doesn't need to be conclusive to be evidence. Ron Goldman's DNA was found in OJ's car. This makes it more likely that OJ killed Ron Goldman. And yet ...
 
A

And here again and again and again is my concept of evidence:
A fact known to man leading him to know another fact.​



So, you have now again and again and again my concepts of universe, God, and evidence.


As regards God I have to tell you again and again and again: you have to acquaint yourselves all you atheists with the concept of God as propounded by theists of the Christian faith: because you are denying their God, so you have to get acquainted with their concept of God, not they getting acquainted with your concept of God.

Yeah, yeah, yeah, blah, blah, blah. Stop avoiding the one thing you need to establish; Namely this fact "known" to man and the one thing you are being asked to prove: Evidence that a Christian God does exist and it's the only one as a fact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom