gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
the funniest thing to me is that whenever there is a perfectly normal correction all the top callers and bubble-heads reappear with their "I told you so" nonsense, having been wrong the last time they did it, and the time before, and the time before..

and this time is far from a normal correction, there are extremely good reasons that gold should be heading upwards fundamentally, however a combination of panic deleveraging and banks having to sell gold to raise cash (including negative lease rates) has caused a decline instead.

but one wonders how having called the top of the bubble so wrongly, so many times, and then disappearing as it rips off to new highs once more, people who don't actually understand the first thing about it then have the nerve to then reappear and try once more at the next correction.

this made me chuckle this week, Mish (who is an ardent deflationist) ripping the ever gold-clueless Roubini a new one

http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2011/12/dear-nouriel-roubini-fundamental-case.html

Dear Nouriel Roubini

As noted above, the fundamental case for gold has not changed. In a single sentence, the fundamental case for gold is that Monetartist clowns and Keynesian fools will eventually get their way.

When it comes to bailouts and printing money, it is nearly given central banks will try it, with more and more force, each time. The irony Nouriel, is you are begging them to do just that, every step of the way.

Gold has only fallen because central bankers ignored (for the time being), your foolish recommendations to print and spend more money.

If central banks do not resort to the printing press, if governments do not give in to more absurd Keynesian stimulus ideas, and if the US budget deficit is brought under control, then, yes, gold may have topped.

How likely is that?

Nouriel, if you want to better understand the fundamentals of gold, I advise you to look in the mirror and recite your "cure" for the economy.

How long have you been bearish on gold anyway? For something like forever or simply the last 1000 points? Regardless of your answer, the monetary policies you yourself espouse would have us at $2000 right now.

edit, if you check out this chart and combine that with the levels of institutional investment shown in Sprott's report you *should* be able to work out where we actually are.

sigh.
 
Last edited:
Gold Falls to Five-Month Low

Gold Falls to Five-Month Low in London as Dollar Extends Gains

"Dec. 29 (Bloomberg) -- Gold fell to a five-month low in London as extended gains in the dollar heightened speculation of slowing demand for precious metals...

Gold for immediate delivery fell as much as 2 percent to $1,524.80 an ounce, the lowest since July 7 and was at $1,527.49 an ounce by 11:08 a.m. in London.

Futures for February delivery declined 2.1 percent to $1,531.40 an ounce on the Comex in New York and earlier today dropped to $1,525, also the lowest since July 8."
 
Gold Falls to Five-Month Low in London as Dollar Extends Gains

"Dec. 29 (Bloomberg) -- Gold fell to a five-month low in London as extended gains in the dollar heightened speculation of slowing demand for precious metals...

Gold for immediate delivery fell as much as 2 percent to $1,524.80 an ounce, the lowest since July 7 and was at $1,527.49 an ounce by 11:08 a.m. in London.

Futures for February delivery declined 2.1 percent to $1,531.40 an ounce on the Comex in New York and earlier today dropped to $1,525, also the lowest since July 8."

did you have a point or is this just a price report?
 
did you have a point or is this just a price report?
Price is what this thread is all about. The poll asked:- "Where do you think the gold price is going?"

Back on the 3rd of September I said "Obviously the price of gold can't continue to rise at its current exponential rate" and predicted a bubble. Your response to that was derisive, but gold is now trading at a significantly lower price, with no indication that it will beat its August peak anytime soon. Gold's performance so far this year has been well below average (only a 9.9% gain, vs 19% average since 2002), and indications are that it will continue to languish through 2012.
 
Price is what this thread is all about. The poll asked:- "Where do you think the gold price is going?"

Back on the 3rd of September I said "Obviously the price of gold can't continue to rise at its current exponential rate" and predicted a bubble. Your response to that was derisive, but gold is now trading at a significantly lower price, with no indication that it will beat its August peak anytime soon. Gold's performance so far this year has been well below average (only a 9.9% gain, vs 19% average since 2002), and indications are that it will continue to languish through 2012.

I dont remember ever saying

"straight up with no corrections ever"

we see significant corrections regularly, followed by consolidation and explosive moves higher, this time will be no different.

shall I keep you updated every $50 on the way back up? :D
 
Gold's performance so far this year has been well below average (only a 9.9% gain, vs 19% average since 2002), and indications are that it will continue to languish through 2012.

Compared with what, and at what risk? I'm ok "languishing" at 9.9%. How about that SPX? The spread between the 9.9% and the roughly 1.5% the SPX has returned so far for 2011 is about equal to the historical annual expected total return for equities. Too bad you would have missed a year if you were in equities (except for Central Scrutinizer's stocks, of course, we all know they levitate).
 
Gold's performance so far this year has been well below average (only a 9.9% gain, vs 19% average since 2002), and indications are that it will continue to languish through 2012.

Daily Price Report

Gold rebounded strongly overnight as the Asian and Antipodean markets realized the New Year Sale was in full swing with some amazing bargains to be had, with buying topping out at over $1560 in overnight trading and trading as high as $1563.20 in early European markets.

As always much has been made in the media of the correction with all the usual suspects proclaiming "the end of the gold bull market" yet again, however Hedge Fund End of Year "window dressing" and selling their main winning positions to cover their margin calls and equities losers, combined with negative gold leasing rates and large short side speculation on the paper gold market have been unable to dampen enthusiasm from the other side of the world who do understand the monetary role of gold in today's broken fiat system.

Gold's performance this year - when looked at peak to peak (2010 - $1430) to (2011 - $1920) which is a more accurate technical assessment of performance than attempting to pin arbitrary dates (01 Jan to 30Dec) on it has in fact been a stellar 34.2% with no indication of slowing.

Indeed the strong overnight bounce following massive churning volume on the GLD yesterday morning is likely indicative of a solid bottoming out and has caught some newer traders who really should know better (me) wrong-footed and still short at $1535 hoping for a further fall to $1480 before BTFTU (backing the ******* truck up) on the long side again.

(here's hoping for one more final plunge to at least let me out of my leveraged gambling position)

This has been Kevsta's Daily Gold Report signing off on the last day of 2011, we would like to wish everybody a happy new year and we will see you back here on Tuesday 3rd January 2012 :D
 
Last edited:
Daily Gold Report

Gold rallied again in overnight trading touching as high as $1587.05 in overnight trading, and continued the rally as Europe came back to work for 2012.

One particular trader (who really should have known better) closed out his shorts for a loss on Friday but is glad he did this morning, and especially as he got long again at $1579 this morning.
 
Daily Price Report

Gold continued it's rebound yesterday trading up to $1607 in the afternoon, with what looked like a short squeeze in action, and many traders still caught on the wrong side of the action.

Overnight trading was then rangebound between $1593 and $1608, but hit highs of $1613.20 in early London trading today.

the EURUSD / PMs correlation which has been so strong over the latter part of 2011 initially powered the recovery as EURUSD bounced back from 1.2875 above the critical 1.30 point, up to approx 1.307 but the metals correlation appeared to be breaking down last night with EUR and Gold/silver going in opposite directions on the 5 minute chart, it has been many months since this has been observed.



Note I wont be continuing with the daily price report, I dont really think it's necessary with every minor move, lets check in at say every $100 in either direction?
 
Last edited:
$1700 falls once again.

178524f204bf96a0a1.jpg


ZIRP4EVA and a leveraged FOMC report is a thing of rare beauty :D
 
Last edited:
heh, only on the way down eh? ;)

edit: ok then, this is news, gold to hit new highs in days

Yeah, I've heard that before....and it might happen.

Call me cynical, but the way both the property market (in the UK at least) and the PM markets have been rigged since 2008 leads me to believe that the real action in gold and silver isn't going to happen until the economic whirlwind finally swallows up the US dollar. All the action is in the Eurozone at the moment. The world appears to have forgotten that the UK and the US have both also got unresolvable debt problems, and that the US potentially has "political paralysis" problems to rival those of the eurozone.

In the end the gold and silver bugs will win, but it might not be until the very end.
 
Yeah, I've heard that before....and it might happen.

Call me cynical, but the way both the property market (in the UK at least) and the PM markets have been rigged since 2008 leads me to believe that the real action in gold and silver isn't going to happen until the economic whirlwind finally swallows up the US dollar.

cynical.

All the action is in the Eurozone at the moment. The world appears to have forgotten that the UK and the US have both also got unresolvable debt problems, and that the US potentially has "political paralysis" problems to rival those of the eurozone.

who has? I haven't.
 

Anyone who currently believes that dollars, sterling or US and UK government debt will be some sort of "safe haven" from the storm. Well...I guess people whose business is betting on short-term currency moves might want to play about with dollars and sterling, but I don't understand why anybody in their right mind would buy long-term US or UK government bonds. I have even less idea why anybody would buy US municipal bonds. There are cities and states in the US that are in almost as much trouble as Greece.
 
massive battle going on at $1750 but looks it might fall this morning, if we breach $1756 - next stop is Sinclair's (Jesse Livermore's) $1764 "Angel"

I'm personally still hoping for a re-test of $1705 or maybe even $1680 but gold is looking so strong it's starting to look doubtful, for the moment at least.

Sinclair32.jpg
 
Yeah, I've heard that before....and it might happen.

Call me cynical, but the way both the property market (in the UK at least) and the PM markets have been rigged since 2008 leads me to believe that the real action in gold and silver isn't going to happen until the economic whirlwind finally swallows up the US dollar. All the action is in the Eurozone at the moment. The world appears to have forgotten that the UK and the US have both also got unresolvable debt problems, and that the US potentially has "political paralysis" problems to rival those of the eurozone.

In the end the gold and silver bugs will win, but it might not be until the very end.

I think you are forgetting that the reason why people have been running to the US is because the eurobanks are highly leveraged. While US does leveraging on their own, its nothing compared to what the banks in Europe are doing.
 
I think you are forgetting that the reason why people have been running to the US is because the eurobanks are highly leveraged. While US does leveraging on their own, its nothing compared to what the banks in Europe are doing.

lol. oh it is if youre counting the many trillions of derivatives, 97% of which are written by the (US) big 5.

http://www.occ.treas.gov/topics/capital-markets/financial-markets/trading/derivatives/dq111.pdf

this is why the ISDA cannot rule that even a 70% haircut is a default, because you'll find out exactly how leveraged everybody is then, and why when it actually matters, contrary to popular belief, Net = Gross

How US banks are lying about their European exposure and why Net will equal gross
 
Last edited:
lol. oh it is if youre counting the many trillions of derivatives, 97% of which are written by the (US) big 5.

http://www.occ.treas.gov/topics/capital-markets/financial-markets/trading/derivatives/dq111.pdf

this is why the ISDA cannot rule that even a 70% haircut is a default, because you'll find out exactly how leveraged everybody is then, and why when it actually matters, contrary to popular belief, Net = Gross

How US banks are lying about their European exposure and why Net will equal gross

I have a solution. Keep "restructuring" well into the thousands of a percentage point eg (99.9999999%). That way it's never a default, and the CDS don't get triggered.

That or just threaten European taxpayers with armageddon if they don't assume all of the bad debts and phony insurance policies, debase the currency, and pay off the creditors.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom