Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

It is repeated, several times IIRC, that,

"If you let them go we will continue to protest peacefully."

Did you not hear this part, or just didn't bother to write about it?

The video is several minutes long, there is much of it that I "didn't bother" (ah, words) to write about. I wrote mostly about its value as support for your interpretation.

I did hear the chant you mention, but I'm at a loss as to the point you're trying to make.

I didn't make the video, I posted it - if you wish to critique the captions the person put over the video, feel free to PM them on youtube.

You offered the video as support for your interpretation. I pointed out that the only way the video supports your interpretation is in the captions. I critique the captions, those that misleadingly 'support' your interpretation, and others, so that we might understand how they fail to 'support' your interpretation (although they seem to share it) and perhaps give an insight into how someone can delude themselves that there is evidence for their presuppositions.

Considering the circumstances, surrounded and outnumbered and being told,
"If you let them go, we will let you leave."
And
"If you let them go, we will continue to protest peacefully."

That is a verbal threat, echoed by the mob.

:rolleyes:

Oh, pwned by a smiley. Fair enough then. Big butch police, in force, armed and armoured (and, we hope, trained and experienced) feel 'threatened' by peaceful student protestors blocking their way. I see your rolled eyes and raise you that scoffing dog that I won't stoop to actually posting.

I'm loving the emotion you're injecting into this. However, your translation is incorrect. The proper translation is,

"We object to your actions and implore you to reconsider them or else."

"Or else we will continue both to object and implore". Is there a step up from the scoffing dog?

The police removed those who were arrested to a location where they would be picked up by a cruiser and removed from campus. As well as physically blocking this cruiser, you can see the police being surrounded on all sides by the protesters. I'm not sure how you overlooked this, but I'd hate to think you did it on purpose.

Well, those inaccurate and biased captions get in the way a lot. Can you reference a frame or so where we see the police surrounded? Seriously, I said I'm prepared to accept that they are, but your claim that the video shows it is, I believe, inaccurate. But I accepted it. And you're still arguing about it.

The protesters were verbally threatening the police with rioting. I'm not sure why you want to discuss whose more threatened as it is irrelevant to the legal issue.

It is not irrelevant to your claim or your position. Your use of the word 'threatened' might have some pedantic dictionary application to the situation, but its use is fatuous here. Maybe if you'd said 'the police were threatened by the people that they were threatening', but maybe you just didn't bother?

But let us take a sidestep into a world of the imagination for a moment, and agree that the protestors are being verbally threatening. What is the proper response to a verbal threat? Is it pepper spray? Is it to pepper spray a seated person who is offering no threat?

Most of their defenders, like thaiboxerken for instance.

Context. I may be wrong but I don't think thaiboxerken told the caption writer anything. Unless it is you? Is it? You have snipped part of a comment on a caption. Even if we were broadly discussing whether protest can ever be 'peaceful', what thaiboxer ken has to say is neither here nor there. Speak for yourself, and take what issues you will with what I say. I'll speak for myself and I trust thaiboxerken won't care that he does not speak for me. I'd be fascinated to learn if he has spoken to the caption writer, but it would remain irrelevant if he had.
 
Dude its a university. If you are lucky enough to get a bunch of students in one place you either deliver a lecture or wait for them to go away.

I think you have found the perfect way to break up these types of student demonstrations. Get a group of professors, set up a microphone and loudspeakers, and provide educational lectures continuously until they disperse. Shouldn't take too long.
 
Taking down tents which were put up illegally on campus is anything but a harsh rule/law. Knock it off.

Its relative. The point is that "its the law" doesn't on its own amount to much of an argument.


Immature and impractical opinion noted.

Its a valid method of dealing with the problem although admitedy it helps if you have a british style climate. Students are a fairly transient population. You are unlikely to end up with another greenham common.
 
yeah! That'll show those nasty coppers that they shouldn't remove people blocking a public sidewalk in a way that minimizes risk of injury to themselves and the protesters! Teach those pigs that the best way to remove people from a place they're not supposed to be when they're interlocking arms is to wrench those arms right out of their sockets!

yeah! Brute law enforcement [[[[rocks]]]]!!!!!!!! Doesn't it????
 
Oh, I also looooooove how JREF re-writes my posts for me! THANK YOU JREF!!

JAAAAAAYYYY REF... You make my DAAAAYYYY!!!
 
Your complete and utter ignorance of the matter is also noted.

The UC Davis Chancellor is on record as saying that she specifically ordered her employees, the police not to use force to make people leave.
As IDB87 noted, Katehi's cover-her-ass statement did not say what you claim. The quote is,
"Katehi has said that she ordered protesters' tents removed but had not authorized police to use the chemical spray in the manner shown on the videos." In other words she didn't say, "If the students lock themselves together and resist your orders, no not pepper spray them"

'Lawful' would be the direct order not to use force to remove the protestoers.
Disobeying that direct order isn't lawful.
First, see above. There was no direct order as you claim. Second, the instruction given to an employee doesn't create a "law" that if violated constitutes breaking the law.
 
As IDB87 noted, Katehi's cover-her-ass statement did not say what you claim. The quote is,
"Katehi has said that she ordered protesters' tents removed but had not authorized police to use the chemical spray in the manner shown on the videos." In other words she didn't say, "If the students lock themselves together and resist your orders, no not pepper spray them"

First, see above. There was no direct order as you claim. Second, the instruction given to an employee doesn't create a "law" that if violated constitutes breaking the law.
You are simply playing semantic games. What the Chancellor ordered was well understood.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/loca...f-huddled-with-13-on-decision-to-remove-camp/

The policy on use of force, which as already mentioned is predicated on case law and specific regulations, limits pepper spray to certain situations.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/local-news/ucd/2002-court-ruling-limits-use-of-pepper-spray/

The Chancellor ruled out one of those situations (using violence to move the protestors), and the only way that the police would have been authorized to deploy OC would have been as a proportionate response to actual threat of attack.

These internet games of 'well this actually could have meant that on a different space-time continuum' are idle speculation.

If you want to actually do something about police abuses, sitting around parroting a bunch of superstitious internet gossip isn't it.
 
The video is several minutes long, there is much of it that I "didn't bother" (ah, words) to write about. I wrote mostly about its value as support for your interpretation.

You ignored a rather important bit because it actually supported the idea that the protesters were not acting peacefully, which was thaiboxerken's claim. Please pay attention.

I did hear the chant you mention, but I'm at a loss as to the point you're trying to make.

That's because the post I originally made was from a different poster with a different opinion. I can't help it if you can't figure that out.

You offered the video as support for your interpretation. I pointed out that the only way the video supports your interpretation is in the captions.

In the captions, in the actual video, and by what the protesters actually say.

I critique the captions, those that misleadingly 'support' your interpretation, and others, so that we might understand how they fail to 'support' your interpretation (although they seem to share it) and perhaps give an insight into how someone can delude themselves that there is evidence for their presuppositions.

My position is that the protesters at Davis were not protesting peacefully. They were verbally threatening the cops and preventing them from arresting fellow protesters. This is seen and heard in the video, regardless of whatever captions were put over it.

Big butch police, in force, armed and armoured (and, we hope, trained and experienced) feel 'threatened' by peaceful student protestors blocking their way.

Please show me where anyone claimed the police felt threatened? That is a claim I have not made, at the very least. But now you're saying the protesters were peaceful. I disagree and site the threat they issue to be the opposite of peaceful, that being "do what we want or we will escalate our protest beyond peaceful action."

Maybe if you'd said 'the police were threatened by the people that they were threatening', but maybe you just didn't bother?

It is not my claim that the police felt threatened. My claim is that the protesters were not acting peacefully when they were threatening the police.

But let us take a sidestep into a world of the imagination for a moment, and agree that the protestors are being verbally threatening. What is the proper response to a verbal threat? Is it pepper spray? Is it to pepper spray a seated person who is offering no threat?

The protesters were not pepper sprayed because they had threatened the police.
 
You are simply playing semantic games. What the Chancellor ordered was well understood.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/loca...f-huddled-with-13-on-decision-to-remove-camp/

Meyer, the administrator who oversees the police department, has described similarly what was asked of Spicuzza during the teleconference.
“Once these actions begin, however, … there is great discretion given to officers both for their safety and the scene, to make decisions in the field,” Meyer told students at a town hall meeting.

Even if she had instructed the officers to remain non-violent, which is only corroborated by statements she's given after the fact, it appears to be understood that actions taken in the field are dictated by what the reality is.

The policy on use of force, which as already mentioned is predicated on case law and specific regulations, limits pepper spray to certain situations.

http://www.davisenterprise.com/local-news/ucd/2002-court-ruling-limits-use-of-pepper-spray/

What is the difference between spraying someone who purposefully immobilized themselves, and those who refuse to disperse? Do you believe there is no difference?

The Chancellor ruled out one of those situations (using violence to move the protestors), and the only way that the police would have been authorized to deploy OC would have been as a proportionate response to actual threat of attack.

This is what she said:

“In a peaceful way, (Spicuzza) was only supposed to take the equipment down, not disperse the crowd, not remove the students.

The equipment was taken down peacefully. The crowd was NOT dispersed, and the only students who were removed were ones that physically prevented the cops from taking down the tents. The people who were pepper sprayed were physically blocking the police from removing those they had arrested within the policies laid out by the Chancellor, and even their own code of conduct.

You have yet to show that the Tents were taken down in a violent manner, the crowd was dispersed violently, or that the students who attempted to prevent the police from removing the tents were removed violently.
 
You are simply playing semantic games. What the Chancellor ordered was well understood.
You're the one playing loose and fast with what she said. I gave the quote. It fails to match your claim.

The policy on use of force, which as already mentioned is predicated on case law and specific regulations, limits pepper spray to certain situations.
Other police tactics and experts say what they did was entirely within the acceptable use and standard procedures of many departments.

The Chancellor ruled out one of those situations (using violence to move the protestors), and the only way that the police would have been authorized to deploy OC would have been as a proportionate response to actual threat of attack.
I see Katehi has successfully convinced you that the police acted entirely contrary to her explicit orders, even though there were no such orders.


If you want to actually do something about police abuses, sitting around parroting a bunch of superstitious internet gossip isn't it.
This has been discussed extensively in an earlier thread. Police tactics experts have already weighed in on the issue and their quotes cited as evidence that the Davis police response was appropriate.
 
How am I supposed to deal in facts and reality when you haven't presented any yet?

Facts (and reality) exist independently. They do not require some member or other to post them here. There is life outside JREF.
 
You ignored a rather important bit because it actually supported the idea that the protesters were not acting peacefully, which was thaiboxerken's claim. Please pay attention.

I'm paying attention, not least to you resorting to sophomoric tactics in debate. Address the argument, not the arguer. Which bit (of the many bits I didn't comment on because they were irrelevant to your claim) do you now claim supports your interpretation? Please pay attention to your own work and provide references. (By the by, why the hell are you still referring to thaiboxerken, like he had anything to do with this? Take it up with him, we've covered the whole "I don't speak for him, he doesn't speak for me, you're spouting garbage" thing).

That's because the post I originally made was from a different poster with a different opinion. I can't help it if you can't figure that out.

And you're still not making sense. Anybody who was in any doubt about that would realise that now from your ad hom response. Again, attack the argument. Casting unsubstantiated aspersions on the arguer is very poor form round here.

In the captions, in the actual video, and by what the protesters actually say.

Oh, these multiquote spats are tiresome. I don't know what you're talking about here, and I don't care. We've established that you had an opinion and now interpret all the evidence in a way that supports your opinion. That's cool, that's human nature.

My position is that the protesters at Davis were not protesting peacefully. They were verbally threatening the cops and preventing them from arresting fellow protesters. This is seen and heard in the video, regardless of whatever captions were put over it.

Yes, your position is clear. Big fat armed and armoured cops felt 'threatened' by peaceful seated protestors. We get that. I laugh at it. Who do you expect will believe it?

Please show me where anyone claimed the police felt threatened?

Oh boy. See above.

That is a claim I have not made, at the very least. But now you're saying the protesters were peaceful. I disagree and site the threat they issue to be the opposite of peaceful, that being "do what we want or we will escalate our protest beyond peaceful action."

'Cite'. Excuse the pedantry. I have not said they were 'peaceful'. I said I hoped they were non-violent direct activists, and I've expressed my ambivalence about their verbal 'violence'. Life simply isn't as black and white as you'd like it to be. We see no violence in your evidence, we see no threat of violence, and yet you insist it's there because you need it to justify your position.

It is not my claim that the police felt threatened.

You claim they were threatened. Do you now claim that they didn't feel threatened? Why the pepper spray then?

My claim is that the protesters were not acting peacefully when they were threatening the police.

And you're wrong, as the video you foolishly presented as evidence clearly establishes. Apart from a brief chant of "**** the police", there is no violence in that video apart from that inflicted on peaceful protestors by the police. Unless you consider any and all resistance to immoral authority 'violence'. What would that make you?

The protesters were not pepper sprayed because they had threatened the police.

Were they not? Again, this pernickety multi-quote scrapping is not debate, it's not an honest exchange of ideas, and I have no interest in establishing what the hell you're whining about here. It's clear you have a socio-political position and nothing will sway you from it, least of all facts and reality.
 
Last edited:
I think it's quite clear from the videos the students WANTED to be pepper sprayed. They were warned, several times, that they would be peppersprayed if they didn't move and they were not hindered to move in any way.
 
YEAH! That'll show those nasty coppers that they shouldn't remove people blocking a public sidewalk in a way that minimizes risk of injury to themselves and the protesters! Teach those pigs that the best way to remove people from a place they're not supposed to be when they're interlocking arms is to wrench those arms right out of their sockets!

Uh, no.

Capture-2.jpg



See here.


Nice try; thanks for playing.

Enjoy your bliss.
 
Even if she had instructed the officers to remain non-violent, which is only corroborated by statements she's given after the fact, it appears to be understood that actions taken in the field are dictated by what the reality is.



What is the difference between spraying someone who purposefully immobilized themselves, and those who refuse to disperse? Do you believe there is no difference?



This is what she said:



The equipment was taken down peacefully. The crowd was NOT dispersed, and the only students who were removed were ones that physically prevented the cops from taking down the tents. The people who were pepper sprayed were physically blocking the police from removing those they had arrested within the policies laid out by the Chancellor, and even their own code of conduct.

You have yet to show that the Tents were taken down in a violent manner, the crowd was dispersed violently, or that the students who attempted to prevent the police from removing the tents were removed violently.
ROTFL!! In the field?? In the freaking field??? Yeah, tell us all about how it is in the field :rolleyes:


Thanks for proving my earlier claim that you were simply trolling for a dishonest internet debate game.

The video, the case law, the POST standards, every piece of reality debunks you, while all you've provided is denial and a fallacy laden polka.

And let me spare you the effort of parroting the boring internet cliches whining about personal attacks, and demanding that proof be reproven so you can ignore it some more.

That's what you're going to get when you try to peddle fantasies on a skeptic's forum.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom