Why the PATRIOT Act?

It seems to suggest a huge conspiracy, yes. If the quote about the New York Congresswoman is correct, then I think that's significant. At least it should be investigated further I think.

No that is answering what you think the stats are suggestive of. I wanted to know which of the two possibilities so far mentioned you thought was more likely. Feel free to answer any time.
 
No that is answering what you think the stats are suggestive of. I wanted to know which of the two possibilities so far mentioned you thought was more likely. Feel free to answer any time.

More investigation is needed about that. But I think we should drop it. Because it could really show that there is a huge conspiracy. And people wouldn't perhaps be able to handle the truth about that.
 
More investigation is needed about that. But I think we should drop it. Because it could really show that there is a huge conspiracy. And people wouldn't perhaps be able to handle the truth about that.

Would you like to try again, with out needless speculation or hyperbole. I did not ask if you thought an investigation was required, or what the consequences would be, or if the discussion should be dropped.

I asked which of the two possibilities mentioned so far to explain the discrepency in data, was more likely. An admistrative error, or the massive conspiracy you describe.

It is very simple to answer: You tell me which you consider to be more likely.
 
Would you like to try again, with out needless speculation or hyperbole. I did not ask if you thought an investigation was required, or what the consequences would be, or if the discussion should be dropped.

I asked which of the two possibilities mentioned so far to explain the discrepency in data, was more likely. An admistrative error, or the massive conspiracy you describe.

It is very simple to answer: You tell me which you consider to be more likely.

I have dropped that issue. It could be dangerous to look too much into it. If you want to research it further, please go ahead, but me, I'm dropping that baby like a piece of hot coal! Ouch!
 
I have dropped that issue. It could be dangerous to look too much into it. If you want to research it further, please go ahead, but me, I'm dropping that baby like a piece of hot coal! Ouch!

Odd, as I am not asking you to look further into either possibility at all. I asked which was more likely.

Can I assume you are unable to answer?

Have you bitten the dust again?
 
Odd, as I am not asking you to look further into either possibility at all. I asked which was more likely.

Can I assume you are unable to answer?

Have you bitten the dust again?

I have already replied that more investigation is needed before I will answer that question, and I also pointed out later that I will not look into it further. This means, in case you don't understand what I mean, that I will not answer that question, and nor will I answer any repetition of that question.
 
I have already replied that more investigation is needed before I will answer that question, and I also pointed out later that I will not look into it further. This means, in case you don't understand what I mean, that I will not answer that question, and nor will I answer any repetition of that question.

Then would it not have been more civil to simply reply with the statement "I can not answe that question" when first asked, rather than answering different questions instead?

Why did you answer different questions, or give none-answers instead of simply saying you couldn't answer?
 
Then would it not have been more civil to simply reply with the statement "I can not answe that question" when first asked, rather than answering different questions instead?

Why did you answer different questions, or give none-answers instead of simply saying you couldn't answer?

Ah! I can change my mind very quickly. So even between two posts I may sometimes, hopefully not too often, change my mind.
 
Ah! I can change my mind very quickly. So even between two posts I may sometimes, hopefully not too often, change my mind.

You changed your mind about which question you answered?

The question would have remained the same.

Even if you DID change your mind, about what? If you couldn't answer the question then you had nothing to change your mind about because you COULDN'T answer. If you COULD, then you still answered different questions.

Why?
 
Are you saying 3000 victims are missing in the statistics because of the below reasons?

* The death was not reported to the Social Security Administration (SSA).


If the person was not receiving benefits and left no one to receive survivors' benefits, there was no need to report the death to the Social Security Administration.

*The person did not participate in the Social Security program.


372 foreign nationals (not counting the terrorists) died in the attacks. Guess what? They didn't participate in Social Security. :rolleyes:

* Survivor death benefits were (are) being paid to dependents or spouse.


This would apply to any participants with minor children.

* Human error.


"Never attribute to malice . . ."

Can that really explain all the 3000 missing victims in the statistics? And don't you think the New York congresswoman knew about that before demanding answers about the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans?


She obviously didn't, or she would have only asked about the 2600 Americans.

Further, they aren't all "missing." Many are listed, and have been. If you'd bothered to read the post I linked, you'd see that even the conspiracy theorists who started this garbage said that they were able to find about a quarter of the passengers on the planes in the index. Fail.
 
You changed your mind about which question you answered?

The question would have remained the same.

Even if you DID change your mind, about what? If you couldn't answer the question then you had nothing to change your mind about because you COULDN'T answer. If you COULD, then you still answered different questions.

Why?

There are two reasons for why I will not answer the question. The first reason is that I need more investigation into it. And then someone could ask me to do more research about it. But then after that I added another reason for why not to answer the question. So the change of mind was only about adding the other reason if I remember correctly.

So, what do you know about the Patriot act? ;)
 
There are two reasons for why I will not answer the question. The first reason is that I need more investigation into it. And then someone could ask me to do more research about it. But then after that I added another reason for why not to answer the question. So the change of mind was only about adding the other reason if I remember correctly.

All very interesting, but not what I asked at all is it?

You should know that, you quoted the post in your response, like this:

You changed your mind about which question you answered?

The question would have remained the same.

Even if you DID change your mind, about what? If you couldn't answer the question then you had nothing to change your mind about because you COULDN'T answer. If you COULD, then you still answered different questions.

Why?

You see, the response you gave didn't answer either question I asked. About what you changed your mind on, or why you would not simply say you could not answer the question before it was repeated.

Now I know this will be moderated, I am fully expecting it to be moved to Abandon All Hope any moment. But, if you are expecting to discuss a serious matter I wish to be sure you are capable of answering direct questions. If you are not going to answer direct questions I want to understand why, to know if there a reason I can work around in the discussion, or if you are childish troll determined to look more like a childish troll with each and every response.

For example, you have repeatedly explained why you wont answer a question NOW when you are asked why you did not say that when originally asked. And why you instead chose to answer ENTIRELY DIFFERENT questions.

Just like you have done again.

Will you answe the questions that are asked, or will you continue to change your mind about what questions have been asked?
 
All very interesting, but not what I asked at all is it?

You should know that, you quoted the post in your response, like this:



You see, the response you gave didn't answer either question I asked. About what you changed your mind on, or why you would not simply say you could not answer the question before it was repeated.

Now I know this will be moderated, I am fully expecting it to be moved to Abandon All Hope any moment. But, if you are expecting to discuss a serious matter I wish to be sure you are capable of answering direct questions. If you are not going to answer direct questions I want to understand why, to know if there a reason I can work around in the discussion, or if you are childish troll determined to look more like a childish troll with each and every response.

For example, you have repeatedly explained why you wont answer a question NOW when you are asked why you did not say that when originally asked. And why you instead chose to answer ENTIRELY DIFFERENT questions.

Just like you have done again.

Will you answe the questions that are asked, or will you continue to change your mind about what questions have been asked?

I don't understand what you mean here. If it's some convoluted attempt to ask the same question again then I will not fall for that.
 
I don't understand what you mean here. If it's some convoluted attempt to ask the same question again then I will not fall for that.

I just asked:
Will you answer the questions that are asked, or will you continue to change your mind about what questions have been asked?
And you didn't answer the question that was asked. I can only assume you DID change your mind about what question was asked (again).

I would ask why you don't give straight answers to direct questions. But you wouldn't give an answer.

The point is made. You wont answer diect questions, you wont admit when you can't answer the question until it has been asked repeatedly.

There is no way of having any form of dialogue with you, because you can't engage in an adult discussion. Feel free to chalk this up to a "win" and convince yourself that you somehow came out of this looking big and clever.

But if you can't answer the same question you were asked, how can there ever be a meaningful discussion? On this subject or any other?
 
Prediction: There is no official public information about the total number of U.S. citizens that have been arrested under the Patriot act.
 
But what about this:

"WASHINGTON — A New York congresswoman who represents Manhattan wants answers to why nearly 3,000 victims of the 9/11 terrorists attacks weren’t reported in the Social Security Administration’s official list of deceased Americans. ... “While nearly 3,000 individuals were killed on Sept. 11th, the list does not show an increase in numbers from the typical DMF daily average,” Maloney said." -- http://911scholars.ning.com/profiles/blogs/3000-deaths-from-911-not-in



Seriously? A story from Naplesnews.Com about one question by Rep. Carolyn Maloney trumps primary research you could make calling victims' families?

Do you even know if Maloney believes there's any chance that the 9/11 victims were not killed or whether the attacks were carried out as believed? As she was a major force in victims' rights, government intelligence reforms, and all issues regarding 9/11, I would think her views on the matter would be quite non-insane.

However, you don't have to speculate. You don't have to wonder even fora minute. You can ask her yourself. Call her at: (202) 225-7944

You won't.
 
Seriously? A story from Naplesnews.Com about one question by Rep. Carolyn Maloney trumps primary research you could make calling victims' families?

Do you even know if Maloney believes there's any chance that the 9/11 victims were not killed or whether the attacks were carried out as believed? As she was a major force in victims' rights, government intelligence reforms, and all issues regarding 9/11, I would think her views on the matter would be quite non-insane.

However, you don't have to speculate. You don't have to wonder even fora minute. You can ask her yourself. Call her at: (202) 225-7944

You won't.

I will mostly focus on the Patriot act in this thread.
 
I have already replied that more investigation is needed before I will answer that question, and I also pointed out later that I will not look into it further. This means, in case you don't understand what I mean, that I will not answer that question, and nor will I answer any repetition of that question.

Translation: I'm too lazy to provide evidence, so don't ask for any.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom