Origin of the paint that was found as red-gray chips - any ideas?

I see that the twoofers are scrambling for any excuses to dismiss the results of a study that hasn't even been completed yet. Guess they know they're full of it.

It's almost

Too funny.
 
Chris I notice you never made mention of the Cate Jenkins EPA whistle blowing
report that prominently features Lab Guy Dr. Millette?

You seemed to think that our only interest was Millette's not being more open about his observation of iron microspheres.

MM

Mostly because Cate Jenkin is nuttier than squirrel *** I would assume. Why would it even need to be brought up? It's been proven previously in this thread that she has no credibility. The study that Dr. Millette was working on, at the time, had nothing to do with the spheres so they were irrelevant.
 
I wrote a long reply to this latest blog entry. We'll see if Kevin Ryan posts it.

Ya gotta admit, Chris: what truly neutral and independent lab service would have previously published a dust study for the government AND offer you a deep discount to do another? :D

And isn't the EPA the same agency that told everybody the air was safe at Ground Zero?
 
oh the wonderful well poisoning. meanwhile we are supposed to overlook the repeated running from scrutiny truthers do. now we have a reputable scientist in the truly relevant field willing to subject himself to the scrutiny of real authorities on the suject. oh the denial.
 
I notice you haven't retracted your previous lie about the Tillotson communication?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8032814&postcount=1960

So much for your credibility.

MM

Of course, I retract nothing since I have the mails from two authors of this article... ;)
An extract : "DSC in an O2 atmosphere will combust the organic impurities and greatly add to the energy release. However the DSC in question was done in ultra purenitrogen"

So I repeat: thermXte scammers lie when they said that they have contacted Tillotson and he has confirmed ambiant air for DSC.

This protocol would be stupid since he had epoxy residues in his sample (I have given the page in a precendent post)
Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ya gotta admit, Chris: what truly neutral and independent lab service would have previously published a dust study for the government AND offer you a deep discount to do another? :D

And isn't the EPA the same agency that told everybody the air was safe at Ground Zero?

The same scientist that would state his findings in a gathering of peers related to his field.

The same scientist that has every intention, along with his presentation, of having his paper peer reviewed by people in his field.

Neither of these two did Harrit et. al. have any intentions of doing. I would say that speaks volumes. Also, the fact that Kevin Ryan and co. wouldn't release their samples is pretty telling about what they have to hide.

Poison the well all you want to, in hind sight this study is just a nail in the coffin. Unneeded for any reason at all, mostly due to the fact that every single piece of credible, researched information shows that any form of explosive, no matter how many names you give it, is not responsible for the destruction of the 3 buildings that day.
 
Chris I notice you never made mention of the Cate Jenkins EPA whistle blowing
report that prominently features Lab Guy Dr. Millette?

You seemed to think that our only interest was Millette's not being more open about his observation of iron microspheres.

MM

The charges against Millette are pretty serious. I guess it's not all that surprising why this would be the scientist, among the "dozens" Chris interviewed, picked as supposedly neutral and independent.
 
Chris I notice you never made mention of the Cate Jenkins EPA whistle blowing
report that prominently features Lab Guy Dr. Millette?

You seemed to think that our only interest was Millette's not being more open about his observation of iron microspheres.

MM
I looked for any negative reviews of Jim Millette and found none on the internet prior to choosing him. His name appears in the Jenkins accusations, but looking it over, he wasn't a primary player. All I could see was the fact that Millette said lots of iron in the dust but didn't specifically say iron-rich microspheres. Nor do I consider it necessary for him to have said it in a paper about health hazards. If you read his actual paper, it lists some REALLY hazardous organic chemicals, radiological waste, aresenic, asbestos, you name it. It was a very thorough and honest report on the hazards of the WTC dust, flatly contradicting the initial EPA declaration that the air in lower Manhattan was safe to breathe. As he said to me about the dust, "If I find it I'll publish it." He has already proven this by publishing a report that lists some very major environmental hazards, EPA declaratiions notwithstanding!
 
The charges against Millette are pretty serious. I guess it's not all that surprising why this would be the scientist, among the "dozens" Chris interviewed, picked as supposedly neutral and independent.

No, RedIbis, they are only serious to you, because you're more interested in discrediting the individual that is going to prove the Harrit et. al. paper to be a fallacy for CT'ists.
 
Ya gotta admit, Chris: what truly neutral and independent lab service would have previously published a dust study for the government AND offer you a deep discount to do another? :D

And isn't the EPA the same agency that told everybody the air was safe at Ground Zero?
Hi Ergo, Red Ibis, MM, others,

I've said it till I'm blue in the face: I have found nothing serious in any allegations against Dr. Jim Millette. I have asked him point blank several times about what few allegations I have been able to find (iron microspheres etc). These accusations are not serious. Not specific. They are ad hominem attacks which must be backed up by specific claims. Please tell me what those claims are, specifically. Don't just say he wrote for the EPA. WHAT did he write that was dishonest? Have you wasted hours actually researching these allegations as I have? Quotes and references and proof please. You're attacking and attacking the professional integrity of a scientist I think is honest. This is nauseating. Even I don't take you seriously any more.
 
Chris,

Kevin Ryan wrote

This is a claim whose veracity can't be assessed without seeing the actual communications. Were these entirely by e-mail, and do you have copies of the entire exchange? Then maybe you could ask Kevin to publish the entire exchange, so that people can see for themselves if his allegation holds water!?
We'll see if Kevin allows my reply on his blog. If he does, and if he continues to assert my dishonesty, I WILL ask him to publish the entire exchange, which is 100% email. As a matter of policy I never publish emails of 9/11 truth people without permission.
 
The charges against Millette are pretty serious. I guess it's not all that surprising why this would be the scientist, among the "dozens" Chris interviewed, picked as supposedly neutral and independent.
How can a pH level be a factor of 10 off? Please explain.

Cate Jenkins, her paper, how did you find it? Did you read it? Please explain what she said, and back it up with some chemistry.
 
Last edited:
Poison the well all you want to, in hind sight this study is just a nail in the coffin. Unneeded for any reason at all, mostly due to the fact that every single piece of credible, researched information shows that any form of explosive, no matter how many names you give it, is not responsible for the destruction of the 3 buildings that day.

How do you poison a poisoned well?

MM
 
We'll see if Kevin allows my reply on his blog. If he does, and if he continues to assert my dishonesty, I WILL ask him to publish the entire exchange, which is 100% email. As a matter of policy I never publish emails of 9/11 truth people without permission.

You mean if he doesn't, right?

Please keep us posted!
 
"Chris I notice you never made mention of the Cate Jenkins EPA whistle blowing
report that prominently features Lab Guy Dr. Millette?

You seemed to think that our only interest was Millette's not being more open about his observation of iron microspheres."
"The charges against Millette are pretty serious. I guess it's not all that surprising why this would be the scientist, among the "dozens" Chris interviewed, picked as supposedly neutral and independent."

Well I have made no charges but before everyone jumps on that, I would like to say my concern lies with Dr. Millette's key role in EPA reports which have been charged as fraudulent to the detriment of the public health.

Paul Lioy said:
"... In our work, published in 2002 in Environmental Health Perspectives, July we did not find any of this material and we measured many things, organic and inorganic. Within our Team Jim Millette of MVA, Atlanta GA did our microscopic analyses..."

In her whistle blowing complaint filed on May 6, 2007, Cate Jenkins, Ph.D of the EPA listed Dr. Millette 4 times.

Chris Mohr who has constantly publicized his exhaustive 9/11 research and self promoted his large collection of pro Official Story YouTube videos, made no mention of this controversial link when promoting the virtues of Dr. Millette and his laboratory association.

Chris stated how he checked out dozens of possible candidates before deciding Dr. Millette was the most objective and trustworthy.

But reading back through his JREF posts, a different narrative appears.

On Nov. 15, 2011 Chris posted here about receiving an anonymous email referring to the paper; Comparisons of the dust/smoke particulate that settled inside the surrounding buildings and outside on the streets of southern New York City after the collapse of the World Trade Center, September 11, 2001. Paul Lioy and Jim Millette were listed as two of the authors.

So Chris tells us he decides to contact Paul Lioy for a lab recommendation for a new investigation into the claims there is thermitic material in the WTC dust.

Paul Lioy naturally recommends the person he used in his 2002 report for all the microscopic analyses, Dr. Millette.

Of course, Chris follows up on that recommendation by contacting Dr. Millette about doing this investigation.

On Nov.17, 2011, Chris posts that he has received another interesting email "from a guy (I'll leave him anonymous for now.) Since his company participated in a WTC dust study."

With hindsight, that anonymous person was obviously Dr. Millette.

On Nov.18, 2011, Chris posts that he might have found someone he actually wants to work with.

The rest is history.

This person, Lab Guy Dr. Millette remained anonymous in all Chris's posts until Dec.23, 2011 when he made his official 'out of the closet' announcement.

Of course at that time, Chris was seeking funds to semi-legitimize research that Dr. Millette has shown he was more than willing to pursue regardless of our dime.

So I am left wondering about many things.

Things like the dozens of investigated labs.

Things like, why did Chris redact Dr. Millette's identity for so long, referring to him as the Lab Guy?

Things like the Dr. Millette releasing some of his findings but withholding the rest until peer-reviewed.

Things like promises of early disclosure by Chris and Dr. Millette that became significant delays due to the Atlanta Conference and peer-reviewing. This is stuff they knew in advance and should have mentioned before hyping the project by creating false delivery date expectations.

Things like carbon nano-tubes found in the lungs of many suffering first responders.

Was all of this a setup so that Dr. Millette could present a pseudo-objective report to counter the 2009 Bentham Paper and possibly also discount his non-discovery of health critical, nanothermite-related, carbon nano-tubes?

Chris has made much out of Kevin Ryan's unwillingness to cooperate and now I have a better understanding of why that might be.

I can only hope that we get honest results from Dr. Millette's work but all things considered, I am not optimistic.

MM
 
Last edited:
I see a lot of fear in Ryan's blog, namely that a professional peer reviewed study is going to show him up. No one knows what Dr Millette is going to find so why is he poisoning the well? Why are other truthers, with regard to the environmental effect of the dust, all of a sudden trying to portray this man as part of a cover up? They are trying to discredit a man before any data or paper has come to light. That is poisoning the well.
I wonder if there is a case for libel.

Harrit and Ryan should both have submitted their samples to an independent laboratory for examination to confirm the presence of thermite. They haven't done so. Why not?

I'm sure that "McCrones" would readily accept samples from Harrit, Ryan and Millette (as well as any other source) for a result if it was paid for. McCrone wrote the book on particle analysis. However, I'd bet everything I had that even this wouldn't be enough for truthers to accept.
 
Surely one of the main difficulties in getting the dust examined is the ability for a lab to actually get hold of any dust or red/gray chips to analyse. A lab that can't source dust or chips is useless. Seeing as Harrit et al have not openly acknowledged to supply their samples or dust as far as I or others know, and the fact that Ryan refused, then surely obtaining dust is one of the factors in the choice of laboratory.

Secondly, cost is an issue. If it cost $10, 000 to perform such tests then this is an obstacle to such testing bearing in mind how obscure and insignificant such a test is with regard to the scientific community.
 
BYU links to delusional paper by Jones and his gang of paranoid nuts on 911 issues. (plus some more nutty papers)

http://www.physics.byu.edu/research/energy/

Is BYU indirectly, unknowingly endorsing idiotic claims?

Does BYU know someone included Jones' delusional papers on his hero page? Who edits Jones web page for the University? Does BYU include crazy conspiracy stuff to attract more students? Why include anti-intellectual papers on a University web page, papers which are politically bias, and make up conclusions not supported by the paper?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom